News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:14PM (#38200690)
no because even though pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt (not per megawatt hour; please get your units straight) it still uses two orders of magnitude less land than is available

please do the math instead of posting random bullshit withoutany regard to whether or not it is true

i did

https://dercuano.github.io/notes/solar-economics.html

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by jcranmer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:37PM (#38200855)
If this is the math you did:

> A crude calculation (earthradius_equatorial^2 * pi * (1000 W/m^2) * 1 year in units(1) --- gosh, Unix is great!) suggests that the total solar energy falling on the earth is about 40000 * 10^20 joules per year.

... that's not a good approximation. There's someone who actually has done less crude math for maximum possible solar energy, at least for the UK: https://www.withouthotair.com/c6/page_38.shtml (though the HTML version is somewhat annoying because it's still paginated as if it were a book). Spoiler alert: it's roughly enough energy to cover total transportation energy demand, nowhere near total energy demand in the UK.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by atoav on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:47PM (#38200939)
I mean UK isn't quite known for its sunny weather, right? I would guess in Norway during the dark part of the year it is even going to be worse.

The farther north you go the more relevant technologies like wind energy and geothermal will become.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:12PM (#38201101)
and maybe nuclear or synfuel. also, the farther south; there used to be a nuclear reactor in mcmurdo
Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:54PM (#38200999)
you would look much less foolish if you read more than just the introduction to my notes; i did a great deal more math than that

while i appreciate mackay's calculations a great deal, his estimates for very polar countries such as the uk are not generally applicable, and even for the uk are probably conditioned on overly pessimistic assumptions; he would undoubtedly agree if he were alive today

but i do think it's plausible that without wind the uk would have to continue importing energy from abroad, as it has done since the 19th century, unless it goes nuclear

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by jcranmer on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:22PM (#38201165)
> you would look much less foolish if you read more than just the introduction to my notes; i did a great deal more math than that

Perhaps, but I see nothing in your post that actually corrects for effective solar irradiation on Earth, or for the fact that half the Earth's surface is by definition not receiving any sunlight at any given time, or for the fact that most of the Earth is water and not land (although I suppose you dropping the 4 from the multiplier for the surface area is meant to account for that). In other words, at no point did I see anything that took into account the error I pointed out.

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:37PM (#38201237)
you didn't point out any errors; maybe you noticed one and forgot to mention it

if you're interested in taking the capacity factor into account, which accounts for things like night, clouds, and oblique illumination, a number of my other notes in https://dercuano.github.io/topics/solar.html (linked from the bottom of my above-linked note) do that; for example in https://dercuano.github.io/notes/japan-energy-autarky.html i calculated that energy autarky for japan, if purely solar, would require 5% of its land area and about 1.7 trillion euros of solar modules, taking into account all of those factors as well as panel efficiency. since then, the price has dropped by more than a factor of 2, but the land area required remains about the same

of course, the real-life solution also involves wind and grid-scale storage

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Saturday November 11, 2023 @12:12AM (#38227821)
> you didn't point out any errors; maybe you noticed one and forgot to mention it. please let me know if so

i'm still waiting, it's been two days

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by D_Alex on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:53PM (#38200988)
>pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt (not per megawatt hour; please get your units straight)

"Per MWhr" is a better measure when comparing intermittent-power generation such as wind and solar.

>posting random bullshit

^^

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:58PM (#38201022)
you can and should use 'per megawatt produced' rather than 'per megawatt nameplate capacity' when comparing things like solar to things like nuclear

but intermittency is irrelevant to basic incommensurability of units; neither nuclear nor solar uses more and more land over time to produce a constant amount of power, which is what 'land per megawatt hour' implies

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by gravitronic on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:08PM (#38201072)
> pv uses orders of magnitude more land per megawatt

Glad we agree

If anyone's reading this and wants a decent resource I suggest Bill Gates's book How to Avoid a Climate Disaster

Re:First planned small nuclear reactor plant in the US has b... by kragen on Thursday November 09, 2023 @01:26AM (#38201815)
i suggest learning the basics of the field, so you can do a modicum of critical thinking, instead of parroting talking points from thought leaders