And yes, this has been talked about endlessly. Heck, some people have proposed even further restrictions; for example, in practice, the first and last hours that the exchange are open tend to have the highest volume, so why not only keep the exchange open for those two hours?
If releases like this were scheduled for 30 seconds into a 5 minute box, basically any trader that cares would be able to react inside the box. We could say 99.9% for the sake of argument.
I can't exactly state whether it's a good idea overall, but the idea that it might not catch literally everyone doesn't really matter. It's an extreme example of letting the perfect be the enemy of the good, when it comes to this single aspect.
It would equalize the field. However it also means unexpected expenses cannot be handled. Furnace breaks, even though you have plenty of $$$ in stocks you are unable to get it fixed. (I know a retired person who was forced to buy a new car with cash because the bank didn't accept their > $million in investments as proof they could pay for a small loan)
It's a statement about strategy, not about suggesting regulation.
Or maybe I remember wrong.
It's how the market opens every morning and closes every afternoon [1]. There is still an advantage to low latency--the closer your get your order to the submission deadline, the more information you can incorporate into it.
[1] https://www.nyse.com/publicdocs/nyse/markets/nyse/NYSE_Openi...
Cryptocurrency seems to refute this assumption. I'd be curious to see if these fairness regulations actually lower capital costs for companies more than they cost to comply with.
I don't think nanosecond-sensitive trading should be a thing, personally, but sweeping changes to the way security exchange works seems less likely than societal collapse. Most apparent experts insist that letting algorithmic money vacuums operate is "good for liquidity," and that there is no viable more-fair alternative. I don't really buy it. IMO the obstacles to something better are just public ignorance, industry inertia, and a deeply lacking interest in fairness, i.e. corruption.
You do realize those "apparent experts" are mainly those ones making money from it (or are closely associated with them)?
I also think the best policy national is for everyone to pay me $10 daily. And I can give you hundreds of pages in support as to why that is. And after I've made a few tens of millions of that, I can buy you an army of "apparent experts" that will agree with it.
And for starters, by ensuring that money is moving daily (to my pocket), regardless of if a person is sitting on the couch at home watching tv all day, "greatly increases liquidity".
I'm likewise very aware that that's a factor in people's defense of the status quo.
That's how I understand it. And it feels like a leaky dam with fingers stuck all over it.
What are the major, huge, "no-one will go for that" changes that might simply replace the dam?
If we apply a Tobin Tax? If we time box trades to every five minutes? If we end trading on margin? Place derivatives under insurance law ?
Or is it that experienced players have a huge incentive to fleece inexperienced players and that's just the way of the world, and the casino needs to have really good pit bosses, or there is no casino?