News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by londons_explore on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:50AM (#37982333)
I saw an analysis recently that suggested a nuclear war between the west and Russia would no longer end in mutually assured destruction. Instead, it was likely that most of the west's missiles would be able to disable most of Russia's weapons before they could get to their targets, while the reverse was not true.

Such a war would also likely extend the west's dominance by ~50 years or more if the replacement government in Russia was a pro-US one.

Could this be the start of testing that out?

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by bangkoksbest on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:26AM (#37982525)
If you write "I saw an analysis recently..." it's best to link to or at least describe the source of the analysis, otherwise the rest of us are just left with completely unsourced hearsay
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by jrflowers on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:34AM (#37982569)
Technically now that we’ve read that comment we too have read an analysis to that effect.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:05AM (#37982782)
Care to pass it around?
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by verdverm on Monday October 23, 2023 @12:46PM (#37988212)
only if it requires a single click to elevate it
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:53AM (#37982343)
This is the dumbest thing that I've read this year. In multiple respects. I'd be dying to know where you get your daily news from. Because I have a friend thats thinks like you. He reads a lot of 9gag. Called me once in the middle of the night a year ago because "Putin was about to nuke us". We traced the source of his fear back to a fake news article dubbing over random Russian TV excerpts with vile subtitles. He's otherwise considered sane and a family man.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by vsnf on Monday October 23, 2023 @02:57AM (#37982358)
Care to elaborate on why? It seems overly hopeful, not to mention somewhat dangerous to just assume western missile superiority, but it could also be true. It’s not like MAD is a law of physics.

Edit: when I replied, the parent poster consisted of one sentence claiming the idea to be dumb, with zero substantive refutations. They have since elaborated in their original post.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by sitkack on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:13AM (#37982448)
It would plunge the whole world into chaos and billions of bystanders would die. It is an insane, repugnant idea.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:08AM (#37982426)
You are aware you're using the word "hopeful" in a sentence that's exploring the killing of hundreds of millions humans for a perceived personal gain.

Do you think such thinking is justified because of the Ukraine war? I suggest you start reading UN reports of actual observers on the ground and stop reading propaganda intended for halfwits.

I also suggest you read the analysis of us military experts on the subject hypersonic missiles. This whole thread is vile nonsense.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by postingawayonhn on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:41AM (#37982602)
> exploring the killing of hundreds of millions humans for a perceived personal gain.

Nobody here is suggesting the US conduct a preemptive nuclear attack against Russia, or that it would be a good thing for humanity. The argument is merely that if a nuclear war was to break our (for whatever reason) the US now appears to have an edge over Russia.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:53AM (#37982693)
> if a nuclear war was to break our (for whatever reason) the US now appears to have an edge over Russia

What does that mean? Are you not aware that even a relatively small amount of 10 average modern strategic nuclear weapons is enough to trigger a 100year nuclear winter? US and Russia have a combined number of 10k+ of them. I thought there were engineers on this forum. Saying what the OP did would get you fired in my company same as saying what you did. Not for the ideological implications, but because of the complete lack of critical thinking. Are you getting any of this?

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by vsnf on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:03AM (#37982765)
I am sympathetic to stance here, no one is claiming nuclear war would be anything other than catastrophic. But the question at hand here, and to which your charged reaction is causing you to miss, is whether or not such an analysis about western missile superiority could be true or not.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:17AM (#37982851)
> whether or not such an analysis about western missile superiority could be true or not

I'll go with US military experts saying Russia has a clear edge in missile tech and the fact that 10k nukes kill the Earth 1000 times over. What you're saying is simply insane.

The fact you're completely omitting my points made, means you're one of the people one cannot reach with reason. You'll cheer for your team and kill the enemy, no matter what that means exactly.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by postingawayonhn on Monday October 23, 2023 @09:32AM (#37985356)
Russia has no edge. Ukraine is routinely shoots down their "hypersonic" missiles with US Patriot air defense systems.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:22AM (#37982496)
Feels like Reddit. Getting downvoted because I'm ridiculing the idea of preemptively nuking hundreds of million of people because "they're our enemy". A shameful display for mostly US engineers. Of course without replies. People who think genocide is a good idea usually aren't that good at expressing themselves.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by capdiz on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:43AM (#37983087)
I feel your pain. On here, when it comes to anything to do with the Russia or China, it's best you stay quiet. You are dealing with most propagandized community when it comes to world affairs.

PS. The downvotes don't put food on your table.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:01AM (#37983224)
> The downvotes don't put food on your table.

Remaining quiet around people joking about genocide would follow me around in my conscience. Also fearing downvotes is like an admission to defeat. Besides - all it took for the patriots to shit up the place was one lie: "I saw an analysis recently that suggested a nuclear war between the west and Russia would no longer end in mutually assured destruction." The lie is now the most upvoted comment in this thread.

What happened to you HN? Did you ban all the smart ones and let the redditards in?

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by capdiz on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:36AM (#37983426)
The most scary thing is that they are living in an echo chamber. The world around us is becoming more dangerous at an unprecented pace, conversations that were wrongly pushed to the dinner table are starting to come out in full view.

The HN community will be in shock when it finally hits on them that they too will be affected by what is happening across the ocean. The belief of unlimited superiority is blinding the fact that other people are now more willing to do harm than previously imagined.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by argentier on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:15AM (#37983668)
> A shameful display for mostly US engineers

Who do you think built the US military?

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:28AM (#37983744)
You mean the next gen jets that cannot fly in harsh weather conditions and are solely designed to make money? You know the ones that are only being used simbolically in patrol missions over europe while the old F-16s fly actual combat missions? Or the US hypersonic missiles which disintegrate on test flights?

So yes, the fact the majority of people on this forum are engineers who seem to support the made up idea that the US can win a nuclear war against Russia, does shed a negative light on them. But then again so do many other things. But it's mainly the fact that the majority seems to read this comment as me propagating the idea that Russia would win. Lunatics.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by huytersd on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @11:32PM (#38008849)
The F16 is not supposed to fly in thunderstorm just like the F35. These are just precautions and Lockheed cleared the F35 for rain/thunderstorms back in 2015 after checking the inerting systems.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by username332211 on Monday October 23, 2023 @03:53AM (#37982694)
>Instead, it was likely that most of the west's missiles would be able to disable most of Russia's weapons before they could get to their targets, while the reverse was not true.

How is disabling most of Russia's nuclear missiles OK? Who made this analysis? The "Ream American Association Against the Degenerate Urban Elites" or something?

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by waveBidder on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:00AM (#37983212)
"some of you may die, but that is a price I am willing to pay."
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by Garvi on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:22AM (#37983333)
No one made the analysis as there was no analysis. This is propaganda. Unclear whether OP is a tool or gets paid to stir up hate against an ethnic group. One can look up legitimate military analysis of US vs. Russian missile capabilities and get mostly opposite opinions to what OP is spreading. US lacks hypersonic capabilities or the capability of intercepting such weapons, while both countries have reliable retaliation strike capability with hidden nuclear subs. What OP is suggesting is complete lunacy and a simple lie. It's horrifying not more people are picking up on this.

Now imagine this circlejerk on reddit. Realize what an effect it has on young people seeing hundreds of comments agreeing with such a lunatic perspective, while all others are censored or didn't dare posting in the first place. We're about to solve the Fermi paradox.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by elashri on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:21AM (#37982890)
I wouldn't put the fate of humanity as a potential price for testing a hypothesis. I prefer trying to test the theory that we can produce a (Micro) black hole at CERN (Because it will not do what you think it will). That is an old and safe theory.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by tutfbhuf on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:21AM (#37982898)
Disabling most is insufficient. All it takes is a few ICBMs hitting NY, LA, etc., and the calculation already becomes nonsensical. It would be intriguing, however, if it becomes possible in the future to intercept ICBMs during the launch phase using some kind of new technology. Even then, though, you would need to ensure a 100% success rate.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by FreakyT on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:43AM (#37983082)
> if it becomes possible in the future to intercept ICBMs during the launch phase using some kind of new technology

This was largely the concept of the Strategic Defense Initiative (aka Star Wars) in the 1980s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Defense_Initiative

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by tutfbhuf on Tuesday October 24, 2023 @06:18AM (#37996959)
> In 2019, space-based interceptor development resumed for the first time in 25 years

It seems as though the program has been resumed lately.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by badrabbit on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:02AM (#37983595)
Major US cities being destroyed is pretty bad but not MAD bad. The rest of the US will still be around long enough to decimate Russia or China. MAD means both sides get wiped out completley not some horrible killing of 50mil people happened.

I.E.: if they fire first, firing back does not mean everyone dies.

Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by otabdeveloper4 on Monday October 23, 2023 @04:50AM (#37983139)
You should definitely test this theory, anonymous experts are certainly people you can trust with your life. #yolo
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by HHC-Hunter on Monday October 23, 2023 @05:05AM (#37983245)
Who ever did that analysis is an absolute fool. Propagation of such an idea should immediately be shot down.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by mullingitover on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:15AM (#37983672)
I've always said that nuclear is the answer to reducing our carbon emissions, but this is not what I had in mind.
Re:US Tests Explosive at Nuclear Site as Russia Revokes Ban ... by argentier on Monday October 23, 2023 @06:18AM (#37983687)
What could possibly go wrong?