News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by sequoia on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:53PM (#3794510)
"generating a feed of stories personalized for members of a social network" "tagging digital media" "methods for enabling users to fetch items"

hahahaha... I can't help but chuckle when reading these. Why don't they own the patents for "displaying discrete items of information in a linear fashion", "entering personal information into a computer using a hand operated alphabet device" and "methods for communicating one's emotional state electronically to friends and acquaintances"? Hmm... that last one might actually work.

Of course facebook has little choice but to countersue, but I'll be happy when the ongoing three ring patent circus (or is it freakshow?) is put to rest.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by pyre on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:19PM (#3794630)

  > Hmm... that last one might actually work.
LiveJournal would be a huge corpus of prior art from the pre-Facebook days.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by api on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:24PM (#3794379)
... and patent law continues to be nothing more than an employment program for lawyers, and to impede innovation.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by tmh88j on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:40PM (#3794447)
I had an in depth discussion about patent trolling with a friend's father who is a very prominent lawyer, albeit not in patent law. Regardless, I mentioned how ridiculous it has become and gave a couple examples (Honeywell vs Nest, Yahoo vs Facebook, Arrival Star vs every poor city). He agreed but pointed out that there's no reason to be upset with the lawyers. It's congress who's allowing them to get away with it. Subconsciously I knew this, but it's hard not to be angry with the lawyers who are taking advantage of it.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by Karunamon on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:47PM (#3794483)
>Subconsciously I knew this

I have to disagree with this. Just because the law allows something doesn't make it acceptable to do so on any other level. (Ethically, morally, being-a-decent-human-ly, what have you.)

The law should be the final, last resort "stop" on behavior. If you rely on the legal system to decide what's okay and what isn't, you'll end up being a pretty horrible person. We shouldn't allow companies to say "But it's legal" as a defense to any bad behavior.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by vibrunazo on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:43PM (#3794947)
I usually try to look for practical solutions for real problems instead of trying to figure out "who to blame". Technically, both lawyers and congress are guilty. But in practice, from our point of view, it's easier to change congress by trying to elect better candidates and calling your representative, than it is to try to convince every lawyer that exists to abandon greed.

So I don't disagree with you, that lawyers are also to blame. But I'd argue that our energy is better spent focused on congress.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by jballanc on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @10:07PM (#3795858)
I agree in principle, but the cynic in me feels the need to point out that you might want to consider what profession the majority of senators and congressmen were in before they took office.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by reader5000 on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:45PM (#3794473)
How are lawyers "taking advantage of it"? Their clients tell them to sue, they sue.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by tmh88j on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:58PM (#3794535)
>How are lawyers "taking advantage of it"?

I'll search for the link, but I recall reading an article where a group of lawyers contacted companies who they believe had their patents infringed upon and offered their services to them.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by mailarchis on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:40PM (#3794723)
There are companies Not necessarily law firms, who provide services on analyzing patents and submitting a list potential candidates that can be sued.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by DevX101 on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @06:06PM (#3795033)
Lawyers don't sue companies. Companies sue companies.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by donaldc on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:09PM (#3794581)
He agreed but pointed out that there's no reason to be upset with the lawyers. It's congress who's allowing them to get away with it.

There's more than enough blame to go around. The law profession should take more responsibility for what it's involved in.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by lonnyk on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @10:31PM (#3795935)
I don't blame the lawyers and I assumed that most other people blamed the lawyers. I blame the law.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by Tossrock on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:52PM (#3794505)
When your value proposition is "we won't sue you", you've lost your competitive advantage in innovation. Note that this also applies to the RIAA/MPAA.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by wallawe on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @05:29PM (#3794911)
I just picture Facebook execs in the scarface tone of voice, "you wanna fuck with me, huh?"

Although two wrongs don't make a right, I'm glad that Facebook took this line of action. Taking a counter-attack/offensive stance and putting Yahoo on the defensive will hopefully wake them up to the stupidity of their actions.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by lonnyk on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @10:32PM (#3795938)
I think Facebook should just pull their access to the FB API. Y! already stated how helpful it was for their news and then they sued FB. If they don't like it then don't use it.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by Finbarr on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:07PM (#3794573)
It seems to me that Yahoo has bitten off more than it can chew. I bet Facebook can out-lawyer them at this stage.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by nullflux on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @07:18PM (#3795306)
Yes, they can, if not in staff in tenacity.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by kiba on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:18PM (#3794348)
Why did Yahoo think they can attack facebook without facebook countersuing?

Did management gone bonker?

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by vibrunazo on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:25PM (#3794381)
IANAL, but I suppose that, since patent claims are extremely subjective to one judge's personal opinion. That objectivity is of very little concern, the results are very unpredictable. There's very little precedence to most software patent suits. So even something that seem objectively ridiculous, could turn out to be a profitable attempt if you get lucky.

So in short, they know they can get lucky, measure costs and potential benefits, and assume the risk is worth it. Maybe if it seem unlikely to win. A dying company doesn't have much to lose. And in the odd occasion that luck is in their favor. They could win a huge load of money.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by jballanc on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @10:10PM (#3795873)
I don't think they were expecting to win in court. For the number of patent suits that are brought, the number that are seen through to a judgment is really quite small. I can't find the link at the moment, but there was a story that Yahoo did essentially the same thing to Google before their IPO. The suit was dropped in exchange for Yahoo getting some of Google's pre-IPO stock. I'd guess the same thing is going on here. The suit/counter-suit is likely nothing more than a trumped up "we want some of your stock" negotiation.
Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by itsnotlupus on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:58PM (#3794799)
Apparently, Facebook recently bought 750 patents from IBM (http://www.cnn.com/2012/03/23/tech/social-media/facebook-ibm...).

This is probably not unrelated.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by ktizo on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @07:46PM (#3795395)
I've heard the idea that economically we are in an IP investment bubble at the moment due to the current IP arms race that is going on over smartphones and associated internet/tech bobbins.

This got me thinking that if we are in a bubble, what would an IP investment crash look like? And how would it be likely to start?

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by reustle on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @03:36PM (#3794425)
Let's hope this doesn't get out of hand... remember this?

http://assets.fiercemarkets.com/files/wireless/fierceimages/...

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by doktrin on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @04:26PM (#3794658)
Frankly, at this point the only viable solution appears for the situation to truly spiral out of control, with glaringly obvious detrimental effects on segments of the economy.

Only then, it seems, will legislators be spurred to take action to curb this inane practice.

Re:Facebook counterclaim accuses Yahoo of infringing 10 patents by EliteSonic on Tuesday April 03, 2012 @11:04PM (#3796020)
Patents are killing the damn industry. Sigh.