News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by amelius on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:09PM (#37618969)
However transposing music should not have a dramatic effect on notation. Melodies that sounds the same should look the same.
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by pclmulqdq on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:28PM (#37619111)
I'm not convinced, personally. Melodies that sound the same don't really sound the same (hitting different registers on the same instrument), and they aren't played the same (different fingerings), so why would they look the same in notation?
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by TylerE on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:50PM (#37619241)
Strong disagree. On many instruments there is a strong memory association between the place of the note on the staff and the physical movement to play that note, Esther it be a fingering? Or lip tension or whatever.
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by klodolph on Friday September 22, 2023 @11:10PM (#37620294)
With sheet music, transposing music means moving it up or down the staff, and changing the key signature to match, and adjusting any accidentals.
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by bluGill on Friday September 22, 2023 @11:58PM (#37620480)
Music theory gives good reasons for changing keys to have a significant effect on how the song sounds. Most pianos are tuned equal temperment so you don't get that effect, but there is a good argument for other tunings that do. (You may or may not agree, but the argument is valid)
Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by yayitswei on Saturday September 23, 2023 @12:58AM (#37620678)
I agree. Even though some (most?) instruments have different shapes for each scale, notation should transcend implementation and aim for the most general representation. See: isomorphic instruments.

I'll concede that traditional music notation is the most efficient way of representing classical music.

Re:Show HN: Learn piano without sheet music by heleninboodler on Monday September 25, 2023 @05:00PM (#37650532)
Part of me says yes and part of me says no. The thing that music notation recognizes is that which specific notes are important changes depending on which key you're in.