Please do not, as you just did, imply that to criticize Israeli policies is to legitimize the horrors brought upon thousands of innocent civilians on Oct 7. That is a false dichotomy. Furthermore, a personal endeavour to split every hair on this topic while emotionally compromised will likely lead to a negative mental health outcome.
Do you have proof that Iran is responsible for the linked post? If not, I wouldn't consider that providing context.
> It's not about exposing some scandal, it's about framing Israel as some psychotic evil thing thus legitimizing massacares such that happened on Oct7, and turning public opinion rabidly against Israel.
How can you make that claim? Also, turning opinion against Isreal (by highlighting things they've done) and legitimizing killing innocents are not part and parcel. People being informed about both sides of a conflict is a good thing, isn't it?
> Oh, and I'm not using emotional rhetoric, I'm really feeling these emotions. You have no idea what we have been through, and then seeing the barrage of unhinged lies and half truths being thrown against us really is scary and disheartening.
I sympathize with you, but even if it's genuine it's still emotionally charged rhetoric.
Your comment comes across as "this thing that happened 10 years ago doesn't matter because Hamas attacked Israel recently". It's a nonsequitor that makes your sentiment appear disingenuous, even if it isn't.
I have no idea what you specifically think or believ, but understand, what we have been through is extremely dark and brutal. And we are not even out of our mourning for the dead, we still have hundreds of people missing. We saw videos of brutalized innocents. This is not "information" for me, it's a tragedy I'm still living through.
The funny sad thing is that the people who got brutalized mostly come from communities who are staunch supporters of a two state solution and ending the Israeli occupation. One of the murdered ran a program for giving gazan children treatments in Israeli hospitals.
I don't know why I'm writing all of this, but understand, I'm not having an intellectual discussion here. This is a tragedy I'm living through. We are in pain here, and it really is hard to cope with that while seeing vile attacks on US campuses, and reading here, this little sanctuary of tech I can enjoy for a bit, thinly vailed libel and half truths. (Not that I blame you specifically.)
River to the sea doesn’t mean ethnically cleansing, like Israel has done to Palestinians. It means a one state solution, with Arabs and Jews as equals. You choose to interpret it as a call for genocide, but I get why you do: projection.
Quick question: how many of those dead on the 7th were due to IDF attacking Israelis? How many hostages have died from IAF airstrikes?
You talk about brutal videos of the 7th, when you can see the same thing and worse every single day in Gaza. You talk about tragedy when 1000s of kids in Gaza have died and you don’t seem to care. Only Israelis dying matter to you. I wonder why.
I'll be the last person to defend everything Israel does, but bloodthirsty evil we are not.
Oh, and I'm not using emotional rhetoric, I'm really feeling these emotions. You have no idea what we have been through, and then seeing the barrage of unhinged lies and half truths being thrown against us really is scary and disheartening.