News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by NickC25 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:35AM (#38099694)
Completely agree. While there's nothing wrong with digital payments, a society without cash just terrifies me. I don't have much to hide, but I don't want every action I take with money to be traceable and that data of what I do with my money to be available to all sorts of private interests without my express written consent. No corporation should get to know if I tip my barber, waiter, uber driver, etc... in cash let alone if I decide to buy a bag of weed.

I prefer to keep a bit of cash on me for many reasons, and I don't think it's appropriate for any organization to tell me 1. that I can't; and/or 2. that they have the right to know what I'm using it for (or that they have the ability to deny my ability to use my capital in whatever ways I desire).

We're not China. As someone who worked with Chinese nationals, even some of them who were complete simps for The Party had no desire to have all their finances completely digitized and tracked.

Modern economies have a need for cash, no matter what big banks or credit card companies or FinTech companies think.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by eastbound on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:55AM (#38100056)
In 99% cases, cash is used to bypass taxes.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by NickC25 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:01PM (#38100179)
Sure, but that also means that taxes on those businesses are burdensome to the point where it's better to not accept digital payments or credit cards.

Or people just don't want to pay inflated prices just so a payment processing company gets a nice % of every single purchase.

As I said in another post in this thread, I myself run a small business, and the vast majority of my sales are done through digital payments. I have no problem with this, but if I was to cut the payment platforms' fee, I could offer much better prices without having to take a hit on my margins (which themselves are sustainable and healthy, but not fantastic). It's not about me bypassing taxes, it's about providing a better price to my customers.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by jbaber on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:29PM (#38100684)
I always wonder if processor terms force vendors not to offer a separate cash price (or cash discount) or if it's just the pain of doing it that makes it not super common. I only use points cards because I'm trying to claw back the premium for everybody using credit. I'd love to just pay less in the first place and do cash everywhere.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by toast0 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:25PM (#38108226)
In the US, processor terms and state laws often prohibited charging processing fees, but a cash discount was ok. Recent court decisions support merchants charging processing fees or offering cash discounts, and most merchant agreements and state laws have been updated to be compliant.

There's rules about the fees and making sure things are transparent to customers, but I think merchants are tending not to do it because of the pain of doing it. Otoh, the last time I was at my car dealer service center, they wanted to charge 3% to run a credit card, so that one went on debit.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by buzzdenver on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:08PM (#38100297)
You're paying the same taxes whether customers pay with cash or CC, aren't you? What am I missing here?

I've been to a few restaurants that are cash only. Is that an option for you?

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by NickC25 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:15PM (#38100429)
I'm paying the same taxes, yes, but on top of taxes, I'm paying a cut of each sale to the CC company or payment processing platform (Stripe, for example, charges 2.3% of each transaction). That cut, while it might seem like pennies to a customer (because in a sense, it literally is roughly a quarter for a given $10 charge) but over time and at scale, those cuts really add up.

I'm not a restaurant but I am a food service provider. I wish I could go cash-only but that would restrict who I do business with, which at the stage I'm at, is not really an option.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by buzzdenver on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:09PM (#38101363)
IMO the crux of the issue is that CC companies can legally forbid you from charging a different amount for CC vs cash transactions.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by graywh on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:12PM (#38103396)
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by PopAlongKid on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:15PM (#38101436)
>If my revenue is say, $1m, that's roughly $23k that a CC or payment processor gets right off the bat, so I'm paying taxes on the $1mm but the cut takes a nice hit off my end profits.

If you are talking U.S. income tax, that is incorrect. You are not paying taxes on $1 million, rather you are paying taxes on $977K since the payment processing fees are tax-deductible.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by petre on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:50PM (#38103918)
You could incentivize people to pay cash by giving them a 2.3% discount while raising your prices with the same amount to cover banking comissions.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by eigenhombre on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @02:29PM (#38102734)
Increasingly (in Chicago) I've been seeing restaurants and cafes that are credit card- / debit card-only.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by s_dev on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:59AM (#38100135)
I don't believe that but there is some truth or less exaggerated percentage of tax evasion that could be quoted. Cash is also necessary for buying illegal drugs for example which a lot of people do in all strata.

Other factors that are rarely mentioned in these debates include that cash must be counted and is far more error prone than cashless transactions. Most people counting this cash are actually 19 year olds or people who just aren't enthused by their job, so plenty of mistakes mean cashless transactions have a significant advantage in retail.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by NickC25 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:08PM (#38100305)
It's also necessary for when some states have a super low minimum wage for restaurant/bar/food workers (because the idea is that you'll make the difference up in tips) - in my state (FL) I believe it's something like $2.75 or $3 per hour. Tips are taxed, and you'd better believe the owner of the establishment takes a cut of those tips, too, if they are reported. You tip cash, all that goes straight to the workers, most of whom are probably not rolling in the dough. It goes quite a long way for those types of folks.

The lower the rung you're on economically, the more use you have for cash.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by autoexec on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @01:17PM (#38101469)
This is a good example of one way that cash is useful today, but hopefully it's also one that will go away as soon as possible. We should keep cash, but end tipping and slave wages.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by aleph_minus_one on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:30PM (#38100704)
> In 99% cases, cash is used to bypass taxes.

If the government would care that the citizens are very honest with their taxes, they would create taxation laws that make it incredibly easy to be honest ("a market is controlled by incentives"). The mere fact how complicated the German taxation laws are should be a clear evidence that this is not the case.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by jtriangle on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:09PM (#38100335)
Cash prices in many places are lower, so places like gas stations do tons of cash business. I highly doubt Exxon is using cash to evade taxes, thus this is a fantastically poor take.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by eastbound on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:07PM (#38103334)
You doubt Exxon is using cash to evade taxes?

??

Then why would they encourage to use cash using lower prices? It’s more costly to handle cash than to pay credit card companies.

Also, countless examples of people digging into the cash register as part of their position perks, or usual management of remote petrol stations. Need to pay protection money? Cash. Need to pay a provider? Cash.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lp0_on_fire on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:56PM (#38104021)
> You doubt Exxon is using cash to evade taxes?

What evidence do you have they are?

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by windthrown on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @04:03PM (#38104162)
What is your basis for "It’s more costly to handle cash than to pay credit card companies."? It seems much more likely that they are encouraging cash with lower prices to avoid paying the typical ~1-5% transaction costs to Visa/MasterCard/Amex rather than a large scale tax evasion scheme.

I understand your point about handling cash requiring more labor (no self serve, armored trucks, etc) but I'd be surprised if the cash sales were less profitable than credit cards.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by toast0 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @10:30PM (#38108266)
Some business can more easily avoid reporting income if they transact in cash, but gas stations are going to leave an awful lot of audit logs regardless of method of payment.

You can run the logs from the pumps vs the log book of fuel purchases. Similar for the convenience store. A brand name station is going to have a computerized register, and sales need to match supply for the most part. There will be some mismatch due to theft, but you can't hide enough cash sales for the tax savings to be worthwhile, IMHO.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by sifar on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:21PM (#38100533)
Physical cash is also the only thing preventing central banks from running large negative interest rates since people would simply start hoarding cash.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by gwright on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:05PM (#38100252)
This suggest to me that we should have a more sensible taxing system not that we should build a tax system in which the government must observe all transactions.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by mfringel on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:55AM (#38100064)
[citation needed]
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by swagempire on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:49PM (#38101045)
Tax evasion in what sense? Surely your earnings are your earnings. If you are a business you have to drop that cash into your bank account at the end of the week or else really it's just petti cash and not significant.Then you have to declare it at the end of the year -- and it could be subject to an audit at anytime.

However buying things at a sex shop for example or how much I drink at the local bar on Fridays might be nothing I want my bank to know about.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by yungporko on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @05:03PM (#38105205)
i think the comment you're replying to is wrong, but taking payment in cash and spending it as cash lets you buy a hell of a lot of stuff without being tracked. i've known several drug dealers and handymen who have had entire wardrobes, all the tech they own, bikes, even cars, all paid for in cash that never went anywhere near their bank accounts. pretty much the only important thing you can't easily buy with cash is a home.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by swagempire on Friday November 03, 2023 @01:13PM (#38131789)
You could be right about the comment I'm replying too -- when I click on "parent: it brings up a flagged comment.

But either way -- you also might be responding to the wrong comment.

My comment was about tax evasion, not tracking the purchasing habits of consumers -- which I think is bad.

I'll restate what I said: at the end of the day you'll have to deposit your earnings cash or not in a bank account and declare it as part of your business revenue to the tax man.

If you want to keep piles of cash under your mattress somewhere I guess you can, or if you want to purchase things in cash continously -- this might work for individuals like a single man operation-- but to run a legitimate business you will have to hit bank accounts with the money you earn one way or another and this will be eventually subject to an audit should it look suspicious enough.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by JohnFen on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:38PM (#38103742)
I doubt that the percentage is that high. I use cash quite a lot, but taxes isn't even on my list of reasons why.

It's also hard to see how using cash helps much in tax avoidance except for perhaps with tipping.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by vasdae on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @03:41PM (#38103799)
Sure, but what's the downside?
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by SenAnder on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @08:00PM (#38107129)
In 99% cases, privacy is used to commit crime. Outlaw privacy, tracking collars on everyone, telescreens in every home and house. Turn your societies into open-air prisons, so you may live in crime and tax-evasion free utopias.
Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by lainga on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @12:09PM (#38100319)
> As someone who worked with Chinese nationals, even some of them who were complete simps for The Party had no desire to have all their finances completely digitized and tracked.

HA! Reminds me of Bertolt Brecht's postwar life when he returned to East Germany. In public, good socialist playwright who wrote laudatory letters to the SED, in private, critic of Stalinism... the great firewall between the two? The East German authorities let him keep a Swiss bank account and Austrian citizenship, so he could hold the earnings from his plays out of their reach.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by gumballindie on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @06:42PM (#38106404)
> I don't have much to hide

I have everything to hide from corporations. If they want my data they have to pay me. Why are governments forcing me to feed a database owned by some corporation for free? Every product you buy and pay for collects data about you. Now they want to know everything i buy from other people and corporations too. Guaranteed transaction data will be made available to the highest bider. Crazy times.

Re:10 Reasons to Fight Cashless Contagion by throw10920 on Wednesday November 01, 2023 @11:21PM (#38108603)
> As someone who worked with Chinese nationals, even some of them who were complete simps for The Party had no desire to have all their finances completely digitized and tracked.

Heck, even if I/they were ok with the government tracking them, our current big private payment networks (Visa/Mastercard) actively track you and sell your transaction data to buyers - I really don't want that.

Unless and until Visa/Mastercard/et al are legally forbidden from selling or sharing your transaction data, there will always be a legitimate use for cash, and it's immoral to not take cash payments.