News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:29AM (#37611124)
Curious what Poland's anti-nuclear neighboring country will think about this?

AFAIK Austria was also suing Hungary and Slovenia for going nuclear.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by ethbr1 on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:39AM (#37611224)
Honestly, I feel like the German government would be perfectly happy buying nuclear power from Poland.

It's the ultimate NIMBY.

German greens would hate it, but I doubt it'd arouse the same anti-nuclear rabble with the general public as a plant on German soil.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by pydry on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:05AM (#37611495)
Germany the same cost/benefit trade off when it decided not to build nuclear power stations that Iran did when it decided to build them.

Iran wants to move itself closer to being able to build a nuke in a hurry if necessary, which is why the west is publicly freaked out and angry about their PWRs.

Germany isnt bothered.

Like everyone else who builds nuclear power plants it certainly wasnt doing it because it was a cost effective way of going green because at 5x the cost of solar and wind, and more expensive than hydrogen+solar+wind thats the last thing it'll ever be. Even the lack of intermittency doesn't come within a mile of making up for a 5x cost difference: https://theecologist.org/2016/feb/17/wind-power-windgas-chea...

The "nuclear is the new green jesus" movement makes no sense.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by panick21_ on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:26AM (#37611760)
> why the west is publicly freaked out and angry about their PWRs

The West wasn't freaked out. In fact, France had agree to provide the technology and help built the plant. They would also do fuel management.

Then the US came in guns blazing killed the deal and started a 20 year idiotic trade war on Iran because of it.

> Like everyone else who builds nuclear power plants it certainly wasnt doing it because it was a cost effective way of going green

If we compare the cost it took France to go Green and what Germany now spends without even being Green, this is simply inaccurate statement. The complete cost of the whole French nuclear fleet is less then the emergency money Germany deployed during the energy crisis. And French consumers had low energy pricing during the crisis while Germany had very high energy prices.

Nuclear is incredibly cost efficient and proven to work as soon as you built large numbers in a short time period.

And Wind and Solar alone are simply not a solution, you have to take into account the cost of upgrades to the grid and you have to take into account storage.

> The "nuclear is the new green jesus" movement makes no sense.

Look at how well it worked for the UAE. Its not that expensive per plant, these plants will work for the next 80-100 years and even only building for the per plant cost goes down.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by realusername on Friday September 22, 2023 @10:09AM (#37612280)
I don't get why peope don't understand that. The only reason that France has so much nuclear power is because of the fuel crisis of the 70s.

Nuclear is stellar at replacing fossil fuels and that's basically why it got developed in the first place.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by panick21_ on Friday September 22, 2023 @05:36PM (#37618106)
Even when fuel prices improved, France continued building.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by realusername on Saturday September 23, 2023 @03:39AM (#37621385)
Indeed, but the petrol crisis made a pretty deep lasting impact on the french public. The country had to resort to petrol coupons for the first time since the second world war.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by ethbr1 on Friday September 22, 2023 @10:24AM (#37612476)
The political failure to solve nuclear power construction and lifetime fuel lifecycle issues for the last 40 years is a huge component of climate change.

We technically could have switched substantial amounts of power generation to nuclear, safely, at reasonable cost, with a spent fuel storage solution... by the 1980s.

Sadly, the stars were aligned by the mid-80s, if Reagan hadn't punted post-Chernobyl and had instead used it to crow about the superiority of modern, safer Western reactor designs and put serious federal money behind construction programs.

Per unit costs are dominated by volume.

Why politicians can't understand this boggles the mind.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by zozbot234 on Friday September 22, 2023 @10:33AM (#37612590)
No need for storage, even. Spent fuel can be reprocessed for use until fully burned up, at which point it's not especially challenging to store.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by themaninthedark on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:23AM (#37611719)
>Even the lack of intermittency doesn't come within a mile of making up for that cost difference.

How do you account for the cost of power intermittency?

The 2021 Texas blackout is estimated at 80 ~ 130 Billion, with 246 deaths. https://www.dallasfed.org/research/economics/2021/0415 https://www.austintexas.gov/sites/default/files/files/HSEM/2...

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by throwbadubadu on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:28AM (#37611777)
> The "nuclear is the new green jesus" movement makes no sense.

Just the dream of staying lazily in luxury.. so have pardon please.

> build a nuke in a hurry .. everyone else who builds nuclear power plants it certainly wasnt doing it because it was a cost effective way

While easily confirmed that's the last thing people want to hear ;)

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by sojournerc on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:24AM (#37611730)
But with wind and solar, you still need base load, so you have a plant either way, or an enormous investment in battery (which have their own lifecycle of emissions and pollution)

Nuclear is cleaner than Nat. Gas is cleaner than coal.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by lo_zamoyski on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:52AM (#37612073)
It wasn't "the West" that was freaked out, it was Israel. AIPAC spent a ton of money to oppose the deal.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by rob74 on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:13AM (#37611602)
Well, Poland is located to the East of Germany, so any nuclear fallout from an accident in Poland is less likely to land in Germany than fallout from dodgy old reactors in Belgium or France. These probabilities didn't help with Chernobyl though - some fallout still ended up in Western Europe...
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by panick21_ on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:20AM (#37611681)
Poland has a ton of coal to replace and likely no nuclear to sell.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:27PM (#37616562)
Nobody can beat Germany at coal :))
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by pbjtime on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:41AM (#37611240)
Lol, good fucking luck with that
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by mc32 on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:34AM (#37611176)
Self-determination and all that. It’s not for weaponry but instead cleaner energy, or would neighbors rather have the byproduct of coal derived energy?
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by Galaxeblaffer on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:38AM (#37611210)
well, the anti nuclear movement makes no sense anyways, so yes they'd probably rather inhale coal particles than have nuclear "close" by
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by pydry on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:03AM (#37611468)
The "nuclear is the new green jesus" movement makes no sense. It's 5x the cost of solar and wind. It's more expensive even than turning wind energy into hydrogen, storing it and burning it for electricity - even if the nuclear plant isnt doing load following (that would cost even more): https://theecologist.org/2016/feb/17/wind-power-windgas-chea...

The only reasons to build nuclear power plants are military. The international community is clear on the reasons when it's Iran building PWRs but it's equally as true for every other country that does it (thats why we can be sure of Iran's motive).

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by vladvasiliu on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:34AM (#37611861)
The high price of nuclear power-plants is usually due to the loss of know-how after a long period of "nuclear bad". During this period, the people who built the NPPs of the 60's and 70's retired, and not enough new ones were trained since it was politically on the way out.

> It's 5x the cost of solar and wind.

Do you have a citation for that? In France, the EPR which is absurdly late and out of the initial budget, and the poster child of how if you don't train highly-skilled people you can't just pick it back up when you want, is estimated to produce electricity at an all-in cost that is a little less than twice that of solar, and twice that of terrestrial wind. Wind installed in the sea is pricier than the EPR. The already-built NPPs are the second-cheapest of the lot, behind geothermal.

Source, in French: https://prix-elec.com/energie/production

The same argument according to which solar panels and such will become cheaper as demand increases (because of economies of scale and technical improvements) also applies to nuclear power plants.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by Gwypaas on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:56AM (#37612113)
https://www.lazard.com/research-insights/2023-levelized-cost...

> The same argument according to which solar panels and such will become cheaper as demand increases (because of economies of scale and technical improvements) also applies to nuclear power plants.

The French nuclear scale-up famously did negative learning by doing. Economics of scale is not something you can assume. This is from before Flamanvile 3 started, that is even more negative learning.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S03014...

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by themaninthedark on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:39AM (#37611923)
I don't think this is "nuclear is the new green jesus" but rather "Nuclear is not the devil that the Greens painted it as."

It is very interesting to see the viewpoint shift happen here. I see people saying that oil companies/Russia were funding/pushing talking points to the green organizations.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by zozbot234 on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:15AM (#37611625)
The point of nuclear power plants is to provide energy when the wind isn't blowing and the sun isn't shining. The real alternative is not "wind" or "solar", it's natgas peaker plants plus demand reduction where feasible. Energy storage is theoretically possible but quite hard outside of established systems like pumped hydro - which still can't deal with prolonged shortfalls as might happen, e.g. in mid-winter over quite large geographical areas. It's not clear that these offer a better scenario than just building some modern, comparatively safe nuclear plants.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by danek_szy on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:33AM (#37611851)
>The international community is clear on the reasons when it's Iran building PWRs but it's equally as true for every other country that does it (thats why we can be sure of Iran's motive).

[citation needed] Who's exactly the "international community" and where's the data to that claim?

Cheap bait...

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by mcpackieh on Friday September 22, 2023 @10:35AM (#37612619)
"International community" is usually a euphemism for "a bunch of American and European NGOs" It's a slang term to imply broad consensus to bully people into conforming.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by Galaxeblaffer on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:35AM (#37611873)
nuclear was green Jesus 50 years ago. Today it's been regulated into oblivion making it super expensive in most of the western world. that doesn't make the technology any less interesting and it still has huge potential as part of the mix. you can throw around your numbers for wind/solar + p2x but that shit is still experimental and will require insane investments in infrastructure that's usually not counted in the numbers spewed by the solar/wind is the new green Jesus lobby. my bet is still on nuclear winning the race eventually, but we'll have to see i guess. right now it's pretty insane here in solar/wind land (Germany, Denmark) er haven't brought down emissions one bit in a long long time and prices for electricity is fucking crazy. like people have to actively look if it's ok to boil water, turn on the oven or wash their clothes and we're effectively pulling the whole of Europe down with us because of the insane rules for the "free" market for electricity. but let's see who win out in the end.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by sojournerc on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:30AM (#37611793)
That's the second time you've used that phrase in this thread... seems to be flame bait more than anything. Nuclear is cleaner than coal or natural gas, does not emit carbon after construction, and modern technology has made it much more safe (though we'd actually have to build more modern reactors).

Those are facts, not religious beliefs.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by the_mitsuhiko on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:42AM (#37611250)
It wasn’t suing for going nuclear but using funds from the renewables subsidies.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by gambiting on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:44AM (#37611272)
Poland doesn't have a border with Austria, and even if it did the power plant is going to be built literally on the opposite end of the country - it will be like 800km from the nearest border with Austria. So yeah, good luck with that argument.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by FirmwareBurner on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:46AM (#37611287)
Did my point fly so high above peoples' heads? The question was whether Germany will sue Poland the same way Austria does to it's neighbors, not whether Austria will sue Poland.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by eganist on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:49AM (#37611331)
> Curious what Poland's anti-nuclear neighboring country will think about this?

> AFAIK Austria was also suing Hungary and Slovenia for going nuclear.

---

> Did my point fly so high above peoples' heads? The question was whether Germany will sue Poland the same way Austria does to it's neighbors, not whether Austria will sue Poland.

It did, yes, because based on what you wrote, you assumed most people on HN know that:

1. Germany has a large anti-nuclear presence

2. Austria is not bordering Poland.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by gambiting on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:47AM (#37611300)
It hasn't even crossed my mind that Germany would.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by timeon on Friday September 22, 2023 @12:32PM (#37614148)
> Did my point fly so high above peoples' heads?

Well you put too much assumptions there.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by mrweasel on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:46AM (#37611297)
The location seems to place the plant pretty far away from neighboring countries, it's pretty much in the middle of the Polish Baltic coast.

The French a probably the most upset, seeing as the Polish went with a US contractor.

Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by nixass on Friday September 22, 2023 @08:48AM (#37611314)
Germans can suck it. I'd love if every neighbour around Germany went full NPP while Germany is choking in its own brown coal smoke and failed energiewende agenda
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by aredox on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:06AM (#37611512)
Let's see first if they manage to build the plant in less than 2x the projected completion time and 3x the projected cost. And if the price of electricity will still be high enough for the plant to be profitable by then.
Re:Westinghouse/Bechtel Consortium Agreement: First Nuclear ... by oldnet on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:17AM (#37611639)
Czech republic is full pro-nuclear. New blocks will be build and new nuclear power plant is in talk.

Westinghouse is also in both games.