The rich shouldn't be taxed just for providing for other people, but also as a sort of dampening effect to make sure that getting rich doesn't become the non-rich people's only objective in life (like it seems to, for many in the US).
Taxing the rich at high rates and ensuring that lifestyles are slightly more equitable will enable everyone (both rich and non-rich) to be able to enjoy the kind of "semi-retirement where a person dips out of high-pressure work in favor of lower pressure intellectual work" that you mention.
In fact, taxes on the rich could be set up explicitly to fund something like basic income programs for older people.
It doesn't work this way. Ambitious people either just move to a county that's more open to business, bringing jobs and economic growth there instead, or they go into politics and get rich just by leeching off the economically productive populace, like corrupt officials in Russia and China.
Europe is a good example of this: it's got the highest tax rates globally, and some of the lowest GDP growth rates (and number of new businesses) in the world. People in France, Germany and the UK are seeing their standards of living get worse year by year, not better
https://projects.propublica.org/americas-highest-incomes-and...
You(a nation-state government entity) has the power to drag someone back home to pay their taxes. If Apple went 100% based out of Ireland, you could tariff the hell out of Apple products until their sales drop to zero.
You can put sanctions on places that run offshore bank accounts where people hide their money.
You can nationalize industries that are falling apart due to the requirement to increase profit, ie rail infrastructure.
The issue is why would the elected officials who benefit from this, do something to counter it. They're fine with an inequitable world governed by the Koch Brothers' school for business fairy tales.
The economy is a sham, the government could pay people to run the farms and clothing factories and stockpile the excess rather than burn it to create scarcity. There are other ways to live beyond this narrow system of faux economic sciences.
Musk is the obvious example. Tesla provides ~120k well paying jobs. Its the first electric car company that makes having an electric car cool thus putting tens of thousands of people in non polluting vehicles. SpaceX has fundamentally changed space travel plus employs 12k people directly. Should we have just capped his income after he sold paypal? Think of all that would have been lost.
Also who are we to decide what people should aspire to?
It has nothing to do with comfort, dude lives in a 200 SqFt fabricated house or sleeps at work.
Now, some might make the argument that without the possibility of becoming a multi billionaire some might not be motivated to start or run a business. That, I think would be a small enough loss to be worthwhile
I've always seen this as a very weak argument. With future automation we will have to figure out some form of collective ownership and dispersal of profits.
Why do anything, shut the company down and leave, its not your responsibility any more
Not to mention all the ancillary jobs that are going to be lost. Boat builders, private aircraft manufacturers, etc.
Those who build billion dollar companies do so for more than money.
A lot of people do that in some form but it's generally hard to convert into something that pays. (It's easy to contribute to open source projects for example. It's a lot harder to get paid a modest sum for doing so at your own pace and at your own pleasure.) The same things applies in general for casual consulting, writing, etc. in semi-retirement. You can certainly do it for the stimulation but it's hard to get someone to pay you and, in any case, that probably requires a certain amount of maybe-less-fun business activities.
They're not the ones you need to be talking with. They only serve to gatekeep, don't really understand what the company needs, and can't champion you from the inside.
The engineering manager from two jobs ago on an adjacent team who's since gone off to start their own startup with some other ex-coworkers who need help in area X that you've spent years working in, but not enough for it to be a full time position yet? Reach out to them.
You can actually see it here, the age keeps going up. (Canada) https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/t1/tbl1/en/tv.action?pid=141000...
Our money isn't a durable store of value since the gold standard was abandoned, you used to be able to make up for it by investing but the line can't go up forever.
Few that save for retirement keep their savings in cash. Most would save in some sort of instrument that would expose them to the stock market, money market, real estate etc. You might not always beat inflation but you also aren't seeing your savings eaten at the rate of inflation.
> the line can't go up forever
Central banks normally have an inflation goal of 2% meaning they literally want everything to slowly go up, forever. The problems usually occur when it's faster and slower than that...
The historical returns are a aberration from a high growth world, populations are falling. They won't look like that in the coming decades.
> Central banks normally have an inflation goal of 2%
2% CPI. CPI is a political measure first and a scientific measure second, from hedonic quality adjustment, owner imputed rent and the simple fact that most households don't have teams of economists planning their budget in order to maximally limit inflation means its far from a accurate barometer for the experiences of real people in the economy.
The single income households of yore had a higher percentage of discretionary income than two income households today. CPI was unable to capture this change and finds those households are wealthier somehow.
Apart from some countries with curious and massive drops in fertility coupled with low or no immigratoin, are there any signs that global population is falling rapidly? If anything it seems it's entering a pretty stagnant phase (for example in the US). Of course stagnation might still mean an aging population, which is a problem in some cases especially when it comes to pension systems, but it doesn't magically make the economy stop growing. GDP growth isn't merely population growth.
Not only that, there is evidence birth rates fell when regions were conquered or captured by the Romans and Greeks. Birth rates fell during the end of golden ages in China, I believe birth rates fell during the renaissance.
I believe there is some limiting factor in humans. We paradoxically make more children during bad times and stop producing them when times are good. We wouldn't be alone, crickets have genes that respond to cricket population levels, changing behavior, I think we have something similar.
Also lots of environmental stuff is messing with fertility, plastics, etc.
And if you put your money in something like global index funds, it would take something like large scale war for it to not give a positive real yield. Even just a 2-3 real interest becomes quite significant if left ot accrue over 50 years.
a) people were passing away shortly after retiring. E.g. the early pensions after the industrial revolution.
b) people in retirement would take on essentially unpaid social work. Carrying for elders and kids and so on. E.g. what was going on in late USSR and soon after it's collapse.
Those options may survive even with no population growth. But nowadays people expect to live long AND social work to be done by paid employees. And that is not sustainable with or without population growth.
But pensions on the other hand usually involve some sort of government system which often ends up trapped by demographic swings. The key for a pension system is this: don't allow it to depend on demographics. Make sure each generation provides for it's own pensions.
I used food above, but lots of other things likewise need current work. You cannot retire and sit on a log watching birds, you need to get lots of things from society.
Just storing value as cash just means that you have a greater claim to the productivity of a given society than other people, it doesn't necessarily "grow the pie".
>I could certainly see a kind of semi-retirement where a person dips out of high-pressure work in favor of lower pressure intellectual work that can be completed on a looser time frame. A lifetime of experience could probably be leveraged to provide valuable insight or work on high-value niche problems in specific domains, and that can be fairly lucrative and is often very amenable to remote part-time employment.
This is how most old folks lived for all but the last 100 years. I'd totally be down to work 1-2d / wk if the labor market allowed it, but most jobs are 40h / wk or more with very little in the way of part time flexibility. We're going to have to change to allow this sort of work again in the future.
(Edit: Humans going to the Moon or Mars don't count. People could do that but the distances are significant enough that those are going to be mostly separate economies. They will not impact Earth's economy very much.)
Population growth is the fundamental driver of GDP growth. Growth can still happen in other ways via innovation and efficiency improvements but without population growth it's going to be in the low single digits.
Without significant growth, retirement just can't work. Savings can't compound enough. Taxing the rich won't provide enough and taxing the middle class will kill the economy and make the problem worse.
Lastly retirement is really an institution that was born in an age when people did not live as long (on average) and work was much more physically punishing.
I could certainly see a kind of semi-retirement where a person dips out of high-pressure work in favor of lower pressure intellectual work that can be completed on a looser time frame. A lifetime of experience could probably be leveraged to provide valuable insight or work on high-value niche problems in specific domains, and that can be fairly lucrative and is often very amenable to remote part-time employment.
But regardless of things like that, this is a recipe for pretty significant social conflict. Young people already resent "boomers" for burdening them with cost via not just taxes but squatting on all the real estate and rigging the system to increase its value to fund their retirement. This will get worse, not better.