News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by echelon on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:17PM (#37692699)
They need to disinvest from new buildings, "lifestyle" dorms, expensive gyms and amenities, and sports programs (except for schools well-regarded for this).

Tuition inflation is absurd. The goal is to grow learners, not set them back.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Racing0461 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:26PM (#37692820)
nah, we just need the government to not back student loans and allow it to be discharged in bankruptcy. the system will sort it out from there.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:38PM (#37692963)
> we just need the government to not back student loans and allow it to be discharged in bankruptcy

Honestly, start with the latter. See what happens. Maybe include a first-loss provision for schools with an endowment.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by silenced_trope on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:07PM (#37694155)
This is what really gets me about loan forgiveness.

I'd be in favor if it was only for people who pursue certain degrees that we need. But going to party schools? Going for the cliche "underwater basket weaving" degree? The money being funneled into building a new pool and rock climbing wall for one of the dorms?

No, no, and no!

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by julienb_sea on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:37PM (#37694658)
How is this going to solve anything? Unless the school itself has skin in the loan, currently the only impact of bankruptcy discharge would be on private loan operators (who would probably go under) or on taxpayers who would absorb the loan losses. The schools are getting paid their tuition from the loans immediately, they won't even notice.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by morsch on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:45PM (#37694762)
Presumably the idea is that guaranteed student debt is what enables US tuition levels. The schools will already have been paid, but the next generation of students won't be able to get loans for tens of thousands of dollars -- the lenders will have gone under and nobody else will want to be in that business, so universities will have to lower prices.

I think that's the idea. It sounds rather painful to me? But the status quo is also very weird?

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Racing0461 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:45PM (#37694772)
> taxpayers who would absorb the loan losses

that's no different than what we have no. we don't need everyone going to college especially to major in history of tampons type degrees.

the end goal is for loan companies to decline people who won't be able to repay their loans given the expected value of their degrees. (Your future earning potential is the collatoral for your loan).

For people that want to "expand their horizons", they can go watch khanacademy on youtube.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by imchillyb on Thursday September 28, 2023 @06:05PM (#37696492)
Your mentality is why so much of the world is set back centuries from the USA.

That's the old Brit way of thinking, and we sent that packing over a century ago.

I'd thank you to not return us to the 'good old days.'

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by rqtwteye on Thursday September 28, 2023 @07:31PM (#37697342)
Be careful. You may end up with universities where only millionaires take classes. The universities would like this because of money and the millionaires would like it because the proles would keep out of well paid careers. We would be back to how education and science worked a few hundred years ago.

As in health care I don’t think there is a market solution. Government needs to mandate lower prices for them.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by cvccvroomvroom on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:13AM (#37700739)
Demographics vary by institution. Some shakedown the poor by packing 600 students to a lecture hall.

The Stanford's get unlimited free laundry.

Government isn't going to get involved here because most are private, for-profit masquerading as nonprofits while fattening up their endowments.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by rqtwteye on Friday September 29, 2023 @09:51AM (#37704241)
If they are for-profit, at a minimum they should lose any special tax status.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by throwing_away on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:31PM (#37692866)
> The goal is to grow, not set back.

If you're a university, the goal is to fill up your university with satisfied customers and increase revenue.

If you're a student, the goal is to form social networks that you can later use to help in business.

If you're a politician, the goal is to increase college attendance rates.

If you're a hard-line right winger, the goal is actually to set undesirable groups back, but that's a pretty fringe position.

If you just want to learn and grow, you should avoid the university system entirely.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:34PM (#37692914)
> If you just want to learn and grow, you should avoid the university system entirely.

I disagree with this. The university system is really good for exposure, assuming that people who are attending the system actually take advantage of the exposure. e.g. I was able to take dedicated lessons in multiple languages, artistic mediums, theories in various fields, by experts in each field. Many of these experts were presenting their work for free outside of lessons, and often times provided free food and drink to boot! Also, because my institution was larger, we often had scholars travel here to present their various works and even little get-togethers where multiple scholars from multiple fields collaborated and presented work. For free! With free food and drink!

I can't get a single dedicated language instructor for my life nowadays, it's bullshit apps or stuff oriented towards children only. Same if I wanted to learn the basics of, say, a performance art, or painting. The best system I have nowadays for learning is mostly hacker spaces and maker spaces, but they're specialized in what they can teach me and don't often have the kind of dedicated experts "office hours" or anything like that.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by bombcar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:11PM (#37693409)
You may find it worthwhile to reach out to local community colleges, because once you're "in the group" you can find people doing various things, and they're often not advertising, but will be willing to take a bit of cash on the side.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Karrot_Kream on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:26PM (#37693624)
I'm sorry for derailing this thread, but am curious. Have any of you used services (e.g. classes, study groups) at the local community college? How does it work out when you're a decade beyond your graduate program? I miss a lot of aspects of the university system but have a full-time job and a life now (sadly.) I've been thinking of taking classes and networking at some of our really well-rated community colleges but I'm not sure what the experience is like.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by mlyle on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:31PM (#37693682)
It really depends upon the community college and class.

You tend to have some younger screw-up, unmotivated students, especially at entry level classes; some younger students that are there for economic or other reasons; some older students going back to school for life reasons; and then some older students who are intellectually curious and doing it for enrichment.

What the make-up of a class, and the resultant culture is, is a crapshoot. But it can be outstanding.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by bombcar on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:44PM (#37693874)
As the other said, it really depends on the college. The one near me is more technical oriented and has a number of programs basically designed to train people for employment at local factories.

If you avoid the standard college classes, you get a pretty wide cross-section of the people in the community. Math 101 is mostly going to be college-age kids.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by nonameiguess on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:20PM (#37695260)
I'm sure it heavily depends on local circumstances, but for whatever it's worth, I badly fucked up my first attempt at going to four-year right out of high school due to mental health reasons and ended up doing two years at LA City College before going back. It may have been mostly the Biology and Chemistry departments, but the quality of student there was still the highest of any school I've ever taken classes at, and that includes Georgia Tech, which is typically regarded as a top 10 engineering school. The reasons were somewhat peculiar and specific, but the fall of the Soviet Union in the late 80s left a whole lot of immigrants from former Soviet Republics fleeing the collapse and most of them ended up in LA. We had a whole lot of former engineers, scientists, and medical doctors who came to the US only to find their foreign credentials were not honored by US institutions and they had to start completely over. They utterly destroyed our curves thanks to all of the knowledge, dedication, and discipline they already had compared to an average 19 year-old.

Heck, even my Bio 101 professor was abnormally brilliant. She'd been a researcher at Harvard Medical School who worked on highly experimental treatments in a ward full of terminal patients and just finally burned out from being around so much death all the time, so there she was in Los Feliz three blocks from Scientology world headquarters teaching at a community college, probably the hardest class I've ever had to take.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:14PM (#37693437)
I do, but I would argue that local community colleges is still most certainly in the "university system", just another tier/flavor of it. I would consider participating in community college activities to be participating in academic institution style activities that also happen at universities.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by mlyle on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:28PM (#37693643)
Yah- I don't think they're disagreeing with you, but just suggesting that CCs and other adult education may be a practical way to scratch the itch that you described.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Karrot_Kream on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:31PM (#37693687)
> I can't get a single dedicated language instructor for my life nowadays, it's bullshit apps or stuff oriented towards children only. Same if I wanted to learn the basics of, say, a performance art, or painting. The best system I have nowadays for learning is mostly hacker spaces and maker spaces, but they're specialized in what they can teach me and don't often have the kind of dedicated experts "office hours" or anything like that.

Exactly. I'm fairly knowledgeable about my STEM specialization but in university I had access to great language learning and exchange programs, top-notch political science and philosophy departments, architecture departments, etc. I remember bumming around in philosophy seminars not because I was a philosophy student (though I did take some philosophy classes) but because I found it so interesting. As long as I didn't increase the grading burden on any of the grad students/professors, everyone was happy and the quality of instruction I received was fantastic. In the real world the closest I have is books I read or MOOCs where a lot of people are in it to get a certification or a badge of completion rather than just marinate in ideas.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by whatshisface on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:33PM (#37692903)
I went to school to learn what they were teaching in class and I did actually learn it.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by dfxm12 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:42PM (#37693028)
If you're a hard-line right winger, the goal is actually to set undesirable groups back, but that's a pretty fringe position.

Based in recent history, most recently on spending cuts in the proposed house spending bill, this appears to be well within the mainstream of the Republican party.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Clubber on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:18PM (#37693500)
I'm not supporting the GOP, but we are $33T in debt with interest rates rising dramatically. We're probably in a perilous position. We need to cut back and raise taxes.

FWIW, I'm well aware the GOP has also contributed greatly to that debt.

https://www.usdebtclock.org

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by krapp on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:19PM (#37693519)
I don't know why you're being downvoted, every word of your comment is the truth.

The purpose of higher education in the US to create a market for student loan debt and generate revenue for states. The US is a capitalist society, and education is not a right, it's a privilege, and student loan debt is a billion dollar industry. We saw how the states nearly rioted over the possibility of being denied the revenue from student loan interest if it was forgiven. Believing education is about educating people is about as naive as believing hospitals are about healthcare, or houses about shelter. All of it is entirely about profit, debt and tax revenue.

So much of how the US works (or doesn't work) makes perfect sense when you realize this. Education, business, tech, government, the media, pop culture - it's all grift, top to bottom. It's all carnies and frauds and sociopaths working angles and trying to squeeze you just a little harder to wet their lips with one more drop of your lifeblood.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by CMay on Thursday September 28, 2023 @08:49PM (#37697968)
It is not the truth, it is largely opinion informed by deep cynicism that fails to reflect on the complexities of human behavior and motivation. That does not mean it is completely divorced from any truth, but it is not usefully informative by itself.

Whether a society is capitalist or not does not define whether education is a right or a privilege. Another mistake is defining a country as capitalist and then shutting down any remaining capacity to think about it. Most countries contain a mixture of economic principles at work, so a surface level knowledge of capitalism that seems stuck in the 1800s will only leave you appearing naive and outdated.

Which country is it again that created the internet and has helped expand education not only locally, but globally for all mankind to benefit? Which country is it that created the greatest video platform on Earth, populated with a vast wealth of university lectures and documentaries on top of allowing people casually sitting at home to speak their mind for anyone to see (within reason)?

The U.S. is not without its problems as any country, but we're familiar with many of the problems we have which were already solved once before within the last century. Young people trained on cynical ideologies are highly suggestible, almost encouraged to see certain events as validation for that cynicism. It becomes their organizing principle, no longer looking for what solutions are being produced by a system or what uncorrupt motivations someone might have for any given decision. Only the negatives.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by vehemenz on Thursday September 28, 2023 @04:30PM (#37695381)
It's a shame you didn't learn about the teleological fallacy in your philosophy classes when you attended university.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by manuelabeledo on Thursday September 28, 2023 @01:55PM (#37693192)
> ... and sports programs (except for schools well-regarded for this)

Those shouldn't be called "universities", then.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by trgn on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:11PM (#37694218)
A healthy mind in a healthy body. We should all aspire to it. It's a beautiful thing, to have institutions nurture both athletes and scholars.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by whyenot on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:32PM (#37694576)
Maybe it's a "beautiful thing" for some sports, but for contact sports like football, it doesn't lead to a "healthy mind." Instead, it leads to brain damage. CTEs didn't go away just because we stopped talking about them.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by wolverine876 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:10PM (#37695907)
Your comment seems sarcastic, but the athletes aren't getting much of the beautiful mind part, few students get the athletic experience, and the institutions are nuturing their TV revenue.

Good intramural sports would serve far more students.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by trgn on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:47PM (#37696328)
I wasn't sarcastic!

point taken though, maybe the choice of sports does not fit the ideal.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:03PM (#37693299)
And also from grievance studies departments and administrative bloat.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:13PM (#37693429)
I don't know if grievance studies is a cause of tuition bloat. Most of the departments I know to be labeled as grievance studies were founded well before tuition increased, so it makes not much sense to attribute them to increased tuition. The increase in tuition hews much more closely with the decrease in government funding to these institutions, which requires more tuition from students, which means students desires must be catered to... so increased lifestyle luxuries makes sense there...
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by whatshisface on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:23PM (#37693570)
It might be naive but I imagine training students to make improvements to weapons systems increases government support of universities and training students to criticize the government decreases it.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by EatingWithForks on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:28PM (#37693637)
Like I said, the founding of such studies predates the increases in tuition. Trying to argue that specific academic studies causes tuition increases by making students mistrustful of government, but only several decades later, needs a lot of evidence for that kind of claim. There are far more direct, closely related situations, like the federal and state governments decreasing funding or the inverted proportion of funds coming from govt/grants vs student-paid tuition via the loan system.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by whatshisface on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:33PM (#37693724)
>Trying to argue that specific academic studies causes tuition increases by making students mistrustful of government, but only several decades later, needs a lot of evidence for that kind of claim.

Right-leaning politicians are citing "grievance studies" as their reason for not liking universities, so the only stretch in this hypothesis is to think it might have been happening for decades before bubbling to the surface. It's not that it makes students distrustful of the government, it's that it makes politicians ask, "why are we paying them if they're going to make our goals harder to achieve?" I would not be surprised if the protests against the Vietnam war turned the inner view that many held about university faculty, but few expressed it because of the esteem the public held them in at the time.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by UncleMeat on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:04PM (#37695813)
This is a totally different claim than what was obviously meant by the first post.

"We are wasting money on these fields" and "these fields piss off reactionaries so they cut our budgets, despite being a tiny portion of the overall budget and not hiring new lines in years" are just totally different.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by whatshisface on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:25PM (#37696103)
Whose first post do you mean? My two posts mean the same thing, doing what legislators want would tend to increase funding and doing what they don't like would do the opposite. I guess you could read my first post as being about wasting money if you think criticizing the government is not useful... I guess there are some countries like Singapore out there where that is the case.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Clubber on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:23PM (#37693556)
When I went to college in the 90s, the gave us a breakdown of tuition costs. Half the cost was crap the student government wanted.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by BeetleB on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:42PM (#37693843)
That's because tuition was cheap in the 90's.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by fallingknife on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:09PM (#37694185)
Maybe not the departments directly, but the nonsense they push certainly does. e.g. University of Michigan has 163 full time DEI employees.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:12PM (#37694235)
Were they the same size upon founding as they are now? A few activists get their foot in the door, push to hire friendly administrators, who push for more activists, who push for more administrators… Eventually everything is taken over
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by cycomanic on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:57PM (#37694936)
In what world do academics have power over which administrators can be hired? If you really think that some professor in CRT could take over a department, then you just show that you don't have a clue.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by Georgelemental on Thursday September 28, 2023 @09:59PM (#37698434)
> In what world

The world I see around me with my eyes, and more specifically the public university I currently attend.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by wolverine876 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:12PM (#37695938)
Also, the history and English departments don't have big budgets to start with.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by silenced_trope on Thursday September 28, 2023 @03:07PM (#37694165)
Yes, I may be in favor of loan forgiveness if it was for appropriate degrees that the nation actually needs.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by AmericanOP on Thursday September 28, 2023 @02:16PM (#37693476)
Parents can't afford to send kids to summer camp so they can save for college which is four years of summer camp.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by wolverine876 on Thursday September 28, 2023 @05:08PM (#37695874)
Like many other things now, from healthcare to midtown Manhattan, it's by the wealthy, for the wealthy, of the wealthy.

The wealthy want beautiful new buildings and a good football team, and a high-touch experience for their kids. They are happy to pay administrators lots of money to deliver on those things.

Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by cvccvroomvroom on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:30AM (#37700855)
That's not how a university works.
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by wolverine876 on Friday September 29, 2023 @06:32PM (#37710870)
Would you elaborate?
Re:Universities have disinvested from their presses just as ... by cvccvroomvroom on Friday September 29, 2023 @04:08AM (#37700699)
Most universities are on the death march to rebuild Versailles for athletes and whoever else. They can't even bother to build something beautiful like a gothic church with all that ill-got blood money. Instead, it's a construction competition to teardown and replace buildings like bathroom decor.