The ATF also considers soda bottles to be suppressors, aka silencers, if there are any suspicious circumstances. Same for any metal tube that's threaded or otherwise easily attached to a firearm barrel. ("Silencer" is a misnomer; they are not silent; they generally reduce noise by roughly 20-30 dB.) Even possession of (1) a gun, (2) a soda bottle, and (3) duct tape, in close proximity, would motivate the ATF to charge you with a firearms crime. Unlike many european countries where such devices are sold without a license and it's considered rude to hunt without one, in the U.S., hysteria over organized and gang crime caused many things to be irrationally banned or strictly regulated, including suppressors and switchblades. [2]
There's also the "rifle" vs "short barreled rifle" classification. The term AR15 is a category of firearms that can range from stockless (nothing to rest against the shoulder) and very short barreled (circa 5-8"), to long range variants that have shoulder stocks and barrels 22" or more. If you buy a rifle variant of an AR15 and buy a short barrel, you've committed a crime. The receiver (the central metal piece that accepts the ammo magazine), because it was originally part of a rifle, is forever classified as a rifle receiver. By converting it into a handgun-like firearm, legally speaking you have converted it into a SBR, or short-barreled rifle, which requires beaucoup paperwork in order to be legal.
In contrast, if you start with a handgun-classified variant of the AR15 [1], no special paperwork is required.
tl;dr : there are some absurd classifications of objects as firearms, or firearms as more heavily regulated types of firearms, that a reasonable person would not understand or comprehend.
[1] http://www.bushmaster.com/catalog_carbon15_AZ-C15P97.asp
[2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Switchblade#Postwar_knives_and_...
Gun laws are one of those things where intelligent, well meaning people replace reality with their model of reality and end up with a backwards system which does nothing to address the root causes. Hint: the root cause of violent crime has a lot to do with inequality, not the number of guns in someone's basement.
And that's a bad thing? I suspect the number of casulties from six-year-olds shooting their classmates and teenage rampages would drop significantly if it weren't so easy to get at daddy's gun...
Gun laws are one of those things where intelligent, well meaning people replace reality with their model of reality
In contrast to all these omniscient people who don't argue from their mental model of reality?
and end up with a backwards system which does nothing to address the root causes.
Only because it doesn't address the root cause does not mean you should stop treating symptoms.
I'm sure that the casualties from shootings would indeed go down. Casualties from knife injury on the other hand... (http://www.dailyrecord.co.uk/news/scottish-news/2009/09/11/t...)
>In contrast to all these omniscient people who don't argue from their mental model of reality?
Some models are better than others.
>Only because it doesn't address the root cause does not mean you should stop treating symptoms.
In my opinion, it is by far more important to resolve the root causes of problems than it is to duct tape them in an effort to partially stop the bleeding. I thought this was obvious. Humanity has a bad habit of going for quick fixes where none exist and that is the root cause of many of the problems which plague us. Instead of thinking about "saving the children", how about we stop treating each other like crap and encourage people to cooperate not because a stick is being held over their heads but because they actually want to?
Besides, if violence begets violence then are we even duct taping the wound by using oppression to treat oppression or are we reinforcing those pesky root causes even further? Consider that the system which enforces these laws is inherently unfair in that the rich have orders of magnitude more leverage than the poor. How is reminding people who have stepped over that line and taken the inequality into their own destructive hands that they live in an unfair system going to help anyone? The duct tape has a sting of it's own.
But guns are far superior tools than knifes if your intent is to kill. If the body count goes down, that's a win in my book...
Some models are better than others.
No argument there, but you haven't convinced me that yours is the better one.
how about we stop treating each other like crap and encourage people to cooperate not because a stick is being held over their heads but because they actually want to?
Because our monkey-brains are not wired for that. We're at least partly subject to the whims of the blind idiot god of evolution, and being an asshole has been a sound strategy for a long time and still largely is. Education can help with that, but is no cure-all.
Besides, if violence begets violence then are we even duct taping the wound by using oppression to treat oppression or are we reinforcing those pesky root causes even further?
There are many countries with stricter gun laws than the US, and I'd be surprised if most of their citizens would feel any more oppressed than their counterparts in the US.
How is reminding people who have stepped over that line and taken the inequality into their own destructive hands that they live in an unfair system going to help anyone?
How is restricting access to personal firearms a reminder of an unfair system if it applies equally to all citizens? Also, do you have any data on support of stricter gun control laws by income? It's nice to speculate about the opinion of the downtrodden masses, but some facts would be even better...
Possession of burglary tools or drug paraphernalia is typically a modifier used to punish ill-intent. If I'm a carpenter walking home from work with a saw and hammer in my bag, I'm not going to be arrested for possessing burglar tools. If I'm trespassing on someone's property in the middle of the night with a crowbar, on the other hand, I'll probably be prosecuted for possessing burglar tools.
"Hacker tools" is sort of in the middle. A sysadmin with metasploit on his laptop is no different than a carpenter with his hammer. The Level-1 helpdesk technician pinched for stealing passwords is using it as a tool for doing "bad" things. The complication is that the line between "hacker tool" and "legitimate" software is thin or even overlapping.
If I carry x quantity of illegal drugs, I'm a user getting charged with a misdemeanor. If I carry x + y quantity of illegal drugs, I'm presumed to be a drug dealer.
I'm just explaining the thought process -- not agreeing with it. Unlike drug sales or burglary, the most important tool for hacking is whatever is in your head.
Hacking tools don't kill people. And they rarely hack into a system by accident.
People handling firearms without proper care cause accidents.
Hacking tools on disk don't break things. People handling hacking tools break things.
People using firearms often results in unintentional harm, just as people using 'hacking tools' does.
You forget to turn your packet sniffer off when on a public network, you accidentally port scan the wrong IP address, etc.
Obviously the use of hacking tools is unlikely to result in death or serious injury, but they cause real harm. Ask Stratfor what harm hacking tools can do...
For guns, knives, drugs, and other more routine contraband, law enforcement action required to maintain such bans have their own costs. Law enforcement can at best selectively enforce such laws, because contraband is almost always hidden. As a result, privacy erodes as politicians and law enforcement want more ability to discover who has contraband.
If something is harmful enough and also rare enough or requires substantial skill to procure, like nuclear weapons or biological weapons, then there's the argument that banning those things improves the safety of society. I am not convinced that the legality really matters; the economics of procurement provide a strong barrier to random ideologues and nutcases from procuring such weapons, and if they can anyway it's doubtful laws would stop them; there's also much more opportunity for anyone along the logistics chain to notice something strange about their buyer and report it to someone, even if the transaction were legal. That can't be done with firearms or knives with thousands being sold a day. However, the consequences of nuclear and biological weapon use is so horrific that despite the economics, it still might be in everyone's best interest to leave them effectively banned.
Those people legislate firearms out of fear and mistrust and insecurity...why should they be allowed to rule on hacking tools?
... and then half the scrolling length of this discussion thread was about guns. Great job!
Actually it's not your fault, it's just HN terrible threading algo again. Can't we just do what Reddit does and collapse things a littlebit? Because it seems there's always some top comment (not always the top-most) that dominates 90% of the discussion. And frankly it's very hit-and-miss whether that dominating comment is on-topic or not.
We could have so much more interesting discussions here on HN ...
Consider the following question: how long does a wire have to be before its ability to transfer information to me places that information in my possession? From both a philosophical and legal point of view, this question seems to permit no satisfying answer.
I don't have to say that I am on the fence on certain aspect of gun control. Rules regulating storage (I'm from Canada) are in my view valid. So are rules on certain classes of guns. At the same time, any gun can kill so some of the restriction might not be useful but like I said I'm on the fence on a lot of these things.
think of a knife. 99.99% use the knife for good reasons. However, some use it to harm others. Does it make sense to outlaw knives?
I use wireshark often to see what goes into the request. A lot of developers use it. I think it is mostly used for good intentions.
Maybe 99.99, maybe 99% of guns are also used or possessed for those good reasons, or simply collecting. Suppose 100 homicides a day are carried out in the U.S, although last I looked it's somewhat less than that. How many guns are used at firing ranges and for hunting? Perhaps 10,000, perhaps more.
That's true about knives. Yet the UK has banned carrying any knives other than non-locking pocketknives in public, even for utility. [1] The problem with no lock, is that the blade has a tendency to snap shut on your fingers.
[1] http://www.goxplore.net/guides/Knife_law_%28UK%29#Carrying_K...
That tells us more about you than it says about guns. It says is that you're either ignorant or a thug.
We can easily distinguish the two. How many people have you assaulted? If 0, you don't know that folks who use guns criminally have a history of other criminality. If not...
> think of a knife. 99.99% use the knife for good reasons.
That's true of guns as well.
I use a gun to kill. That's its only purpose. Hunting/killing and target practice for hunting are the only things a gun is useful for. I can't use a gun to help me with the crops, to fish, or while working in the garage.
Knives can be used to construct. Guns can only be used to destruct. Not saying guns have no legitimate purpose (I use one for hunting many times per year), but that legitimate purpose begins and ends with killing or practicing to kill. It's a long leap from taking the life of a deer to taking the life of a human, but you use the exact same tool in the exact same way, the only way it can be used.
And lets be honest here, you would most definitely use a knife in self defense if it came down to that. It's a preposterous argument to say that in a life or death scenario, you'd opt for a lesser source of protection in order to not use a sharp object.
Really?! Well, I guess it's different if, thanks to your gun laws there's a good chance the intruder might be carrying a firearm. No scratch that, if they got a gun, then you're still screwed with a knife.
First, do you know where to hit them to disable them at once? If not, you're now standing really close to a really angry, bleeding intruder.
Second, even if you do, they now bled on the walls, the furniture, everywhere. Have fun cleaning that up.
Third, you just killed a person. You can't really "disable" someone with a knife, either you kill them or you don't.
My advice? A big stick. Like the wooden handle of a broomstick or something. Keeps people with knives at a distance, you can hit them, poke them, and pin them to the ground while you call the police. (stick locks below the chin, behind the jawbone, base of the neck, pushing backwards. very uncomfortable)
I covered target practice in "practicing to kill". Whether or not you intend to do so, a gun is used for killing, and practicing with a gun is practicing how to use a tool designed for killing. I understand this may not be your view, but this is reality the way I see it.
If that's true, the designers aren't very good because most guns aren't that useful for killing. Seriously - .22 is basically a joke for killing people.
> Hunting/killing and target practice for hunting are the only things a gun is useful for.
Unless you're claiming that hunting is "not constructive", you're disagreeing with "there is no way i can use a gun for constructive purpose."
> I can't use a gun to help me with the crops, to fish, or while working in the garage.
So? You can't use golf clubs or a book on python for any of those things either. Oh, and you can use a gun to kill fish. (You then scoop them up with a net.)
Obviously it's nigh-on impossible to measure, but I'd suspect it is the other way round...
(Any debugger is a killer cracking tool too)
I predict a big market for tetris clones with port scanning functionality...
And there are very few countries that explicitly ban all fire arms even the Uk which has very stringent laws still allows shotgun licenses.
I'm from the UK myself, so I'm aware my perspective on firearms might be skewed somewhat.
Nevertheless, in my experience there seem to be very few people who see the restrictions on the possession of firearms as a case of throwing the baby out with the bath water.
There are plenty of people who, although acknowledging that more widespread firearm possession may have certain benefits, would nevertheless rather live in a society in which firearms are few and far between.
Of course people like me would still work for the GPO or DBP or ATT and have cool email addresses like c=uk cn=maurice - but subs like the rest of you would have email addresses that looked more like phone numbers.
BTW I used to have root on on the UK's ADMD - in internet terms this is the equivalent of having root on .com
It's not quite that simple. Consider firearms. You might argue it should be the use of a firearm — to threaten, maim, or kill another person — that ought to be legislated against, not mere possession. Plenty of people disagree, as exemplified by the numerous democratic countries around the world where possession of a firearm is illegal in one form or another.
The obvious retort — the "guns don't kill people, people kill people" argument, if you will — is that possession of a tool alone should not be illegal because mere possession is not inherently harmful. That's the point you seem to be making here.
Indeed, both hacking tools and firearms can, in addition to their more obvious harmful uses, also be used to alleviate and even prevent harm — authorised penetration testing being the obvious example in the former case.
Nevertheless, plenty of people are willing to forego those benefits in the case of firearms; why not the same for hacking tools?