News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @07:49PM (#38007320)
Why do people care so much about...I don't know if there's a word for this...I wanna say serial integrity as in integrity of the series? If I like a general premise and cast I have zero issue with them doing dogshit if they're having fun and it simply produces more content on a quantitative basis that can add to the binge rewatching duration value? Maybe I'm just weird like that.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by bee_rider on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:37PM (#38007716)
I mean, it is fiction, so of course you can just pick and choose what you engage with. But, it is pretty common to leave hints of backstory and future stuff. It is nice because you can fill in the blanks. “Happily ever after” can be as nice as you imagine.

Or the author goes off the deep end and starts getting better known for political rants. Subsequently it may be hard to enjoy their older works as you are looking for signs of what will develop…

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by fullshark on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:00PM (#38007426)
I tried to vibe with this POV. What's wrong with more content? But it really does cheapen the art/media you used to adore. Even if you try to ignore it, i.e. you don't have to watch / read all the Star Trek content that has been produced in the last 20 years, and after picard season 1 I completely checked out of all of it, but it just kind of makes everything you loved seem so empty. It was all about generating positive cash flows...the whole time.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:12PM (#38007535)
See my "all i care about" comment
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by to11mtm on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:41PM (#38008114)
I feel a lot of this.

Parts of Discovery are good, more-so if you look at it from a 'home team' perspective where you'll take any win. OTOH It's only re-watchable to a certain point.

Lower Decks, I do like as far as escapism goes but frankly has a lot of 'Yeah this is licensed parody' moments.

Sometimes, things should end. Sometimes they end too soon (Farscape comes to mind [0], thankfully it did get a finale at least,) but when you keep adding on 'the additional adventures of' the risk of winding up in some form of everyplot, or just breaking canon, gets wayyyyy tooo damn high.

As a counterpoint to that, Picard Season 3 is incredibly watchable, (even RLM thought so,) I hope you try it if you haven't. It somehow does a pretty dang good job with things.

[0] - It really is a benchmark for a lot of sci-fi despite the fourth wall tapping.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @05:09AM (#38010816)
I feel like you're so close to getting to the point of realization that this fixation on duration and quality is ultimately arbitrary and, in my view, harmful. How else do you explain reboots besides the money part? There's clearly demand for it since people like what they know and their millions+-strong population must in some sense agree with me
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @03:54AM (#38010354)
I appreciate you succinctly boiling down what I am trying to address here. I obviously disagree with this position strenuously but in my own way and for the purpose of really "putting a name" to that which I am advocating against, you have done both sides a great service.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:37AM (#38012115)
Amicus hackae
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by grotorea on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:25AM (#38012047)
> I completely checked out of all of it, but it just kind of makes everything you loved seem so empty

As someone who really agrees with the previous poster, this may be the crucial point. I can "disbelieve" the stuff that I think is stupid cashgrab sequel crap, specially if it was not made by the original author.

Because think about it, if someone somewhere made a bad fanfic, would it ruin the previous media? Obviously not, right? So why is it different when it's a billion dollar media company that bought the right to slap the "official" name and logo on their fanfic*? If you don't like it, ignore it. If you like it, then great more media of the franchise you enjoy!

* Assuming the people writing it are fans and not 100% just there for the money.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:35AM (#38012108)
I dont know if this comprehensively addresses my issues with the topic but its pretty damn close :) Like this is more an issue of revisionism than it is...I don't even know how to formally refer to the opposing argument and I would rather let everyone else chime in and speak for me here
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:53AM (#38013470)
I wanna emphasize the part about the actors having fun. That in some sense is a tricky thing since actors profession and main task is to conceal what they are and take on whatever role—or at the very least, to sublimate their personal qualities into their subject. Having said that, I feel like even a famous and highly-skilled actor is not going to be able to perform at their best if they are really just in contract-fullfillment mode for a money-grubbing production...

It would seem that no matter how well they were technically perceived, it would slip through somehow and thus violate my condition that the actors are mostly having fun and voluntarily performing, particularly if its with a group of their actor friends that appear in each others' films. I don't worry about the money-grubbing so much cuz chances are the actors are in on it and to some degree inclined to do well and make it enjoyable for themselves and their audience.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:13AM (#38013671)
I don't mean offense but it seems almost as arbitrary as complaining that additional purchased game content or whatever the acronym is destroys whatever game it extends when you had all that fun along the way, maybe even to the extent that players/you wanna play a little longer.

Harmless doesn't even begin to cover that outside of complaints that its unfair socioeconomically to extend the cost of playing such that kids who were "lucky" to even be able to afford merely the game are being discriminated against economically or whatever either in isolation or with reference to their more fortunate peers. Im getting a bit sidetracked here so I won't be taking notes on this, unfortunately :( but I do think its pretty much analagous in my opinion.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by syndicatedjelly on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @07:51PM (#38007349)
You sound like the advertising industry’s ideal consumer.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:08PM (#38007499)
All I care about is hanging out with "my friends" more, I guess I develop enough of an emotionally-compelling connection with shows/works + the characters/actors I like that I kinda never want it to end and its moot to consider the welfare of the characters or overall quality because its all abstract or academic anyway and I derive such sustained benefit or enjoyment from it continuing in perpetuity. Nothings getting solved or done or any progression truly achieved anyway so who gives a fuck? Film critics be damned, if Im happier and my mental health is better and I enjoy mysef on account of this, I really could care less about critical acclaim. Its the actors' job(s) to worry about consequences like typecasting or regret or whatever
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by throw_pm23 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:28PM (#38007646)
You seem to be saying that you are a "non-discerning customer" when it comes to this type of work, and that's fine if it works for you. Others find works produced only for money to be lower quality or heartless. Maybe you similarly care about stuff in some other aspect of life (food? clothing? music? personal relationships?), just not for movies/comics.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:50PM (#38007797)
I would argue that your discernment angle is literally just that in a similar sense with how critical theory folks approach works from various sociological and literary angles to the extent you could say those are component to the same work rather than ever possible to be definitive or representative. Like dividing by zero. Its not answerable and also discernment seemingly is axiomatic to the point its basically no different from religion or palate/taste.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by syndicatedjelly on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:07PM (#38007904)
Random question, did you do policy debate in high school and/or college?
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:24PM (#38008024)
Nah, should I have? Also relevant username ;)
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by syndicatedjelly on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:42PM (#38008524)
The last time I heard someone argue like you, was as the recipient of a negative case in a policy debate round 14 years ago.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glossary_of_policy_debate_term...

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @11:23PM (#38008787)
> This section does not cite any sources. (October 2020)

Is there an actual article with more substance illustrating what you mean or what this section (#Kritik) was derived from? Also, I'm having a little bit of difficulty in parsing out your overall position with respect to what I've said (do feel I'm doing a bad job of it or what do you mean, exactly?)

I definitely was using that (critical theory) as more of an example and only briefly analogizing rather than me trying to argue from that vantage point specifically.

Edit: are you saying "heard" as in you were there, or you know the details of the case through reading or maybe both? Whatever the case, is there an actual source available?

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by syndicatedjelly on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @12:27AM (#38009123)
Honestly, I haven't the faintest clue what you're talking about in any of the comments in this thread. I was just trying to say that I haven't felt so bamboozled since the one time I tried doing policy debate, which was different from the usual form of debate I participated in (Lincoln-Douglas). I was a decent debater, but policy debate was entirely inscrutable. Gish galloping was the name of the game - trotting out as many arguments, as quickly as possible, in as little time so as to trip up the opponent on some minor point they missed. I linked to Kritik because your seemingly random inclusion of critical theory reminded me of this convoluted type of argument which, if not responded to, will lose you the entire round.

Everything you said in this thread reminded me of that experience. Good day to you.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:28AM (#38009456)
I think this was a bit tricky in the sense its such a qualitative matter essentially and the heart of the the opposing position seems not really falsifiable (the longer a series runs = crappier a series "becomes" -> the more it dilutes the overall qualitative artistic and intangible entertainment value+prestige of not only the series as a whole but also the individual episodes that precede such enshittification and with which one could hypothetically have previously expressed and documented satisfaction. Regardless of whether this was said outright, the logic here seems to be such.

Why don't we just normalize ex post facto law while we're at it?

I feel like we all might have gotten a bit lost in the plot here but I will leave you with this quote that I feel represents the encapsulation I have presented here:

> I tried to vibe with this POV. What's wrong with more content? But it really does cheapen the art/media you used to adore. Even if you try to ignore it, i.e. you don't have to watch / read all the Star Trek content that has been produced in the last 20 years, and after picard season 1 I completely checked out of all of it, but it just kind of makes everything you loved seem so empty. It was all about generating positive cash flows...the whole time.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @05:33AM (#38010964)
Also, historical revisionism anyone?
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @12:46PM (#38014816)
Gish-galloping is a cool word, thanks for introducing that to me. I genuinely had never heard that or would have ever stumbled upon that but for you so props.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:34PM (#38016482)
Could you critique my sort of closing argument just below where I mention the Gish-Galloping thing? I wonder if that is a bit more explicit and clarifying with respect to what I've been discussing here. I feel as if I wrapped up decently there and I am actually intellectually interested in your assessment of that and if you feel in any sense that I perhaps cleaned up my thinking to where you can at least parse the conclusion I come to. Genuinely would appreciate
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by syndicatedjelly on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @09:02PM (#38020436)
The first paragraph of your closing remarks, beginning with "I think this was a bit tricky..." made sense. The first sentence was a bit of painful run-on, but I think the argument you're trying to make is that it's impossible to prove that "enshittification" doesn't destroy the product in it's entirety.

> Why don't we just normalize ex post facto law while we're at it?

This really puzzled me...I re-read it half a dozen times. I know what ex post facto law is. The connection to an excessively long-running television series (e.g.) defeats me.

Finally, you claim that a quote from earlier in this thread corroborates/provides evidence that "enshittification is inevitable and ultimately good" (which I think is your thesis?). But the quote you provide proves the exact opposite - that "more content cheapens the art/media you used to adore".

In only a handful of paragraphs, you flip-flopped positions entirely.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:11AM (#38011939)
Outside of you
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:40AM (#38012140)
*passing example
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:59PM (#38008635)
[]
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:54PM (#38007827)
I mean, I am discerning in that I have expectations that if I don't like the characters or topics or "moral tenor" (like in that it cares too much about being a moral bullhorn as opposed to faithfully representing that which it handles or has an opportunity to push the envelope further) or various other intangibles, I don't like+watch it.

In my view, your position is a tad elitist and I don't particularly care for the way it places you on an implicitly superior level of comprehension but also fundamental worth in the context of this discussion.

Arguably, I both in real-time and through the aformentioned repetition get to know the show and its constituent parts far better than you single-viewing "discerners" ever could. But yeah, you notice more even though you technically notice less.

I'm inclined to suggest that you are literally the quantity over quality viewer (ie: non-discerning) and I am in fact the quality over quantity since I view less discrete works but notice and derive a more refined level of enjoyment and recognition of the subtleties present in any artistic production (and the artistic part is not something I'm going to argue with you about; its intangible and as worthlesz or priceless as the viewer subjectively evaluates)

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:08PM (#38007910)
Also, I've further insulated myself from the advertising industry's influence or ROI far more than you could ever know and likely replicate personally. This is just so glib and lovechild-of-terse-and-misguided on so many levels I can't even get to the bottom of the pile. Lets just disagree to agree on this.

Edit: Also you stay away from my miniature son and never come back ;)

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:09AM (#38011916)
Also, I feel like people who in some sense watch the same materials on repeat are—dunno, maybe less valuable to ads than someone who's constantly perusing new shows (diversifying their ad profile). Its intuitive but im not certain i can logically defend it sufficiently robustly. "You know wat I mean"
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Miraste on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:17AM (#38009724)
I hate this opinion, but even accepting it at face value, it doesn't apply to comic strips. A TV show is a mishmash of dozens of visions from the start, so it's easy to let the Ship of Theseus continue on with new writers or sequels or spinoffs. An author-drawn comic is the work of one person. It doesn't have a cast, it's just them. Letting corporate greed machines get it removes the whole appeal by default.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @05:11AM (#38010829)
How would it not apply even moreso to comic strips? Comic strips are even less accounted for in terms of the general body or oeuvre of that series. Like who can name every single comic strip "episode" relative to who can do so for its syndicated or movie counterpart(s)?
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:05AM (#38011894)
I doubt even the creator could reliably and reproducibly do so
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by 1123581321 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:45AM (#38012183)
Calvin & Hobbes fans know the published strips very well.
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @08:54AM (#38012257)
ALL of them, seriously? Never missed one or went on vacation and the paper got thrown out (assuming that was the predominant medium)? Can all of you populate a spreadsheet by heart and argue in good faith with due accuracy as to each one out of the likely 10,000s?

Sorry but I doubt that. But even so, it still doesn't lend itself to your point. You're saying 10,000s are perfection but + one new strip would immediately or at least in some historically-tainting way destroy everything? Is everything really that fragile?

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Izkata on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @09:42AM (#38012675)
There are about 3150 Calvin and Hobbes strips.

For comparison, there are about 900 Star Trek episodes (including the animated ones).

I don't find it hard to believe someone can know all of them, because I am one of those people for Star Trek, and comic strips are so much shorter. I couldn't populate a spreadsheet from scratch, but name an episode and reference the plot somehow, I'm fairly sure I'll remember it and be able to fill in some details without looking it up.

> Never missed one or went on vacation and the paper got thrown out (assuming that was the predominant medium)?

Also they're all available at https://www.gocomics.com/calvinandhobbes/ - I read through the whole thing a few years ago.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @10:12AM (#38013023)
K thats my bad on the quantity, that was reckless but it doesn't change the nature of my conjecture and you avoided the primary question: does n + 1 = 0 with regard to an arbitrary number of "new" comics/works? What if there was a "vault" of undiscovered or arbitrarily retained C&H works? You're seriously gonna say "nah" to that?
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:05AM (#38013603)
[]
Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by 1123581321 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:23AM (#38013772)
Yes, all of them. They might’ve missed newspapers, but they read them in published collections and re-read them in the complete omnibus. I’m confident they’d recognize a fake strip. Your general point about comics might hold but C&H is something else.

As for being displeased with continued low quality publishing, yes, that would be dismaying. If it continued on and was really good, obviously that wouldn’t be but Watterson’s point was that the odds of that working out well were low, even if he tried to retain creative control. I understand from your other posts that quality isn’t important to you once you’ve started following the characters; fans of C&H are not like you.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @11:54AM (#38014106)
Can you give your thoughts on the notion of how hypothetical "lost episodes" or "vault" would be rejected consistent with your suggestion that the corpus of readers all feel exactly as strong as you on the matter even if it literally meant that there was a risk of rejecting precious canon material simply because you all consider C&H "done" and have no room for additional content?

I realize this example is super contrived and I legitimately hope I'm not mischaracterizing your fundamental position but I don't know you've really given me a basis to understand how you or the typical fan would approach such a dilemma...and it seems relevant to the overall questions of at least authenticity, continuity, currency etc that are inherent to the broader discussion despite the fact its likely never gonna happen.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Miraste on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:31PM (#38016436)
You are mischaracterizing the position. It's not "Calvin and Hobbes is done," it's "Calvin and Hobbes is Bill Waterson and he's done with it." If lost strips came out or he announced a continuation, fans would be excited. If some MBA pit got their claws on it and made their own continuation, fans would hate it.

This is why Watterson's new book is at the front of every bookstore in the country, despite having nothing to do with C&H and being impossible to market. Despite the ongoing poison of franchises, people do still care about stories from authors they trust.

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @03:17PM (#38017011)
Thank you, I understand and actually sort of agree with you now that I understand where you are coming from. I feel very similarly and perhaps I was not dilligent enough in fleshing out that I also want the author/creative force behind it to be involved and for it to more or less continue at their pleasure.

My issue was merely with the notion that something that was "finished" or ended previouslu could never be continued or elaborated on due to what I perceived as an obsession with the "sanctity" of a completed or discontinued creative work.

I don't know if this resonates at all but I feel the deep need to keep things open and I just can't thumb my nose when a series I enjoyed offers to continue that experience and pick back up where "we" last left off and that I so enjoyed prior.

I get attached to the franchise/show/whatever and crew and its hard to accept the notion that at some point they go away with any finality or that they will necessarily remain frozen in time where nobody can move forward or I don't feel like we can grow and abstractly interact anymore.

This probably sounds really stupid and maudlin but there you have it. I'm sorry and I'm glad we could get to this point :)

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Obscurity4340 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:38PM (#38019773)
I don't think I was explicit enough in saying I also want the author to be running the show or at least heavily involved and that is usually (in my mind) a useful heuristic or proxy for quality in some sense if they have self-respect and are interestef not only in capitalizing on the work but also to see their creation actually come to life in live action or whatever the format and be enjoyable for themselves, their families, and the rest of their audience (us).

I do care about quality and fortunately with the smaller typical season size nowadays (8-10 episodes) it seems like that flows pretty naturally. Having to write like 30 episodes per season is insane , I'm glad how its going now although it necessarily results in longer turnarounnd times. But its worth the wait :)

Re:Bill Watterson's Life After "Calvin and Hobbes" by Miraste on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @02:24PM (#38016338)
I don't understand what you're getting at. I'm talking about the number of people involved, not the length. I know a few comic strips that were handed off to new creators after the original died or retired, and they're very, very obviously different pieces, appealing to different audiences. It usually takes a single strip to notice.