News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by NamTaf on Thursday September 21, 2023 @08:46PM (#37606490)
Quite tangential, but during lockdown I was looking for a way to use my iPhone as a webcam and came across this project:

https://vdo.ninja/

It started out as being a means to send a video feed into OBS[1], which is how I rigged the webcam input, but as the project grew, it expanded to being a way for me to spin up desktop video and audio sharing in a browser, sorta like Zoom, etc. This let me run virtual movie nights with people remotely.

Whilst it's possible to use it via the 'create a room' interface, you can also do it all via URL parameters which I found much more flexible and robust. See here[2].

You create source and recipient URLs and then it just automagically makes it all work via WebRTC. I was able to for example make a source that captured my VLC window and sent out the video and audio, and then two destination URLs which received the source video and audio, but also sent their own audio to one another. This meant we could hear and watch the movie but also talk to each other via our microphones. All within browsers.

I've got no relation to this project besides thinking it's really awesome.

[1]: Used for streaming your computer online, e.g. on Twitch. https://obsproject.com/

[2]: https://docs.vdo.ninja/master/how-does-it-work

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by w-ll on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:11PM (#37606656)
I mean if you have an iPhone and thats your only Apple device this looks cool, but its kinda crazy Macbooks still ship with 1080p cameras. Not the event this month, but i think the one before that they demoedd using your iphone as camera for facetime on the desktop.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by faeriechangling on Thursday September 21, 2023 @09:42PM (#37606885)
The webcams are for videoconferencing. It’s pretty rare for videoconferencing to support better than 1080p30. Apple is not exactly shy about using mediocre parts when it won’t make a difference.

What surprised me was how long Apple was on 720p.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by twobitshifter on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:28PM (#37607163)
Well there’s more you can with more resolution than transmit a bigger picture. Try the iPad camera during FaceTime. That will pan and zoom the view to keep you in focus and it’s only made possible by good resolution and a wide angle camera.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by faeriechangling on Thursday September 21, 2023 @10:44PM (#37607256)
I’ve configured OBS to do this with a 4K camera with a wide angle lens I have, plugged into a laptop with a 1080p camera. Which is be better than any camera they could ever fit into a Mac due to the sensor size. I usually don’t turn this effect on because I find it’s a little distracting…

The other issue I didn’t bring up is the form factor. Phones and tablets simply have more room for a webcam than the MacBook Pro screen and I don’t actually know anybody shipping a laptop with a built-in 4K webcam. Mind you that Apple could ship a better camera with its studio display but opts not to.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by pnpnp on Friday September 22, 2023 @12:31AM (#37607888)
The iPad also has a lot more room for camera hardware than a MacBook. They’re a lot thicker.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by hunters_laptop on Saturday September 23, 2023 @11:58AM (#37624412)
I dont understand what you mean, I dont use itad or faceclock
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by TylerE on Friday September 22, 2023 @02:22AM (#37608547)
What probably would move the needle would be some sort of built in ring light.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by stavros on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:05AM (#37608831)
We should mount a big light-generating component right under the camera!
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by mxxx on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:01PM (#37607347)
The res isn’t even the problem, the minute you aren’t in broad daylight the image quality drops off rapidly.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by brailsafe on Thursday September 21, 2023 @11:59PM (#37607663)
It's ironic that they default to using the built-in webcam for Apple Developer ID authentication, because text doesn't come out clear enough to be recognized.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by pnpnp on Friday September 22, 2023 @12:30AM (#37607879)
I see this argument a lot, but it’s actually a pretty complex trade off.

Screen size, target audience (1080p Zoom), cost, sensor size, and pixel size all come into play.

You can pump numbers for the sake of it on paper, but the reality is that it’s very hard to cram a good image sensor into a laptop screen in an economic way. There’s unfortunately just not enough real estate as thin as they are.

Meanwhile, phones are quite a bit thicker & cameras are a huge selling point. Plus, almost everyone has one. It makes sense that if you want higher quality video on your computer, you’d use the other device which has video higher up on the design priority list.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by munk-a on Friday September 22, 2023 @02:10AM (#37608470)
> There’s unfortunately just not enough real estate as thin as they are.

Darn, one piece of marketing BS getting in the way of other marketing BS. Yea, 1080p is plenty high res enough for your work meetings and family calls - but users don't really care about the thin aspect, we care about weight. Getting better key depth on laptops in exchange for a modicum of extra width is a deal I'd take any day of the week... and that'd allow far better cooling engineering and for a few more bulky components.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by afiori on Friday September 22, 2023 @02:26AM (#37608578)
In the context of cameras thickness is of the screen, not of the laptop as a whole
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by OJFord on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:39AM (#37609082)
I think that was just another example, since key depth obviously has nothing to do with camera image sensor resolution.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by makeitdouble on Friday September 22, 2023 @05:42AM (#37609936)
There is no physical restriction preventing the screen from getting thicker though. At the end of the day it's a trade-off Apple is taking.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by afiori on Saturday September 23, 2023 @05:59AM (#37621906)
yes, but a thicker laptop has a lot of advantages, a thicker monitor only a few.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by cpuguy83 on Friday September 22, 2023 @09:40AM (#37611940)
The TV industry would like to have a word with you. :) Aesthetics is a thing and people love thin screens.

Beyond pure aesthetics thickness absolutely does matter when you are sticking your laptop into a backpack.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by matt-attack on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:35AM (#37609052)
They just need a thick camera like the iPhone 15 Pro but then just create a hole for it by the track pad.
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by high_priest on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:51AM (#37610768)
Imagine the gunk collection in said hole. Yuck!
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by audunw on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:23AM (#37610580)
Higher resolution would be a complete waste for videoconferencing. Having good pixels and a good lens is far more important than high resolution, especially for video. And resolution often comes at the cost of pixel quality. Small pixels have worse sensitivity, unless you can fit a bigger CMOS sensor.

But you’re not going to fit a really good lens on the laptop screen without an annoying bulge anyway, and for 99% of people it would be a waste to spend resources on it anyway.

Using the phone is a much better solution. People are likely to have a good camera there with an OK lens anyway.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by gsich on Friday September 22, 2023 @07:52AM (#37610775)
>But you’re not going to fit a really good lens on the laptop screen without an annoying bulge anyway, and for 99% of people it would be a waste to spend resources on it anyway.

It can be done without a bulge. But designers gonna design and make something ugly. Smartphone CMOS sensors are not bigger than the usual stuff in Laptop bezels.

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by haunter on Friday September 22, 2023 @01:39AM (#37608293)
I use the Elgato app for this, works perfectly across all everything (including OBS)

https://apps.apple.com/us/app/epoccam-webcamera-for-computer...

Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by BoorishBears on Friday September 22, 2023 @03:00AM (#37608797)
Macbooks natively support using an iPhone for this with much better UX (and desk view)
Re:Android 14 adds support for using your smartphone as a we... by NamTaf on Friday September 22, 2023 @05:18AM (#37609781)
I used a Windows desktop at the time, so that wasn’t an option. My only webcam was also 320x240 from the USB1 era.