News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by daft_pink on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:20PM (#37993858)
I think AMD is the most likely to win this race as they are way more reasonable than Nvidia and Qualcomm in terms of margins and better at working with the vendors.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by brucethemoose2 on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:52PM (#37994052)
That is a reasonable assessment.

Nvidia and Qualcomm are just so... Nvidia and Qualcomm like. They can't help themselves.

That being said, history also suggests AMD will bungle the software side.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by photonbeam on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:47PM (#37994682)
I’ve always been baffled by this, why hasn’t AMD brought in an army of software devs
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by mtoner23 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:17AM (#37994803)
So much easier said than done. Have you met those kernel/SW people? They are hard to poach and hard to manage well.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by gleenn on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:24AM (#37994834)
Pay them more money maybe?
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by sherincall on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:56AM (#37995582)
Because of stock appreciation, they'd need to pay up to 10x what the other company is already paying.

Consider a senior SWE at e.g. NVIDIA making $300k, let's say halfsies split between base and RSU. The $150k RSU grant from a few years ago that still hasn't fully vested is worth $1M now. So even for a 50% increase in nominal total comp, it doesn't make financial sense to switch.

I don't know that anyone can afford to pay their engineers 10x more than the competition, and then also offer a cheaper product with thinner margins.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by HWR_14 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:05AM (#37996040)
What percentage of the cost is the engineering?
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by freeone3000 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:26AM (#37995397)
Yeah, I have — and I got the impression that stability and long-term goals are paramount. You need a good manager, but who doesn’t?
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by anonzzzies on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:07AM (#37996062)
I did kernel dev and drivers for over a decade on embedded systems; people in the space are not easy to find, especially with experience. Because of that it is not hard to make 400-500k/year working remotely from my garden in the eu (and have been for the past 20 years). Why would I move and go to an office for similar of less? I would accept a position at Nvidia if the conditions are similar and I know my colleagues (who also have been working from home for most of their careers) would but that’s not on offer.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by nvm0n2 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:24AM (#37996192)
Where are you making 400-500k a year doing systems programming? Embedded or kernel dev usually doesn't pay so great.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by spoiler on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:53AM (#37996428)
I wish to know the same... I've been doing it as a hoby for years, but now I'm having financial FOMO lol
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by bradfa on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @06:56AM (#37997235)
Having professionally been doing embedded/kernel/systems development since 2011 and a variety of software and hardware engineering before that, I'd say embedded software pays decently, but I'm definitely not making $400-500k USD/year, not even half that. Maybe I'm doing it wrong?

In my experience, pretty much all software engineering positions pay better than hardware engineering positions with equivalent experience. I don't fully understand why, as hardware is hard and if you have a really good hardware engineering team you can shave months off your time to market, so those engineers should be just as valuable to a business as systems/embedded software people.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by Roark66 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @10:06AM (#37999357)
I've found it mostly true during my 20+ years career in IT (mostly devops, but also "solution architecture", cloud migration of legacy software, and even integration early on, etc) that if one wants to make more money there is almost always an opportunity to do so if one is willing to work hard and take risks for it. Switching jobs every 2~3 years and doing it with a plan in mind is one way of doing it.

Based on that people end up earning what they consider "a comfortable wage". Some people are not going to feel comfortable until they can buy a jet for their acro-flying hobby, some are happy when they can afford to easily save 1 year of income and being able to afford to buy a new pc every 3 years.

Other people have no idea these opportunities exist and they are miserable working in one place for a decade. Or they are not willing or can't take risks.

That's how we end up with two people doing similar jobs one earning $100k and the other $500k. In days of remote work the biggest differentiating factor in the earning potential IMO is your English (if not a native speaker) and willingness to work in timezones 6h+ away.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by 4gotunameagain on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:11PM (#38001243)
> I don't fully understand why

I think it has to do with the VC faucet, a completely irrational capital allocation mechanism.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by anonzzzies on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @01:27AM (#38009447)
I have a company (only me in it but having an actual company looking pro Does make you more money and gives more freedoms like wfh for all years I have worked after/during uni) for 30 years that works for other companies creating products for/with them. If you work like this for a company like Gemalto or startups with VC invest, 250-300/hr are on the table. I have almost no overheads and invest almost everything so the gross has been close to net for practical purposes.

But you are right; the hardware market is harder than making web stuff. I just enjoy hardware/firmware more. Currently I am starting a new hardware/firmware project for a US company that will last 3 years with this income.

It depends where you live, spend and how you count; i optimised everything for the past 25+ years around making sure I never have to think about money if I would drop everything today. Your situation might be very different of course.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by nvm0n2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @05:44AM (#38011031)
Don't you hit the problem that after six months you can't be a contractor anymore and have to be classified as an employee (on employee rates)?
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by anonzzzies on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:52AM (#38011792)
No, the entire setup I have is geared to function as company: I have many clients (who keep coming back because they can kick me out any time which is a bit of an issue in the EU, but then they don't) and I also make products which even more cements me as 'defacto employee'. I had many discussions (especially) with the dutch taxes who tried to catch me out; never worked.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by nvm0n2 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @09:10AM (#38012398)
Pretty cool, thanks for sharing with us! It originally sounded like you were earning this from a specific job, but yes if you can build a successful business then your earnings can get arbitrarily high. I'm not sure most of us would describe it as "not hard" though! Congrats!
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by sfmike on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:50PM (#37994699)
They have and thats the problem
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by gofixurcode on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @01:33AM (#37995120)
Issues like this typically boil down to management. If they had a driven forward thinking manager who could deliver value early and impress their superiors, then they could have leverage to make change in the organization and push for more devs, a change in philosophy or push for more resources for the software arm. These things take time though of course.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by AtlasBarfed on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @09:04AM (#37998623)
Hardware never does software well because software is more expensive on a per person basis.

That disrupts the organization because the hardware people are arguably smarter and more talented than software people. They have actual engineering degrees.

A good software org has to value its people. A good hardware org is a manufacturing operation tries to minimize personnel costs.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by MikusR on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:34AM (#37996285)
And AMD is so AMD.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by dehrmann on Monday October 23, 2023 @10:02PM (#37994124)
Plus their product is an almost one-to-one replacement for Intel's. There's no question of if X will work, and you don't need to port anything before doing performance tests.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by conradev on Monday October 23, 2023 @11:08PM (#37994474)
Qualcomm already ships SoCs for Surfaces, Chromebooks and Galaxy Books. Those chips lag in performance, and I’m curious how much of them catching up will just be “updating to the latest ARM IP”

NVIDIA also shipped Tegra SoCs with their own Denver cores, but they scrapped the project

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by jwells89 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:04AM (#37994747)
If AMD makes the Linux versions of the various software surrounding their ARM CPU open source, it'll likely win by default. Even if Nvidia's and Qualcomm's offerings perform a bit better, nobody wants to put up with those two's nonsense if they don't have to.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by orwin on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @05:02AM (#37996490)
Yes. The only reason I'm on intel on my main (general purpose) computer is that I want reliable software that will just work on a clean install, without having to modprobe or modify the grub.

AMD is cheaper (less power too for the same performances), so for my NAS and laptop it's my choice, and probably if I had to build a gaming computer I would use AMD too.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by throwaway914 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @12:31AM (#37994866)
It pisses me off that AMD does either low/cheap laptops or extremely gaudy gaming machines. There's this high performance ultrabook niche that I wish they could make inroads to.

It is impossible to find: AMD + high resolution screen (3840x2400) + 120hz + OLED. In the last year even the Intel ones downgraded though, everyone went 3200x2000 @ 120hz OLED.

It's just frustrating when you're looking at upper-end AMD laptops and you cannot find 16GB of memory, or a decent screen. I'm glad they can dish out $500-$800 laptops, but I don't know why OEMs are always pairing the good components with Intel.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by fodkodrasz on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @02:33AM (#37995443)
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by pizza234 on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:22AM (#37996179)
> It's just frustrating when you're looking at upper-end AMD laptops and you cannot find 16GB of memory, or a decent screen.

This is not correct. Just looking at Lenovo, even a mainstream laptop like the Yoga 7 14" AMD ships 16 GB, and it has a 2.8K OLED display as option. If you want more, the T14(s) can ship with 32 GB and matte display.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by grujicd on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:33AM (#37996272)
Also check Asus Zebook line, they have models with AMD CPU, OLED hidpi displays and 16GB/1TB.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by throwaway914 on Wednesday October 25, 2023 @07:18PM (#38019593)
You are right, but 2.8k is them again gimping AMD. We should be expecting 2160p minimum.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by smallstepforman on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @04:27AM (#37996216)
Two years ago I got the AND advantage edition chipset in HP Omen. 5800 gpu, 6600M navi + dmbedded vega, 32gb ram 3200, 16” QHD @165Hz, 1Tb nvme + extra nvme. This was Stock, I just added an extra 1Tb nvme drive. Cool snd quiet. Even has full size cursor keys, and a row for home/end and friends, including prtnscrn. And lots of expansion ports.

AMD do offer solutions, its the vendors that ignored Navi and insisted on supplying power guzzling 3060 instead. Blame the customers for that.

Good laptop with 3 flaws - should have been 16:10, and the touchpad driver is terrible, and power supply is a brick. Fix these and you would have had oerfect laptop.

Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by stoobs on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @08:06AM (#37997942)
AMD doesn't make laptops, take it up with Acer, Asus, Lenovo, etc etc.
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by chaostheory on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @11:37AM (#38000648)
[delayed]
Re:Nvidia to Challenge Intel with Arm-Based Processors for PCs by throwaway914 on Thursday October 26, 2023 @11:58PM (#38034532)
Really I have the most trouble with getting a high-end GPU and high resolution screen on an AMD laptop. Framework is great, but doesn't offer what I'm looking for.

Need me some 2160p or 2400p @ 120hz OLED. I'm often in hotel after hotel after hotel and I don't have a docked setup. I just have the 1 laptop. Certainly not toting around a high-end portable monitor for this need, you can't find 120hz OLED anyway. Another poster linked how Intel influenced what OEMs were offering with AMD CPUs and I think that's exactly what's going on. When you go to Dell.com you can very easily see the many options for Intel-CPU'd laptops, and the handful or less of AMD options for screen configurations, hard drives, memory, or graphics cards. It's just very fishy.