At some point, it will become impossible to tell the difference.
It is crazy if you need a good example of what Stephen Fry id talking about look at the "Attenborough Lore" channel. I honestly can't tell other than I doubt he'd do voice overs for dozens of 40k videos and the narrator is listed as "AI".
By having a publicly associated wallet which can sign the release/link/buffer of an audio file one would be able to assure legitimacy of the output and the rest of the world can carry on without worrying they are being bamboozled by a deepfake.
However, blockchains have been going so deep down the path of cryptocurrencies and get rich quick schemes that their real use cases are being ignored for random tokens.
The blockchain I envision being used for this purpose I stated above would have no token, it would just be… a blockchain.
I guess you could have the ‘mining/POW’ part take place during the signing of the data and would be done by the signee.
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
However, any system which can achieve the same goal is perfectly valid. This was just my initial thought — probably from my large exposure to blockchains etc
I live in Japan where Instax instant camera are super popular. Fujifilm makes more money off of making and selling Polaroid-style analog instant film than any single other business. The Impossible Project is cute and fun for hipsters but Instax has been there making film all along.
But they realized that young women today aren't happy how they look, and they want to use Instagram-style beauty filters on themselves, so they started selling Instax Bluetooth printers. They take analog instant film cartridges, but they use an LCD to imprint the photo onto them. So now you get the nostalgia of Polaroid photos, but you can edit your face as much as you want. Is this digital or analog?
It's just blurry digital. The polaroid film is acting as a really lossy medium for the digital information. Look close enough and you will likely still find artifacts of digital photography in the "film" printout.
That way, you can set up a chain of trust, to track where some information is coming from.
This works as long as there is at least a top level signature provider that is uncorrupted. That will be hard in authoritarian societies and maybe even harder in radically polarized societies. Imagine a world where the CPP, DNC and GOP (and others) each controlled their own CA's, and had the ability to present a fake view of reality to their supporters.
Which can easily omit things they did say but wish they hadn't.
If I’m right, if you take a photo of Leonardo DiCaprio you can’t just use it in a commercial to promote a product without his permission even though you own the copyright of the photo.
Nor can you place an actor in a movie without their permission - they did that with Crispin Glover in Back to the Future 2, he sued the studio and I believe won or the studio settled.
That's always been possible, but in the past it would be clear that random Joe isn't a good actor and DiCaprio is. But if the whole thing is CGI anyway, you can make him as good or bad of an actor as you want.
... which we do already do, of course, if the protected item is something like an iPhone.
In both cases, though, if you falsely claim that the actor/phone IS the real thing, then it's clearly forgery.
And, I suppose, if you specifically bake too much of a similarity into it (ie a phone that looks exactly like an iphone, except the logo), one may argue that the likness effectively misleads the same way a forgery would, and that it can be illegal for that reason.
Unfortunately that's Jackie, Don, Joey,and Joe instead of Sylvester, Patrick, John, and Martin.
So it's no surefire thing.
As mentioned in my previous post, in Back to the Future 2, the studio hired another actor to play Crispin Glover's role by wearing a mask of his face to look like him. Glover sued and got a nice payout.
This would not have been a problem if they just recasted the role like they did with Claudia Wells (who was replaced by Elisabeth Shue).
— Also, none of the above is legal advice.
There was also the case of Crispin Glover in Back to the Future 2. Glover also got paid.
Difference between "someone sounds like Fry" and "have trained a model on his voice and hoped he won't notice". In second version his rights to his voice would be violated
It matters not what you could potentially do with a tool but rather what you actually did with the tool and the consequences of what you did. "Fraud" charges already can capture a lot of these things without additional regulating around what models you can legally train in the first place.
https://www.smh.com.au/entertainment/tv-and-radio/fox-news-m...
This might feel like nitpicking but given the topic... there are places where there is no notion of 'fair use' like this. There are a whole variety of answers to the question of how much of your identity is yours (and how much is even separable from yourself). One shouldn't take whatever IP regime you're familiar with as the only possible truth.
Deepfakes have already been to the supreme court (hustler v. Falwell). Cutting back on such uses risks cutting into freedom of speech. As with Falwell, the answers involve educating the public so that they can tell fake from real, not giving famous people the ability to blackball every work they feel is too similar to themselves. Lots of people talk like Stephen Fry. He doesnt get to own that accent or mode of speach just because he is the most famous.