So uhh... how does it work in spite of that description?
No clue why GP thinks it "shouldn't work": it's an extremely difficult engineering problem, but the physics of it is relatively straightforward.
I think this misrepresents the situation, but I can't say how, so I can't dismiss it quite so quickly.
Stronger signals from some black holes depending on which way they're oriented relative to the arms. And if there were many different simultaneous signals, some could mask the others.
Clearly, we need a 3-armed, space-based LIGO. Or better, a dozen of them.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LIGO
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virgo_interferometer
[2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/GEO600
[3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/KAGRA
[4] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_A...
Amusingly Einstein both identified gravitational waves in his then new general relativity and then changed his mind about whether they existed. Indeed he had found three different types of these waves, and two of them were simply coordinate artifacts (they could be made to travel at any speed, Eddington famously quiped that they could be made to move at the "speed of thought"). The third type however didn't have this problem (though again here Einstein would write a paper where he claimed these gravitation waves required singularities, but these turned out these were all coordinates singularities .... sort of like how late and long coordinates misbehave at the poles)
In some ways the physics of it is straightforward, in other ways....not so much.
This question is important enough that there have been papers written on it. I suggest you read https://pubs.aip.org/aapt/ajp/article-abstract/65/6/501/5300... which may strengthen your understanding.
This is a physics education journal: its papers are supposed to be interesting and accessible to undergrads, not on the frontier of the field.
What the linked paper amounts to is noticing that the sensitivity of a detector depends on the relative length scales of the arms and the waves you're trying to detect. This is true, and also one of the first things you would consider when figuring out what size your detector should be. It's a good homework problem, but not news to anyone actually working on LIGO.
> No clue why GP thinks it "shouldn't work"
It's also possible you think that this is all about laser interferometry, and aren't properly considering how it could work in the context of compressing space, since a laser interferometry system in compressed space wouldn't produce interference.
That's unfortunately true for a lot of physics. For example, there are very few good explanations available for what is electric current and it is pretty funny observing even people with lots of experience offer the same lame, false explanation.
I think the chief confusion here is that you may be thinking the light arrives at the detector in the same amount of time regardless of spacetime curvature. That is, the the ruler is itself squishing.
But what needs to be considered is the constant speed of light.
This implies that what happens is, in the presence of additional curvature, and constant speed of light, the additional distance traveled will have appeared to slow the light.
In the laser interferometer this registers as interference.
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ajZojAwfEbs
It is also worth noting that any claims of detection are thoroughly investigated and confirmed with other detectors.
> It is difficult for a single LIGO detector to confirm a gravitational wave signal on its own. The initial discovery of gravitational waves required that the signal be seen in both detectors (Hanford and Livingston).
I thought it made the light reduce in frequency. Or did I misunderstand?
New light that is emitted at one end of the journey while there is a stretching status will have the same frequency as normal, and just see the longer journey. In fact, the gravitational waves that LIGO is able to detect are slower than the time it takes for light to make the journey, so the stretching is effectively gradual, and the detector is basically an extremely accurate length measurement. The gravity waves aren't fast enough to make the light changing frequency a thing that needs to be worried about.
This is the thing I (as a layperson) can't really wrap my head around yet; there's gotta be so much interference from so many different sources, there's gotta be some impressive data processing going on to filter out anything not relevant to their core measurements, and then THAT data will have to be compared to that of other detectors.
This device, the LHC, space telescopes, really cool and all if you look at the published pop-sci results, but the actual data is like... individual photons captured by a worldwide network of detectors and processed / data analyzed into the first "photo" of a black hole.
1. If you have a light wave in the universe, and you "hang" a mass by each valley and trough of the light wave, and then you squash and stretch the universe, the masses stay connected to the valleys and troughs of the light wave. Said another way, when you squash and stretch space, lightwaves within that spacetime are also squashed and stretched.
2. LIGO claims to work by measuring the squashing and stretching space with light. However, as we just learned, squashing space also squashes light waves. So the LIGO arms and light waves in the arms are all compressed together.
Said another way, LIGO can't work because the ruler itself is squashing as space squashes, so you can't measure if space is compressing.
LIGO does work, but if you can't explain how it works despite this description, then you don't understand LIGO.