News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by gustavus on Saturday September 16, 2023 @09:28PM (#37540564)
My wife has several family members with CF. They have started on trifekta and it has changed their lives radically to the point the disease barely effects them day to day.

It truly is a miracle and a breakthrough, and the only shame is that these brave pioneers are only getting $3 million for their heroic efforts.

Meanwhile the actual cost of the medicine is $10k a dose.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by bdcravens on Saturday September 16, 2023 @09:59PM (#37540744)
The pricing is more like $25-30K/month. It's taken twice a day, in pill form. (I have CF and take Trikafta)
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by squeaky-clean on Saturday September 16, 2023 @10:23PM (#37540866)
Please tell me insurance pays for most of that?
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by bdcravens on Saturday September 16, 2023 @10:26PM (#37540889)
Of course :-)

Vertex's copay assistance is also very generous, even for those with high income. I have a good developer income, and pay essentially nothing.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by trollian on Saturday September 16, 2023 @10:49PM (#37541021)
Not having to deal with insurance & copay shenanigans for my daughter's CF meds is one of the things that keeps me at the large tech company I work at...
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by amluto on Saturday September 16, 2023 @11:54PM (#37541381)
I personally consider copay assistance to be essentially fraudulent as a concept. The drug company is literally paying the patient to invoke an insurance benefit that kicks a bunch of money to the drug company.

I imagine that when an auto body shop pays their customers’ deductibles, it is fraud, legally and ethically.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by Aurornis on Sunday September 17, 2023 @12:01AM (#37541409)
Nobody actually pays those sky-high drug prices themselves. It’s a scheme to extract as much money as possible from insurers.

Companies often have programs that provide the drug free of charge (or at a nominal price) to people without insurance. They might also have “copay assistance” programs where they reimburse patients for their copay to bring the out of pocket costs down.

The goal is to maximize the amount billed to insurance companies. They’ll go out of their way to reduce the amount billed to the patient directly, because that results in more patients signing up and enabling them to bill more insurance companies.

It’s not a good system, but it’s how things work right now. Nobody pays that $100-300K price themselves. Well, we all do through higher insurance costs.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by koolba on Sunday September 17, 2023 @01:03AM (#37541688)
> Nobody actually pays those sky-high drug prices themselves. It’s a scheme to extract as much money as possible from insurers.

Alternatively, we all pay those sky high prices. It’s baked into our premiums.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by hackernewds on Sunday September 17, 2023 @02:09AM (#37542008)
while employed Premiums = $0. while unemployed, premiums = $3600/year for $0 deductibles for private insurance. would you rather pay 10% of your income in higher taxes like so-called universal healthcare providing countries maintain?
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by viciousvoxel on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:27AM (#37543134)
Yes, personally. Instead of my employer paying for my healthcare (and that being factored into base salary), I would rather receive that money as salary and pay higher taxes. The idea of employers paying for health insurance in the US only came about in the first half of the last century as a way for companies to attract employees without having to raise/compete on salary.
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by verall on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:03AM (#37543346)
Can you give me a link or reference to this incredible $3600/year for $0 deductables insurance?

That's cheaper than I pay with my employer covering most of my healthcare. That could be literally lifesaving for friends of mine who currently have to choose between paying about $800/month for insurance with deductables or going without.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by heavyset_go on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:30AM (#37543514)
One look at the individual market for insurance shows that you will be paying many times the quoted figure if you want insurance that you can actually use, and you will have $8k deductibles and higher out-of-pocket maximums with cheaper insurance.
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by verall on Monday September 18, 2023 @03:30AM (#37553346)
It's just completely BS then? Looks like it's plenty upvoted too.
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by bdcravens on Monday September 18, 2023 @05:02AM (#37553873)
Yes. As for upvotes, chalk it up to the bias against "socialized" medicine.
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by viknesh on Sunday September 17, 2023 @09:54AM (#37545080)
This is such a short-sighted take. Who do you think pays for your $0/year premiums? You do, through reduced wages.

The main difference between US healthcare and socialized health care is that in the US, nobody is responsible for lowering healthcare costs... and so they go up. Why do you think PE loves buying up healthcare facilities?

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by bdcravens on Sunday September 17, 2023 @11:57AM (#37546440)
The premiums are nowhere near that cheap.

I have the best insurance policy my employer offers, where I have a $250 annual out of pocket max. I pay an additional $230/mo for the coverage over their base plan; I pay $900/mo to add my wife to the plan.

I'm just one datapoint, and there may be better plans out there, but you're presenting an alternative that doesn't exist for 95% of Americans.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by bdcravens on Sunday September 17, 2023 @03:08PM (#37548339)
Correction: Deductible $250, out of pocket maximum $1500
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by reaperman on Monday September 18, 2023 @02:57PM (#37560414)
These numbers are pretty far off for me. I have:

- $4,000 deductible

- $8,000 Out of pocket max

- $1,800/year premiums while employed, $7,200/year premiums on COBRA if unemployed.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by masklinn on Sunday September 17, 2023 @05:21AM (#37543097)
> It’s a scheme to extract as much money as possible from insurers. [...] The goal is to maximize the amount billed to insurance companies.

A big part of the goal is being able to bill a profit, insurers generally require significant drug rebates for coverage. So you triple the sticker price of the drug, offer a 66% drug rebate which the insurer can advertise to their client under the guise of fighting for their access, and they cover your drug at essentially the price you wanted for it in the first place (modulo nonsense like prior authorization, and insurance kickbacks).

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by yread on Sunday September 17, 2023 @06:30AM (#37543516)
There is one major reason for high costs, Vertex needs to recoup high licensing costs that they paid to .... drumroll.... The CF "Foundation"

https://www.cff.org/about-us/our-history

> 2014: The CF Foundation sells royalty rights for CF treatments developed by Vertex for $3.3 billion – bringing resources to the fight against CF never thought possible

CFF funded the original research https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3219147/ and then made the drug unavailable to most patients. How do these people sleep at night?

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by cowsandmilk on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:04AM (#37543711)
> high licensing costs that they paid to .... drumroll.... The CF "Foundation"

What are you talking about? The CFF invested in the research being done at Vertex and then sold their shares in the investment. There are no licensing fees.

> made the drug unavailable to most patients

Where’s the data showing the majority of CF patients aren’t receiving Kalydeco or Trifekta?

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by refurb on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:37AM (#37543936)
Outside of the US access to Kalydeco and Trifekta is quite limited.

Last I checked only 8 of 13 provinces/territories in Canada pay for it, and only for children and adolescents - adults are excluded.

The UK also refused to pay for it but I think that was resolved? Been a while since I checked.

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by jamesblonde on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:10AM (#37544188)
They pay now
Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by yread on Sunday September 17, 2023 @08:54AM (#37544553)
> CFF invested in the research being done at Vertex and then sold their shares in the investment

Maybe they should just rebrand to CF Investment Fund then. I thought it's a charity with a mission of improving the lives of CF patients not an investment vehicle that happens to invest into compounds around CF. I hope the patients who contributed to the charity and now can't afford the drug are happy with the rate of returns

Re:Life-changing cystic fibrosis treatment wins US$3M Breakt... by vibrio on Sunday September 17, 2023 @07:39AM (#37543957)
The drugs may have never been developed without the CFF. They arguably took more financial risk than vertex. Vertex was trying to be a hepatitis c company at the time and cf was an off focus program that happened to come with an acquisition. With out CFF funding my guess is the program would have been cut. The fact that the nonprofit got a royalty stream from their significant financial investments is good practice. The drugs are expensive, but how much is a patients life with? How much money does stopping progression save the healthcare system financially? Aside from giving the patients more normal and longer life, persistent and repeated hospitalizations and lung tra transplants are very costly and poorly effective. This is an example of transformative Medicne. Our society needs should prioritize such work.