News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by short_sells_poo on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:36AM (#37898310)
Technically, morally or practically?

Technically nothing.

Morally, you are depriving the content creators and Youtube of revenue (if they rely on Youtube ads). You could argue that they aren't somehow fundamentally entitled to make money, but you are also not fundamentally entitled to consume their content. The content creator had to do work to produce the content and YT has to do work to provide a platform where it can be disseminated. Naturally, they want to be paid for doing this work. We can argue about how much they should be paid, but again nobody is forced to watch YT. It's a voluntary transaction. If you don't like ads, buy a YT subscription. If you don't want to support YT, encourage your content creators to provide their content elsewhere.

Practically, some companies have been historically willing to shut one or both eyes over open source/free projects as a gesture of goodwill (or marketing exercise). The moment money is involved, the lawyers tend to be unleashed and the whole "this is just a free hobby project with no monetary incentives for the developers" goes out the window.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by 2Gkashmiri on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:49AM (#37898431)
> You could argue that they aren't somehow fundamentally entitled to make money, but you are also not fundamentally entitled to consume their content

i don't know. take radio for example. The advertiser has paid real money to the voice actors, scripts, etc, and the radio company for hosting their content and for propagation, this is real cost. so what happens if you turn off your radio and don't hear the radio commercial? are you obligated to listen to adverts on a radio? what happens if you make a manual hardware sponsorblock?

can the advertiser sue a manufacturer of this manual hardware sponsorblock machine that is an addon to radio? the original selling point of the hardware machine would be to block explicit songs and adblocking would be an added benefit.

could radio companies sue radio makers or this hardware machine maker for selling this addon? knowing full well that this maker is earning money.

>but you are also not fundamentally entitled to consume their content

here is an alternative answer argument. when you publish on a public website, you give away this "right to prevent consumption". youtube is a public website meaning anyone without login can access content so youtube and content creator and advertisers are forfeiting their right to demand remuneration. the alternative? well look at netflix. It is a paywalled service where only paid users access the content. There isn't much of adblocking on netflix or tracking protection and other stuff.

What i am trying to say is, only netflix by their nature of a paywalled gateway can expect this "no payment, no content" rule because they have put technical roadblocks. if tomorrow netflix goes open, they will be treated like youtube.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Monday October 16, 2023 @07:50AM (#37898443)
> If you don't like ads, buy a YT subscription.

Why?

They can block non premium users if they don't want non paying visitors to view the content. And I am free to switch virtual desktop, browser tab, mute it or turn my head away and put earplugs when they want to show an AD. This is just the same, but made with software.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:12AM (#37898714)
Just be honest and say you think you should be able to enjoy those artists’ work without paying. You know how this works: they get paid either from your premium subscription or when ads play. There isn’t a third option where you can watch their work and they get paid.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:02AM (#37899261)
Direct donation ?
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:07AM (#37899323)
That’s called YouTube premium. If you don’t like their business practices, I’d also try to buy directly from the artists or see if they have something like Patreon.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:19AM (#37899504)
> There isn’t a third option where you can watch their work and they get paid.

That's the point there are other ways ...

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:26AM (#37899583)
Not legally. That’s the entire point here: you can use YouTube’s content without following your part of the deal but you don’t have any right to complain when they start blocking that. Nobody is saying you have to like them, only that you don’t have a right to use private property without the consent of the owner.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:32AM (#37899667)
Don't know your point was:

>Just be honest and say you think you should be able to enjoy those artists’ work without paying.

If we go back to legality then as others mentioned I believe in the right to transform what data is served to me.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:42AM (#37901444)
That’s the same point: artists put stuff out where you can see it on the expectation that they’ll get paid. If you don’t want to keep your side of that bargain, you don’t have much standing to complain about being blocked.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:04PM (#37901835)
The artists sign a contract with youtube. Non subscribed users don't. The same way promises only apply to those who believe in them, terms of services only applies to people signing a contract for them.

If a physical shop decide their terms only allow the customers with a membership card to look at the window from outside but decide to not put curtains, those terms do not apply to bystanders who could see inside. Same when my neighbour is naked with all the lights on. If she doesn't want me to see her, she knows what to do.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by mcpackieh on Monday October 16, 2023 @01:03PM (#37902852)
It's like a bookstore that allows anybody to walk in from the street, browse the shelves and read books on a couch, but then says that you're only allowed to do any of this if you also make a purchase or politely listen to one of their employees give me a sales pitch. Well unless they get the cops to arrest me for trespassing, I don't care about their rule. I'll browse their books, read a few, and walk out without buying anything if I please.

If they don't like this, they can turn me away at the door. But they don't, they let me and I'm not signing any contracts with them, so fuck their rule.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:43AM (#37901451)
There is no deal, no contract signed. So there is no deal to follow.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:48AM (#37901538)
The terms of service still apply. If you choose not to follow them, don’t complain when they stop allowing you access. Nobody _needs_ to access YouTube so there’s no harm in not having access to their service.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Tuesday October 17, 2023 @06:18AM (#37912843)
Nobody signs any terms of service except the subscribers of a membership accounts. Nobody is bound to terms listed in a small link hidden somewhere in the page.

Besides, I checked the terms of service in this page[1] today and nowhere is it written that people are forced to look at the ads and can't turn away. And rightfully so it would be illegal to have such terms in most juridictions. So even those that are aware of those terms because they actually looked for them ought to see the ads.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/t/terms

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by mcpackieh on Monday October 16, 2023 @01:00PM (#37902806)
> Not legally.

Call the police, nobody cares.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:40AM (#37901405)
I am honest: I don't want to see ADs nor be tracked, and removing ads is not worth paying 10$ a month to me, especially as I will still be tracked. I haven't signed any contract with youtube, nor with its content uploaders. If Youtube or the people uploading content to it wants to force me to pay to view it, they have a simple solution: make it subscription only. The fact is they do not, so I still retain my rights to use my own client, configured the way I want to and view it with my rules the same way I had the right to switch channel, go for a pee, walk, drinks during adverts when I was still using a television.

Besides YouTube content is not comprised only of artists.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:45AM (#37901477)
If you have a principled objection to being tracked, don’t use YouTube. They do that either way so all you’re really arguing is that you want to use someone else’s work without paying them. That’s a position but don’t expect much respect for it.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by prmoustache on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:53AM (#37901646)
> That’s a position but don’t expect much respect for it.

The same way they shouldn't expect much respect from ad viewing.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by HenryBemis on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:14AM (#37898747)
It's kinda like the F2P and P2W. Looking away is F2P. You get the delay, in a 5min vid you spent 6mins. Getting premium is P2W.

My problem is not the $10 per month, it is that those people will STILL collect and sell my data to anyone who will buy it. $10 don't keep my data 'safe'. $10 is just to avoid ads. I wonder if they will ever make a PremiumPrivate subscription that will cost $20 where you get to avoid ads AND keep your data pritave. (easy answer --> no)

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by janoc on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:08AM (#37898652)
The problem with that argument is that that ship has long sailed.

Today it is next to impossible to securely use the internet without having an adblocker installed and enabled (or using something like Freetube, which is essentially a specialized ad blocking browser), otherwise you are exposing yourself to drive-by malware installs. Ads were and are a major vector here, including Google ones, given their market size. Heck, even FBI recommends it for exactly these reasons!

So if someone is arguing that I have to make my computer less secure only to make sure they can monetize my eyeballs, that's a no, full stop.

I would happily pay and support the artists or creators (and I do so) - but not by removing adblock and opening myself to an indiscriminate onslaught of insecure and poorly made ads.

And lets not delude ourselves with these moral arguments here - this isn't and never was about funding the creators of that content. Most Youtube video creators don't see a dime for their work from Google - and yet Youtube wouldn't exist without them and Google directly profits from that work.

The choice of business model - provide free video supported by advertising - was also Google's. Nobody forced them into it and they are free to make YT subscription-only.

However, if YT was a paid service from the start, they wouldn't be anywhere near where they are today.

And don't get me started on the evolution of ads on YT - I have no issues with watching an ad or two per video. But these days you have unskippable pre-roll ads, you have (often multiple) mid-roll ads, you have ads at the end of the video and all that in addition to whatever sponsor promotion is directly in the video itself (and which actually pays the video creator). So out of a 10 minutes long video there is often ~6 minutes of just ads.

No,thank you.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Mindwipe on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:23AM (#37898840)
> Today it is next to impossible to securely use the internet without having an adblocker installed and enabled (or using something like Freetube, which is essentially a specialized ad blocking browser), otherwise you are exposing yourself to drive-by malware installs.

This is incredibly overstated.

I don't run an ad blocker. I consider it immoral.

It's fine.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by dns_snek on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:37AM (#37899738)
> This is incredibly overstated.

How do you figure that? It's been less than a month since simply loading a .webp image could result in arbitrary code execution in your browser.

Does it happen often? No, but it only needs to happen once to get screwed.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by vharuck on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:52AM (#37899897)
>So out of a 10 minutes long video there is often ~6 minutes of just ads.

I wish it were just this. In the past month, I'm seeing 30 minute "ads" on 10-minute videos for kids. These "ads" are stories with thin plots used to sell toys, like G.I. Joe of yore.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by pydry on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:10AM (#37898695)
As I understand it most content creators rely more on revenue from patreon, sponsorships and being on content owner controlled platforms like nebula.

If you want, primarily, to contribute to the "free sushi restaurant" fund for google employees and financially support your friendly abusive global monpolist for purely moral reasons though by all means turn off that ad blocker...

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izacus on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:30AM (#37898918)
> As I understand it most content creators rely more on revenue from patreon, sponsorships and being on content owner controlled platforms like nebula.

They really don't (which is demonetization hurts them every time YouTube does it). And they don't actually pay YouTube for infrastructure costs via Patreon either. And as many competitors to YouTube (one I worked for myself) found out, carrying video is very expensive.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by pydry on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:37AM (#37898990)
If you're very very popular you can live off ads. Theyre the ones who can negotiate bigger cuts. Otherwise no.

A lot of the content creators I watch are demonetized but google still runs ads. I try to support them directly.

If you're in the mood to donate to Google's profit margins feel free though. They do have an expensive lawsuit to fight against accusations of being an abusive monopolist and I'm sure they could use your cash to help out.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by amelius on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:15AM (#37898753)
There is nothing moral about how the market works. You only get as much money as your business model allows you to get. Someone invents a great mathematical identity, but oops, there is no business model, so no money. Also, if there was a way to unwatch content and get your money back, I bet most people would use it. But this doesn't exist and content makers greedily exploit this fact.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by anothernewdude on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:21AM (#37898812)
> Morally, you are depriving the content creators and Youtube of revenue

No, Youtube deprive the content creators. Like all publishers they give back only a fraction of what the content is worth by abusing their monopoly.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by adra on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:37AM (#37899729)
You know that YouTube is actually one of the few major platforms that are actually not fcking their content creators dry? They have kept their 50/50 split while other platforms have hacked away at percentages to keep more for themselves.

At least with YouTube's case, they actually allow effectively anyone to upload mostly unlimited non-infringing content to their platform without the expectation of a single ad view. You may call them stealing from artists by not giving 100% back to their creators, but a notable chunk of the money collected really does go to keep the lights on for the entire product. It isn't just rent seeking. Complain about the splits, sure let's have a conversation. Complain about YouTube stealing money from artists, I'd say you don't have a leg to debate here.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by e2le on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:40AM (#37899023)
I feel this is setting up a false dichotomy, either you believe creators ought to have the right to monetize views and thus watch the ads, or you don't. It's possible for an individual to believe in their right to monetize their own work but have other reasons (overly aggressive, quality, scams, fraud, and malware) for choosing not to consume the advertisements.

I suspect that if it weren't for the steep decline in the quality of advertisements or their over aggressiveness, many users of content blockers would have never being pushed to seek out a solution that grants them reprieve from the punishing barrage of advertisements.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izacus on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:44AM (#37899080)
No, you're setting up a false dichotomy. YouTube asks you to pay for Premium subscription if you don't want to watch ads. You're bloviating about some kind of moral highground where all you really want is to avoid paying those 15$ the service asks you to pay to use it.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:56AM (#37899191)
It'not like Youtube premium stop the tracking ... And it would mean linking to identifying informations.

As opposed to using YT without any account or multiple ones, linked to a minimum of information, if you want to curate your recommandations.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izacus on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:27AM (#37899594)
I bet a lot that you'd refuse to pay for some other trumped up highground reason if Premium would prove that they stop tracking.

You all just want to get shit for free.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @10:00AM (#37900003)
Don't know on the trumped up, but absolutely I will never trust any promise made by Youtube as long as it's a Google Entity.

As for just wanting things for free, well I'm paying a Nebula subscription so ...

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:54AM (#37899174)
YouTube has an easy way to ensure you never see an ad: pay for premium.

Remember, this is private media, not something you have a right to use. Not liking the terms offered by the owner doesn’t conjure up a right any more than my not liking the dress code at a restaurant means I have standing to sue when they kick me out.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by skydhash on Monday October 16, 2023 @01:36PM (#37903356)
Is it private? I think a lot of people put videos up because they want it to be public. The expectation was for the creators not to pay hosting/storage/processing fees because Youtube will add ads when the video is playing. I choose not to see ads then it’s Youtube loss. They can’t decide what I do with data on my computer. It’s their rights not to send me data, but not to say what I choose to do with it. Imagine buying a bluray and they told you to watch it twice a week at least or the data will get scrambled.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:53PM (#37906475)
It’s private property unless the copyright owner places it in the public domain. Even then, you have no right to use Google’s resources unpaid so you’d have a right to host your own copy but not to use theirs.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by Timshel on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:51AM (#37899141)
Morally I prefer to support creators outside of the Google ecosystem. With youtube premium it's not like they stop tracking then selling what you do, you just gave them even more information with your paiement details ...

The tracking/advertising industry is a cancer, yes it allows some free content and remuneration but at the same times it kills competition from less established actors. Those actors can't just burn money to keep you there while they resell all they can on their own ad network.

So yes I'll block it and if it makes Youtube lose money then they will need to change their model and make it more hostile to users. Which can only help external platform such as Nebula and others grow.

And if those platform grows then creators might be able to leave Youtube.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by BLKNSLVR on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:51AM (#37899144)
I put a lot of effort into maintaining my network and various devices so that content that I don't want is kept on the outside of the boundary that I can control. I have thusly earned the nice, palatable clean feeds of public internet.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by drexlspivey on Monday October 16, 2023 @08:52AM (#37899161)
> Morally, you are depriving the content creators and Youtube of revenue (if they rely on Youtube ads)

In my 20+ years on the internet I have never clicked on an ad. I might have been made aware of a product that I went and purchased later when I actually needed it but never at the moment I saw the ad, meaning no affiliate revenue for the platform/creator. Am I allowed to block ads then, since there is a 100% guarantee that you won’t be getting any money from me?

(I pay for YT premium so it doesn’t directly apply to me but the point still stands)

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @09:04AM (#37899294)
Ads are also billed by impression, so you’re still removing revenue from the people who made the videos you watch.

More importantly, however, this is like going into a restaurant and saying that you should be able to order only a side dish while eating food that you brought with. You might have a good reason for wanting to do that but that doesn’t somehow create a right to use someone else’s private property in violation of their wishes.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by someone7x on Monday October 16, 2023 @10:21AM (#37900233)
Must I buy the product at Costco after I’ve tasted the sample or am I just a freeloader?

Am I morally obliged to acknowledge the sponsors for everything I personally don’t purchase?

To whom do I owe patronage when I accept something gratis?

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @11:20AM (#37901065)
> Must I buy the product at Costco after I’ve tasted the sample or am I just a freeloader?

No, because the owner of that property has set terms allowing that. Try to eat a dozen samples, though, and they’ll probably ask you to leave.

This isn’t actually a complicated concept: their property, their rules. If you don’t like YouTube, that’s totally reasonable – I don’t – but no amount of sophistry will create a right for you to use their private property on your terms. Just go somewhere else: there are tons of creators who’d love a better deal than Google/Facebook offer them but that’s never going to happen as long as people insist on paying them through YouTube.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by someone7x on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:35PM (#37902381)
By your reasoning, YouTube (like Costco) should ask the actual freeloaders to stop instead of imposing ads on every Costco member in a misguided quest to profit on every single free sample.

I’m impressed you saw what should really happen at Costco, but disappointed you could not extrapolate that thinking to the YouTube case.

Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @12:58PM (#37902776)
That analogy doesn’t make any sense - the free samples are the ads! – but in both cases there’s a simple principle: your use of someone else’s property happens on their terms. If you don’t like their business, go somewhere else.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by skydhash on Monday October 16, 2023 @01:47PM (#37903495)
No! They want me to look at their videos because they need me to look at their ads. I choose the former, not the latter. There’s various way they could enforce their rules but they won’t do it because they want the maximum people they can get. I’m not asking for free content, they are pushing it to me. I just take the content and leave the ads out.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by acdha on Monday October 16, 2023 @04:52PM (#37906442)
That’s a position, sure, but don’t complain when they block you.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by skydhash on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:27PM (#37906896)
I won't. Lots of news sites do and I just go back.
Re:FreeTube – The Private YouTube Client by izzydata on Monday October 16, 2023 @10:56AM (#37900696)
>If you don't like ads, buy a YT subscription

I won't buy a YouTube subscription precisely because I don't like ads. Buying a YouTube subscription is directly in support of ads. If you give Google money for a YouTube subscription you have just let Google know that ads are a great way for them to make money. They are now incentivized to implement more ads in the future.

Paying to remove ads only causes more ads in the world.