Nothing good is going to come from that the vast majority of the time.
Local zoning should be local so costs/side effects/benefits are associated with decisions as closely as possible.
Otherwise, it would be trivial to penalize to the point of almost destroying entire states or regions because they were on the wrong side of some ideological line on another topic. Which would then be paid back 4 or 8 years later, of course.
The US is a little bit of an outlier in having a federal system so there are some limits to what Congress can do, but there aren't to what a state can do, and some of our states (like CA and NY) are the size of countries themselves.
I'm not saying the majority of zoning decisions should be taken at the state/country level -- that would be ludicrous simply from an organizational standpoint.
I'm simply describing that states are perfectly free to override local decisions whenever necessary, with full democratic legitimacy. How do you think the interstate highway system got built?
However, almost every state already sets aside the level of control municipalities have explicitly.
Here is Texas’s
[https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/SOTWDocs/LG/htm/LG.211.ht...]
The US is one of a kind, as is every country I’ve run across.
Typically, zoning rules are the way they are (everywhere, and they are almost everywhere) because the benefits of them outweigh the perceived costs for the folks in power over that locality.
Changing them is not taken lightly because a lot of money is at stake and disruption is high.
Lots of people complain of course. But money talks, and bullshit walks.
I’m curious when things will switch from talk to actual change. Next 5ish-10ish years maybe as the boomers start aging out?
How do you think the interstate highway system got built?
The federal government appropriated a ton of land whether local people liked it or not.
Obviously the government didn't want to provoke massive unrest so it did some negotiating, but at the end of the day it did take whatever land it wanted, regardless of local opinion.
Also, regarding states ceding control of zoning to localities -- of course. That's just practical. But what the state gives, the state can take too. I'm talking about basic democratic principles, not what happens to be current law.
you might find this interesting [https://highways.dot.gov/public-roads/summer-1996/federal-ai...]
There was widespread national (bipartisan) support for it, a clear national military/security need, and it took the political capital of a very popular and trusted president to make it happen - and continuing support by his predecessors. Over 20+ years.
The federal gov’t basically proposed the overall plan, helped co-ordinate between states, and funded about half of it with the states using a cost share program (eventually increasing to 90% in some cases). The states did the actual building (and continue to do the maintenance too!) and things like right of ways, specific plans, eminent domain were handled by them.
No federal forced appropriation I’m aware of. Just co-operation and money.
But for the purposes of my argument, it's irrelevant whether the states did the eminent domain or the federal government. My point is this whole thread is that a higher power did, and localities couldn't do whatever they wanted. Your town couldn't veto the interstate passing through it.
And when the federal government is doing the planning and incentivizing with federal funds, the question of whether the eminent domain was "really" done by the federal government or the states is somewhat academic.
Again, my original point still stands completely: as a general democratic principle, when a higher level of government makes policy that conflicts with lower levels, the higher level wins. The US federal system happens to have more limits around this than most other democracies, but it's still a general principle.
The interstate detailed plans (which towns, for instance) was drafted by the states. If a state wanted to move around a town, they could (and did!). They had to roughly follow the federal plan and connect at specific points to get their share of the money, but there are tons of state level highways that have no Fed involvement - and places the states said ‘nope’ to the Fed money and did what they wanted.
It isn’t irrelevant if the states or the fed did the eminent domain - it’s a critical distinction. That it was the states is because the states are the ones who control their land and it’s usage - there is no (actual) higher power for zoning that isn’t already okay with it as-is!
That’s my point.
Now, the states can be convinced to change the rules of course (per state), but that is an entirely different situation no?
The supposed saviors have been the ones in charge the entire time!
Problem solved. A state can democratically ignore the local zoning requirements of the town, and force them to allow more housing.
That it is delegated to the local towns is because that’s what they (as in the state and the towns) wanted.
And it’s likely to stay that way unless extreme effort is put into changing it, because otherwise the local folks will usually get very angry, as you’re taking away their self determination and ability to control their immediate surroundings. And everywhere is local somewhere.
So why don’t you ask the state legislatures? They’re the ones who have always been in control here on this topic.
That's what people are doing.
California is a great recent example.
Fairly recently there were massive legal changes that are forcing local towns and cities to add significantly more housing.
(Obviously the housing situation has been bad for a long while in California, but I am talking about the recent changes which have been huge)
Those laws are going to come into effect, and forcibly over rule local zonings and housing laws.
There are other countries that work the way you suggest, but people prefer to migrate out of them rather than into them.
So it very much is how it works, but there are technical questions about how much and in which areas.
As for migration, I don't have the slightest idea what you're talking about. Most countries don't have a federal structure to begin with, including most democracies.
Why stop there? Why not: So the moral authority comes from universe-level democracy, and planet-level, being able to rightly supersede national, provencial and local level.
Absolutely nothing stops a planet-level democracy, except that you've got to get all of the existing countries to democratically choose to join it first. Which is a gigantic historical undertaking that might happen someday, or might never happen at all.
But if you're asking why stop there now, in 2023, it's because a planetary democratic body simply doesn't exist. While countries do.
There are various names for the concept over higher-over-lower power in a democracy -- supremacy, preemption, paramountcy.
If smaller units want to accomplish things together that can't override their individual sovereignty, then they sign treaties, form alliances, and groups -- like NATO or NAFTA and so forth. The thing that distinguishes a grouping that makes an actual state is precisely the fact that it can strike down the laws of lower organizational units when they conflict.
Now, nobody's claiming this power is unlimited -- that would be fascism. There are still rights that exist precisely to limit state-level power. But the general principle of supremacy/preemption/paramountcy still exists.
>> Ok, what is it about larger aggregations make them have more moral authority than smaller aggregations?
> Well, the simple fact that if they don't, they literally have no reason to exist.
This is circular reasoning. You made an assertion. Either defend it or declaim it. What is the specific moral authority that you claim larger aggregations have over smaller ones?
And very often that requires city policy that is the opposite of what current residents want, but is what other people across the country/state want.
E.g. if current residents don't want growth, but lots of other people want to live there, there's nothing about democracy that says the current residents' preferences take precedence over people who want to be residents.
The entire point of a nation is that it's able to coordinate and redistribute internally, for the good of the country, often against the wishes of a small minority (e.g. the current residents of a city).
Can you imagine if every neighborhood and town and city had veto power over everything? Where would you put landfills? Everyone needs them, but nobody wants them nearby to them.
So the moral authority comes from country-level democracy, and state-level, being able to rightly supersede local level.