I’d need to educate myself a bit more in terms of whether there are third-party authorities beyond Microsoft for the packages.
Found this introductory video for anyone else interested:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=phrD081sMWc
Note: I didn’t intend the Surface pun above, but it happened and we can all be glad that it did.
So whilst Microsoft will sign for you if you distribute via their store, otherwise you pay per year for certificates and can distribute outside the store.
There are problems with the system (cost, bugs, usability problems) but it is decentralized.
It's easy to run unsigned binaries/app packages on macOS: right click on the .app, hold down Option, then click Open and confirm the warning.
The closest Apple comes to this capability is achieved via device Supervision and MDM, which might be comfortable for some of us here in this forum but obviously isn’t practical beyond more technical circles.
Baddies keep ruining all the fun for the rest of us.
IMHO the blame rather lies with our politicians who are unwilling to take the steps necessary to cut the baddies off from the Internet. Let's see just how fast India, Pakistan, Turkey and other scammer hotspots clean up their act when the US+EU threaten to cut them off from the Internet and SS7 unless the scam callcenters are closed down for good... the amount of corruption regularly exposed by scambaiters on Youtube is insane. Billions of dollars of damages each year [1] from that bullshit and our politicians don't. fucking. care.
[1] https://www.vibesofindia.com/fraudsters-in-india-cost-americ...
You don't need the whole world. The Western world is enough - no Internet and phone service (both easily enforced by requiring providers to reject ASNs / phone country codes) means a lot of lost business for an affected country.
> Pressuring India is hard enough, try Myanmar, a place that doesn’t get along with the West at all and is already a hotspot for phone scams targeting Chinese speakers.
Honestly, that's China's problem to solve.
> So I’m all for pressuring India to crack down on scammers, but I don’t see how that would reduce the desire to tighten software controls on PCs.
When software vendors don't have to gate more and more features behind more and more obnoxious bullshit simply to whack-a-mole scammers, they won't.
On Unix/Linux land the prevalence of pipe curl to bash type installers is not much different.
I normally keep both types away from my computers.
True, but saying so will likely to earn you downvotes from those committed to the practice ...
This is a problem but only if you install software on Linux by manually going to the project page and copy-pasting whatever curl they have there, I think the difference is that mostly you're encouraged to go the package manager route, whereas on windows downloading .exes directly (ala the curl example) is the norm.
Directly sudoing a curl-ed script is like running a binary on Windows with admin permissions and with Defender turned off, which makes it somewhat more scary to me.
On Windows I use Chocolatey when I can, and if I can't (or it looks dodgy anyway) I'll either just not install it or try it in a sandbox. Things that aren't choco-able are generally commercial software obtained from the vendor's download page, we theoretically trust those things somewhat. YMMV.
Most people would just say yes to any prompt they get, those wise enough not to aren't running random curl scripts either.
As for Defender being any kind of protection, I have my doubts.
> it seems to be increasingly the case that package managers just don't have some software - or have a version that's years out of date.
This is entirely distro dependant, some are very up to date and have most things you'd want, especially if you include the likes of AUR in that. But then there's usually a Flatpak or an AppImage that you can use in the odd case that they don't.
Basically how Linux distributions works since the beginning. Tough at the start the installation source was not remote but a CD-ROM things didn't change.
You have a repository of packages (that can be on a local source as a CD or remote source such as an HTTP/FTP server), that have some sort of signature (on Linux usually the pagkage is signed with GPG) with some keys that the user trusts (and the default are installed on the system), and a software that allows to install, uninstall and update the packages.
Android/iOS arrived later, but they didn't invent anything.
I suspect the final form for software installation is probably where iOS and Android are going in the EU, where there's a single means of installing software to the device so that everything can be sandboxed properly, but the acquisition/update process can be pointed to a URL/Store that the user has pre-approved.
macOS comes pretty close to what I'd ideally want in an OS with regards to installation - independent packages that are certified/notarised, but I'd like to see the OS allow for user-specified authorities beyond just Apple. That being said, I'm not sure I'd ever use them as it's part of what I'm paying Apple for, I'm really thinking more of Linux there.
A kind of flatpak/snap approach, but that has signing of the package and centralised management of the permissions for the sandbox at an OS level would be ideal in my view. That way it's still free-as-in-speech as the user can specify which notarisation authority to use (or none at all).
I really don't understand why seperate programs are handling removing their mother program in 2023, that's registry spaghetti messy.