News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by numlock86 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:32AM (#38303267)
> 1gig is still the standard for wired

A lot of people already get more than that from their ISP. I had at least 2.5g on every consumer product from the past 5 years. Small businesses use at least SFP on the floor level. Yada yada yada. Point is it's probably a regional thing.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by bitcharmer on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:34AM (#38303292)
Nah, you're in a very small minority. Most households have few hundred megs at most
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by p1esk on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:48AM (#38306103)
You’re probably in US. Meanwhile in Switzerland people are enjoying 25gbps internet: https://www.init7.net/en/internet/fiber7/
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by bitcharmer on Friday November 17, 2023 @12:44PM (#38307093)
I'm in the UK. What I stated applies to most countries. Switzerland is a niche.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by Almondsetat on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:44AM (#38303426)
You also need to have 2.5GB capable hardware in all of your home devices though.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by sgjohnson on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:23AM (#38304806)
No, you don’t. You do need it only if you want to pull 2.5gigs on one device.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by maccard on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:56PM (#38313964)
"One device" could be your router, and if your router can't do 2.5gb then nothing will be doing 2.5
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by whatevaa on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:45AM (#38303445)
Yeah, no. You live in a bubble. Most consumers are not above 1g even on fiber. It's probably not even regional, it's very location specific.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by Aaargh20318 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:59AM (#38303610)
Where I live (the Netherlands) gigabit is available pretty much country-wide. Not everyone may subscribe to a gigabit plan but it's available to them if they wanted it.

ISPs are now just starting to roll out multi-gig, a few are already offering 2.5 or 4gbit plans. Even the ones that do not offer multi-gbit plans yet are already installing 10gbit capable CPEs. I suspect 10gbit service will become available nationwide within a few years.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:51AM (#38303526)
A lot of people?

2.5G is rapidly approaching, if not already past the point, for a lot of people where a single machine will never use all of that capacity, and the advantage of higher total bandwidth is to support multiple people doing high bandwidth tasks.

In this scenario a 2.5G (or 10G) router is all that's really required to get the benefit, while using the existing 20 year old wiring.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by thfuran on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:55AM (#38303558)
>rapidly approaching, if not already past the point, for a lot of people where a single machine will never use all of that capacity

Now where have I heard that before...

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by Aaargh20318 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:03AM (#38303666)
Back in college we had 100Mbit internet connections in our dorm rooms when most people had 10Mbit cable or DSL at most. At the time it was considered ridiculously fast and certainly not something an average consumer would ever need.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:58AM (#38303602)
> Now where have I heard that before...

Ok, sorry, in another 30 years time people might want more than 1G to do brain dumps to their robo-shrink.

In 2023, there are very few uses for home users that will exceed what a 1G connection can provide.

But please enlighten me about where you think you've "heard this before"?

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by hnlmorg on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:20AM (#38303941)
Not the commenter but I’ve heard people make statements like that time and time again, only for those limits to be obliterated a few years later.

The thing is, the moment a new upper bound becomes available, developers find a way to use it. It’s like the freeway problem that adding more roads ironically adds to congestion.

Take storage, the greater the storage capacity of media increased, the larger game assets became. The faster CPUs and system memory became, the heavier our operating systems and desktop software became.

Likewise, the faster our internet becomes, the more dependent we will become on streaming high fidelity content. 4k on a lot of streaming services is compressed to hell and back to work with people on slower internet connections. And much as Google Stadia was shutdown, video game streaming services aren’t a failed experiment. Plus even with more traditional services, how many of us roll our eyes at multi-hour download times for new games?

Once gigabit internet becomes the norm (it’s common place in a lot of countries already, but it’s not quite the norm yet) then you’ll see more and more services upscale to support it, and thus others on the cutting edge of the tech curve finding that gigabit internet isn’t quite fast enough any more. And that will happen sooner than you think.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:39AM (#38304207)
> 4k on a lot of streaming services is compressed to hell and back to work with people on slower internet connections.

A 4K UltraHD Bluray (that's 100GB for one movie) has a maximum bitrate of "just" 144Mbps. If you're suggesting online streaming services have some swathe of content that's (checks notes) in excess of 7x the bitrate used for 4K Bluray discs, I'd love to hear about it.

> video game streaming services aren’t a failed experiment

I'd have thought latency was a far bigger concern here, but even if not: it's still just sending you a 4K video stream.. it just happens to be a stream that's reacting to your input.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by ndriscoll on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:24AM (#38305688)
AFAIK we're still very far below the dynamic range human eyes are capable of seeing, so there's plenty of room to need to up the bit depth (and rate) for video if displays can improve. Our color gamuts also do not cover human vision.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:41PM (#38309010)
So I had to use a calculator to help me here, and I used https://toolstud.io/video/bitrate.php, but apparently the raw bitrate for 4K@25fps/24bit is 4.98Gbps, which then obviously gets compressed by various codecs.

Taking the above 4K@25fps/24bit and pumping it up to 60fps and 36bit colour (i.e. 12 bits per channel, or 68 billion colours, 4096x as many colours as 24bit, and 64x as many colours as 30bit) the resulting raw video bitrate is 17.92Gbps... so it's an increase of <checks notes> about 3.6x.

It seems quite unlikely that we'll have every other aspect of 36bit/60fps video sorted out, but somehow the codecs available have worse performance than is already available today.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by ndriscoll on Friday November 17, 2023 @03:34PM (#38309708)
My understanding is that today's HDR sensors and displays can do ~13 stops of dynamic range, while humans can see at least ~20, though I'm not sure how to translate that into how much additional bit depth ought to be needed (naively, I might guess at 48 bits being enough).

I don't see why we'd stop at 60fps when 120 or even 240 Hz displays are already available. Also 8k displays already exist.

So it's true in 2023 (especially since no one will stream that high of quality to you), but one can easily imagine boring incremental technology improvements that would demand more. There's plenty of room for video quality to increase before we reach the limitations of human eyes.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by hnlmorg on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:40AM (#38305964)
> A 4K UltraHD Bluray (that's 100GB for one movie) has a maximum bitrate of "just" 144Mbps. If you're suggesting online streaming services have some swathe of content that's (checks notes) in excess of 7x the bitrate used for 4K Bluray discs, I'd love to hear about it.

We are still a long way off the parity with what our eyes can process so there's plenty of room for bitrates to grow.

Plus the average internet connection isn't just streaming a video. It's kids watching online videos while adults are video conferencing and music is being streamed in the background. Probably with games being downloaded and software getting updated too.

A few hundred Mbps here, another few there. Quickly you exceed 1 gigabit.

> I'd have thought latency was a far bigger concern here, but even if not: it's still just sending you a 4K video stream.. it just happens to be a stream that's reacting to your input.

Latency and jitter matter too. But they're not mutually exclusive properties.

Plus if you're streaming VR content then that is multiple 4k streams per device. And that's on top of all the other concurrent network operations (as mentioned above).

You're also still thinking purely about current tech. My point was that developers create new tech to take advantage of higher specs. I've seen this happen many times in my lifetime but you don't even have to be that old to have seen it yourself.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:35PM (#38308919)
> Plus the average internet connection isn't just streaming a video. It's kids watching online videos while adults are video conferencing and music is being streamed in the background. Probably with games being downloaded and software getting updated too.

That's exactly the scenario I gave where 2.5G WAN would be useful, but a 1G LAN to each machine is likely enough for most tasks, for most people - multiple users simultaneous use.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by hnlmorg on Friday November 17, 2023 @06:38PM (#38312318)
For today, yes. But you're demonstrating a massive failure of imagination by assuming those needs are going to be the same in a few years time.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:32PM (#38315218)
Not moving goal posts at all mate.

My original comment, in reply to someone saying "a lot of people already get more than 1G from their ISP" and implying that it's therefore worthwhile to have 2.5GEth on all local devices ends with:

> In this scenario a 2.5G (or 10G) router is all that's really required to get the benefit, while using the existing 20 year old wiring.

I'm sorry if the correlation between having a 2.5G router and having greater than 1G WAN wasn't obvious to you.

Complaining that a quasi backbone link saturates gig eth when my entire point was that single computers are unlikely to need more kind of misses the whole point I was making for an excuse to complain.

I never said no one needs more than gig for anything.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by Aaargh20318 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:08AM (#38303743)
> In 2023, there are very few uses for home users that will exceed what a 1G connection can provide

Video games are getting bigger all the time. The latest Call of Duty apparently is 200GB. On 1gbit you are limited to 125MB/s downloads (assuming zero overhead) that's almost a half an hour to download. PCIe4 SSD's are capable of write speeds of about 7GB/s and PCIe5 SSD's are just hitting the market with even faster speeds. At 10Gbit you can download that game in less than 3 minutes. In neither case are you even approaching the speed at which your PC can store that data.

When PCIe5 SSD's go mainstream a home PC user would even be able to saturate a 100Gbit connection.

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:20AM (#38303932)
Please, I implore you, to read the line you quoted again, and then perhaps pull out the old Oxford English, and look up what "very few" means.

I'll be generous and give you a hint: it doesn't mean none.

But your example also has great relevance to the "familiar" sentence in my original comment which was:

> 2.5G is rapidly approaching, if not already past the point, for a lot of people where a single machine will never use all of that capacity, and the advantage of higher total bandwidth is to support multiple people doing high bandwidth tasks.

I italicised the part that I knew people would somehow ignore in my original comment and I've done it again, because obviously once wasn't enough.

Here, let me pull out the important words yet again just to make it really clear:

> for a lot of people

Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by theryan on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:04AM (#38303683)
I believe they are referring to the quote from Bill Gates '640K ought to be enough for anyone' in reference to ram.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by stephenr on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:11AM (#38303790)
I guess I shouldn't be surprised that someone who believes the debunked Gates quote is real, also can't comprehend the difference between "for anyone" and "for a lot of people".
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by organsnyder on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:44AM (#38304280)
I just got 5gbps symmetrical FTTH installed. I'm in Michigan, so hardly some connectivity utopia. I'm going through a round of upgrading my network devices to be able to actually handle it.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by PinguTS on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:49AM (#38304348)
You never visited Germany, aren't you?
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by numlock86 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:06PM (#38336483)
I am living Germany. You're welcome.
Re:Ethernet Is Still Going Strong After 50 Years by PinguTS on Sunday November 19, 2023 @04:30PM (#38338301)
I'm in the Nuremberg area. We have no fibre in downtown Nuremberg for the company in an old building.

I live in a very small town in the outskirts, we will have no fibre for next years. Only the main town will get fibre the next few years.