News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Enginerrrd on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:00PM (#38019444)
Transportation engineer here: Multi-lane roundabouts don't typically have any safety benefits. Single lane roundabouts do.

Also, on the small side where you have traffic circles rather than roundabouts, those also suck.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by olyjohn on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:27PM (#38019672)
Correct me if I'm wrong... but compared to a traffic light, you have to go significantly slower, so most accidents are not as severe as at a traffic light. You also aren't crashing into someone in a t-bone situation, usually they are sideswiped at more of an angle for less impact force. Of course someone could still fly into a roundabout at full speed. Anything is possible, but feel like think overall there still have to be benefits.

People generally don't slow down for lights, and lots of times accelerate to make it through before it turns red.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Clent on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:59PM (#38020406)
Correct. Anyone that says roundabouts are less safe doesn't have science backing their claim. While, they do not reduce the number of accidents and in some cases can increase accidents, but they consistently reduce the severity of the accidents.

A three lane roundabout may be annoying when encounter as a tourist but the majority of locals going about their daily commutes quickly master them. For a three lane roundabout the inner lane is left turn only. The inner lane is left turn or straight and the right lane is right turns only.

The ones in my area have ample signage indicating which lane allows for each type of turn.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by mikepurvis on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:43PM (#38021088)
I would argue that the safety stats for them are still excessively car-centric. That is to say, roundabout collisions have better outcomes for car occupants specifically because they turn crashes into the kinds of crashes that cars handle best, which is low speed rear-endings, with the crumple zones doing all the heavy lifting to protect occupants.

I’m much more skeptical about how roundabout users fare when they are people walking or riding bicycles. At least in my city, we've had roundabouts for years, and the yield rate for pedestrians is ghastly— like, sub-50% of drivers stopping for someone waiting to cross and remaining fully stopped until the person is completely off the roadway. In theory this is a fine of hundreds of dollars ("failure to yield to crosswalk"), but it appears to receive basically zero enforcement in practice.

As a result, the fancy multi use paths that accompanied our roundabout installations get little use, since it's obvious to anyone who tries them how dangerous and unprotected they are.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by pmontra on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:49PM (#38021401)
I'm both a car driver and a cyclist. There are a zillion roundabouts in the country I'm living in. This is my experience and I'd like to hear a traffic designer about it.

Roundabouts feel safer than a 4 way intersecting when I'm in a car even if it's annoying to have to slow down and accelerate again when there is very little or no traffic, which is normal in the countryside. It also consumes more fuel, wears the car, adds to pollution.

It's different when I'm riding my bicycle. Roundabouts put me closer to cars, especially if there are traffic dividers that force cars closer to the side of the road. Then cars are usually slower than a bicycle in a small or medium sized roundabout (think of race bicycles with drop bars,) which adds up to chances of being packed between two cars. My feeling is that what's good for cars is bad for bicycles.

As a cyclist I can see what's around me much better than when I'm in my car. Intersections don't feel like a problem because of the extra visibility. When I'm riding I long for old times straight roads, with a line on the side and half a meter of asphalt on the other side to ride on. No roundabouts, no speed bumps especially the 3M style plastic ones, which I can jump but they are annoying. All those safety devices, including roundabouts, increase fatigue and danger. They are also the main reason for crashes in bicycle races but that's not an issue for normal people.

Finally, as I both drive and ride I know how to behave not to put in danger the cyclist. When I drive I don't overtake bicycles before a roundabout because they'll be at least as fast as me. I don't overtake when there is a short traffic divider which narrows the road. A long one, oh well, I have to. Same thing when I approach an intersection where I have to yield or stop. Bicycles will be definitely faster there because they can look around better than me and decide what to do quickly.

When I ride and I'm approaching a roundabout or entering a short narrowing of the road I look behind me and if it's safe I lean a little to the center of the road to prevent cars to overtake when they'll be forced to come close to me.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by axiolite on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:01AM (#38022584)
Your observations are quite apt.

"Researchers in Belgium found that single lane roundabouts without a protected bike lane increased crashes by 93%, while Danish researchers said roundabouts that did have separated lanes saw an 84% reduction in crashes."

CNBC: Roundabouts Are Safer. So Why Does The U.S. Have So Few Of Them? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atORPw-w83I

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by usrusr on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:12AM (#38022645)
Ah, those traffic dividers, clearly designed by people assuming that all roads should be limited access...

"All those safety devices, including roundabouts, increase fatigue and danger."

They literally distract from the traffic when you aren't in a little isolated house on wheels where people are prone to forget that traffic even exists. All those things designed to help getting a driver's eyes off WhatsApp require cyclists to get their eyes away from traffic.

On the topic of roundabouts, one thing I rarely see discussed (never?) is that traffic lights conveniently compress the vehicle stream into packets of high and low intensity, greatly helping smaller intersections downstream. Roundabouts on the other hand flatten the vehicle frequency and of there's a difficult place to enter or cross the stream, even a modest amount of traffic can be too much. In the end everything that isn't a roundabout can only be navigated by relying on someone in the dominant stream showing off compassion with those waiting. This makes everything go even slower and you quickly end up with even dominant streams going less than walking speeds.

I have a hypothesis that roundabout-dominated road graphs are particularly prone to effective throughput dropping once a certain threshold of throughput demand is reached. Traffic light dominated graphs are immune to this if drivers are just a little careful to not enter an intersection before they can assume that they will be able to leave before the lights change.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by quickthrower2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:13PM (#38020894)
That is a good point. In the UK when I was last there they needed all sorts of tricks to get people to slow down on roundabouts on A roads or just after a motorway end, going from say 70mph to zero.

You might have a curve leading up to the round about plus roundabout signs, plus give way signs, plus 300, 200, 100 yard markers, plus painted lines on the road that get closer together as you approach, and finally the <<<<< sign on the roundabout itself.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kmeisthax on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:04PM (#38019485)
wait I thought "traffic circle" and "roundabout" were synonyms
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by RandallBrown on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:24PM (#38019654)
They are in most contexts.

There are "traffic circles" that aren't roundabouts but just a round block in the middle of an intersection that requires the traffic to move around in a circle so cross traffic is slowed. Also called a "traffic calming circle."

https://www.seattle.gov/transportation/projects-and-programs...

That could also be a location specific term too. These circles are very common in Seattle.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by lotsofpulp on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:42PM (#38020257)
I thought that was a roundabout. At least my UK family would call that a roundabout.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by patja on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:57PM (#38020393)
Roundabouts have to have splitters and other features that traffic calming circles lack. Also, technically you can go whichever way you want around a traffic calming circle: counterclockwise is recommended, but many trucks physically cannot navigate them that way. And there are zero traffic laws distinguishing a traffic calming circle from an uncontrolled intersection.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by j16sdiz on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:14PM (#38020899)
Depends on which country/state you are from, they may or may not be the same.

Look up on wikiprdia, there are even different types of roundabouts

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by pests on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:59PM (#38021166)
This is the first time I've even heard the term "traffic circle"
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kmeisthax on Thursday October 26, 2023 @09:20PM (#38033635)
It's an Americanism. "Roundabout" is the God Given Queens[0] English equivalent.

[0] King Charles is so uncharismatic I do not acknowledge his existence

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by pests on Friday October 27, 2023 @12:01AM (#38034550)
I am American! Metro Detroit area. I guess we also don't have many roundabouts. A lot of our road designs are based on Michigan Lefts[0] though which Wikipedia says are also called "median U‑turn crossover or median U‑turn, or restricted crossing U-turn (RCUT)" which I don't see much elsewhere in the country.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michigan_left

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kgermino on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:10PM (#38019530)
> Also, on the small side where you have traffic circles rather than roundabouts, those also suck.

Interesting. Can you elaborate? We have a few of them (and growing) by me and they’re fantastic as far as I can tell. No stopping every block for stop signs, I’ve seen landscaping truck with trailers sneak through them fine, and it’s so much easier on a bike or while walking. What’s the downside?

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:43PM (#38019817)
While you're here, can I ask you a question I've always wanted to ask about traffic circles? Perhaps this is also related to why they suck for safety.

At least where I live, there are two rules for traffic circles: (1) yield to traffic that is already in the traffic circle, and (2) when two cars arrive at the same time, yield to traffic on your right.

Rule 1 is the same as for a roundabout, but rule (2) is a bit strange when the two are put together. It creates a scenario where if the leftmost car doesn't yield for whatever reason (perhaps they thought they arrived a microsecond earlier), then now they move forward and become "traffic in the traffic circle", which means they steal priority and the right-most car now has to yield to them. If the rule were flipped the other way, such that we default to always yielding to the car on the left, then this wouldn't happen; it would work just like a roundabout, and the order of yielding priority would be the same regardless of agreement on the exact timing of when each car arrived at the traffic circle.

So, why is it that at a traffic circle we yield to traffic on the right, rather than the left? Is it just to be consistent with 4-way stops?

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by eszed on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:08PM (#38021215)
Just clarifying: you drive on the right-hand side of the road, so "right" for you means on the outside of the circle?

Yeah, that seems mad.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:52PM (#38021418)
Correct, right-hand side of the road.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by fshbbdssbbgdd on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:14PM (#38021247)
They added some circular medians in the middle of 4-way stops where I live, are those traffic circles? Are you suggesting that when I get to a 4 way stop, whether I yield to traffic on the left or right should depend on whether the intersection has one of those medians in the middle?

Personally I find it confusing that yielding works the opposite way on roundabouts and 4-way stops, and nobody else in my neighborhood seems to know what to do either. Whether people yield to me seems to depend mostly on the size of the vehicle I am driving.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by mitthrowaway2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:53PM (#38021422)
In this case, they've removed the stop signs, so it's not a 4-way stop anymore, just a traffic circle.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Moru on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:34AM (#38021993)
Sweden treats the roundabouts as it's own road. To get into the circle you yield to whatever is inside the circle. The cars inside the roundabout is on their own road so only yields on lane change from inner to outer lane. When exiting they are leaving the road and is yielding to any pedestrian/bicycle crossing directly after the roundabout. Well, they are supposed to do but mostly don't.

There are a few non-standard roundabouts that has no yield sign and the lane goes straight into the roundabout but then it usually doesn't have an outer lane before that entrance.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by smeej on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:14PM (#38020041)
I think you're right about single vs. 2+ lanes. It doesn't matter how many diagram signs they put up before the roundabout entry, people will NOT understand a roundabout with more than one lane, and under no circumstance will people going straight through realize they have to yield to someone coming from the opposite side who's going 270° around the circle and exiting from the inner lane.

Roundabouts are fine if the rule is, "Just get in there without hitting anybody and go around until you're ready to leave," but expecting anything more than that from most drivers is a lost cause.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by yreg on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:31PM (#38020163)
> people will NOT understand a roundabout with more than one lane

We have tons of 2-lane ones and everyone understands them…

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by dublinben on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:37PM (#38021054)
The number of drivers who think you can freely exit from the inner lane suggests otherwise.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:58PM (#38021164)
Not sure exactly what you mean by freely, but in most popular roundabout designs you can exit from the inner lane. A "standard" two lane roundabout will have two lanes entering AND exiting. You never change lanes in roundabouts, at least where I'm from. Only in a massive multi-lane roundabout (that's at that point more like a ring road) would you ever change lanes to exit.

e.g. for a standard two lane roundabout with four exits, if you enter in the left lane, you can exit directly out of the 2nd, 3rd, and 4th (i.e u-turn) exits, but always in the left lane of the exit. If you enter in the right lane, you can exit out of the 1st or 2nd exits, but always in the right lane of the exits. With this design cars travelling alongside you can never cross your path, only cars entering the roundabout ahead of you can cross your path and it's their responsibility to yield.

The thing that most often causes problems is people in the outer lane NOT exiting (e.g. thinking they can take the third exit from the right lane) and swiping the car in the inner lane correctly taking the second exit.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by dublinben on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:20AM (#38021557)
The car from the inner lane swiping into the car in the outer lane is the exact issue I'm talking about. The problem is when drivers enter in the left/inner lane, fully intending to take the first exit. If they proceed to exit directly from the inner lane, without first changing lanes, signalling, or yielding to outer traffic, they would intersect with a car in the outer lane innocently heading to the second exit.

In practice, people are not able to navigate two-lane roundabouts in a compliant and safe manner. Any intersection of roads busy enough to have two lanes in each direction is too busy for a roundabout to be safe.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by rembicilious on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:09AM (#38021825)
It’s still safer than a normal intersection. Roundabouts prevent HIGH SPEED t-bone and head-on collisions. The difference in safety is easily worth the “cognitive load” of a 2-lane roundabout.

I think drivers will get used to them and in practice there will be few collisions.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by autoexec on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:23AM (#38023111)
> I think drivers will get used to them and in practice there will be few collisions.

I think drivers will avoid them at all costs since even low speed collisions can cause extremely expensive repairs (and even total an older vehicle) meaning they'll never get the practice they need to navigate them safely, yet eventually those drivers will find themselves in a situation where a roundabout can't be avoided and suddenly it's chaos for every car in the intersection.

Even if multi-lane roundabouts were suddenly everywhere we'd probably need generations of new drivers trained to use them in drivers ed classes as teens before you could just trust people to be able to navigate them correctly

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by verve_rat on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:02AM (#38022593)
The experience of most NZ cities and towns on a daily basis says otherwise.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:40PM (#38032048)
> The problem is when drivers enter in the left/inner lane, fully intending to take the first exit. If they proceed to exit directly from the inner lane, without first changing lanes, signalling, or yielding to outer traffic

Yes, in that case a driver not understanding the rules of the road (that you can't take the first exit from the inner lane, which is usually clearly signed) could cause an accident. The exact same way turning right from the left lane in a signalized intersection can cause an accident. The question is, what's the damage of an ignorant driver and how fast do people learn? The research indicates that right-of-way incursions in a roundabout result in dramatically fewer injuries than right-of-way incursions at other types of intersections, and the research also indicates that contrary to your belief, drivers actually do learn how to use them.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Too on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:59PM (#38021460)
They are right to. Simplified greatly, the further in the roundabout you are, the right of way is yours.

The exception is you can obviously not shoot straight from the left lane to the first exit.

In a 2 lane roundabout it is very simple. Enter in the left lane and you can exit 2nd or 3d, enter in the right lane and you can exit 1st or 2nd.

Where it gets complicated is roundabouts with 2 lane entry but only 1 lane in the third exit. Then you have to change lane right halfway through and be careful with people entering prematurely from your 1st exit, or people incorrectly staying in the right lane past the 2nd exit. It’s not always obvious but for those entering the rule is the same, since they enter after you, they should yield to you.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Moru on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:15AM (#38021857)
I guess this is depending on country. In Sweden you are allowed to exit from the inner lane. But you have to yield to traffic in the outer lane because you are doing a lane change even if you go straight for the inner exit in a two lane exit. The outer lane is not causing the accident, they do not have to yield and they are allowed to go to the third, fourth or fifth exit fully in the outer lane if they want to. You just have to make sure you don't hit them on the way out.

This however does not stop accidents to happen all the time in this situation because of drivers trying to get past the traffic jam by going inner lane in high speed and then exit in front of traffic trying to get to next exit. And mostly without blinking at all.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Moru on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:06AM (#38021808)
Our town has loads of them too, and everyone think they understand them. Still accidents are common because people think it's ok to just go straight through by changing lane to inner and then directly exiting without yielding to the ones crossing their path in the outer lane.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by bobthepanda on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:42AM (#38022054)
At least in the Netherlands its recommended that the two lane roundabouts have mountable curbs specifically to prevent lane changing.

The US is unfortunately loth to install any sort of divider more than paint or a feeble plastic post, and less than a jersey barrier.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by dtech on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:58AM (#38022145)
We have quite a few without curbs too, but they usually have markings for what lane is for what direction and are "skewed" so that you don't normally have to change lanes.

Example: https://maps.app.goo.gl/3z6NZXGdb2HRVtfW7

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by yreg on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:04AM (#38023374)
In my country accidents per roundabout are far less common than accidents per traditional crossroad.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Moru on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:37AM (#38023547)
Sorry, didn't write the whole thing. Yes, it's much less accidents and those that happen are at much lower speeds and leads to less bad accidents.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by RHSeeger on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:56AM (#38022132)
Honestly, even looking at a picture showing how a 2-lane roundabout works (https://www.epermittest.com/drivers-education/roundabouts), I still can't understand how it works. Assuming 0 is the bottom and 90 is the right, how is it that a person following the inside route from 0 (exiting the left lane at 180) isn't going to get hit by someone following the outside route from 90 (exiting the right lane at 270)? I would almost certainly use it wrong and/or expect to get hit.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by verve_rat on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:56AM (#38022548)
The "correct" answer is the 0->180 car has no indicator on as it enters the roundabout, and has its right indicator on as it exits the roundabout.

The 90->270 car sees the right indicator and lets the other car passed.

The real answer is somewhere between the above and the 90->270 car waiting to enter the roundabout because it is not sure if the other car is actually going 0->180 or 0->270 because they are a shit diver that doesn't indicate on roundabouts.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by fifticon on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:21AM (#38022707)
well, that breaks all schemes, as my experience in 52 years is, that most people don't or won't operate their indicator signals properly. They seem to believe they are for special holidays, or for a particular audience they have spotted (spoiler alert: they are for the opposite). Or, my favorite: Activating the indicator two thirds of the way through the already completed turn, presumably to celebrate the success.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by sfn42 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:37AM (#38022835)
The part you're missing is you have to yield when changing lanes, just like in any other road. If you are in the inner lane and you want to exit, you have to make sure the coast is clear. In other words, you are responsible for not getting hit. If you just blindly change lanes you might get crashed into and that would be your fault.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:25PM (#38031898)
> The part you're missing is you have to yield when changing lanes, just like in any other road.

This is not true with most roundabouts in North America at least. If you look at the diagram GP posted, you do not change to the outer lane to exit. You exit directly from the inner lane. In fact, you NEVER change lanes in a roundabout. The reason this works (where the inside lane crosses the outside) is because the roundabout is small enough that the traffic in the outside lane has to let you exit as part of yielding to enter the roundabout in the first place. After that, as long as everyone respects which exits they're allowed to take from which lane, there is no more crossing traffic. In practice, if you are in an inside lane, you want to keep an eye on the outer lanes to make sure someone isn't trying to take a later exit than they are allowed.

From GP link:

> Do not change lanes in a roundabout

> Do not travel in the outside lane further than allowed as it may create a hazard for the vehicle exiting the roundabout from the inside lane

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by sfn42 on Friday October 27, 2023 @02:27AM (#38035306)
That doesn't work. If I enter a 4-way roundabout going left, I will start off in the left lane. I will pass two exits and leave through the third. When I exit, someone from the second exit could be in the lane next to me, going to the same exit i am. If it's not a two-lane exit I have to yield. They could also be going further, people don't always follow the rules.

When you exit from the inner lane you necessarily have to change lanes because the inner lane is completely inside the outer lane. You may not think of it as a lane change because you're going across the lane not merging into it, but it is a lane change and you have to pay attention.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Saturday October 28, 2023 @01:01AM (#38047284)
> I will pass two exits and leave through the third. When I exit, someone from the second exit could be in the lane next to me, going to the road I came from. I have to yield.

No, they have to yield to YOU because you're already in the roundabout. It's hard to believe, but trust me, this is just how it works and all of the links I've posted agree. The reason why it works is because when you're in the situation you describe, for the person entering at the second exit to be a factor, they would have to be entering as you're already alongside the second exit and in the process of exiting at the third. So they need to be yielding to you as they will be crossing your lane. Part of waiting for the gap is waiting for the exiting traffic to clear. Not for only YOUR lane to be empty.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by sfn42 on Saturday October 28, 2023 @07:14AM (#38048897)
I can't see any links you've posted that agree with what you're saying. I only checked a couple, you said all of them so I figure thats good enough.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Sunday October 29, 2023 @12:58AM (#38055893)
Apologies, I mistook some of the ones I responded to with being ones I posted.

Here's a video from Minnesota timestamped to them talking about exactly this scenario in detail. Namely, yielding to all lanes of cross traffic: https://youtu.be/CEhNboz5GPk?si=LxdVQZx0MHrYhl8w&t=196

> With multi-lane roundabouts, it is important to stop for vehicles in all lanes of traffic. Wait until there is a gap in all lanes of traffic and then enter slowly. Never try to enter alongside cross traffic or assume any driver's intended path. One of of the most common mistakes people make when entering a roundabout is failing to yield to all lanes of traffic. Yield doesn't mean just slow down or merge. Yield means that you must wait until all traffic in the roundabout has cleared before proceeding. Make sure that no one is in either lane of the roundabout and then proceed.

The video also has a good overhead view that is better than most at showing the scale of the roundabout. The important thing to note here is that to enter the roundabout, you have to cross the lanes that are exiting, not merge into them. So you are yielding to all exiting lanes.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:34PM (#38031984)
> Assuming 0 is the bottom and 90 is the right, how is it that a person following the inside route from 0 (exiting the left lane at 180) isn't going to get hit by someone following the outside route from 90 (exiting the right lane at 270)?

The person following the outside route from 90 must yield before even entering. It's very confusing until you're actually in them, but they're small enough that what you're saying usually isn't really a problem (at least in well designed roundabouts). When the car at 90 enters the roundabout intending to take the 270 exit, they yield to traffic in ALL lanes that might be exiting. Not just traffic in the outer lane. If they were intending to take the 180 exit, they only need to worry about traffic in the outer lane (or people incorrectly changing lanes when exiting).

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by worthless-trash on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:02AM (#38022173)
I agree, Australian cities seem to think that they solve every traffic issue. There is a double lane less than 200m from my house.

The shitty part about roundabouts is when people allow blocking of the view to the right on the round about so you are unable to see incoming traffic till its almost on the round about.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by paganel on Thursday October 26, 2023 @03:30AM (#38022777)
Traffic police here in Romania had to actually add some stuff to the legislation that would make 2-lane plus roundabout traffic easier to understand, the reason being that the traffic policemen themselves had conflicting opinions about who had the right of way inside said roundabouts (when changing lanes, for example).
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by dagw on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:38AM (#38023556)
Where are you? We have tons of 2-lane roundabouts in Sweden as well, and I can assure you that far from everyone understands them. And even if they understand them in the sense that they got the theory question about them correct on their driving test, everybody certainly doesn't implement that knowledge consistently and correctly when faced with a 2-lane roundabout.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by yreg on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:39AM (#38023869)
Bratislava, Slovakia. I don’t recall anyone I know having an accident on a roundabout.

Newbie drivers I talk to/drive with are much more worried/unsure about crossings (both the ones without traffic lights and the big ones with many lanes) and of course about parking.

Of course, there will be SOME people who are clueless on roundabouts, similar to how there are always some people who will stop on a highway after missing an exit and pull back. But let's not argue about the long tails.

IMO if you learn to drive at a time when roundabouts are already ubiquitous, they are trivial. At least I found other aspects of driving more difficult.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by JohnFen on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:09PM (#38029484)
> there are always some people who will stop on a highway after missing an exit and pull back.

What?? People do that??

My mind is blown. I've never once seen that happen, so the possibility never entered my mind. Now that I think about it, though, I should probably be more surprised that I haven't encountered it.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by yreg on Thursday October 26, 2023 @11:09PM (#38034280)
Some people drive crazy

https://youtu.be/r86kxxU-LUY

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kimixa on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:28PM (#38028846)
There's lots of multi-lane roundabouts in the UK, and generally seem to work well, but they're often inconsistent with how lanes merge or depart.

One that gets me every time I go past is one where there's like 20 signs saying that both lanes continue to the main road to the right (270 degrees around, the UK so driving on the left), but I don't think I've ever been through there and not have someone try to merge in to me trying to get into the left lane to exit, despite both lanes leading to that exit.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by hnick on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:10PM (#38020867)
I don't know what the letter of the law is but I (and most people I've seen here in Australia based on driving patterns) interpret yielding to cars on the roundabout as giving way if I will get in the way. If they're still on the other side of the island, and we can both pass through without getting in each others' way, it's fine.

Of course the de facto standard here (which many people actually think is the law) would be "give way to the right" (i.e. left for US) meaning some people will proceed without stopping even if the car to their direct left got there just before them. I think this is predictable since more risk falls on the driver who is going to get T-boned in their driver side door if they don't stop so they will be naturally cautious.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:13PM (#38021245)
> expecting anything more than that from most drivers is a lost cause

I can't speak to the area you live, but where I'm from we get along just fine. Yes sometimes you still get the odd unfamiliar driver that doesn't understand them, but for locals there's a critical mass where roundabouts stop being avoidable and you adjust.

See also: https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/safety-at-two-lane-roundabo...

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by trevyn on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:16AM (#38022290)
Are you from Stockholm?
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by edejong on Thursday October 26, 2023 @12:23AM (#38021573)
Where I’m from, every driver knows how to use these and use them safely.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by watwut on Thursday October 26, 2023 @05:29AM (#38023506)
The big issue is that multi lane roundabout forces the driver to watch too many things at the same time while giving him very small margin of error. If you are not fast with reactions and aggressive enough, you can end sort of trapped in the inner lane and people are afraid to do one more unnecessary round.

And that means everyone has to watch both left and right at the same time while also trying to figure out layout (Will the outer lane force me out when I do not what to? Some roundabouts are like that. Will the inner lane keep me trapped? etc)

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by datavirtue on Thursday October 26, 2023 @06:36AM (#38023851)
This. My community built training facilities. Didn't help much. Also, for new drivers these just induce anxiety and give them new opportunities to halt traffic and get horns blasted at them.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by JohnFen on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:06PM (#38029441)
> It doesn't matter how many diagram signs they put up before the roundabout entry

It doesn't help that often those signs are pretty confusing all by themselves (at least the ones I've seen), and can't really be grokked from a brief glance driving by.

It would be better if all such roundabouts were consistent in how you should navigate them, but that isn't the case in my area.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by gruez on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:25PM (#38020113)
>Transportation engineer here: Multi-lane roundabouts don't typically have any safety benefits. Single lane roundabouts do.

Source? Not doubting you, just want something to reference in the future.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by peeters on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:49PM (#38021114)
> Multi-lane roundabouts don't typically have any safety benefits.

There seems to be quite a bit of literature that flatly disagrees with this statement. Perhaps you could add a source? The conventional wisdom where I'm from is that multilane roundabouts don't reduce the absolute number of crashes (and might even increase crash rates), but they still dramatically reduce the severity of crashes.

Canada:

> However recent data in the United States and Canada are showing that collision frequency at multi-lane roundabouts is often higher than expected, and sometimes higher than the prior signalized intersection. This trend is worrisome given that roundabouts are often constructed as a means of increasing safety. The good news is that fatal and injury crashes are almost always reduced with roundabouts, even if property-damage-only crashes are not.

https://www.tac-atc.ca/sites/default/files/conf_papers/weber...

Netherlands:

> Multi-lane roundabouts. These are less safe than single-lane roundabouts, but still safer than other types of intersection [22]. Multi-lane roundabouts are less safe because they have a larger number of conflict points, they are more complex, driving speed is higher, and they have a less sharp entry angle [23].

https://swov.nl/en/fact/roundabouts-how-safe-are-different-k...

US:

> Roundabouts force drivers to slow down and all but eliminate the most severe types of intersection crashes — right-angle, left-turn and head-on collisions. Single-lane roundabouts see fewer total crashes of any type.

https://www.iihs.org/news/detail/safety-at-two-lane-roundabo...

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by Moru on Thursday October 26, 2023 @01:26AM (#38021930)
The accident rate also goes down with time, people needs to get used to roundabouts.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kazinator on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:56PM (#38021157)
All roundabouts prevent vehicles from just blowing straight through the intersection in the desired direction without so much as slowing down. They remove the middle part of the intersection where conflicting paths intersect.

Two-lane roundabouts are larger; cars go around them faster. There is ambiguity. Some cars short-cut using the middle lane, and veer right out of it to their desired exit. Cars in the outer lane might be wrongly assumed to be turning off at the next exit. North American drivers get really confused by two-lane roundabouts.

I don't think these situations will typically lead to anything worse than fender benders.

The same intersection without a roundabout could be host to fatal collisions, when two vehicles enter at speed and hit each other in the middle.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by jameshart on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:50PM (#38021407)
> All roundabouts prevent vehicles from just blowing straight through the intersection in the desired direction without so much as slowing down

Not at all. A large enough roundabout with good visibility from the approach can allow you to traverse it without slowing down at all - if the speed limits coming up to the yield line are appropriate, and traffic is flowing.

There's a sense in which a roundabout is just a short circular section of highway with a series of on and off-ramps around the edge. Well designed onramps allow you to merge without slowing, and off-ramps let you leave without disrupting traffic. Roundabouts can permit the same.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kazinator on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:58PM (#38021451)
There is a recursive fix for that: put a small roundabout into each T shaped intersections of the huge roundabout.
Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by autoexec on Thursday October 26, 2023 @04:32AM (#38023173)
> I don't think these situations will typically lead to anything worse than fender benders.

Since even a fender bender can cost many thousands of dollars in repairs that's still pretty terrible. Speed bumps slow drivers down too and don't risk people turning into you because they were trying to exit from the inside lane of a roundabout.

Re:What are roundabouts? The safety benefits of these circul... by kazinator on Thursday October 26, 2023 @02:58PM (#38030204)
s/because they were trying to exit from the inside/you were trying to outrace them in the outside lane/

The two lanes are there in larger, busier roundabouts to reduce collisions, not for "slower traffic, keep right"; it's not a freeway. Cars enter the outer lane, and may use the inside lane to avoid other cars entering.