News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by LadyCailin on Saturday October 14, 2023 @08:58AM (#37880132)
We have no choice but to have and use our brains, not so with LLMs. We don’t have to start building core technologies off of fundamentally flawed models.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by diydsp on Saturday October 14, 2023 @09:14AM (#37880224)
Great point. Btw: The problem is corporate irresponsibility:

When self-driving cars were first coming out a professor of mine said "They only have to be as a good as humans." It took a while but now i can say why that's insufficient: human errors are corrected by discipline and justice. Corporations dissipate responsibility by design. When self-driving cars kill, no one goes to jail. Corporate fines are notoriously ineffective, just a cost of doing business.

And even without the legal power, most people do try to drive well enough to bit injure each other which is a different calculus from prematurely taking products to market for financial gain.

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by cdogl on Saturday October 14, 2023 @10:09AM (#37880587)
Very succinctly put - this captures my view but I couldn’t have put it in these words; thanks!
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by kenjackson on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:55AM (#37881483)
Human errors are not corrected by discipline and justice. Drunk driving is still a huge problem.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by WoodenChair on Saturday October 14, 2023 @01:53PM (#37882626)
The top 3 causes of death by vehicle accident in USA are [0]:

- DUI

- speeding

- distraction

In other words all human errors. Machines don’t drink, shouldn’t speed if programmed correctly, and are never distracted fiddling with their radio controls or looking down at their phones. So if they are at least as good as a human driver in general (obeying traffic laws, not hitting obstructions, etc.), they will be safer than a human driver in these areas that really matter.

What do you care more about—that there is somebody specific to blame for an accident or that there are less human deaths?

0: https://www.idrivesafely.com/defensive-driving/trending/most... and many other sources you can find

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by diydsp on Saturday October 14, 2023 @04:11PM (#37883844)
Under corporate control safety spirals down to increase profit. See: opiods, climate change, pesticides, antibiotic resistance, deforestation, and privacy. 50 years from now self-driving cars will be cheaper and more dangerous. Human driving misbehavior will still be disincentivized through the justice system, but corporations will continue to avoid individual responsibility for dangerous programming.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by bliteben on Sunday October 15, 2023 @08:26AM (#37889185)
We could likely put 80% of cars on rails just as easily
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by robswc on Saturday October 14, 2023 @02:26PM (#37882909)
They only have to be as good as humans because that's what society deems an acceptable risk.

I do think the point about how companies are treated vs humans is a good one. Tbh though, I'm not sure it matters much in the instance of driver-less cars. There isn't mass outrage when driver less cars kill people because that (to us) is an acceptable risk. I feel whatever fines/punishments employed against companies would only marginally reduce deaths, if that. I honestly think laws against drunk driving only marginally reduce drunk driving.

I'm not saying we shouldn't punish drunk driving... just that anything short of an instant death penalty for driving drunk probably wouldn't dissuade many people.

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by Szpadel on Saturday October 14, 2023 @05:00PM (#37884233)
In my country, drunk driving is punished by losing license and banning you from using another one for half year for first time and of life for second. And it's very effective, as those cases are rarity now
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by int_19h on Sunday October 15, 2023 @03:30AM (#37887715)
> It took a while but now i can say why that's insufficient: human errors are corrected by discipline and justice.

If they did, we'd be living in utopia already.

But also, by the same token, generative AI errors are similarly "corrected" by fine-tuning and RLHF. In both cases, you don't actually fix it - you just make it less likely to happen again.

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by manojlds on Saturday October 14, 2023 @09:03AM (#37880157)
Yeah, if we wanted to flap wings to fly, we would have never got the airplane.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by Filligree on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:02AM (#37880994)
The ornithopter is real, mind you.
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by stevenhuang on Saturday October 14, 2023 @09:08AM (#37880192)
> fundamentally flawed

Citation needed

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by Davidzheng on Saturday October 14, 2023 @10:33AM (#37880764)
Such a strange take. We have no choice but to use our brains??? It is also an incredibly capable system! At some point if the capabilities are so drastically different is it confusing that you would choose a much more capable system even with all its flaws?
Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by pixl97 on Saturday October 14, 2023 @07:28PM (#37885258)
Because you are demanding and may rise up with pitchforks if the corporate class asks too much.

At the same time, humans are also unreliable as hell , push us much more than 8 hours a day of actual thinking work and our answers start to get crappy.

Re:All of ChatGPT's System Prompts by IshKebab on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:48AM (#37881416)
Are you suggesting we just ignore the immense capabilities of these models because we don't fully understand them?

I hope you never need any medicine!