Or in other words: you're being a useful idiot for Russia.
Really, we are all so far removed from the geopolitical reality, who can say what is the truth of the matter? Please share your info/reasoning, if you think you have a special reason for thinking you have a better handle on it than others.
In fact, this is really a general comment, that I direct at anyone who purports to know this or that.
The only account that actually makes sense is still Seymour Hersh's - especially given the small matter of Biden's public threat and the motives.
> I also believe that WaPo may be making Ukraine look like they've coordinated the attack in order to keep blame away from any US involvement.
No, that's not what the WaPo is doing.
> The most unlikely guilty party would of course be Russia, who has the most to lose in Nord Stream's sabotage.
This is factually incorrect for a number of reasons, a big part of which is that Russia has more to gain from dividing the EU than from losing Nord Stream.
Myself, I am trying to establish the truth of the matter - I don't accept so-called authoritative sources when they are proven liars. The only way I know of to satisfy myself off the truth is to verify it personally. Involving myself in these narratives, is like acting upon (convincing) hearsay or gossip. It's simply not part of my life.
I won't call for harm to people I do not know on account of a story that could be a lie.
Or in other words: you're being a useful idiot for Ukraine.
Do you see now how useful your comment is?
To try to make both sides as equal, as if both are lying to the same extent and there's the same amount of evidence for either side and that we cannot know anything.
I say that comments like these are useful idiots for Russia because they're echoing the Russian propaganda and talking points.
Am I echoing "EU propaganda"? (Which is really the whole western world, not just EU.)
Not willing to entertain the idea that yes Ukraine is lying and engaging in propaganda too (just like the Russians), I'd say that yes you are echoing western propaganda; though it may not be conscious, hence the word echo.
"To try to make both sides as equal, as if both are lying to the same extent and there's the same amount of evidence for either side and that we cannot know anything."
I said that's a poisonous perspective to anyone who actually values reasonable discussion and trying to ascertain the truth, because you're effectively saying only your side (ukraine) is right and suggesting anything else is russian propaganda. So again that's why I think your perspective is poisonous.
"To try to make both sides as equal, as if both are lying to the same extent and there's the same amount of evidence for either side and that we cannot know anything."
I'm not suggesting it.
> I said that's a poisonous perspective to anyone who actually values reasonable discussion and trying to ascertain the truth, because you're effectively saying only your side (ukraine) is right and suggesting anything else is russian propaganda. So again that's why I think your perspective is poisonous.
You are not going to get much traction with this nonsense, there is no 'my side' or anything else but thank you for confirming what 'your side' is.
When you have something productive to add to the conversation, let me know.
This is a fine starting point, but only if you ignore the mountains if evidence where Russia has consistently lied about everything from Ukraine being Nazis to who set up the torture chambers on liberated land, while racking up thousands of war crimes.
Implying that both sides lies to the same extent is just stupid wrong, and is exactly the narrative that Russia wants to promote.
Of course everyone uses propaganda, but there's an incredibly large difference between what the free world can get away with and what the totalitarian Russian government csn and will do.
In this case they were also one of the countries most strongly lobbying against the pipeline. I don't think it should exist either, so even though I "blame" the US for having blown it up, I think it's a good thing it happened.
A democratic or diplomatic solution would have been nicer. So... thanks but not thanks?
The US because I agree with you about their history of playing such games; Russia because they are currently doing stupid things and blaming everyone else for it; and Ukraine because (while it would be really risky if they were found out) it has an obvious direct benefit of making it much harder for anyone in the EU to spend money on Russian gas even if they wanted to.
There could be others, but I'm not sure who. China doesn't seem likely to be interested to me, but I could be wrong. North Korea seems like a chaos gremlin, but I don't think they have the capability.
Greenpeace? :P
But the others all have motive means and opportunity to varying degrees. The one thing that is still most underdeveloped is how hard it really is to perform a feat like this.
Note that the original cast of Greenpeace might not have been all against doing something like that. They started out as what today would be called eco-terrorists, and they had some pretty amazing capabilities for a group that small. Beware of intelligent and dedicated people. Their roots are in anti-war and anti-nuclear groups and over time their goals broadened. Today's Greenpeace is a gentle marketing club in comparison with how it all started.
A turning point was the bombing of the Rainbow Warrior, after that the nature of the organization changed considerably.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warrior
Ironically, it served as a wake-up call that something like Greenpeace is very much needed and was probably one of the biggest reasons people changed from 'neutral' to 'pro environment'. The French did not exactly do themselves a service with that action.
But nobody knows who the paymasters were. Note that there are still Ukrainians fighting on the Russian side and that 'the fog of war' is a thing.
"If Russia invades Ukraine, one way or another, Nord Stream 2 will not move forward."
"If Russia invades, that means tanks and troops crossing the border of Ukraine again, then there will be no longer a Nord Stream 2, ... We will bring an end to it."
"Senator ..., like you, I am, and I think the administration is, very gratified to know that Nord Stream 2 is now, as you like to say, a hunk of metal at the bottom of the sea."
Top officials of what country made these statements?
It's a huge mess and with Putin, the US and the Ukraine all in play there are a whole slew of possible scenarios. Nothing short of a massive investigative effort will clear this up.
Isn't that unusual given how quick all the officials and media are to blame just one side of the conflict (we know which one) for everything, with or without evidence?
[1] https://www.google.com/search?q=site%3Aiaea.org+znpp+shellin...
So, the IAEA and Grossi either can't establish where the shells are fired from (hard to believe given the prolonged and intensive nature of the shelling and the amount of evidence) or are hesitant / not allowed to incriminate the party they believe is responsible.
If we apply the same logic of no A : no B, then "Russian invasion" would be the B in some other equation, e.g., no A : no Russian invasion. What would that A be?
> I encourage you to spend less time watching/reading the mass media news.
Thank you for your life advice.
NATO never would have accepted Ukraine but now that Russia has invaded Ukraine if the Russians get kicked out it might just happen. See also: Finland, Sweden.
Note that since you claim you are Dutch: it's amazing that given your access to news sources that you should be carrying water for a party that does not exactly have your best interests at heart, and I'm saying that as someone who has lived in a country under Russian occupation.
Does it really matter who's doing the shelling? The shelling is fundamentally happening because Russia invaded Ukraine in a war of aggression.
(The IAEA is likely not all that equipped to determine the source of artillery fire. That's not really their thing.)
It's unclear what happened to the planned 'forensic evaluation', but somehow there was no further interest in holding attackers responsible.
> Does it really matter who's doing the shelling?
Sure it does. The entire good guys vs bad guys narrative falls apart when your, cough, ally is the one attempting "nuclear blackmail" against you. I for one don't want to help things escalate to the "together into the abyss" stage [2], not for any reason, least of all because someone's intergenerational vendetta went off the rails.
[1] https://thehill.com/policy/international/3615324-internation...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Friedrich_Glasl%27s_model_of_c...
It really doesn't. There'd be precisely zero shelling near the Zaporizhzhia nuclear plant if Russia hadn't invaded anyone. They clearly bear the lion's weight of responsibility here, and they additionally have a vested interest in using the plant as cover for their forces.
The IAEA isn't going to rock the boat, as criminal responsiblity isn't their mission; keeping the plant safe is. Getting thrown out by the Russians won't help that mission any; any criticisms are going to be... cautious.
(Like the ones in https://www.iaea.org/newscenter/pressreleases/update-192-iae... "The IAEA experts also need access to all six turbine halls together. However, they were only granted partial access to the turbine hall of reactor unit 2 on 27 October, after earlier the same month receiving similarly restrictive access to the turbine halls of units 1 and 4.")
That's my problem. One can't have their moral cake and eat it too.
No, the US shouldn’t be in the Middle East in a military capacity. It hasn’t done the world much good there.
"But overthrowing the democratically elected governments, meddling with politics and financing gallant people is fine, because it's not our boots on the ground who dies there"
The US should remain involved diplomatically.
I eagerly await the next faux outrage about some bizarre misreading of that statement.
> faux outrage about some bizarre misreading of that statement.
I'm eagerly await the next reason why US has the right to fuck with anyone.
Well, I guess nothing really matters because "Russia invaded Ukraine in a war of aggression"? I encourage we go with Five whys [1] to dive deeper into the why of them doing it. Maybe we'll find something new. Justifying everything with "they invaded first" is, apologize, fucking stupid.
There's shelling near the nuclear plant.
Why? Because there are troops fighting there. Why? Because Russia invaded Ukraine. Why? Because Russia wanted to weaken NATO. Why? Because Russia isn't managing to compete for a sphere of influence on merits. Why? Because Russia has long lost trust as it attempts to expand its sphere of influence via force in other places like Georgia.
If you believe "bring an end to it" can only encompass explosive options, Trump's call to "put an end to" the Republican primary debates must be quite confusing. https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/4227533-trump-campaign...
He's notorious for confusing and incoherent ramblings like this:
"I looked at them and said, ‘if the prosecutor is not fired, you’re not getting the money'. Well son of a bitch, he got fired".
We will never know what he meant, but I'm confident it was just a parable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Viktor_Shokin
> Through 2015 and early 2016, domestic and international pressure (including from the IMF, the EU, and the EBRD) built for Shokin to be removed from office. The Obama administration withheld $1 billion in loan guarantees to pressure the Ukrainian government to remove Shokin from office.
> "The truth is that I was forced out because I was leading a wide-ranging corruption probe into Burisma Holdings, a natural gas firm active in Ukraine and Joe Biden’s son, Hunter Biden, was a member of the Board of Directors." Shokin continued, stating that, "On several occasions President Poroshenko asked me to have a look at the criminal case against Burisma and consider the possibility of winding down the investigative actions in respect of this company, but I refused to close this investigation."
Nothing fishy about any of this. Good, honest public servants doing their job.
In opposition to all those facts, we have... Shokin himself being grumpy over being fired.
What's in question is whether it works, which I suspect varies from politician to politician. The assertions of Joe Biden having acted based on Hunter's desires, thus far, don't seem compelling.
You're mixing up your different administrations I think.
If I may respond in kind, you're mixing up your evidence and propaganda through repeating ad nauseam. Unfortunately that happened to many, with grave consequences like priming the populace to support the war.
And if it isn't your administration why bother polluting this thread?
Nord Stream 2 was pressurized ready to deliver cheap gas (which German industry desperately needs) with one flip of a switch. That presented a risk to the United States, who didn't want them to be tempted.
>If you believe "bring an end to it" can only encompass explosive options
Absolutely not but when an end to it is brought explosively and one party has threatened to do just that and has the most motive:
* German energy intensive industries is being lured over to America with promises of cheap energy.
* Germany is now paying a lot more TO America for its expensive LNG (something it has publicly wanted for a while).
* The US has been wanting to pull Germany out of Russia's economic orbit for a long while now.
Then the most plausible story is the one broken by the same guy who broke my lai: Biden not only threatened to do it, he did it.
That's a potential motive, yes. "Make it look like US/NATO/Ukraine did it to sow discord" is also a plausible potential motive.
> Absolutely not but when an end to it is brought explosively and one party has threatened to do just that and has the most motive:
When was an explosive resolution specifically threatened? Biden was even asked in said press conference how it'd be accomplished and declined to be specific.
It's surface level plausible, as was the theory that 9/11 was an inside job because it gave the US an excuse to attack Iraq.
Russia was trying to reel Germany in with cheap gas as the bait. The whole point of natural gas to putin was to use as leverage. Blowing up their own bait and their leverage (which cost 11 billion dollars to build) doesn't make a whole lot of sense.
>When was an explosive resolution specifically threatened?
Well if you put it like that I'm pretty sure he didn't mention the precise date, the type of explosives used or the name of the diver that placed the explosives either.
It is and the US can and does regularly make sanctions threats but that wasn't a sanctions threat it was a deliberately and overtly vague threat.
When the US makes overtly vague "nice pipeline you've got there be a shame if something happened to it" then they're probably making a "nice pipeline you've got there would be a shame if something happened to it".
https://oalexanderdk.substack.com/p/blowing-holes-in-seymour...
As for what Ukraine would win: hypothetically: they could cause Germany to stop relying on Russian gas a bit quicker. But there are other parties that stood a lot more to gain from this and 'qui bono' is an even better question, especially in the context of a false flag. The fact that the trail that was uncovered was a mile wide is in itself quite suspicious.
I'm dubious that the risk to European support is worth it for Ukraine; they're hardly the only ones with means, motive, and opportunity.
There are so many little factoids about this thing that it is very hard to make sense of it, for instance this little tidbit:
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2023/apr/28/russian-navy-v...
Barring some country coming out and admitting it, we may never know for certain.
Anonymity, 'people familiar with his role', that bit is repeated over and over.
I'll reserve my skepticism until there is hard proof and even then: if it turns out that this was a rogue action how much weight should be attached to it? Does that rule out some invisible paymaster?
Ukraine top government officials have denied involvement and knowledge of involvement and that's where it stands for now.
Source: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2023/11/11/...