News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by jonathankoren on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:44AM (#37654922)
EMPs are a fantasy. Absolutely and unreservedly a complete fantasy. ZERO have ever been tested, and there’s literally a better use for a nuclear warhead. Not only is it a a completely hypothetical attack, it would look identical to a normal nuclear ICBM attack, and absolutely would result in a traditional retaliatory attack. Why would anyone trade an EMP for all their cities? Literally doesn’t make sense. No one in the nuclear arms control world takes it seriously. It’s a boogeyman for defense contractors and grifters, but I repeat myself.

All that said, GPS denial is a very real thing, and has been repeatedly demonstrated in an operational context. It’s relatively trivial to do. You just need a regular ground based antenna, and not a particular strong transmitter because satellite signals are weak. Just broadcast a different timing signal and voilà! You now tricked someone into thinking they’re 50 miles away from where they really are.

https://medium.com/war-is-boring/the-overrated-threat-from-e...

https://www.c4isrnet.com/opinion/2022/07/22/why-isnt-russia-...

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by orbital-decay on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:29AM (#37655718)
>ZERO have ever been tested

Wait what? There were specific nuclear EMP tests. And sure, in any realistic nuclear war scenario EMP is just an unpredictable byproduct like your link says, but that doesn't make it fantasy I believe?

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by irjustin on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:56AM (#37655939)
I wonder if the parent is talking about pure EMP without the nuke because those are pure fantasy. Kill all electronics w/o all the fallout.
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by jonathankoren on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:09AM (#37656475)
No. There is no “fallout free” EMP. That’s literally science fiction. Every proposed EMP attack is literally a hydrogen bomb delivered via a ICBM and detonated at extremely high altitude. That is the only way to deliver one to the proper place and the only way to deliver the amount of energy. That’s just the physics.

Again, an EMP is fantasy not just because it the effects are unpredictable because none have been tested (again, literally zero nuclear weapons have been detonated at high altitude) But because there are zero situations where one would be advantageous, let alone not result in regular nuclear retaliation.

Once you’ve decided to detonate a hydrogen bomb via an ICBM you’re already in a full on nuclear exchange and the decision to respond is literally 15 minutes from detection, which near instantaneous of launch.

Launch on Warning (ie launch a retaliatory strike when an incoming missile is detected in the air) along with ground and space based surveillance systems makes attempting to execute an EMP attack suicidal. And. It just suicidal, but the attacker literally wasted a nuke that could have actually blown something up.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by TTorler on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:27AM (#37656654)
> literally zero nuclear weapons have been detonated at high altitude https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Starfish_Prime
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:24AM (#37656625)
>There is no “fallout free” EMP.

False. There are non-Nuclear EMP's, and the USA even has a bit of experience with the Russian variants ..

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by wnkrshm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:35AM (#37657250)
Regarding your other comment: why wouldn't a high-altitude detonation, even outside the atmosphere cause an EMP? I feel like the gamma photons emitted in space will eventually hit the atmosphere and with that cause electrons to spiral along field lines. Isn't the question just one of intensity?

Or is it largely dependent on multi-photon interactions to impart enough impulse on the electrons?

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by orbital-decay on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @08:57AM (#37658607)
> Even then, the actual effect at ground level, is unpredictable because of simple shielding and atmospheric turbulence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet_Project_K_nuclear_tests

>EMP ran to thousands of amps, damaged at least 570 km of telephone lines, 1000 km of buried power lines, and caused the destruction of the Karaganda power plant.

A 300kt blast at 290km was able to induce 1.5 to 4.5kA in the unshielded power line buried underground at 2m, over the area hundreds of kilometers across. Imagine what it could do to the areas that are a bit more populated than Kazakh steppes in 60's.

So yeah, while the nuclear EMP is probably not going to be used as a primary weapon in a global nuclear strike as you said, it's not a huge stretch for one of the warheads to be dedicated for the EMP over some large but less important area, not necessarily as a decapitating strike, so preparing for it makes sense. Besides, there would be at least local EMPs in the area after the "ordinary" nuclear strike, which can be really disabling if unprepared for.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by krisoft on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:04AM (#37658681)
Yeah. So you are probably correct that it is unlikely that someone only sends a single warhead to do an EMP attack. What I don't understand is why you would think that it is unlikely that they send their whole volley, and some warheads are programmed to hit targets while some others are programmed to detonate to maximise EMP damage.

Sure there is MAD, but if you are a military leader would you like to hang your hat entirely on that? After armageddon when you climb out of your bunker would you like to be the one who still has tanks to command, or the one who can't command anyone because all your radios have fried?

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by ochrist on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:19AM (#37656098)
I don't think it's pure fantasy, but it's difficult to predict the probability https://www.theregister.com/2022/10/24/datacenter_solar_stor...
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by sonthonax on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:27AM (#37656158)
> Why would anyone trade an EMP for all their cities?

ICMBs were a theoretical threat. Cold War doctrine had a more realistic (and less apocalyptic) WWIII that would be fought by tactical nukes and tanks through Europe.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by 3seashells on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:44AM (#37656290)
But a emp is a icbm in all but name.
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by jonathankoren on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:45AM (#37656299)
Bullshit. They’ve been demonstrated. Repeatedly, and publicly. That’s the whole point of having them.

Also, there is no difference between a tactical and strategic nuke from an escalatory perspective. Once the genie is out, it’s out.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by wnkrshm on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @06:13AM (#37657059)
There are people who argue that there are ways to keep limited nuclear warfare limited. [0] I think the RAND institute also published some study on it not outright rejecting the idea but I can't find it atm.

[0] https://www.sup.org/books/title/?id=21511

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by grotorea on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:43AM (#37659195)
In that case, why both sides of the Cold War spent fortunes on conventional forces along the Iron Curtain?

Like yes it is playing with (nuclear) fire, and maybe they were wrong, but there plenty of professionals who, maybe biased by their positions, who felt the need to get ready for limited nuclear war. And I'm not really convinced either side would want to risk destroying human civilization over Frankfurt.

> Also, there is no difference between a tactical and strategic nuke from an escalatory perspective. Once the genie is out, it’s out.

I mean, why? Why shouldn't tactical and strategic be separate steps on the ladder?

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by alexnewman on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:50AM (#37659293)
That’s what I thought as well but his articles address those concerns. Very good read if you didn’t read them
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by arethuza on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:11AM (#37656497)
"and less apocalyptic"

Not if you happened to be the relevant parts of Europe!

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by bookofjoe on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @07:26AM (#37657685)
>I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones."

― Albert Einstein

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by nojvek on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @11:57AM (#37661243)
We will have countries against each other fighting for their borders but world war is v unlikely in our lifetime.

We love our cheap goods, cheap-ish energy and ability to change presidents and prime ministers.

Yes China, North Korea and Russia banding against the rest of the world is a real threat but China has shown it is selfish too and cares more about its economy.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by Ancapistani on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @01:01PM (#37662327)
> We love our cheap goods, cheap-ish energy and ability to change presidents and prime ministers.

I'm not saying I don't agree, but this is almost identical to arguments made prior to WW1.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by nojvek on Wednesday September 27, 2023 @09:50AM (#37674643)
No mutually assured destruction back then.

WW1 was a pretty inefficient war, WW2 got better weapons and communication infra, but modern war fare is seriously destructive.

Intercontinental missiles fired from stealth submarines with nuclear payloads that break apart in air into 20 little payloads that then destroy an entire city 1000s of kms.

Modern warfare doesn’t need armies of millions of men. Whoever can best see their enemy via satellites and oceanic array, direct the most destructive energy using missiles and drones decapitates their enemy.

One nuclear warhead possesses multiple times the energy spent on both world wars combined.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by eru on Monday October 02, 2023 @06:54AM (#37736531)
> Yes China, North Korea and Russia banding against the rest of the world is a real threat but China has shown it is selfish too and cares more about its economy.

I really want to believe that. But the same logic did not stop the first world war.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @04:54AM (#37656368)
>EMPs are a fantasy.

The Defense Department doesn't agree with you one bit.

Russia is the worlds leader in Non-Nuclear EMP/RFW systems:

https://apps.dtic.mil/sti/trecms/pdf/AD1124730.pdf

Non-nuclear EMP weapons are a thing.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by raaaaraaaaa on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:32AM (#37656698)
In past two years we learned a lot about hi-tech Russian capabilities :D
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @05:37AM (#37656752)
We didn't, and thats the point.
Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by blincoln on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @09:56AM (#37659374)
"unique radio-electronic weapons based on new physical principles" sounds an awful lot like the breathless tales of secret Russian Tesla death rays that have been circulating since the 80s, if not earlier.

If Russia could "neutralize entire armies with just one short electromagnetic impulse", or even just "disable missile warheads and onboard aircraft electronics miles away", don't you think they'd be using that capability against Ukraine?

The author of that paper was obsessed with the idea of EMP weapons,[1] so I'd take it with an entire shaker full of salt unless you can find solid supporting evidence elsewhere.

[1] https://www.legacy.com/us/obituaries/washingtontimes/name/pe...

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by helpfulContrib on Tuesday September 26, 2023 @03:12PM (#37664397)
> don't you think they'd be using that capability against Ukraine?

No, and that's entirely the point.

Their non-use of their advanced weapons systems is as equally interesting a subject as their forward-deployment of expendable, less advanced systems.

The Russian military certainly have their inefficiencies - as all modern militaries do, including "our own" - but they also have capabilities that are going to be more important to use against NATO/USA, than Ukraine.

The Russian mindset appears to support the idea that World War Three is well and truly under way and has been since the West illegally invaded Iraq, in 2003. Ukraine is merely the latest in this conflagration that has been rendering 'lesser nations' asunder, for two decades already. The whole world has been watching not only American/NATO, but also Russian doctrine in play for decades.

So I guess the doctrine is, don't play your best hand first .. and reserve your big muscle for when you fight big muscle.

NATO is adding its muscle to Ukraine, no question. But I wouldn't expect to see Russian - or NATO - advanced weapons systems in use until there is actually direct, open conflict between Russia and NATO.

Only then would non-nuclear EMP's, and indeed tactical ("micro") nukes, and other such more 'advanced' weaponry end up on the battlefield, if there is even one after the first few hours of 'real war'.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by another2another on Friday September 29, 2023 @08:23AM (#37702796)
Russia have thrown everything they have at Ukraine over the last year-and-a-half. Cruise missiles, hypersonic missiles, their best troops and naval assets.

Now they're buying equipment from Iran (!?) and North Korea.

Russia, in their deep USA envy thought they'd have their own Shock and Awe! 3 day SMO.

Instead they overestimated themselves, and massively underestimated Ukraine.

The cupboard is empty. The only thing they have left is nuclear weapons, which they're quite rightly terrified of using. All that remains now is a long slow and grinding defeat as Putin expends every available Russian male in his desperate attempt to remain in power and not back down.

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by helpfulContrib on Saturday September 30, 2023 @12:35PM (#37717096)
>Russia have thrown everything they have at Ukraine over the last year-and-a-half.

I don't believe that's the case. Russian military doctrine has always been to reserve the best systems for the end-game, and front 'fodder' in the beginning stages of things.

I see Russia's war theatre manifest also in Syria, where the very same tactics are utilized to suppress the field.

"Shock and Awe" is a US doctrine. Russian is more "Shake and Hold".

"Massively overestimating themselves/underestimating themselves", is very difficult to contextualize, if you don't actually speak Russian.

>The cupboard is empty.

I'm sorry, I really don't agree. You might want to take a deeper look:

https://www.cna.org/reports/2021/10/Russian-Military%20-Stra...

You must, of course, steel yourself for some whiplash. The world is not entirely as it "seems".

Re:SR-71 Blackbird Astro-Nav System (a.k.a. R2-D2) worked by... by _kbh_ on Saturday September 30, 2023 @11:17PM (#37722204)
>> Russia have thrown everything they have at Ukraine over the last year-and-a-half.

> I don't believe that's the case. Russian military doctrine has always been to reserve the best systems for the end-game, and front 'fodder' in the beginning stages of things.

This still doesn't explain the BMP-T's, the T90's and S300's that are deployed to Ukraine and destroyed in Ukraine.

>>The cupboard is empty.

> I'm sorry, I really don't agree. You might want to take a deeper look: > https://www.cna.org/reports/2021/10/Russian-Military%20-Stra... > You must, of course, steel yourself for some whiplash. The world is not entirely as it "seems".

If the cupboard isn't empty then why are there ~80 smoldering T62's in Ukraine.