My question is are there other groups or religions experiencing the same. So far we have two major ones (Jews,Catholics) but what about the social halls and groups of old? I just get the feeling that people are grouping into these over arching tribes more and more.
Also, to your point, I’m not sure the kids of ours will see a rebellion against their parents religion as the cool thing, I think the teenage rebellion tide will turn and the kids will focus on something else that’s “cool.” After all, religion has been around a long time and it’s survived countless teenage generations, surely it’s not predestined that all kids would be like you.
That isn’t to say that attrition doesn’t happen. It does. But this group has resisted it more than other faiths.
Also, are the ultra-orthadox exempt from the military service that the rest of Israelis are required to enrol in? This seems like the only opportunity for ultra-orthadox Israelis to even be exposed to outside influences
both. they supposed to enroll to army but in case they study in yeshiva they typically avoid it, till they reach the age when army "looses" interest in you.
it's one of the major pain points in israeli politics/society. army supposed to be people army but big chunk of population avoids it and all the time tries to pushes through knesset laws to make this avoidance permanent and supreme court strikes it down (because it violates equality clause)
one of the reasons for the very messy supreme court reform in israel that been ongoing for past half an year is to allow to make law that will give permanent exception from army to orthodox . they even wanted to make recently law that equates tora study to army service
I guess in countries where shots are actually fired in anger this experience may vary wildly.
At the very least an 18 year old who has been forced to fend for themselves is very different to an 18 year-old who still lives at home and has their mum do their washing.
I know who I'd rather employ.
With regards to "fending for yourself", you should visit Israel some day. It's something that is mastered by age of 8
Following orders that are barked at them by usually less intelligent people that just happen to have some stripes on their shoulder is not fending for oneself. You get fed, sleep and eat on command, what fending is there to do?
A teenager living at home has a high degree of freedom, but they don't have to fend for themselves, that is, they don't have to take responsibility for doing all the things that need doing in life, they will find their dirty shirt left on the floor, magically cleaned, ironed and put back in the wardrobe.
Someone in the army has a low amount of freedom, but they have to take responsibility for all the things that need doing in life. If they don't make sure their shirt is washed, ironed, etc they will be held responsible.
Moving into your own place for the first time is much more like fending for yourself. Having to learn to cook, wash, manage your finances.
The only thing the military is really good at teaching is obedience but at the expense of suppressing critical thought and creativity. If I were an employer I'd like my employees to tell me if they disagree and not blindly follow orders.
Interesting. Why is it that Arab Israelis are not required to serve then? Wouldn’t that same equality clause apply?
anecdotally, in past decades some arabs tend to volunteer to army/alternative service
Yes that will fix it.
My gf did confirmation because you get loads of presents, which is an easy sell to a child.
Same mistake as we make for radical Islam.
These aren't religions, they're cultures/law systems/political systems/belief systems, that encompass everything you can think of, for people born in these nothing of value exists out of them
But young people live in a more open world. The ones that still adhere to such strict rules are a tiny minority.
When I look at my own country it seems that people are less and less following their parents' religious choices. Most Catholics in Holland of my generation are only so in name. That say they are to please the parents, but they don't do anything church related.
The same happens to more strict religions like Calvinism. My generation generally doesn't care about it, only their parents do. I guess even at a young age kids find information these days and start making their own choices. Having a religion that forbids loads of fun stuff isn't really attractive when you see other people living their life without all those rules.
My parents tried to make me Catholic but I already rejected it when I was very young. I was baptized but I refused to do any more like communion or Sunday school. It just made so little sense to me (and science made so much sense instead)
I wonder if the same will happen there.