News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by aeturnum on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:36PM (#37697390)
It is absolutely wild to me that Discord put up with this at all - but it's not surprising that they would want to change this. It also makes me wonder if Discord could add permanent image hosting to their list of Nitro benefits. I do think they're in prime position to become a service hub for the Very Online but not very technical.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by ehnto on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:49PM (#37697525)
I agree and hadn't really considered the Very Online but not technical as a cohort before. Perhaps in contrast to people who are online but not "online natives".

Discord has become a defacto platform for online native communities, in the same way many of us treated IRC. It's really the same atmosphere, any of you old nerds yearning for the IRC golden years should try and find a discord server to join.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by treyd on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:52PM (#37697550)
> any of you old nerds yearning for the IRC golden years should try and find a discord server to join.

If we're still on IRC then we mostly would clearly have an objection to using discord for the very many legitimate reasons to object to it, such as the mass data collection, phone number requirements for many users, lack of control / selfhosting capability, or just general requirement to use (very heavy) nonlibre software to access it.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by personjerry on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:30PM (#37697820)
why would being on IRC be synonymous with any of that? maybe people on IRC just want to hang out and chat with people?
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by meiraleal on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:01PM (#37698039)
That's what IRC was originally for. Later, it took on a counterculture vibe. Now, it's mostly nostalgia for older folks.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by prophesi on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:23PM (#37698205)
This is a very contentious topic but looking into the relatively recent Freenode vs Librem.chat debacle I think signifies how important privacy is to the common IRC user.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by e63f67dd-065b on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:08PM (#37698489)
I don't think that's the right conclusion to draw at all from the Freenode debacle. A pretty significant amount of the channels stayed on Freenode after Andrew's takeover, until Andrew kicked them off himself with the mass Libera purge. There were many communities still on a wait-and-see approach -- at least until Andrew was revealed to be semi-insane (Emperor of Korea, digital territory, alt-right conspiracies, etc).

Yes, the open source privacy crowd is a big chunk, but there were just as many social communities. Don't you remember the olden days of sex channels and all their drama? The roleplay, alt history, sci-fi, and just general random niche hobbies that populated the IRC landscape. IRC was, above all, a social space, it just so happens that many of these communities died or migrated to discord over time. Those that remain are those who are most attached to privacy/open source/etc, all the rest are gone.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by lolinder on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:39PM (#37698680)
I don't remember privacy being a significant part of the discussion about the Freenode takeover and the subsequent founding of Libera.chat. My memory is that the hostile takeover was a big problem for some, and the majority of the exodus happened when Andrew went crazy and started hijacking channels and banning people en masse.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by sScTE9qEMCxEk34 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:40PM (#37699023)
Privacy was an enormous part of the argument for even starting Libera.

> I believe that his intentions are malicious, and that he should under no circumstances gain control over the network, nor access to its user data.

Just from the first "explainer" I remember (https://gist.github.com/joepie91/df80d8d36cd9d1bde46ba018af4...)

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by burnished on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:44PM (#37697940)
At the end of the day its just a chat protocol, not a lifestyle.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by axus on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:54PM (#37698000)
The Medium is the Message.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:00PM (#37697612)
Just in time for the rugpull that became inevitable the day money stopped being free? No thank you.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by SV_BubbleTime on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:14PM (#37697721)
ZIRP rules everything around me.

Ruled… and hopefully not returning too soon.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:58AM (#37704329)
Not that I don't agree, but that doesn't make it pleasant to live through a titanomachy.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by SV_BubbleTime on Friday September 29, 2023 @11:58AM (#37706136)
A pleasant wasn’t an option with ZIRP.

Here is the option though… we ignore the titans above us, the ones that desperately need us. See some of them fall; and hopefully they shrink small enough were we aren’t craning our necks so much.

Or, we continue to pretend that everything is fine and keep praying and sacrificing (printing money) and pretend that will just keep working.

ZIRP was a mistake. Better to rip the bandaid off now.

But… for what it’s worth, I think it will lead to war. Actual war, not this proxy stuff. We’re too far in and owe China too much. There needs to be some debt reset because “paying it off” isn’t a thing.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:25PM (#37707436)
Good grief. Here I thought I was all doom and gloom today...
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by SV_BubbleTime on Saturday September 30, 2023 @09:33PM (#37721707)
If you don’t see war coming, you haven’t read enough history.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Sunday October 01, 2023 @01:23PM (#37728185)
I don't see that it's certain.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Thursday October 12, 2023 @11:02AM (#37858190)
Man, that one sure aged in a hurry, huh...
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by ehnto on Friday September 29, 2023 @01:55AM (#37699777)
A fair concern if you're building the community. But if you just want to get involved, nothing is forever, all my IRC haunts are dead too. So get involved, enjoy yourself, make friends, take the memories with you when it inevitably dies.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by throwanem on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:51AM (#37704235)
Sure. Just that when the platform's on the way to the hospice ward doesn't seem like the best time to make that sort of start.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by tmpX7dMeXU on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:55PM (#37697580)
As an ex heavy IRC user, I couldn’t possibly disagree more with this. Not even for the same “free! libre!” reasons as the other replier. It is just at its core still a gamer chat platform heavily misappropriated for other purposes, with a UX that will spare no opportunity to make you aware of that.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by bombcar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:20PM (#37697762)
I also feel people treated irc much more ephemeral, important things were in a forum post or a bot.

Discord is just treated as the sum repository of all for way too many people.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by MrVandemar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:54PM (#37698788)
> Discord is just treated as the sum repository of all for way too many people.

The barrier of entry of asking and answering questions on a Discord is very low. Setting up a forum, that's needs a bit of effort, not to mention hosting, and on-going headache of spam and liability.

I mean, I'm really interested in Audio Description, but there is no forum for discussing the nuts and bolts, issues, research, advocacy etc. Conversely there are AD groups on Twitter, Facebook, Linkd In, Discord and a few more besides.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by ehnto on Friday September 29, 2023 @07:06AM (#37701956)
I guess it could be treated that way, but it is just a chat network to me and many. I don't expect to scroll back to infinity and find old messages.

On IRC of course, you got X amount of history when you logged on, and that was what you worked with. It does feel a lot more ephemeral, more like a real conversation.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by burnished on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:59PM (#37698027)
How do you reckon?

For contrast I've gotten a lot of use out of it for connecting with various topic focused communities and I've seen people do neat things with it. The python server manages to offer an awful lot of surprisingly high quality tutoring, all things considered, and a big part of it is through the automation they've built in via bots. Oh! And I found a server focused on electronics when I was looking for help repairing a damaged TV that had knowledge resources the likes of which I rarely see anymore.

In all that I never felt like the experience was hampered by discord's association with gaming. Honestly it felt like a chat client that wanted to be used - if you want to start using IRC as a newb today you first have to pay obeisance and perform the ritual stumbling through. Discord doesn't (or did not as of a few years ago) even need an account to get started, just type a handle and go.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by Gormo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:02PM (#37698447)
> f you want to start using IRC as a newb today you first have to pay obeisance and perform the ritual stumbling through

Nah, web-based clients like The Lounge (https://thelounge.chat/) or Convos (https://convos.chat/) provide a very similar user experience to Discord or Slack.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by lmm on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:13PM (#37698521)
They try, but they still end up clunkier. E.g. you're never going to be able to put pictures in a message in a nice way, because even if your client supports it, other people on IRC don't.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by Gormo on Monday October 09, 2023 @10:44AM (#37820957)
IRC v3 supports feature extension standardization via message tagging, so these features aren't client-specific. Anyone who --wants to see pictures in their feeds will be able to do so by using a client that supports the feature, without a single proprietary client being forced onto everyone. That's a win-win.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by sScTE9qEMCxEk34 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @11:44PM (#37699051)
Between the random ads for this Discord service or that Discord update that are all focused at gamers... and the voice and video... and the integrations Discord themselves offer... and the store... I can see why one would describe it as GP did.

> The python server manages to offer an awful lot of surprisingly high quality tutoring, all things considered, and a big part of it is through the automation they've built in via bots

So did/does IRC.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by ehnto on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:00AM (#37699807)
Fair enough. The UX is really not an issue for me. I am a terminal diehard but I still don't miss IRCs interface.

I am mostly talking about the communities themselves, there are not many truly large everyone-in-a-room chat networks with diverse and modern topics. Yeah IRC is still there, but I am in it for the people, and the people are on discord at the moment. They'll probably move when Discord fucks up, but that doesn't change the conversations I have today.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by lnxg33k1 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:12PM (#37698130)
I’ve done it, and found myself back in the middle of wars vim vs emacs and arch vs all and slack vs all, I agree it was the same on IRC, but as someone who has lived through it while in middle schoo, I have no desire to go through it again ^^
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by Gormo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:59PM (#37698435)
Or just stick with IRC and avoid Discord entirely.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by ehnto on Friday September 29, 2023 @02:03AM (#37699823)
Could do, I don't find the communities I want to join have IRC though.

I am not saying Discord is better, or you should move. More like, if you gave up IRC decades ago, but want to try some new communities, discord chats are close enough to be fun.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by Algent on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:56PM (#37697581)
They seem to want to money beyond Nitro right now despite it being very pricy (100€/year right now for non classic one). They just added very basic paid animated frames sold for 10€ each and with a crappy discount for Nitro users.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by herpdyderp on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:59PM (#37697609)
I really wish they would add useful features to Nitro. I want to pay for Discord Nitro, but the features they keep adding to it actually actively annoy me and I don't want them. Server boosting seemed interesting but it ends up being extremely ephemeral.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by RulerOf on Friday September 29, 2023 @12:13AM (#37699187)
I've never canceled a service so fast in my life.

I signed up for the trial and hop into a direct call. The other participant shared his screen, and the video looks like hot garbage. High fidelity options buried behind notices that the other user needs Nitro.

If I pay for the service, my UX should improve. It did not. No thanks.

Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by spondylosaurus on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:11PM (#37697696)
Unfortunately the very-online-but-not-very-technical are a hard demographic to monetize, maybe more so than the very-online-and-very-technical.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by lmm on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:14PM (#37698527)
Disagree. The very technical have a "the cobbler's children go barefoot" effect where they're unwilling to pay for anything. The non-technical are much more likely to pay $5/month for a program they use.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by spondylosaurus on Thursday September 28, 2023 @10:33PM (#37698646)
Under normal conditions, I'd agree, but the Very Online (But Non Technical) specifically have a chip on their shoulder about not wanting to pay for online services, even at a fair value.
Re:Discord as a filehost will no longer be possible by the e... by otis_inf on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:48AM (#37700989)
I'd happily pay for such an image hosting. Our gallery site Hall of Framed (https://framedsc.com/HallOfFramed/) with the best virtual photography shots from our Discord community is hosted this way (json file with the urls in a github repo, updated by a bot, the site is hosted on github pages). We directly pull the shots from discord, but we now have to refactor the site so the images are hosted elsewhere.

This poses a problem as the amount of shots is quite large... We have a channel where users post their shots, and the bot basically harvests the links of the shots which have a high amount of votes. So currently no re-hosting of images occurs.

I can image tho why Discord does this. Our gallery is likely not visited a lot, but I can imagine high profile files pulled from discord channels like pirated software/malware etc. are a big problem. The route to the server / channel where the files are coming from isn't known, only to discord