News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by scythe on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @07:31PM (#38199298)
>With the price of renewables dropping precipitously, however, the project's economics have worsened, and backers started pulling out of the project.

I would expect this to continue limiting investment in nuclear, since the outlook for renewables just keeps getting better, and the stumbling blocks are increasingly jejune, like we can't build powerlines fast enough.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by monero-xmr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:16PM (#38200209)
I am still very confused how power will be generated cleanly on cloudy, no-wind days with solar and wind. I am hopeful that hydrogen can be generated in the desert and moved by hydrogen-truck. Or grid-scale batteries actually exist someday. But if we write off nuclear, a lot of coal and natural gas will be burned.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by pixl97 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:34PM (#38200362)
Deserts don't tend to have much water, so where do you expect to get the hydrogen from? Getting water to the desert takes a pile of energy as it is, and typically once it gets there people want to turn it into plants.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:26PM (#38200775)
you can use the hydrogen an arbitrarily large number of times once you get it there, and the amount of water needed is so small that this is not a major part of the cost of a grid-scale storage system system even if you have to truck it in, which you don't because even deserts have groundwater

please do the math instead of posting random bullshit without respect to whether it's true or not

specifically hydrogen is 142 MJ/kg https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density and is 1/9 of water by mass, so each kg of water you drill, truck in, or collect from cisterns can store 15.8 MJ as hydrogen. a square meter of 21% efficient pv panel produces 210 watts nameplate, or 52 watts derating for the 25% capacity factor typical for deserts. that is 4.5 MJ per day. the water needed to store the panel's daily production weighs much less than the panel itself and is therefore much cheaper to truck in

obviously it would be stupid to truck it back out again unless you decided to do your grid-scale storage somewhere else

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by angiosperm on Thursday November 09, 2023 @04:16PM (#38211441)
Deserts all have way more humidity than you could ever need for your hydrogen production. Extracting hydrogen from atmospheric water vapor is a win because it is cleaner than ground water, and has already been vaporized.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by NikkiA on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:23PM (#38200264)
It's never 'not windy' everywhere, plus gravity batteries can store power for days/weeks.

Geothermal is also an 'always on' renewable.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by monero-xmr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:25PM (#38200290)
If it was this easy, gravity batteries and geothermal would be everywhere and widely used, but they remain niche.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by voisin on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:19PM (#38200733)
Because there are currently cheaper options. Those are last mile, high hanging fruit solutions.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:11PM (#38201090)
gravity batteries and geothermal are too expensive to be competitive, except in the niches of pumped hydro, district heating, very polar regions, and stranded assets from before pv and wind got so cheap
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by angiosperm on Thursday November 09, 2023 @04:21PM (#38211520)
Incidentally, the only viable gravity batteries known today are pumped hydro reservoirs. On the up side, they only need a hill. On the down side, they need a hill.

(Gravity Vault, BTW, is 100% scam.)

Suspending weights from ocean platforms (e.g. scrapped supertankers), for flat places with deep sea nearby, should be a viable alternative, but it has not been done yet. Deep cave systems are another, either draining water into them or (for those below the water table) pumping air in. There are a lot of deep caves.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by bradbot on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:20PM (#38200243)
Is it possible to transport wind / solar energy across the country via high powered transmission lines?
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by monero-xmr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:24PM (#38200281)
No, because of physics you lose more power the longer distance it travels. It is also very expensive and difficult to build a network that can move power great distances to where it's needed given how dense the areas that need it are (major cities).
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by bobthepanda on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:12PM (#38200676)
You can certainly get it to places closer, then shift those areas' power to farther away places, etc.

China has a large network of HVDC lines. Unfortunately, due to how the Chinese power market works, they're mostly underutilized, even in times of high power stress.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by threeseed on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:51PM (#38200508)
Sun Cable, formerly known as PowerLink, is an ambitious idea that involves sending solar power via an undersea cable 4,200 kilometers (2,610 miles) from Darwin, Australia, to Singapore.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Australia-Asia_Power_Link

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by cesarb on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:18PM (#38200731)
Yes, and it's already done today; for instance, in Brazil these high power transmission lines transport wind power from the northeast region (which has lots of wind due to favorable geography) to the southeast region (where most of the electricity consumption is). The total distance is on the order of 2000 km.

(A fun fact: many of these high power transmission lines were originally to send power from the hydroelectric power plants in the southeast region to the water-starved northeast region. With the rapid expansion of wind power in the northeast region, the usual direction of the flow has reversed, and it's not uncommon for that wind power to provide over a quarter of the power for the whole country.)

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by monero-xmr on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:18PM (#38201142)
Genuinely curious - why is wind power being cancelled in the North East because it isn't cost competitive, if it's so easy to do?

https://apnews.com/article/offshore-wind-orsted-cancellation...

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:40AM (#38201874)
you're confusing the northeast of brazil, which is what cesar was talking about, with the northeast of the usa

these are not just in different countries but in vastly different climates in different hemispheres

the exact page you linked in your comment literally answers your question: 'due to problems with supply chains, higher interest rates and a failure to obtain the amount of tax credits the company wanted. ... High inflation, supply chain disruptions and the rising cost of capital and building materials are making projects more expensive while developers are trying to get the first large U.S. offshore wind farms opened.'

maybe you should have read it

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by monero-xmr on Thursday November 09, 2023 @07:22AM (#38204087)
It’s strange because wind is supposedly overwhelmingly cheaper and better, yet even with tons of government subsidies and political will behind it, it still can’t be built. Wouldn’t something truly more cost effective be easy to build because it’s cheaper? Clearly something doesn’t add up.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by cesarb on Thursday November 09, 2023 @08:25AM (#38204686)
> It’s strange because wind is supposedly overwhelmingly cheaper and better

There's two kinds of wind power: onshore and offshore. Their costs are different, with onshore being cheaper. The ones in Brazil are all onshore, while the one in the article you linked to is offshore. In the USA, offshore is even more complicated because of the Jones Act (it needs specialized ships to transport and erect the structures, while onshore needs only common cranes).

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:17PM (#38208623)
obviously enough, numerous projects that are profitable when you can finance them at 1% become unprofitable when you have to finance them at 6%, particularly when you're competing with incumbent assets financed at 1%

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/FEDFUNDS

feb 02022, 0.08% interest. since august, 5.33%

nothing is easy to build in the usa; it's halfway to being zimbabwe

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by nimeni on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:43AM (#38201898)
Because the Jones Act of 1920 prevents use of the existing European installation ships so they have to start from scratch in uncompetitive American shipyards.

https://spectrumlocalnews.com/nc/charlotte/news/2023/04/03/t...

https://www.cato.org/policy-analysis/rust-buckets-how-jones-...

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:51AM (#38201936)
this is just one of many factors, and one that was understood by oersted when they originally started the project; the article mentions others that are more relevant

in particular, you should expect to see many, many cancelled projects across the entire economy with the interest rate hikes the usa put in place

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by mrguyorama on Thursday November 09, 2023 @03:38PM (#38210889)
There are mild externalities assumed and feared about offshore wind, despite it being pretty good in a multitude of ways. States are playing a dumb game, because we would be better off if there was lots of offshore wind, but each state individually is better off having offshore wind SOMEWHERE ELSE.

For example, here in maine, our premier engineering school has spent two decades now being a premier wind energy investment and research institution, and we have minted hundreds and hundreds of trained people into the field, yet our Democrat governor still decided to sign a bill that bans offshore wind, something that Orono has explicitly invested into for years.

Our state desperately needs new generation to bring power costs down, but there's no real incentive for anyone to do so (why build new supply to bring down your own revenue?) and apparently the state government has zero interest to help itself there.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by iamthemonster on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:54PM (#38200998)
Ignore the sibling comment, it is definitely possible, typically via HVDC transmission. With 3% losses per 1000km, HVDC transmission of variable renewable energy is absolutely part of our future energy systems.

Wind is especially well suited to this - to a certain extent it's always windy SOMEWHERE whereas with solar you ain't generating any at night, no matter what.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by cesarb on Thursday November 09, 2023 @12:27AM (#38201503)
> whereas with solar you ain't generating any at night, no matter what.

Nitpicking: that's only the case for photovoltaics. Solar thermal can store the heat for a while, and keep generating even after the sun goes down.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @02:51AM (#38202241)
solar thermal is dead tho

just like other thermal power plants, it's too expensive to compete with pv and wind

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by cesarb on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:06PM (#38200626)
> I am still very confused how power will be generated cleanly on cloudy, no-wind days with solar and wind.

You are making it harder by adding that "cleanly" requirement, because the simple answer is going to be "natural gas". Unlike coal or nuclear, natural gas power plants are fast to start and stop (hydroelectric is even faster, but depends on favorable geography), so they can be left powered down (using no fuel) until they're necessary; and both overbuilding wind and solar, and spreading them over a wider area, can reduce the amount of time where that natural gas (or hydroelectric) backup is necessary.

By requiring a perfect solution (100% clean), you are excluding the 90% solution which is already possible, and which can be incrementally enhanced to get closer and closer to that 100% goal (by adding more wind and solar, by strengthening the interconnections so the generation is spread over a wider area, by sprinkling a bit of storage like batteries or reversible hydroelectric, and even by dynamically reducing consumption when there's a generation shortage).

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by StillBored on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:40PM (#38200884)
funded by backdoor taxes if texas is any indication. Prop 7 passed, which is basically just shifting the cost of grid reliability from the energy companies to the tax payers. So now you get to pay top dollar for the energy which is 50%+ carbon sources, while also paying to keep the plants operating from the general budget.

Its like a wet dream for those energy traders.

https://ballotpedia.org/Texas_Proposition_7,_Creation_of_Sta...

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by bobthepanda on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:11PM (#38200662)
Reversible hydro is actually pretty possible in much of the world, particularly the US, because all you need is something bowl-shaped at a high elevation. Pumped hydro for the most part needs storage measured in hours or days, and something like the size of Lake Mead behind Hoover Dam is overkill.

It's also more advantageous than regular hydro, because it does not need to be in the path of flowing water, so you avoid issues with silting up, lack of suitable locations, it's much less environmentally destructive, etc.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by camel_gopher on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:39PM (#38201250)
The problem with this 90% solution is that the more renewables are added, the more natural gas capacity is required to cover the capacity. Good problem for the natural gas industry.

Going clean with nuclear isn’t cheap right now, and it shouldn’t be. It wasn’t at the start of renewables when solar was expensive.

Cheap, reliable, clean; pick two.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by cesarb on Thursday November 09, 2023 @12:20AM (#38201459)
> The problem with this 90% solution is that the more renewables are added, the more natural gas capacity is required to cover the capacity.

That can be the case only if the demand also increases. If the demand stays the same, adding more wind and solar can only decrease how much the natural gas power plants are used, and the required capacity (that is, how much they can produce at full power) either stays the same or decreases (if the newly added wind and solar are non-correlated enough to reduce the chance of all of them "going dark" at the same time).

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:47AM (#38201913)
or if existing plants shut down, for example coal and nuclear plants

they are in fact shutting down in many cases because they can't compete with renewables, and the result is that more grid-scale storage or peaker capacity (or demand response!) is needed

but this is a good kind of problem to have, if you replace 900 megawatts (produced) of coal with 400 megawatts (produced, not nameplate) of solar and 500 megawatts of gas, you've still cut carbon emissions by two thirds, and lowered electricity prices at the same time

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by pasttense01 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:00PM (#38208412)
There already is a massive amount of natural gas generating capacity. But if this capacity is used one tenth as much as it is currently used it will only use one tenth as much natural gas and will last much longer.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by natmaka on Saturday November 11, 2023 @01:03AM (#38227984)
Indeed, and EV's batteries will become more and more significant ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle-to-grid ), as will the clean backup provided by green hydrogen (obtained thanks to electricity overproduced by renewables, then fed to turbo-alternators during periods of insufficient production).
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by atoav on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:52PM (#38200980)
The thing about cloudy no wind days is:

1. These are conditions that don't coincidence as often as one would think

2. If they do happen at the same time they are limited to certain places

Now the only thing you need to have your solar and wind installations not in one place and make sure it is unlikely enough to have all of them inoperational at once.

If you have the proper energy storage and a big enough grid that can balance itself this is totally doable.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by vegetablepotpie on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:10PM (#38201083)
It’s possible to build mostly renewable grids today with existing technology without nuclear. For example Marin Clean Energy generates over 90% of its energy from carbon free sources [1].

Storage and batteries are the key. Although lithium ion has limitations in the use case of long term discharge and storage, new chemistries are becoming commercially available that are appropriate for grid scale power. Iron Air batteries are made out of cheap, common materials, can discharge for up to 100 hours and can store power for long periods of time. Form Energy is building a plant in West Virginia that will produce these batteries and will open in 2024 [2].

Renewables are getting increasingly cheaper. Storage is increasingly more available. The writing is on the wall. Renewables are going to win out and it’s going to happen much sooner than conventional wisdom says.

[1] https://www.mcecleanenergy.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/20...

[2] https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/form-energy-build-lo...

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by pfdietz on Thursday November 09, 2023 @10:32PM (#38214761)
Why would you move the hydrogen? It would be generated near a storage cavern, stored there, then brought up and burned in turbines there.

Also, moving hydrogen by truck is a nonstarter. Pipelines are much better.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by gravitronic on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:49PM (#38200487)
A harder stumbling block compared to nuclear is land mass requirements per Mwh:

https://ourworldindata.org/land-use-per-energy-source

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by threeseed on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:53PM (#38200530)
There are many parts of the world that are uninhabitable because it is too hot.

The perfect location for solar installations.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by atoav on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:39PM (#38200873)
[delayed]
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by fao_ on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:16PM (#38200699)
And the world production of food far exceeds the world's population, yes.

The difficulty, as always, is logistics and economics.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by downvotetruth on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:16PM (#38200702)
You used the word inhabitable. I do not think it means what you think it means.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by threeseed on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:28PM (#38200791)
I have edited to mean uninhabitable.

e.g. places like outback Australia where it reaches 50C and is a long distance from water.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by atoav on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:42PM (#38200894)
So the solar panels will have dust and extremely harsh temperature cycles. I don't have any source on that, but I don't think the gained efficiency from the hot sun is going to outweigh the pain (and efficiency loss) from maintaining that efficiency in such an environment.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:36AM (#38201853)
typically desert solar farms have higher capacity factors, like 25% to 29%, than non-desert solar farms, which are typically more like 20%, or 10% in very polar countries like the uk, germany, or the netherlands; possibly faster degradation will eventually reverse the relationship, but for the time being the gained efficiency from the hot sun does seem to outweigh the efficiency loss

as an ai language model, i cannot feel pain

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by downvotetruth on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:38PM (#38214428)
Places would be better described by unhabitable as the boundary is not fixed.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by readthenotes1 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:20PM (#38200739)
I think they confused "hot" with "wet"
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by CRConrad on Monday November 13, 2023 @07:09AM (#38249309)
That happens all too often in other contexts too.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:14PM (#38200690)
no because even though pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt (not per megawatt hour; please get your units straight) it still uses two orders of magnitude less land than is available

please do the math instead of posting random bullshit withoutany regard to whether or not it is true

i did

https://dercuano.github.io/notes/solar-economics.html

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by jcranmer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:37PM (#38200855)
If this is the math you did:

> A crude calculation (earthradius_equatorial^2 * pi * (1000 W/m^2) * 1 year in units(1) --- gosh, Unix is great!) suggests that the total solar energy falling on the earth is about 40000 * 10^20 joules per year.

... that's not a good approximation. There's someone who actually has done less crude math for maximum possible solar energy, at least for the UK: https://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_38.shtml (though the HTML version is somewhat annoying because it's still paginated as if it were a book). Spoiler alert: it's roughly enough energy to cover total transportation energy demand, nowhere near total energy demand in the UK.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by atoav on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:47PM (#38200939)
I mean UK isn't quite known for its sunny weather, right? I would guess in Norway during the dark part of the year it is even going to be worse.

The farther north you go the more relevant technologies like wind energy and geothermal will become.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:12PM (#38201101)
and maybe nuclear or synfuel. also, the farther south; there used to be a nuclear reactor in mcmurdo
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:54PM (#38200999)
you would look much less foolish if you read more than just the introduction to my notes; i did a great deal more math than that

while i appreciate mackay's calculations a great deal, his estimates for very polar countries such as the uk are not generally applicable, and even for the uk are probably conditioned on overly pessimistic assumptions; he would undoubtedly agree if he were alive today

but i do think it's plausible that without wind the uk would have to continue importing energy from abroad, as it has done since the 19th century, unless it goes nuclear

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by jcranmer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:22PM (#38201165)
> you would look much less foolish if you read more than just the introduction to my notes; i did a great deal more math than that

Perhaps, but I see nothing in your post that actually corrects for effective solar irradiation on Earth, or for the fact that half the Earth's surface is by definition not receiving any sunlight at any given time, or for the fact that most of the Earth is water and not land (although I suppose you dropping the 4 from the multiplier for the surface area is meant to account for that). In other words, at no point did I see anything that took into account the error I pointed out.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:37PM (#38201237)
you didn't point out any errors; maybe you noticed one and forgot to mention it

if you're interested in taking the capacity factor into account, which accounts for things like night, clouds, and oblique illumination, a number of my other notes in https://dercuano.github.io/topics/solar.html (linked from the bottom of my above-linked note) do that; for example in https://dercuano.github.io/notes/japan-energy-autarky.html i calculated that energy autarky for japan, if purely solar, would require 5% of its land area and about 1.7 trillion euros of solar modules, taking into account all of those factors as well as panel efficiency. since then, the price has dropped by more than a factor of 2, but the land area required remains about the same

of course, the real-life solution also involves wind and grid-scale storage

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Saturday November 11, 2023 @12:12AM (#38227821)
> you didn't point out any errors; maybe you noticed one and forgot to mention it. please let me know if so

i'm still waiting, it's been two days

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by D_Alex on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:53PM (#38200988)
>pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt (not per megawatt hour; please get your units straight)

"Per MWhr" is a better measure when comparing intermittent-power generation such as wind and solar.

>posting random bullshit

^^

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:58PM (#38201022)
you can and should use 'per megawatt produced' rather than 'per megawatt nameplate capacity' when comparing things like solar to things like nuclear

but intermittency is irrelevant to basic incommensurability of units; neither nuclear nor solar uses more and more land over time to produce a constant amount of power, which is what 'land per megawatt hour' implies

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by gravitronic on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:08PM (#38201072)
> pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt

Glad we agree

If anyone's reading this and wants a decent resource I suggest Bill Gates's book How to Avoid a Climate Disaster

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:26AM (#38201815)
i suggest learning the basics of the field, so you can do a modicum of critical thinking, instead of parroting talking points from thought leaders
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by jillesvangurp on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:04PM (#38201055)
I would call that a minor hurdle. There's actually no shortage of unused land. Or roofs. And agrivoltaics (combining solar with farming) is a thing. And wind turbines and farms are a common combination as well. And we have off shore wind, and floating offshore wind. Which you can combine with solar. Floating solar to limit evaporation in hydro basins is also a thing.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday November 09, 2023 @11:44AM (#38207322)
Their data source suggests that rooftop solar, onshore and offshore wind and nuclear are basically tied on that metric so not sure what problem you're seeing?

Is it the ground mounted grid solar? I'm sure some countries will happily trade extra land use for much cheaper energy.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by Ericson2314 on Thursday November 09, 2023 @09:23AM (#38205333)
The problem is those prices are wrong; they are pricing the hard thing.

Renewable sells when it wants to, for dirt cheap. And they don't sell when they don't want to. At that point, today, typically natural gas picks up the ball. Other storage is as much in its infancy as SMRs, as is "demand response".

The pricing people compare so favorably isn't pure renewables, it's that renewables + fall back fossil mix.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by matthewdgreen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @10:56AM (#38206620)
This is true. And it also highlights what the part I don't understand about these nuclear investments.

Absent massive government subsidies, any nuclear-based solution has to compete against the renewable + fossil mix, which is dramatically cheaper than any nuclear solution. That means any nuclear investments will have to operate in a pretty unfavorable market until renewables reach a saturation point (maybe 50% of energy generation or more.) That point is still somewhere in the future.

It's not clear when that saturation point will arrives (or if it will), but when that happens today's nuclear investors will also have to "bet" that storage costs won't have dropped to the point where storage eats a big chunk of the market for nuclear generation. And finally: in the course of taking this risky long term bet, nuclear manufacturers will have to build out huge amounts of manufacturing capacity so they can actually meet market demand.

Anyway, the whole thing seems like a pretty risky bet. Maybe not such a risky bet if the technology was mature, but very risky given the fact that storage is relatively mature and basically needs a lot of manufacturing and process tweaks to wipe out the benefits of nuclear.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by ZeroGravitas on Thursday November 09, 2023 @11:10AM (#38206855)
Renewables have a lumpy profile of energy provided. Nuclear has a flat profile.

But demand is also lumpy, so the issues of maching supply to load are basically identical.

What do you think France uses all the gas on its grid for? Why do they have excess electricity in the middle of the night that they need to tempt people to use domestically or export to other countries?

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by Ericson2314 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @10:06PM (#38341777)
My understanding is that newer nuclear is better and ramping up and down? Perhaps SMRs can also help with this too? (e.g. turning on and off individual SMRs as a sort of "dithering".)