News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by afavour on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:14AM (#38190536)
I disagree about your assessment of the early internet. It was extremely white and nerdy when looked at on average. Certainly diversity was out there but it wasn’t easily found, much like the fediverse today.

Even Wikipedia (not that it counts as early internet):

> I knew that early Wikipedia editors were (and kinda still are) academically-inclined hacker dudes, but it's crazy when you realize the article about mole day, created January 2002, is an entire year older than the article "hip hop music" and five years older than "fashion show"

https://twitter.com/depthsofwiki/status/1716655903695425695

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by OfSanguineFire on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:34AM (#38190829)
By 1995 I was regularly interacting on the internet with Japanese, people in the former USSR (who wouldn't necessarily be considered "white"), Romanians, etc. What was special is that when those people had political and social views that may have differed from one's own, but were representative of their countries, they could air those views. And the result was that a user of the nascent internet could learn about the world's diversity of societies and views.

Mastodon's federation policies, which require mod instances to police anti-LGBT speech for example, expressly excludes that. If you spend any time on the Nigerian internet, for instance, you see this is a matter that ordinary people are strident about, but they would be unwelcome in the fediverse except for those few, often westernized+hipsterized people whose views conform to what the Mastodon founding generation is comfortable with. Don't people in, say, sub-Saharan Africa, or the Middle East, or (Great Firewall aside) China have the right to join this ecosystem and still be the ordinary representatives of their societies that they are?

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by afavour on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:49AM (#38191118)
I think “political and social views” covers a very wide range of thought. For instance, an avowed Nazi would not have been welcome in a holocaust survivors newsgroup in the early internet. Someone who is “anti-LGBT” to the extent that they wish those people dead have a similarly extreme view and I’m not surprised that they are policed.

> they would be unwelcome on the Fediverse

I think part of the problem here is central identities. Someone with anti-LGBT views would be entirely welcome in, say, a Lemmy community dedicated to software engineering… because they wouldn’t be discussing LGBT issues and no one would know. But because we have this notion of identity that persists between communities they may find themselves censored because of statements they made somewhere else.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:19AM (#38191590)
You don't need to be very anti rainbow ideology (which should be distinguished from simply being gay, for example: "Listen to gay people" never means Douglas Murray or the Gays Against Groomers organization, for example, because they may be gay but they have the wrong politics) to be tossed from most spaces rainbow activist types moderate.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:31AM (#38191808)
There's a reason there's other letters besides 'G', and "a minority can be hostile to another minority" isn't a new idea.

Of course a person gets booted for attacking other members of the community regardless of who they are.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:51AM (#38192107)
The point is: "anti-LGBT" is much more about politics and ideology than it is about the actual minorities - the minorities are used as a shield against criticism by activist types, who claim critiquing their ideology is hating those minorities. The typical rhetoric is also highly exaggerating, where if I disagree with the sensibility of trans identification, for example, people will readily accuse me of "denying their existence", as if disagreeing with one idea they hold invalidates their entire person (well, I guess it could if they really have no other content in their heads), when it's just one idea.

Same with being pro-LGBT: The activists aren't pro gay people, or pro black, or pro transpeople. They don't want me listening to Douglas Murray, or Gays Against Groomers, or Thomas Sowell. They definitely aren't pro Scott Newgent of "What is a woman?" fame. They're pro rainbow ideologue people. The politics is the point, the minority status simply a convenient shield from criticism and hate claims a cudgel to beat people over the head with.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:29PM (#38195661)
> The activists aren't pro gay people, or pro black, or pro transpeople. They don't want me listening to Douglas Murray, or Gays Against Groomers, or Thomas Sowell.

I think you're committing the error of treating social categories as set-theoretic absolutes when humans are far more multidimensional.

It's like "Well they're not really patriots; they tell me Americans are great but they don't want me talking to Benedict Arnold or Aaron Burr." No, they don't, because those Americans were traitors who hurt their fellow countrymen. "Listen to more LGBTQ voices" and "Don't listen to Gays Against Groomers" aren't actually contradictory concepts; 'listen to' doesn't mean 'give equal, uncritical weight to every'.

The missing sociological tool you may want to dive in on is 'Intersectionality,' which is the concept of how one's privilege is contextual and multidimensional factor; a person can be both oppressed and oppressor.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by marcusverus on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:33AM (#38192819)
Lefties always rationalize their embrace of illiberal tactics like censorship by citing extreme cases (“we just want to filter out people who want us dead”), only to turn around and apply the tactic very broadly (wrongthink = permanban). This Motte-and-Bailey fallacy is the rhetorical lever which has allowed the left to crybully millions of erstwhile liberals into becoming so many cheerleaders for censorship.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by afavour on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:36PM (#38194823)
You’re putting words in peoples mouths here. I’m not LGBT but it’s my understanding that many LGBT folks are open about wanting to block beyond just extreme cases. They wish to participate in a community of shared values, which is hardly a new notion. What is new is that the blurred lines of public vs private spaces has confused everyone’s concept of “free speech”.

An LGBT community is in no way obliged to listen to anti-LGBT voices. In the same way that an unlocked front door is not an invitation for me to enter, the fact that many of these communities are on public platforms doesn’t guarantee your access. Nor is being blocked from that community a strike against free speech: you are able to speak freely in any other location of your choice.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by marcusverus on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:21PM (#38196370)
> You’re putting words in peoples mouths here.

I call it like I see it.

> I’m not LGBT but it’s my understanding that many LGBT folks are open about wanting to block beyond just extreme cases. They wish to participate in a community of shared values, which is hardly a new notion.

Nobody cares about gatekeeping in niche communities. The problem is when niche groups enter larger communities and employ the tried-and-true Motte and Bailey harangue for censorship, which ultimately ends up becoming political and problematic, as with old twitter.

> What is new is that the blurred lines of public vs private spaces has confused everyone’s concept of “free speech”.

What’s new is erstwhile liberals abandoning their commitment to open discourse, advocating for corporations to police speech, and boycotting/organizing against corporations who commit the sin of platforming wrongthink.

> An LGBT community is in no way obliged to listen to anti-LGBT voices. In the same way that an unlocked front door is not an invitation for me to enter.

Agreed! But nor should LGBT voices be permitted (or, rather, used) to dictate rules to everyone else on the planet.

> Nor is being blocked from that community a strike against free speech: you are able to speak freely in any other location of your choice.

This is a cynical and deeply authoritarian take. Does first amendment apply to social media? Of course it doesn’t. The first amendment prevents the federal government from squashing speech, because they can’t be trusted with such power over the people. Are you of the opinion that a power that’s considered too corrupting to be wielded by our elected officials can be responsibly wielded by unelected technocrats?

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by gvurrdon on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:54AM (#38193195)
Your comment reminds me of a time I was a member of a sports club. One other member was thrown out as they were revealed in a newspaper article to also be an active member of a neo-Nazi organisation. But, they'd never said or done anything that gave the slightest hint of it and appeared to be quite pleasant and liked within the club.

I wonder if anyone in the sports club would ever have noticed if it weren't for a journalist looking into that neo-Nazi group.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by 2devnull on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:01AM (#38191300)
It was much more diverse back then only if you were looking for or desiring that diversity. I was drawn to it for that reason, the foreign languages, the strangeness. I feel like the same people now who prefer homogenization of their internet are people who never experienced that diversity. Because they are people who don’t really like diversity, not in the literal sense. They like a certain type of diversity, which is how the internet got ruined.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:25AM (#38191718)
I'd be interested to learn more. What is the bad kind of diversity, and what is the good kind of diversity?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:34AM (#38191856)
Presumably: The bad sort is a diversity where people look different but all think more or less the same, so the proponents can pat themselves on the back for being good and openminded people but don't actually have to deal with genuinely different people. You can see it in how those sorts tend to despise people who look the same as themselves but have different views and how their love of diversity disappears the second the different-looking person doesn't hew to their ideology.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by RationalDino on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#38192178)
The bad kind of diversity is projecting your ideology onto others, and deciding to like them. The good kind of diversity is attempting to understand what it would be like to think in ways that are alien to you.

To consider current events, let's take Hamas. Hamas is a deeply conservative and radicalized group. They believe in banning abortion, killing gays, killing Jews, and that atheists are evil. This is not slander, they would agree with all of this. And there are good historical reasons why they believe these things.

Suppose that you're LBGTQ+ and aren't a member of a church, and are carrying a sign saying, "Palestine will be free from sea to sea." What are you actually supporting? You're supporting people who are brown and oppressed, who in turn would like to see you dead. Now it may be that in your ideology it is worth this on ethical principles. But most people like that who I've dealt with simply ignore the fact that they are supporting people who believe in banning abortion, killing gays, killing Jews, and that atheists are evil. And then are caught by surprise if they encounter the fact that Hamas believes in banning abortion, killing gays, killing Jews, and that atheists are evil. (And try to forget that they heard it.)

I, personally, like knowing a diverse group of people. And understanding them for who they are. I may disagree with them violently, but I still like trying to understand them. But this requires a very different kind of tolerance than most progressives preach. For a start, you can't start by banning intolerant speech. Because there is no way to express the intolerant views that many people actually have without being willing to listen to (though not agree with) intolerant speech.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by 2devnull on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:58PM (#38196040)
Like San Francisco used to be more diverse, that’s what I’m getting at. People will argue that point, because the word diversity has taken on different meanings. I’d say there is diverse-diversity and less-diverse-diversity. I prefer one thing, other people are more tribal and prefer that other structure. Both types are needed, but I think we could use a bit more diverse-diversity at the moment, to increase dynamism. Mix things up a bit. At least with respect to the internet.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:08PM (#38196201)
Interesting. If I'm understanding the analogy to San Fran's past diversity, you mean like it used to be far more multicultural-but-overlapping and now it's a bit more homogeneous-techbro even though a lot of people from different backgrounds still live there?

If I've understood correctly... Yeah, I don't know if it's for good or ill but I think we see less of that kind of diversity as the enlargement of the Internet allows people to build virtual communities that are more like-minded and have less need to tolerate uncomfortable differences (in that you have the option of going somewhere else instead of "putting up with the asshole next door" because this is the only online space that caters to the thing you like).

On the other hand, I have no strategy to force people to coexist in the same virtual space when they don't want to, nor do I have concrete evidence that's even a desired outcome.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by pastage on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:04AM (#38191343)
> [nigerians] would be unwelcome in the fediverse except for those few, often westernized+hipsterized people

Considering people are sentenced to death by stoning for being LGBTQ in Nigeria. It is easy to understand why this might be an issue worth policing if you can.. Is it sane to fedderate with people who might be killed for what they interact with on your fediverse. Ordinary people does include gay people you know.

There is nothing hindering the ones who want to kill all gays to run their own fediverse.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by EricE on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:13AM (#38191492)
Ah yes, the noble bigotry argument. Historically that's never, ever lead to disaster.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by wwweston on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:30AM (#38191797)
The disaster has already happened in your skull if you think that it’s bigotry to wall off death penalty by orientation class from discourse.

For balance, I’d suggest healthy direct exposure to discourse calling for your own death, and if you like we can even provide that.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by pastage on Wednesday November 15, 2023 @11:05AM (#38278208)
It is quite hard to understand short comments. What are the relevant disasters you are talking about in this instance?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by t-3 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:12AM (#38191473)
You seem to be viewing the fediverse as a blob, but it's actually a federated network. There's no need to join an instance if you don't like the moderation!
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:16AM (#38191535)
The point is that the federation mechanism explicitly means that any server that is federated will have to follow those policies, because the admins of all the large servers hew to a certain ideology that will not tolerate dissent from key talking points. So the server can technically speaking exist on the protocol but in practice won't be federated with the broader network unless it's palatable to Californicated activist types.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by t-3 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:30AM (#38191789)
What's wrong with that, though? Forcing people who don't want to interact to interact in the name of diversity isn't likely to lead anywhere productive. Those who are so heavily invested in their political views that they don't want to speak with anyone who they don't fully agree with will be siloed, and those who want diversity can be federated more broadly.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by kelseyfrog on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:34AM (#38191855)
This reads like, "I don't like it because my messages won't end up on other servers," which I guess that's fine. We have to be cognizant that no one running a server is obligated technically, socially, or morally to platform anyone's speech because doing so would violate the NAP of admins.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seti0Cha on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:14AM (#38192506)
Sure, and the result of which is an echo chamber, which was OPs point. I didn't see anyone complaining that their own speech was being suppressed. Does anyone question that it's ideologically homogeneous? It seems to me the question is, is that a good thing or a bad thing.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by kelseyfrog on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:32AM (#38192799)
"I don't see anyone questioning, so we must conclude it's true," is epistemological laziness. Any hypothesis must be testable and actually tested before believed otherwise it's religion. JTB applies here too.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seti0Cha on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:09PM (#38193456)
What the heck are you even talking about? I'm not running experiments, I'm trying to have a conversation. Do you or do you not believe the fediverse is ideologically homogeneous? I see people here arguing that it is, but that it is justifiably so. I don't see anyone clearly claiming it's not, but someone might. I think it is homogeneous for the very reasons you gave (i.e. people are not obliged to propagate speech they think is bad), but I'm not sure whether I think that's a good or a bad thing. If you think I'm wrong about it being ideologically homogeneous, feel free to tell me. If you want to weigh in on whether that's a good or bad thing, please do, that's why I asked the question. If you really want to challenge my epistemological standing to offer an opinion at all, well, I guess we're done here.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by kelseyfrog on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:32PM (#38193859)
I'm saying that while believing in unfalsifiable beliefs or refusing to falsify them is certainly anyone's prerogative, I have to ask, why would anyone want to do that?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seti0Cha on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:52PM (#38194180)
You're cracking me up. I should stop responding, but I can't help but wonder if you'll respond with this same sort of thing even if I say random stuff. I think pumpkin ravioli is overrated. What do you say to that?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by kelseyfrog on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:15PM (#38194498)
Sounds like a personal opinion! I believe that you think that :D
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by t-3 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#38193671)
The fediverse is not ideologically or politically homogenous, there exist right-wing and apolitical instances, there exist instances targeted at exclusive and obscure subgroups, etc. If you never bother to look beyond the most popular instances, you obviously won't see many unpopular views.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seti0Cha on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:18PM (#38194557)
I think there's a terminology issue here. If the left and the right servers are never federated, then the experience will be homogeneous even if the fediverse is itself not. In other words, I probably shouldn't not have used the term homogeneous and stuck with "echo chamber". I was trying to avoid that term because of its pejorative connotations. It seems to me there is value in being exposed to what people you disagree with are saying, and there's value in not having all the drama that entails, which tends dominate all discourse. The fediverse by and large has chosen the later, no?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by t-3 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:02PM (#38195240)
Experiencing homogeneity is a natural thing. Humans always self-segregate into groups when gathered in large numbers. I don't see anything wrong with people choosing an echo chamber if that makes them happy. It's being coerced into the echo chamber or the open forum that I disagree with.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seti0Cha on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:00PM (#38196930)
I more or less agree with that, but can't help but feel that a certain amount of exposure to contrary views (even though unpleasant/unwanted) is more healthy for society. It at least has the potential for defusing straw-man understandings and also keeps people realistic about where they stand with respect to the larger society in terms of beliefs and practices. I'm not sure that the Twitter model does much for that, but the longer form conversations like Facebook may.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by t-3 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @04:27PM (#38197334)
Pretty much everyone gets exposure to contrary views, and they probably wouldn't seek out echo chambers for recreation if they didn't! Most people don't actually want to argue about politics when they vent on their social media, they want to engage with their friends, who probably feel similarly to them. There's no need to worry about these conversations being unbalanced any more than you worry about balance when line workers talk shit about managers and managers talk shit about employees. If people wanted balanced conversation, they would join a political debate forum rather than a social network that connects them to their real-life friends.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by carapace on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:40AM (#38191935)
[delayed]
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:27AM (#38191761)
An alternative federation with different core tenets could exist, but it would have to do the legwork to find people interested in supporting it, build out nodes that want to be in that federation, and publicize its existence.

It's the same kind of leg work that the existing status quo of the major mastodon nodes had to undertake, and there's no reason anyone should expect that the existing status quo of Mastodon nodes would help a mastodon federation ideologically opposed to their own succeed.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by wwweston on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:47AM (#38192038)
If you literally can’t find a space where your views are palatable, then it’s possible there’s something wrong with them.

And if what you’re seeking is the privilege to compel other people who take responsibility for setting up and administering such spaces to carry / broadcast your unmoderated views regardless of their own, what we’re talking about isn’t really any principled kind of liberty.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by throwaway14356 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#38192184)
possibly, but we could also be wrong. Tell me the solution is to not talk about it but do it without the talking?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:15AM (#38191518)
There's nothing about the fediverse, as a protocol-backed set of services and nodes, that prevents a group of like-minded individuals from forming an LGBTQ hostile family of, for example, mastodon nodes. But there's also nothing about the fediverse, as a community, that compels anyone else who owns a node to host or share that content.

You are remembering experiences on forums or, depending on your age, BBSs or perhaps even USENET, the only system I can think of that was architected to move much power from the hands of the service administrators to the hands of the clients attaching to the service (and, not coincidentally, an experiment that lapsed into obsolescence because that's a terrible bargain for anybody to want to host if there are any alternatives).

The internet you are imagining still exists. It just hasn't grown because it turns out most users don't want that. But if someone wants to build a community that is LGBTQ-hostile online, all the pieces are there. They just have to do the legwork themselves because very few people will be interested in helping support that.

(I would also humbly hypothesize that most of that culture mixing you remember is because when the internet was small, people attended communities with others who had hostile worldviews to their own because it was the only community where, for example, Star Trek was being discussed and people wanted to participate in hobbies more than they cared about having to put up with phobes. Now that there's an option to join a Star Trek fan group in social media that is LGBTQ friendly versus one that isn't, the marketplace of ideas rewards one and not the other).

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by jmbwell on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:38AM (#38191908)
> Mastodon's federation policies

Perhaps you're referring to the policies of individual instance administrators, as "Mastodon" has no centralized "policies" as far as I know.

I run more than one instance, and as far as I can tell, I can manage them however I want.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by KittenInABox on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:58AM (#38192232)
How can you possibly claim that social diversity was universal in the old school internet when "tits or gtfo" was an extremely common meme for anyone who claimed to be female?

No, in my experience people mostly kept to individual federated spaces dependent on interests or demographics. LGBTQ people kept to their IRC channels, black people kept to their channels, and banned anyone who was also a member of the local nazi IRC channel. This was totally normal and I don't see a difference between 1990s era IRC and Fediverse in this respect.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by extraduder_ire on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:54PM (#38195987)
Somewhat unrelated: a few months ago, before most mastodon instances started censoring their list of servers they blocked from federating, you could just look at the rules page of almost any popular server and see a server URL and why they were blocked.

To me, this seemed counterproductive. But it was at least interesting to see the creative URLs some people come up with.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by sph on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:20AM (#38190621)
The Early Internet was white and middle class because they could afford it. But there were no recommendation algorithms or content siloes, so even if it was less diverse, it was potentially much more diverse and free than whatever we have today.

Today we have most of the world online, but they live on 5 websites, so even though it feels like there's more diversity and breadth, it has become a much more homogeneous culture.

There must be a name for this scientific phenomenon (variable increases between two spans of time, but the relative effect of it on the entire system has decreased)

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by giraffe_lady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:19AM (#38190601)
hahaha seriously. this is the internet they want to go back to.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by nkozyra on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:33AM (#38190804)
> hahaha seriously. this is the internet they want to go back to.

Well there were obviously good and bad things about it.

Some people think there's a way to be inclusive unlike the way it was once very exclusive while still embracing the general ethos of the original Internet - which was people connected directly via the infrastructure rather than through third party corporations.

We can have an inclusive internet - digital democracy, as it was once called - without walled gardens.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by giraffe_lady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:59AM (#38191281)
Can we though? That comment demonstrates very clearly that it wasn't as democratic as people are remembering.

You had a chance to make an inclusive internet, and you made an encyclopedia that was blind to the largest most significant art & cultural movement in generations. What are you going to do differently this time?

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by nkozyra on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:07AM (#38191395)
I find "we didn't, therefore we can't" a kind of defeatist and unrealistic reaction. The internet has been shaped and reshaped a few times, in a lot of ways for the better, I don't see why it couldn't continue to be refined.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by giraffe_lady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:11AM (#38191467)
I'm not taking that position, quite. But I'm not seeing much contrition for it being that way the first time around, or sophisticated evaluation of why it was, or a plan for how to improve it in the future. Without those I think the hope that it'll improve in these ways is simply naive.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by nkozyra on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:01AM (#38192281)
What I'm arguing is that we're taking 2 steps forward and 1 step back rather than a linear path of improvement. In this case one of the steps backward being the walled gardens, steps forward including the democratization of the internet as a whole.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:21PM (#38193670)
I enjoyed the tweet above as a glimpse into the past, but it's far too cherry-picked for you to use it as an indictment of the early internet. The article for 'Gangsta Rap' (May '01) predates 'Country Music' (Oct '01), 'English Language' (Nov '01) and 'Mayonnaise' (Jul '02), but you wouldn't think very highly of me if I used that to make an opposite claim.

I don't think the 'Hip Hop Music' (Apr '03) cherry-pick even holds up on its own. The creation edit says it's being taken from an already-existing page called 'Hip hop', whose history I'm unable to find.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:06PM (#38196170)
I tracked it down, the 'Hip hop' page is from June 2001.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by cbozeman on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:19AM (#38191602)
No, although I understand why such a simplistic and easily-digestible idea would be appealing to a group of people who increasingly want simple answers.

We want to go back to the Internet of thick-skinned people who rarely even blocked others, much less actively tried to get them banned.

We want to go back to the Internet where you can say wild shit and people are smart / savvy enough to know you're just being edgy and not an actual hateful person.

We want to go back to the Internet that wasn't controlled by gigantic megacorporations who have incredibly outsized influence on what people do and do not see.

In short, a lot of older Netizens want 1999 back. And for good reason.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by giraffe_lady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#38191834)
The problem with the culture of "just assume people are joking" is that some people aren't joking. The background of edgy jokes was used very effectively by actual hate movements, to massive impact.

We all have to live with the consequences of that, and one of yours is that you're not getting the benefit of the doubt on nasty jokes anymore.

You need to acknowledge that something went wrong, and then consider why it did. Rather than have this naive nostalgia for an internet culture that only existed because "thick-skinned" is a euphemism for "people not actually in danger."

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:43AM (#38191968)
Thankfully we've now moved to "joking" at the universities, where free speech is of course highly valued:

---

Whiteness is a condition one first acquires and then one has -a malignant, parasitic-like condition to which "white" people have a particular susceptibility. The condition is foundational, generating characteristic ways of being in one's body, in one's mind, and in one's world. Parasitic Whiteness renders its hosts' appetites voracious, insatiable, and perverse. These deformed appetites particularly target nonwhite peoples. Once established, these appetites are nearly impossible to eliminate. Effective treatment consists of a combination of psychic and social-historical interventions. Such interventions can reasonably aim only to reshape Whiteness's infiltrated appetites-to reduce their intensity, redistribute their aims, and occasionally turn those aims toward the work of reparation. When remembered and represented, the ravages wreaked by the chronic condition can function either as warning ("never again") or as temptation ("great again"). Memorialization alone, therefore, is no guarantee against regression. There is not yet a permanent cure.

- psychoanalyst Donald Moss, https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34039063/

---

"Whites learn to be white. That suggestion by Thandeka is that whites are not born white. They have to become white. And her suggestion is that white children who were not white originally - they were born human. Little by little, they have to be abused into becoming white humans. And this abuse is sometimes physical - of being physically disciplined into whiteness, such as being bullied into whiteness. That's a phrase I like to use, whiteness as bullying, but it's also psychological and cultural, and it becomes with caretakers and guardians. Not the least of which - the more important caretakers are of course the white family, parents etc. but it extends to the white nationhood as a caretaker, the white social system, the white social welfare, the white governance system. They also discipline and abuse white humans into whiteness."

- Education professor Zeus Lombardo

---

"White people are born to not being human"

- Ashleigh Shackleford

---

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seattle_spring on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:51AM (#38193122)
Do you typically cherry pick the most extreme and ridiculous fringe quotes to try and prove your point? Or only in this case?
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by soundnote on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:53AM (#38193173)
Just noting that openly, not at all subtly racist hatemongers somehow have jobs and are called "antiracist". And in Lombardo's case, educating our teachers this way doesn't exactly sound like a good idea.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @01:54PM (#38195128)
Hits different when they're talking about you, huh?

It's the kind of thing that could make a person want to build a space where they could talk to like-minded folk and not have to put up with that culture-jamming noise every day of their lives. Fortunately, there are more tools than have ever existed in human history to do that now.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by mavhc on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:29AM (#38191777)
You want to go back to where you could say the n-word and no one complained because there were no black people within earshot
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by giraffe_lady on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:33AM (#38191838)
ha thank you this got to the heart of it much more concisely than I could.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by 4ggr0 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:56AM (#38192202)
And what a shame that we can't really call people the f-word anymore, can't even use LGBT slurs, angrily shakes fist at the sky.

Seriously, I don't get the people who miss these things. I admit that it was funny to the 14 year old version of me to call my friends the n-word while playing Call of Duty, but rather sooner than later we understood that some things aren't edgy, just offensive, unnecessary and hurtful.

And it's not as if edgyness went away completely. Reddit has it's corners, there's plenty of *chan sites, if you search around on YouTube you'll encounter "eDgY" content (edgy in that context == "racist, anti-lgbt, mysoginistic etc.")

Netflix and YT have stand-up specials from edgy comedians. I saw more than one "edgy" Discord server, with "edgy" memes and jokes.

Also typical that a bit furter up in this comment thread, the one thing which is deemed to be wrong with Mastodon is that Anti-LGBT speech is not allowed, which somehow means that you loose diversity. Because what I want when talking to diverse people is hearing them hate gay people for absolutely no reason at all.

Anti-LGBT takes are not opinions to me. I label myself as a tolerating, open-minded person, which doesn't mean that I accept or want intolerant and closed-minded people near me, and I refuse to accept that this somehow makes me intolerant or anti-diversity.

/rant

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:44AM (#38191991)
I'm not trying to put words in your mouth, but if I may try to interpret: it sounds like you want to go back to an Internet with not nearly so many people on it, where the culture of "being online" was more homogeneous.

One can imagine why that's a problem in a world of 8 billion people, all of whom (some say) have a right to be online.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by cbozeman on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:03PM (#38195255)
Anytime someone says, "Blah blah sentiment blah blah... BUUUUUUT", what they're really saying is, "I'm doing exactly what you think I'm doing, but I don't want anyone to call me out on it!"

And just have the goddamned courage to say what you want to say to begin with. You're exactly the problem. You can't even be honest enough to say, "You just want the Internet to be white again!"

We didn't have voice communication when I was young. Sending a single high-resolution GIF took 10-15 minutes. In 1996, it took 28 minutes for me to receive a single 4 MB MP3 via DCC in IRC using mIRC. We didn't know what color anyone was. Oftentimes we didn't even know what nationality someone was. You were judged solely by the quality of your content. How good were your arguments? How cogent was your point? How well do you present yourself in communication.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by shadowgovt on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:15PM (#38195447)
> "You just want the Internet to be white again!"

I sought not to put words in your mouth because I didn't know your meaning. But if they come out of your mouth as an intepretation of my interpretation, I have to assume that's what you meant to say.

> You were judged solely by the quality of your content

I remember; I was there too. A not-insignificant portion of "quality of one's content" was whether it fit the right 'hacker' mold. How well did you present your argument? Did you use the right words? Were you savvy to the right concepts?

Those concepts were couched in the culture that originated the Internet, which leaned in a certain race, class, and gender direction. You didn't know what nationality someone was, but they got ignored if they didn't use the right words. And the choice of what words were right wasn't a democracy; it was a biased selection from the first people to trailblaze the culture, who brought their cultural baggage with them.

You and I are both old enough to remember "There are no girls on the Internet."

Now that we're building a net for 8 billion people, a lot of those norms are obsolete and over-constraining.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by carapace on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:50AM (#38192099)
The word "plonk" was coined in 1989. https://infogalactic.com/info/Plonk_(Usenet)
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by KittenInABox on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:57AM (#38193235)
> We want to go back to the Internet of thick-skinned people who rarely even blocked others, much less actively tried to get them banned.

IRC had channel-wide, server-wide blocks available since the olden days, as well as user-to-user blocking. The term "flamewar" is old school from these days where people got hella banned. Forums had trolls that were banned and re-banned, see: the age of the term "sockpuppet".

If anything discord is way more open than IRC in that respect. In IRC you can own a channel and ban anyone who comes from another channel you dislike. You cannot pre-emptively ban all members of another server from your discord server.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by cbozeman on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:06PM (#38195318)
> IRC had channel-wide, server-wide blocks available since the olden days, as well as user-to-user blocking. The term "flamewar" is old school from these days where people got hella banned. Forums had trolls that were banned and re-banned, see: the age of the term "sockpuppet".

And you had to really work to get a ban in most forums and IRC channels. You had to really step out of line - and continue stepping out of line.

Cast even a momentary glance at the things people get banned for on Reddit, or used to be banned for on Twitter.

A woman declaring, "Men are not women." is enough to have her Twitter account permanently deactivated. Try telling me that's even remotely close to how things were in the 1990s Internet.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by KittenInABox on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @02:58PM (#38196060)
> And you had to really work to get a ban in most forums and IRC channels. You had to really step out of line - and continue stepping out of line.

I disagree with this. It was easy to get kicked out of a channel for just being kinda annoying, and then if the mods just didn't like you they can just ban you. Also, like I said, it was normal to channel-ban (i.e. pre-emptively prevent any members from a channel to join yours) notorious channels.

Also yeah I would also kick people talking about "men are not women" just for being off-topic in my channel, which was about computer builds lol. If someone got kicked for being off-topic and came back and continued to be that way they got a ban for being annoying. It was super common to just ban vaguely annoying people.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by ekianjo on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:50AM (#38191126)
> It was extremely white and nerdy when looked at on average.

Nerdy = Educated, because most people joining at that time were academics or people who really wanted to use the internet despite the difficulty to get there at the time.

As for the "white" part, that's a very racist thing to say. There were a lot of people from different continents even in the early days, while of course the majority was from the US. And as far as I know, diversity of thought is not tied to the type of melanin you have in your skin.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by RationalDino on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:26AM (#38191736)
> As for the "white" part, that's a very racist thing to say.

I'm sorry, but you're taking offence at reality here.

When I got to Usenet in the early 1990s, it was clear that most users were from North America and involved with college. This group was overwhelmingly white. Furthermore at many institutions, access required learning enough Unix to run rn. A barrier to entry that favored people who were nerdy relative to the general population. Email had similar demographics at the time, for similar reasons.

Therefore it is historically accurate to say that more than 50% of users were white and nerdy, even relative to other educated people. You're right that the other users included a lot of diversity. But afavour is absolutely right about the majority.

On diversity of thought. It is absolutely true that we had diverse thinking on Usenet at that point. However it is like clustering in some high dimensional space. The existence of diversity along some dimensions of thought within some dimensions doesn't change the fact that along some other dimensions there is more diversity of thought when you include people from different backgrounds and cultures.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by elpocko on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @09:54AM (#38191186)
> It was extremely white and nerdy when looked at on average.

What did you expect? It was invented and operated by "white nerds".

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by wiseowise on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:05AM (#38191360)
> It was extremely white and nerdy when looked at on average.

Diversity of thought, my little, racist “friend”.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by DeIlliad on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:45AM (#38192013)
People of a similar background tend to have similar thoughts. If you grew up white in America or black in Africa you will have at least a few experiences that most people of your background share. Expand the amount of people with diverse background and you will get a wider range of thoughts.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by wiseowise on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:54AM (#38193180)
Whatever fits your agenda.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by throw555chip on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:07AM (#38191394)
> It was extremely white and nerdy when looked at on average.

Many of us in the world chatted and conversed (VoIP was a thing already) with people around the world in the mid-1990's.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:25AM (#38191715)
diversity doesn't imply race and anyone who thinks so is a racist.

Just as minorities are not defined by their skin color, neither are whites.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by seattle_spring on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @11:45AM (#38193000)
I always find it deeply hilarious when people online expand on their definition of "diversity of thought." Mostly because it always means more of exactly one single type of "thought".
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @12:08PM (#38193436)
As I'm fond of saying, I'll always defend your right to make such statements, but that never implies it's valid or true.
Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by lisper on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:50AM (#38192097)
> It was extremely white and nerdy

and male.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by cameronh90 on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @10:55AM (#38192180)
I suspect GP was referring to the diversity of thought as well as the diversity of race. However, I would also expect the average isn't a useful metric in this context.

The early internet didn't attempt to silo you as it had no real technical capacity for it. Maybe only (for argument's sake) ~2% of the internet back then was non-US/Europe, but that meant ~2% of the messages I read came from non-US/Europe. Nowadays, Xitter, Reddit, TikTok, etc. all have algorithms that try to fit me into a bucket with similar people, so even if now 50% of the internet is non-US/Europe, what I'm actually experiencing is far closer to 0% than it used to be.

The internet I experience now is far less diverse even than just walking down my local high street. Looking at that mastodon link, for example, is so unbelievably unrepresentative of the kind of diversity (by all axes) I experience just by going outside.

Re:Wikipedia Became the Last Good Place on the Internet by ToValueFunfetti on Wednesday November 08, 2023 @03:04PM (#38196140)
It took a bit of digging, but the page 'Hip hop' was created in June 2001. 'Hip Hop (Music)' was mostly a retitle of that page in April 2003, and what was left eventually became 'Hip Hop (culture)' by way of 'Hip hop culture'. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Hip_hop_culture&o...