News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by TacticalCoder on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:58PM (#38132492)
I love Kitboda's videos. The one thing that strikes me all the time is how arrogant, smug, full of themselves these scammers always sound. They do profoundly believe they're oh-so-intelligent and don't hesitate to make fun of the old people they (think they) are speaking to.

Despicable scum of this earth.

Thanks to Kitboga for fighting the good fight and it's great to see banks and crypto-exchanges immediately freezing the accounts reported by Kitboga.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by williamcotton on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:20PM (#38133762)
Arrogant and smug to one, a confident man to another!
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by netsharc on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:26PM (#38133824)
In regards to the arrogance... I imagine they have to be like that in order to be able to sleep at night, they justify the scamming by saying (mostly to themselves) things like the West stole from the developing countries, so this is them stealing back, and they have to believe the victims deserve it so they can, I repeat, sleep at night. Another justification might be "Look at this stupid moron, I won't feel bad stealing from them because someone would inevitably do, since they're so dumb!", i.e. they have to believe the victims are dumb in order to convince themselves of the previous sentence.

Maybe it's a chicken and egg issue though, maybe only scumbag jerkoffs are attracted to this kind of scam-call-center work. Then again maybe most humans are easily manipulable that they go into such a call-center being a decent person and enter into a Stanford Prison Experiment situation...

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:36PM (#38133933)
They scam many many people all day every day, why wouldn't they get arrogant about it?

your explanation seems overly complicated.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by jwilber on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:52PM (#38134113)
I think they’re speculating about the sort of person who is drawn to that sort of job, how they justify that line of work, etc.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by lstamour on Friday November 03, 2023 @03:58PM (#38134189)
The Stanford Prison Experiment reveals a lot about decent people being easily manipulated - and by that I mean the whole thing has since been revealed as fraudulent: https://www.vox.com/2018/6/13/17449118/stanford-prison-exper...
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by hattmall on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:43PM (#38135373)
Were these studies never replicated?
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by coryfklein on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:59PM (#38135565)
They were not. The Stanford Prison Experiment used to be a case study on people following orders and fulfilling assigned roles, and now it's the case study for the problem of the replication crisis.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by mensetmanusman on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:12PM (#38135714)
Didn’t they ban attempts to replicate because of violence?
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by mcpackieh on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:28PM (#38136398)
It wasn't an experiment in the first place, it was a political stunt with a predetermined outcome. All the participants were coached in the political implications of the stunt and told how they should behave. Psychology departments present it to undergrads as a legitimate experiment with some ethical issues because their discipline is a pseudoscience (or if you're inclined to be generous, a humanity masquerading as science.)
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by drjasonharrison on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:42PM (#38136482)
There isn't a specific ban on replicating the Stanford Prison experiment but instead a ban because it would violate current ethical codes for experiments, that any information gathered through a replication would not be generalizable. Here is one discussion: https://www.verywellmind.com/the-stanford-prison-experiment-...

In other words, while the experiment appeared to demonstrate interesting things, those conclusions are based on the specifics of the experimental setup and it would be better to study more representative environments to draw useful conclusions.

From the above discussion: "The Stanford Prison Experiment is frequently cited as an example of unethical research. The experiment could not be replicated by researchers today because it fails to meet the standards established by numerous ethical codes, including the Ethics Code of the American Psychological Association."

And the APA ethics code: https://www.apa.org/ethics/code

"Psychologists strive to benefit those with whom they work and take care to do no harm"

"8.07 Deception in Research (a) Psychologists do not conduct a study involving deception unless they have determined that the use of deceptive techniques is justified by the study's significant prospective scientific, educational, or applied value and that effective nondeceptive alternative procedures are not feasible.

(b) Psychologists do not deceive prospective participants about research that is reasonably expected to cause physical pain or severe emotional distress."

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by muzani on Saturday November 04, 2023 @01:12AM (#38138343)
The effect happens all the time in MMOs and something like Reddit.

I think a lot of these classic experiments are hard to replicate because the people who sign up for psychological experiments know what behavior to avoid.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by slikrick on Saturday November 04, 2023 @10:10AM (#38141147)
how could they be?
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by JaDogg on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:12PM (#38135069)
Yes, they definitely believe the West stole their money. This is what you hear every day from government propaganda (based on personal experience; refer to my other comment on the original post). Breaking out of propaganda is not a simple task for any individual. While the West may have colonized these countries in the past, it is the government and corruption that are currently responsible for the theft. Moreover, people from these countries are exposed to scams from as early as 5-10 years old. Eventually, this exposure leads to normalization, I believe.

As a side note, I believe one of the worst outcomes of colonization is that these countries lost their monarchies and lacked a natural progression to diplomacy. The only way for these countries to develop and reduce corruption is through educated youth engaging in politics and joining political parties to a degree where they dilute corruption, similar to how acid is diluted.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by monadINtop on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:38PM (#38135987)
> I believe one of the worst outcomes of colonization is that these countries lost their monarchies and lacked a natural progression to diplomacy

I think this is a very loaded and fraught perspective that ignores a large amount of context.

Colonial powers generally co-opt local heirarchies and utilise the pre-existing state machinery to expediate the process of resource extraction and pacification since doing it from scratch is often far to costly prone to instability. In many cases this may inflame pre-existing class confict and further entrench social division. It is rarely the case that pre-colonial power structures simply just vanish and are replaced by the colonial force, and furthermore they don't simply vanish post-colonisation leaving behind a template-less society.

Ex-colonies don't exist in a vacuum. Every society on the face of the earth is embedded in a complex global web of economic and political influence. Post-colonial nations can still be implicitly, and sometimes covertly, subjugated through asymmetric trade agreements, power projection, and a whole range of other processes. It is naive to assign blame of a corrupt or floundering region to a simple moral decay in an isolated system of people that just never figured out how to govern themselves. The answer is found when one instead considers the given region's place in the continuum of economic and historic processes that are far too complex to simplify into an independent narrative.

And finally, how does a monarchy naturally progress to "diplomacy"? To my knowledge there is no single theory that describes a universal archetype of a how a given human society is supposed to "naturally" develop. Even in western countries, the process of economic development from a Feudal mode of production to the current capitalist parliamentary-democracy, is an extremely complicated and poorly understood topic that covers an area of research far larger than the scope any single historian or political theorist. Everything we see indicates that there is absolutely no fixed model of social development, especially not one that isn't contigent on an unimaginable number of nonlinear and interacting factors. It seems to be a reasonable claim that the development of any given society is completely unique to itself, and is the result of it's own unique position in relation to the outside world, and to history.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by JaDogg on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:56PM (#38136156)
Apologies, I agree with everything you mentioned in your comment. I realize now that I made a significant mistake in my previous sentence. I understand a different perspective on how someone could interpret and understand it, and I appreciate you enlightening me.

In any case, what I was attempting to convey is that it is preferable to learn from your own rights and wrongs rather than dealing with the aftermath of a mess left by a third party.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by monadINtop on Friday November 03, 2023 @07:12PM (#38136278)
No worries man
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by alwa on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:23PM (#38137862)
Thank you for this incredibly perspicacious comment. It’s not my area of expertise, but I just read Dingxin Zhao, writing for Noēma, observing many of the same shortcomings of considering social development through a teleological lens [0]. I’m still considering what to make of the “Daoist perspective of history” that he recommends as an alternative, but his prescription of humility sure resonated for me!

[0] https://www.noemamag.com/the-modern-wisdom-of-daoist-history...

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by atleastoptimal on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:27PM (#38137875)
It's still possible to compare former colonies and evaluate the effectiveness/ineffectiveness of their governments. Singapore is a former colony and fares very well compared to its neighbors in forming its own government.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by monadINtop on Saturday November 04, 2023 @10:42AM (#38141430)
Right, and I'd further argue that one of the most significant deciding factor in such cases is the relation of those former colonies to the hegemonic power (either in the region or globally).

For example places like Singapore and South Korea have had positive and close relations with the United States, both diplomatically and economically, and specifically in the case of South Korea, have been the recipient of an immense amout of US foreign aid in the context of the Cold War.

On the contrary, places like Cuba and North Korea who favoured political self-determination, and economic policies that focused on bolstering the local population over trade with the US, have very quickly turned into advesarial relationships. In both these cases they ended up aligning themselves with the alternate superpower. This uneasy situation proved tolerable for a few decades (for example, North Korea's economy actually recovered quicker - intitially - than South Korea after the Korean War despite sustaining far greater damage from the bombing campaign), but once the USSR collapsed, Cuba and North Korea entered into the sad state they are today being completely isolated, economically and politically.

And then there's also the issue of governance. Both South Korea and North Korea were brutal dictatorships for decades, but eventually South Korea liberalised their political system, whilst on the other hand North Korea is, well, North Korea. (The same is true, to some degree, of Cuba as well but I would like to qualify this by saying that the depiction of the despotism of Cuba's government in western media tends to be unfairly exaggerated - due to obvious reasons - compared to other regimes of similar or worse nature such as Saudi Arabia).

But this can't be soley due to a difference in ideology, since most of the countries the US supported during the 20th century where infamous for the brutality of the regimes (Park Chung-hee, Samoza, Noriega, House of Saud, Ferdinand Marcos, Pinochet, Papa Doc, Humberto de Alencar Castelo Branco and so on). Or even more covert campaigns of support and influence such as Operation Gladio in post-war Europe, the Free Albania National Comitee, Iran-Contra, et cetera.

However this is a far more controversial topic and it's not my intention to start an argument around politics and ideology. I simply want to make the point that the effectiveness/ineffectiveness of a given government has far more to do with historical and economic context than the merit of any particular policy or competency of a governing state. Of course this is still a very valid and important topic, just one that I feel is given undue weight relative to other factors.

All of this is of course a huge over simplification and doesn't do any of the numerous topics I've skimmed over any justice.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by FrenchDevRemote on Saturday November 04, 2023 @10:50AM (#38141525)
Believe? Propaganda?

Did you ever have a single history lesson in your life?

Where do you think Afro-americans came from?

Why do you think half the continent is speaking french or English?

Why do you think 14 African countries use a money created and still controlled by France?

Plenty of mines and oil depots are still profiting European countries.

Multiple generations of slave descendants had to pay reparations to France.

Leopold II was chopping hands off Congolese people for rubber.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by JaDogg on Saturday November 04, 2023 @02:35PM (#38143857)
[delayed]
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by xp84 on Saturday November 04, 2023 @04:17PM (#38144714)
At the risk of making my most political comment on HN, which I usually like to avoid, some people (both the elite and the rest) prefer to rehash the past to avoid any uncomfortable discussions about their direct role in what’s presently wrong, and their responsibility or role in improving it. Easier and more popularly appealing to just blame 200-year-old dead Europeans for all the problems than to talk about your corrupt plutocracy.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by JaDogg on Saturday November 04, 2023 @05:42PM (#38145454)
I concur with your viewpoint. Furthermore, I believe that blaming dead Europeans and holding skilled immigrants accountable for job displacement are two sides of the same coin.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by rickreynoldssf on Friday November 03, 2023 @06:44PM (#38136049)
No, 99.9% of them are just scum of the earth criminals. They don't give a shit about who they're scamming.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by lbrito on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:15PM (#38137103)
What? That's a ridiculous, patronizing, borderline racist comment.

Most of the scammers in the video had thick accents, but if from that you conclude that scammers in general are "non western", that's at best a dumb conclusion, at worst a racist one. I don't know details of Kitboga's scammers' demographics, but there is no logical reason to assume the proportion of scammers in the West is any different than in other places of the world.

This is really the kind of absurdly tone deaf, entitled comment that turns me off the most in HN - West uber alles.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by spacechild1 on Friday November 03, 2023 @11:38PM (#38137943)
> but there is no logical reason to assume the proportion of scammers in the West is any different than in other places of the world.

Most tech support spam calls come from India. That's just a fact.

https://www.channelnewsasia.com/cna-insider/tech-support-sca...

https://www.nytimes.com/2021/01/27/magazine/scam-call-center...

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by lbrito on Saturday November 04, 2023 @12:11AM (#38138063)
Please look up the population of India, then re-read my comment, paying attention to one word in particular: proportion.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by spacechild1 on Saturday November 04, 2023 @01:08AM (#38138329)
Even when taking population size into account, India is still vastly overrepresented compared to other countries.

Of course, tech support scams are just one particular kind of scam. Nobody is arguing that India has the largest percentage of scammers in general.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by lbrito on Saturday November 04, 2023 @12:36PM (#38142601)
>Nobody is arguing that India has the largest percentage of scammers in general.

That is _exactly_ the spirit of what the parent comment was implying:

>they justify the scamming by saying (mostly to themselves) things like the West stole from the developing countries, so this is them stealing back

That comment doesn't specify India, but is definitively a blanket statement that (most) scammers are from those filthy, no-good third-world, non-Western countries, and justify their dirty third-worldly scams as a "revenge against the West".

Its a sad, racist non-argument. Quite depressing that it isn't greytexted into oblivion.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by ted_bunny on Saturday November 04, 2023 @10:59PM (#38147645)
No, they meant Nigeria too. Relax!
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by ric2b on Monday November 06, 2023 @06:26AM (#38161165)
I don't think India has over 50% of the world's population.
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by ge96 on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:17PM (#38134420)
Jim Browning (like a kitboga) too
Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by jrace on Friday November 03, 2023 @04:27PM (#38134545)
I have taken quite the disadian for these scanners after the took advantage of my aunt.

Since then when I get calls I keep them on the line to stope them from at least scamming one other person.

I have had three on long enough to actually answer the question I ask

"Why would you scam a poor little old lady?"

All three answered the same:

"You people in the west are rich and don't deserve it."

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by pixl97 on Friday November 03, 2023 @05:13PM (#38135088)
>The one thing that strikes me all the time is how arrogant, smug, full of themselves these scammers always sound.

You're reversing causation... Humans as a whole are more apt to follow people that sound confident. Therefore as a scammer, if you want to boost your success rate you need to sound confident. The scammer never wants you to doubt their ability, but they want you to constantly doubt your own.

Re:YouTuber Kitboga trapped 200 scammers in an Impossible Ma... by kumarvvr on Friday November 03, 2023 @09:35PM (#38137222)
For maximum probability of success, the scammers have to threaten, scream and shout. The most vulnerable of the victims respond to this.

If they were timid and accommodating, the call would most likely end up as "let me check with my bank and get back to you. Thank you"