News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by JoshTriplett on Sunday October 08, 2023 @08:44AM (#37809955)
> the answers involve educating the public so that they can tell fake from real

At some point, it will become impossible to tell the difference.

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by 7thaccount on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:38AM (#37810347)
You mean all those Warhammer 40k lore videos with David Attenborough weren't legit? :)

It is crazy if you need a good example of what Stephen Fry id talking about look at the "Attenborough Lore" channel. I honestly can't tell other than I doubt he'd do voice overs for dozens of 40k videos and the narrator is listed as "AI".

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sandworm101 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:57AM (#37811045)
Attenborough is an interesting example because he had a real life near-analogue. He had a famous brother, Richard Attenborough (John Hammond in Jurassic Park). Their voices were extremely similar and they of course looked much the same. David is more famous now but back in the 1990s Richard was more recognizable. Who owns the voice? Does it default to the person who is most famous at a given moment? How often to we revisit that? Do the brothers battle it out in court to see which is allowed and which forbidden to do voiceovers using the "Attenborough" voice? And the Olsen sisters... that's a legal quagmire.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by makingstuffs on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:25AM (#37810246)
This is one use case I can see for immutable and distributed public ledgers aka blockchains.

By having a publicly associated wallet which can sign the release/link/buffer of an audio file one would be able to assure legitimacy of the output and the rest of the world can carry on without worrying they are being bamboozled by a deepfake.

However, blockchains have been going so deep down the path of cryptocurrencies and get rich quick schemes that their real use cases are being ignored for random tokens.

The blockchain I envision being used for this purpose I stated above would have no token, it would just be… a blockchain.

I guess you could have the ‘mining/POW’ part take place during the signing of the data and would be done by the signee.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by axiak on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:33AM (#37810304)
Genuinely curious -- what does a blockchain provide here that a normal public key signing doesn't?
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by makingstuffs on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:38AM (#37810353)
To be honest the main benefit I can see is that the entire DB would be publicly distributed among a large number of independent users which would make the data a lot harder to falsify/hack/corrupt.

However, any system which can achieve the same goal is perfectly valid. This was just my initial thought — probably from my large exposure to blockchains etc

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sandworm101 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:49AM (#37810965)
A boost to GPU sales.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sneak on Sunday October 08, 2023 @11:49AM (#37811539)
Timestamping and future immutability.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by air7 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:03AM (#37810086)
I wonder if at that point people will rightfully lose confidence in the authenticity of digital media, or if people are doomed to believe what they see...
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by kalleboo on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:08AM (#37810129)
"Digital" doesn't mean anything more.

I live in Japan where Instax instant camera are super popular. Fujifilm makes more money off of making and selling Polaroid-style analog instant film than any single other business. The Impossible Project is cute and fun for hipsters but Instax has been there making film all along.

But they realized that young women today aren't happy how they look, and they want to use Instagram-style beauty filters on themselves, so they started selling Instax Bluetooth printers. They take analog instant film cartridges, but they use an LCD to imprint the photo onto them. So now you get the nostalgia of Polaroid photos, but you can edit your face as much as you want. Is this digital or analog?

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by bordercases on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:17AM (#37810190)
The real argument is around degrees of reconstruction in image. Cameras never depict light fully faithfully in the analog world.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by kalleboo on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:05AM (#37810537)
And even in the fully analog days there was plenty of doctoring of photos, it just wasn't as accessible to the common man without the equipment. Famously: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Censorship_of_images_in_the_So...
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sandworm101 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:46AM (#37810939)
>> use an LCD to imprint the photo onto them.

It's just blurry digital. The polaroid film is acting as a really lossy medium for the digital information. Look close enough and you will likely still find artifacts of digital photography in the "film" printout.

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sandworm101 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:05AM (#37810108)
Or famous people can maintain authoritative lists of things they have done and said. Something as simple as Imdb can do much in debunking fakery.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by trashtester on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:10AM (#37810584)
In principle, any digital artifact may be digitally signed, just like web pages are (using CA's).

That way, you can set up a chain of trust, to track where some information is coming from.

This works as long as there is at least a top level signature provider that is uncorrupted. That will be hard in authoritarian societies and maybe even harder in radically polarized societies. Imagine a world where the CPP, DNC and GOP (and others) each controlled their own CA's, and had the ability to present a fake view of reality to their supporters.

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by dylan604 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:36AM (#37810838)
There’s information about me on IMDb that isn’t accurate. Not once ever have I added information about me on IMDb, so where exactly is this authoritative information on IMDb coming from? Requests by me to have information corrected goes no where. IMDb as an authoritative source is pure folly at best
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by sandworm101 on Sunday October 08, 2023 @10:43AM (#37810904)
Something as simple as IMBD, not literally IMDB. It is possible for famous people to maintain curated lists of their official work. Presidents especially do this, eventually putting it all into presidential libraries. Or it isn't possible to verify any information online because [reasons] and then our entire society falls apart as nothing online can ever be trusted. We aren't anywhere near that point.
Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by JoshTriplett on Monday October 09, 2023 @12:11AM (#37816863)
> Or famous people can maintain authoritative lists of things they have done and said.

Which can easily omit things they did say but wish they hadn't.

Re:Stephen Fry Warns About the Dangers of Voice Clones by Zetobal on Sunday October 08, 2023 @09:05AM (#37810105)
Why differentiate between digital and offline media do you believe the gro isn't produced digitally?