News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:40AM (#37467986)
Data privacy is one of the least important issues of our day. People (especially on HN) foam at the mouth about it but are unable to produce specific harms Google and Meta ad tracking creates.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by srcreigh on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:50AM (#37468118)
The opportunity cost of the advertising industry is incalculable. Entire industries are snuffed because kingpin ad networks can make a few dollars per year per person by having a free app with ads in that space. Less choice for the consumer, less competition, lower quality.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by jraby3 on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:57AM (#37468230)
There are pretty clear benefits to some advertising.

Email, YouTube, calendar, maps are all incredibly useful services we are lucky to have.

There needs to be a line or safeguard as well as an option to pay a reasonable price for these free services to keep your data safe. YouTube is unfairly overpriced for the ad free option as are most of these free services.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by srcreigh on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:57AM (#37469200)
The greatest loss of the 21st century is how far behind we are in all the industries you list. Not to mention news.

The option to pay today’s kingpin isn’t any recompense.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by fangorn on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:15PM (#37469464)
Maybe it's nothing, or maybe it's freudian, but email existed before Google, so did calendar. Youtube was an acquisition. Maps, well, there are great alternatives now that do not require anal-probe-level surveillance to find an address or a route.

Just publicly fund the services that are useful to people. If "government" (i.e. us) can pay for a square for people to meet at, why not "digital spaces"?

And if someone's thinking "but government will use this data to surveil people!" - this ship has sailed, they have access to everything that's not e2ee, and even that's not guaranteed.

Government is practically the only body that can be expected to follow laws and act with people's best interest in mind. Some governments even do, just need a non-dystopian one...

And yes, there's commercial space in government/local authority-operated places. That's fine, just make sure to boot those that decide to install the equivalent of cameras and microphones on their storefront.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cscurmudgeon on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:24PM (#37469604)
> Youtube was an acquisition

And the relied on VC money before that. It wasn't self-sustaining financially.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by rollcat on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:44PM (#37469917)
Email and calendar were doing perfectly fine before pervasive online tracking.

Have you checked OpenStreetMaps? It may lag behind Google or Apple for things like shop opening hours, but I'd choose it 11 out of 10 times over anything else when going hiking in the mountains. Feels like every stone is marked.

YouTube? This one is a tough call. It was generating losses for a decade, maybe a decade and a half. Perhaps it should've been a publicly funded service.

If you enjoyed this comment, please like and subscribe.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by JohnFen on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:52PM (#37470038)
> Email, YouTube, calendar, maps are all incredibly useful services we are lucky to have.

None of which require advertising.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by pulpfictional on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:39PM (#37471689)
That needs money, not advertising.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:22PM (#37470469)
What you're saying is: people prefer free products with ads and that annoys you because you prefer paying for products without ads. That's not a moral issue.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by srcreigh on Friday September 22, 2023 @05:14PM (#37617881)
Enough people use for free products, free products take over, paid products no longer exist (or reduced options by 50x), free products stagnate, we end up behind on quality of services by a long shot.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by rendall on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:48AM (#37469050)
Must I "produce specific harms" before I have the right not to consent to my data collection? Isn't "I don't like it" enough?

Metadata analysis can deduce quite a lot about you. Your sexual predilections or your political or religious outlook, for instance. Who you spend time with and where you spend it and what you do when you are together, for another. Who you care about, who they care about, who they spend time together with...

Not only do you have to trust that the people who have access to this data about you will use it only to advertise to you, but you also have to trust everyone who will ever have access to this data in the future, too.

You might dismiss that there is any inherent risk to total strangers knowing intimate details about you, but I personally think the risk of this is a "specific harm".

I think your stance is a version of "I do nothing wrong, therefore I have nothing to hide, therefore surveillance is nothing to worry about". With respect, it's naive.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by renewiltord on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:22PM (#37469565)
> Must I "produce specific harms" before I have the right not to consent to my data collection? Isn't "I don't like it" enough?

Of course you must. I don't like it when people fart near me, but I don't have a "right to not consent to farting near me". Some people "don't like it" when other people look at them in public, but they don't have a "right to not be looked at in public".

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:29PM (#37469670)
They did still manage to clear this bar in their comment.

> You might dismiss that there is any inherent risk to total strangers knowing intimate details about you, but I personally think the risk of this is a "specific harm".

It would be interesting to discuss the merits of this idea. Call center employees are often heavily restricted in their access to user data for the precise reason that specific harms -- stalking, fraud, etc. -- actually occur.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:18PM (#37470392)
That's why I say it's a low priority issue. Could there be an issue in the future? Possibly. Are privacy laws like GDPR worth the economic and other harms? Probably not. The amount of wasted programmer hours alone has far overcome the negative impacts of big tech ad tracking.

Neither real life or the internet are anonymous. We live with other people. But Google and Meta in particular have an amazing 15 year track record of basically never leaking user data. Various national governments have been much worse in this regard.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by rendall on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:29PM (#37471491)
You downplay the risk, but don't really address it head on. There is data out there about you and your family. Recall the tendency of human beings to arbitrarily discriminate or even perpetrate genocide. Hopefully, there will never be a legal framework requiring Google nor Meta (nor any of the literally thousands of data tracking companies) to hand over this data to powerful organizations who intend harm to you or your descendents, but if it came to that, hopefully Google, Meta and every one of the thousands of data tracking companies do the right thing and withhold data that could identify you as a suspect political minority and predict your movements.

Maybe there's something more mundane and relatively benign. Employment or benefits withheld because of your tendency to procrastinate and watch 80s action films. Your grand niece is canceled because you held views considered problematic by her generation.

Your only argument against this seems to be that it's unlikely. Perhaps, but that's argument from personal incredulity, not an argument that it won't happen. I would love for you to walk me through a rock solid argument that it cannot possibly happen.

Or, you know, we could establish a legal framework and social convention now whereby you can demand data about you and your dependents be collected only with your informed consent and deleted at will, just to not have to ever need to cross that bridge.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:50PM (#37472682)
Government risk from Meta and Google is meaningless. The ISPs have all the same data anyway.

Also all the data is out there and me and my family in a million databases. Just like in the 80s with the yellow books.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by TheIronMark on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:12PM (#37472240)
Meta literally allowed their data to be used by Cambridge Analytica in a fashion that likely swayed the 2016 US election.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:47PM (#37472660)
Literally every part of this sentence is wrong which shows the state of this discourse.

1) CA created their own data with quizzes on FB that people filled out and gave to CA. Even if you banned ad tracking sending people surveys and quizzes is still legal. The FB network only made the quizzes more viral.

2) The CA data was 100% useless for ad targeting and had no impact on the Trump campaigns (any professional advertisers can tell you this, it's not controversial). The big election interference impact was Russia leaking the DNC emails and other hacked stuff to string along the Hillary emails newsline.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by TheIronMark on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:00PM (#37472830)
It's fair to say Meta didn't give the data, but they provided a platform that allowed CA to develop the app which gathered the data. On the topic of data privacy, that's a bad step by Meta.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:15PM (#37473027)
At the time the programmer zeitgeist was calling FB evil for having a walled garden and not sharing data. Them opening up the API was applauded by the tech industry and HN (look up the archives). And it still has nothing to do with FB privacy efforts today which is just light years beyond where it was in 2012.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lewhoo on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:54AM (#37469148)
Spoken like a true salesman.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by criddell on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:39PM (#37469833)
Google has handed over user data to Hong Kong authorities. Chances are Meta and Apple have as well. It's possible that the Chinese government has never sought information on individuals for political reasons but I wouldn't trust that to be true.

If you were in China, would you feel comfortable clicking on a pro-democracy ad running on Meta?

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:16PM (#37470374)
Google and Meta are both banned in China because they wouldn't give the party everything it wanted. Not to mention your ISP has all the same info (with more detail!) and also will give it to the government.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by criddell on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#37472696)
You're making my point better than I did. The unregulated collection of data on people will lead to real harm.

If all that data couldn't lead to real harm, then Google and Meta would have no problem handing it over to whatever authority wants it.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:53PM (#37472719)
That doesn't follow and is very stretched logic.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by criddell on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:22PM (#37473138)
If companies that track everything we do online were to start freely sharing this information with governments around the world, do you think it would lead to real harm?
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by JohnFen on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:50PM (#37469992)
> Data privacy is one of the least important issues of our day

To you. To others, it's one of the most important.

> but are unable to produce specific harms Google and Meta ad tracking creates.

I think that some harms have been articulated repeatedly. And I would argue that just being under constant surveillance is, itself, a harm.

But, really, this is irrelevant in terms of the principle involved. Even if it were 100% harmless, that doesn't mean anything at all in terms of the fact that we should all have the ability to live our lives without having someone constantly spying on us. Human rights don't stop being rights in the absence of particularlized, articulable harms.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by ActorNightly on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:38PM (#37470715)
>To others, it's one of the most important.

Its only really important to a very small minority of the population. The rest of the people say they want privacy, but have absolutely zero clue on what that actually implies and take active steps to worsen their privacy in lieu of using the latest smartphone or smartphone app.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:26PM (#37471435)
> Its only really important to a very small minority of the population. The rest of the people say they want privacy

This argument is absolutely a No True Scotsman. Just because they don't Truly Want privacy doesn't mean they're not expressing that they want privacy.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by ActorNightly on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:37PM (#37471643)
One of the more important lessons I have learned in life is that what people want are expressed through their actions, which are often not the same as what is expressed through words. People may desire or want privacy, but they don't care about it enough to not use devices and software.

For example, if you do something so benign as use an Iphone, you don't care about privacy. Monitor all the network traffic that iPhone sends back to apple if you want to see why. Apple absolutely tracks all the stuff that you do on your device. Thats not privacy.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:44PM (#37471769)
If someone buys an iphone specifically because they believe the privacy marketing from Apple, certainly they are choosing privacy with their actions and they happen to be misinformed.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by ActorNightly on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @07:54AM (#37479685)
Sure, but thats a relationship between you and the company. Those same people shouldn't have a voice that affects legislation that effectively ruins the internet.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by nonrandomstring on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:32PM (#37472531)
> One of the more important lessons I have learned in life is that what people want are expressed through their actions, which are often not the same as what is expressed through words. People may desire or want privacy, but they don't care about it enough to not use devices and software.

I have learned the exact opposite. That people's actions are often their unwanted expressions of what they abhor and truly do not want in their soul. Take any addict for an example.

Guess it all depends on how you see the mind-body and your deeper knowledge of human psychology.

You do seem to delight in the "stupid masses" perspective. But maybe that hides your compassion - perhaps compassion that most people's relation to technology is one of victimhood, learned helplessness in the face of colossal free-for-all cargo-cult of exploitation, dressed up as "choice" and backed by the total failure of the rule of law to protect them.

Anyway, just something we might consider before pronouncing on "what people 'care' about".

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by ActorNightly on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @07:53AM (#37479660)
Its not about "stupid masses". I just don't like hypocrisy. If people would just need to admit that they are ok with all the free shit they get as a result of advertising and that is all worth more to them than privacy, we wouldn't get non non technical politicians trying to create pointless legislation that ruins the internet.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by nonrandomstring on Tuesday September 12, 2023 @08:13AM (#37479891)
> admit that they are ok with all the free shit they get as a result of advertising

I don't think people ordinarily make that connection. Many came from a time when the Internet was solely an expression of generosity. The thing about "culture" is that it carries on even after the facts have changed. You're right that today (2023) access to 'free stuff' is a tacit trade. People pay for free stuff by allowing themselves to be abused.

But nobody ever made that bargain explicit. It was never announced, I guess sometime around 2000, that the rules had changed.

We've had two decades of false "choice" based on a fundamental misunderstanding backed up by a conspiracy of deceit.

> that is all worth more to them than privacy

I absolutely don't believe people make this value judgement. If they truly knew what they were getting for what they are giving, Google, Amazon, Apple and Meta would cease to exist overnight.

It is therefore of paramount importance that the "Myth of the Internet" continues and that all attempts to educate and provide new kinds of digital literacy are opposed by incumbent power.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by nmeagent on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:40PM (#37472585)
> People may desire or want privacy, but they don't care about it enough to not use devices and software.

Most people don't have much of a choice. They either buy one of the insidious little snitch devices that are available or suffer socially and possibly financially. If you can't fully participate in society without some device, the decision was pretty much made for you and how much you value privacy matters little.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:26PM (#37470518)
I don't buy that "constant surveillance" from big tech is a harm, I think it's dramatized language for something quite banal. Which is why I want to see actual harms before being against it! There are many benefits to society from effective advertising.
Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:31PM (#37471524)
I fail to see how these statements are dissimilar with regard to specific examples.

> I would argue that just being under constant surveillance is, itself, a harm.

> There are many benefits to society from effective advertising.

It's not difficult for me to imagine abuses that could possibly occur given constant surveillance similar to how it's not difficult for me to imagine benefits that could possibly arise with targeted advertising.

But since we're not imagining and are instead providing examples: what are some actual benefits to targeted advertising? What benefit(s) should I expect to see from this targeting and where can I go to see this benefit?

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by cm2012 on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#37472704)
With no targeted advertising:

1) you will still get ads, it's just lowest common denominator teeth whitening and weight loss that anybody can buy.

2) it would be much harder to subsidize entertainment that relies on ads.

3) New and emerging businesses rely on ads much more than category leaders to be heard of. Worse ads means a more powerful incumbent advantage.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Monday September 11, 2023 @04:14PM (#37473002)
Thank you. I think your question can be similarly answered.

With constant surveillance:

1) individuals are incentivized to avoid expressing themselves in ways which their overseers dislike, especially if an expression draws punitive measures;

2) a particularly vulnerable person could be worried about being extorted with information that's discovered about them causing some pervasive increase in stress;

3) otherwise innocuous information about a person might indicate a Bad Thing which is only considered Bad well after the fact but might still be used against them in some social setting.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by abdullahkhalids on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:52PM (#37470040)
What is the specific harm if someone takes naked pictures of me without consent? Just the loss of my dignity as a human being. That's an abstract non-economic loss.

My data is my own data. Someone using it, along with dark art individual ad targeting methods to influence my preferences, is also the loss of my dignity as a human being. All humans deserve to be free of such coercive manipulation.

The fact that big economic firms are the ones doing this, is doubly problematic because our "democratic"-capitalistic systems are to a fairly high degree one-dollar-one-vote systems.

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by loteck on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:00PM (#37470154)
Fortunately many smart folks can anticipate major systemic issues that threaten to create exponential and devastating societal harms, and start working on them as early as possible.

Would the following statement be you, in 1980? "Climate change is one of the least important issues of our day. The few people who care about it are unable to produce specific harms burning coal and oil creates."

(Downvoted for the inflammatory mouth foam comment, FYI.)

Re:The right to data ownership is the only way to take on Bi... by 0xbadcafebee on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:03PM (#37471076)
And on the other hand, private data is something nearly nobody talks about. Actually sensitive data about you is not handled in anything approaching a systematic and careful way, and that's the data that gets exposed in massive leaks that we should be caring about. But rather than talk about that, people talk about not wanting cookies, because they're more creeped out by that than having to change their social security number.