Its more nuanced than that.
As a dev, i like a stable environment and i dont like to do big updates all the time, since that means i have to spend hours updating my setup again. Everytime i run brew im scared it will hose my PHP versions, etc, since it auto updates everything.
To install old PHP versions one needs to hack the install files to make it works.
If you bring up any of these issues you are screamed down by the devs as “you should always be on the latest versions anyway bla bla”… but that is just not a realistic scenario in the real world. Legacy code is everywhere.
In the end brew is not really for pro users, but, as i said, maybe for people using it to install youtube-dl or whatever.
Once the pain of reinstalling and hacking it to make it work becomes too big then i will switch.
Also, if you are not going along in the upgrade rabbit race, honebrew gets really annoying and actually in your way at some point.
I see myself moving to macports soon, if brew gets worse and the stability of my setup is compromised (lots of php versions with valet for example).
I guess brew is now more targeted at “prosumers” now since it is imposing unnecessary limits on what “pro” users want and need.