News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Friday October 13, 2023 @02:58PM (#37874180)
> I really hate the way events like that justified so much conspiracy-theory thinking.

Probably because the people who theorized that there had been a conspiracy turned out to be correct, and the usual bromide objections ("someone would have talked," "more than 50 people can never keep a secret," "the government just isn't that competent," etc) were shown to be entirely false.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by nitwit005 on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:17PM (#37874406)
I'm not even sure if this qualifies as a secret. People were openly discussing the UK and US involvement at the time.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:30PM (#37874559)
Yes, and this is one of the main problems with the "someone would have talked" objection. There are often witnesses or leakers, including to events like the JFK assassination, but as long as they can be kept out of the public consciousness or adequately smeared as cranks, it's as if the secret was kept regardless.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by nitwit005 on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:40PM (#37874675)
The New York Times published an article reporting Soviet charges that the United States was behind the coup.

It was just genuinely not a secret.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by t-3 on Friday October 13, 2023 @07:45PM (#37876809)
The same or similar can be said about pretty much any "conspiracy theory", from totally insane ancient alien stuff to mundane corruption and foul play.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by orwin on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:23PM (#37875189)
I'm sorry, but this coup is the only "conspiracy theory" where i got second-hand versions of actual witnesses (actually, participants). There were journalists that wrote on that in France in the 60s (proamerican anticommunist, hardline right wing, so when he wrote "the US did it because Mossadegh was a commie", i mean, everybody should believe it). We had actual political party that wrote that the US did it in their manifesto in the 70s, and taught that to their members in their "modern history" lessons (my father tended to those instead of going to catechism/sunday school). You had public figures in Iran who said "The US paid us".

It was quite clear the US did it until in the 00s a top US official said "yeah, we did it, it was cheap".

JFK assassination is weird, because only 3 people needed to be involved, so it might be hard to find actual participants, but most conspiracy theories needs a lot more (anywhere from dozens to thousands), and those, i wouldn't trust no one serious talked. When Seymour Hersh managed to find proofs on CIA most secret operation (MKUltra, which is way worse imho than lying about getting on the moon or whatever), its hard to keep that objection.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by almatabata on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:41PM (#37875393)
> most conspiracy theories needs a lot more (anywhere from dozens to thousands), and those, i wouldn't trust no one serious talked.

The CIA tried to deleting all evidence of the mkultra project in 1973. They missed a few documents related to the funding that allowed the commission to actually find evidence for it. Had they succeeded you would never have had enough evidence to prove it. You would have had ex-cia members involved in drug experiments. Would the general public have trusted them? If a guy with drug problems claimed the government had experimented on him, who would have believed him?

How many projects did they successfully erase all proof of?

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by greiskul on Friday October 13, 2023 @06:26PM (#37876292)
Yup. Inteligence agencies are something that when you start doing serious research on, you end up being very paranoid. Cause the most sucessful operations leave no traces, and if the people responsible don't happen to leave behind documents about it that happened to be disclosed later, it is very possible for everybody, even the country responsible for it, to never learn the truth.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by redeeman on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:00PM (#37875576)
its funny how governments ALWAYS lies about wars they have been involved with, and people by and large considers this to be true. but currently when there are wars, we are to trust them 100%
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by 0xParlay on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:16PM (#37875099)
This one too. “We’ve always been at war with Eastasia”.

We’ve always known the NSA spies on Americans. We’ve always known ISPs were involved in dragnet surveillance. We’ve always known the CIA assassinated Kennedy

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Saturday October 14, 2023 @11:20AM (#37881168)
Right, this is a common tactic once the conspiracy's effects are set in concrete and the opportunity for agitation or reaction has long since passed.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by downWidOutaFite on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:08PM (#37874302)
Conspiracy theorists can be wrong about 100 things before they're right about one thing. They're useless for understanding the current state of the world.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by csomar on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:19PM (#37874429)
Conspiracy theories do not emerge from nothingness but the lack of transparency, double-standards and lack of a clear moral framework is what gives them a breeding ground.

Realpolitik is like corporate America today. It optimizes return for the next couple quarters disregarding the long-term damage.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by nitwit005 on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:24PM (#37874493)
Have every meeting in public, publish every document, and they'll still insist you're part of a Communist conspiracy to poison the tap water.

Or for a more modern one, examine the diverse accusations around 5G.

Some of it's just general paranoia and distrust, or outright mental illness.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by rightbyte on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:59PM (#37874908)
Mentally ill conspiracy theorist are just mentally ill. Why even bring those up. They are used to smear people pointing out actual conspiracies in such a way that even using the word "conspiracy" will make people think you are a lunatic.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by nitwit005 on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:38PM (#37875367)
We're discussing the reasons for conspiracy theories "emerging". Any honest list will include mental illness.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by rightbyte on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:15PM (#37875714)
Fair enough.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by gustavus on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:12PM (#37874355)
Exactly after all the conspiracy theorists were only right about

- Iraq WMDs

- MkUltra

- The Crack Epidemic

- Watergate

- Glados

- Paperclip

- Robert Kennedy car crash

- Epstien

But they just got lucky a bunch.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by gruez on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:20PM (#37874440)
1. You listed 8 conspiracies. How many false conspiracies (or ones that failed to pan out) are there? If there are 800 of them, then OP isn't exactly wrong.

2. For the ones you listed, were there specific and credible "conspiracy theories" that existed prior to them being discovered/confirmed? Or were there only vague theories of "government doing something shady"?

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by plorg on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:35PM (#37874626)
Then also, which specific conspiracy theories were actually confirmed? Part of the problem is that the kernel of truth in the theory is scaffolded out to "justify" the much broader, wilder claims.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by t-3 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:00PM (#37876882)
> You listed 8 conspiracies. How many false conspiracies (or ones that failed to pan out) are there? If there are 800 of them, then OP isn't exactly wrong.

The set of possible conspiracy theories is infinite. The set believed by any one 'conspiracy theorist' is likely to be far smaller. Lumping in hollow earth, lizardpeople, flatearther, aliens etc with 'government lies about wars' is always a cynical move to avoid legitimate criticism and spread propaganda.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by smegger001 on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:08PM (#37877206)
Exsept the believable ones act as gateways to the hard stuff. Its a small mental jump from epsteins pedo island to the DMC being run by satanic communist pedophilias frequenting a pizza shop child brothel. It only a few more jumps to secret base and tunnel system under Denver airport to hallow flat earth and lizard people.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Sunday October 15, 2023 @11:21AM (#37890478)
This seems about as true as the theory that marijuana inevitably acts as a gateway to harder drugs.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by satvikpendem on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:24PM (#37874488)
Now name the thousands that they aren't right about. Your comment is literally survivorship bias in action.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by downWidOutaFite on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:32PM (#37874572)
Most of this was revealed by mainstream journalists, not conspiracy theorists.

The one I lived through, Iraq WMDs, wasnt a conspiracy theory at the time. All credible evidence said there were no WMDs. Bush and Cheney lied with no evidence. Everyone that was not a partisan Republican called them out on their flimsy pretext. That's why we had the largest antiwar protests ever (while conservatives ridiculed us).

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by klyrs on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:57PM (#37874875)
A conspiracy theory of that time was that Bush was behind 9/11 because he wanted a causus belli to shore up his tanking popularity in the leadup to his re-election. Basically, fitting the plot of Wag the Dog to the facts of the day. The theory remains unsubstantiated.

Another was that the collapse of the world trade center towers was due to planted explosive charges. That one has been roundly refuted.

Of course, people continue to believe what that will, but there's a pretty big gap in the amount of evidence behind those theories and confirmed conspiracies.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by daveguy on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:20PM (#37875158)
> A conspiracy theory of that time was that Bush was behind 9/11 because he wanted a causus belli to shore up his tanking popularity in the leadup to his re-election.

It's not just unsubstantiated, it's flatly wrong on its face. Bush had been in office less than 9 months. He wasn't anywhere close to re-election. This is when the next race typically didn't ramp up until the year of the election.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by klyrs on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:58PM (#37875548)
Fault me for not paying terribly close attention to the conspiracy theorists, but it's true his approval ratings were dismal and dropping (and right after, he was around the most popular president in history). The bit about the leadup to the election is probably my mid-remembered addition.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by daveguy on Monday October 16, 2023 @02:30PM (#37904055)
Yes, I do fault you for not paying terribly close attention to the conspiracy theories... yet accepting what they say as true.

His approval was relatively stable and above 50%. You can see what it looked like if you scroll down from this link: https://projects.fivethirtyeight.com/biden-approval-rating/

I don't care if you pay attention to the conspiracy theorists or not. But please stop propagating conspiracy BS as if it were true.

To be fair, his approval was continually dropping when he decided to invade Iraq on claims of WMD, but that was well after 9/11 and going into Afghanistan.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by klyrs on Monday October 16, 2023 @05:19PM (#37906804)
What did I accept as truth? I said it was unsubstantiated. As in, no evidence for it. The context of the thread is that some people are saying that the broken clock was right a couple of times, and I was pointing to times when it was wrong. And yeah, Biden is pretty unpopular too -- he's doing worse than Bush II.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by yabbs on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:15PM (#37875086)
2 planes, 3 buildings.

Hack those numbers.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by klyrs on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:27PM (#37875828)
I put more stock in the people who can do deeper analysis than your arithmetic.

https://www.nist.gov/pao/questions-and-answers-about-nist-wt...

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by pessimizer on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:11PM (#37875035)
> Most of this was revealed by mainstream journalists

No, most of this was ignored by mainstream US journalists, and the mainstream journalists who still insisted on talking about them were pushed out of the mainstream. Journalists like Judith Miller at the notoriously conservative NYT (a woman who was made to take the blame for everything for some reason) were the face of the mainstream.

The only distinction that makes journalism "mainstream," at least in the US, is a running mutual relationship with the administration and intelligence agencies. Not circulation, not profitability, not influence, not truthfulness of reporting, nor quality of reporting. "Mainstream" outlets float government narratives crediting anonymous sources or sources delivered to the outlet on a platter. They also consult with the government and intelligence agencies before publishing stories, and will avoid entire subjects or questions on request. They do this in exchange for accurate inside information and scoops, or external benefits for the owners of the outlets.

The vast majority of Democrats energetically supported the WMD lie, although it was false on its face based on the reports of the inspectors, and the fact that the documents used to justify it were obvious frauds ("The Dirty Dossier"). The rest was from "Curveball" who was an obvious fraud with an ulterior motive from the first encounter, and who no one ever bothered to corroborate, but who offered what the people who sell war material (and the politicians they fund) were buying.

Democrats ridiculed us, too. All but one of them voted for the war, and they still marginalize her for it.

This personal identification with Democrats among certain people seems to wash away all of their actual votes and rhetoric. Every problem becomes about how evil Republicans are, and no rational reason is ever offered for that evil, because all of the rational reasons (corruption, ambition) apply as easily to their Democratic counterparts. I found a name for those people during the Trump impeachment: "emoluments libs." They were the people who insisted that the Democrats weren't impeaching on emoluments because they weren't brave enough and weren't really trying, rather than because any investigation into Trump taking advantage of his office for cash would in the end implicate most of Congress to a greater extent than Trump, who was an outsider in a bad position to make the kind of money that old masters get up to.

The idea that Tony Blair is the face of conservatism is laughable. Obama taking over the wars was ideal for people who made money from them, because they had become too closely associated with US religious warriors who were trying to put clothes on naked statues. You needed an Obama to indemnify the worldwide black site torture program and the intentional destruction of the evidence of it, to continue PATRIOT and to indemnify the companies that surveilled their customers, and to continue to prosecute those wars.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Curveball_(informant)

Iraq War's Authorization by Congress Is Still on the Books and Dangerously Open-Ended

https://foreignpolicy.com/2023/09/28/iraq-war-aumf-authority...

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by triceratops on Friday October 13, 2023 @05:02PM (#37875594)
> Democrats ridiculed us, too. All but one of them voted for the war

Where are you getting this information from?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37875198 has the actual voting record. Senate Democrats were 57-43 in favor but 2:1 against in the House.

Are you confusing it with Afghanistan? A lot of people seem to do that these days, though I didn't look up the voting record for that conflict.

Republicans had a total of 7 votes against attacking Iraq - in both houses.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by InitialLastName on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:24PM (#37875198)
I was at those protests, but pretending that the Iraq war was a purely Republican partisan contrivance is historical revisionism.

Here's the voting record for the authorization for use of force in Iraq:

House: For: 296 (R:215, D:81), Against: 133 (R:6, D:126, I:1) [0]

Senate: For: 77 (R: 48, D:29) , Against: 23 (R:1 , D:21, I1) [1]

Yes, there was more opposition from members of the Democratic Party, but there's quite a lot of support there from Dems.

[0] https://clerk.house.gov/evs/2002/roll455.xml

[1] https://www.senate.gov/legislative/LIS/roll_call_votes/vote1...

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by beambot on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:18PM (#37875138)
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by stelliosk on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:30PM (#37877042)
A broken clock is right twice a day.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by callalex on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:51PM (#37877145)
I’ve been told in earnest that the earth is flat but people of Jewish decent are hiding that fact from me. Including only the successes on your list is misleading.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by reducesuffering on Friday October 13, 2023 @09:58PM (#37877492)
If you're going to make a list like this, at least make sure all of them are right. "The Crack Epidemic" is not one conspiracy theorists are right about. As the common conspiracy trope is that the government invented crack and gave it to black people to destroy their neighborhoods.

Iraq WMD's is also wrong and case of what happens when conspiracy theorists get a hold of the US government. Most countries and the US house did not accept the WMD conspiracy that immediately turned out to be untrue as most conspiracies do. Now the conspiracy theorists are that it was all done for oil, which is also a blatantly dumb characterization.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by defrost on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:28PM (#37877616)
As conspiracy theories go "The Crack Epidemic" is at least ballpark - the details are hazy but there's something there.

THe OIG (Office of Inspector General) report into "THE CIA-CONTRA-CRACK COCAINE CONTROVERSY" (December, 1997)

https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/legacy/special/9...

didn't touch the bedrock involvement of the CIA-Contra support underpinning the magnitude increase and near literal flooding of cocaine powder into the USofA (because that connection had already been "extensively reviewed in previous inquiries by the Senate Foreign Relations Committee's Subcommittee on Narcotics, Terrorism and International Operations; the State Department; the DEA; and the CIA.")

That, however, is enough on it's own to make the case that the CIA was (indirectly) responsible - had the volume not increased so substantially and had the price not dropped so dramatically there would never had been any driver to make a more addictive by product so readily available.

The rest of the OIG report is volumous but weak - there is no evidence because various targets "fell between the cracks", there was no task force because the agent who suggested one had a case of "her supervisors did not take her request seriously because she was a female agent." and not "because there was pressure to cover up".

These are not great reasons that the evidence is lacking because deeper investigations were not held, and they don't exclude unseen pressure to not look further.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by krapp on Friday October 13, 2023 @10:07PM (#37877534)
Conspiracy theorists didn't know about any of those conspiracies beforehand, most if not all were revealed by mainstream media (or, in the case of MKUltra, by accidental declassification) and conspiracy theorists claimed credit for them after the fact.

Epstein is a particular howler because the QAnon set loudly proclaiming triumph about that was entirely focused on phantom satanic pedophile cults with the Democratic Party while Epstein was never even on their radar.

Yes, they just got lucky a bunch.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Saturday October 14, 2023 @10:54AM (#37880923)
Epstein was on plenty of conspiracy theorists' radars, if maybe not the QAnon set's. There's a through line from the Franklin Scandal to the Dutroux Affair to Epstein, all of which conspiracy theorists have been citing as evidence of elite pedophilia, trafficking, and unaccountability for years.

Probably you're unaware of this because your conception of a conspiracy theorist and what they believe or argue has been handed to you by mass media.

Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by cempaka on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:31PM (#37874567)
The point is not that any given random conspiracy theory is correct. It's that these specific objections to conspiratorial analysis are spurious and disproven.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by AwaAwa on Friday October 13, 2023 @03:12PM (#37874349)
Until that percentage starts to improve dramatically like in the last 5 years.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by oatmeal1 on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:11PM (#37875036)
"Conspiracy theorists" isn't one group of people. "Conspiracy theory" is just a label applied when anyone believes something outside the Overton Window.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by downWidOutaFite on Friday October 13, 2023 @04:14PM (#37875075)
I don't think it's related to the Overton Window. Usually it's just a web of insinuations based on vibes.
Re:CIA publicly acknowledges 1953 coup it backed in Iran was... by smegger001 on Friday October 13, 2023 @08:56PM (#37877163)
Except people didnt keep quiet and weren't that compatent that why it shows up in high school us history books and gave us the shit shows in the middle east and Latin America today. So both side were right and wrong it was a conspiracy of blabering incompatents.