News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wonderwonder on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:03AM (#37467447)
Why would the rich continue to create businesses and employ hundreds of millions of people if the end result was just to be taxed to oblivion. Yes there are rich people that have more $ that they can spend in a lifetime, many of them also provide more to the economy than they take out. Also much of their wealth is imaginary as it exists in shares that they cannot sell without losing control of their company.

Musk is the obvious example. Tesla provides ~120k well paying jobs. Its the first electric car company that makes having an electric car cool thus putting tens of thousands of people in non polluting vehicles. SpaceX has fundamentally changed space travel plus employs 12k people directly. Should we have just capped his income after he sold paypal? Think of all that would have been lost.

Also who are we to decide what people should aspire to?

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by hotpotamus on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:19AM (#37467675)
Imagine if Elon Musk has $100 billion (I believe the number is somewhat higher), and the government takes $99 billion from him in taxes. Do you imagine that he would stop doing his thing? Do you think he would be materially less comfortable than he is now?
Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wonderwonder on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:25AM (#37467763)
Yes. He does not have $100 billion liquid. He would have to liquidate his ownership in spacex and tesla. Losing control of the companies. So yes I think he would be forced to stop doing his thing as he would no longer control the companies.

It has nothing to do with comfort, dude lives in a 200 SqFt fabricated house or sleeps at work.

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wing-_-nuts on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:29AM (#37468743)
I'm sure if we implemented this, we could make accommodations such as making it possible to transfer share ownership 'in kind' and stripping voting rights from those shares. Musk would still be able to do his thing, the government would have a boatload more revenue to work with.

Now, some might make the argument that without the possibility of becoming a multi billionaire some might not be motivated to start or run a business. That, I think would be a small enough loss to be worthwhile

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wonderwonder on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:39AM (#37468905)
Would it? Imagine every private company of a certain size just ceasing to exist as soon as its owner reaches a set net worth. What happens to all of the millions of jobs that exist at those companies? Companies would essentially go public and then all leadership would quit immediately. Why work for free?
Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wing-_-nuts on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:57AM (#37469191)
Why would the companies cease to exist? Why would leadership quit simply because they could no longer be multi-billionaires.

I've always seen this as a very weak argument. With future automation we will have to figure out some form of collective ownership and dispersal of profits.

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wonderwonder on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:44PM (#37470799)
lets say you are allowed a max net worth of 1 million. You hit it. Why would you keep working? You are now working for free. Every extra dollar you get is taken from you.

Why do anything, shut the company down and leave, its not your responsibility any more

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wing-_-nuts on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:03PM (#37471079)
1M isn't what we're discussing here. It's 1B. Let's not strawman this discussion.
Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wonderwonder on Monday September 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#37472700)
even better, 1B, I painted myself in a corner with such a low number. So they will never have to work again, 1m they may have had to. I now have 1B. Why would i keep working? I would send a company wide email say hey guys I'm done. Good luck and shut it down. Why do anything else? You may argue there are reasons but they are all emotional / moral ones, not based on finance. I've peaked, going to go spend my life doing whatever I want, why incur the stress of anything else?

Not to mention all the ancillary jobs that are going to be lost. Boat builders, private aircraft manufacturers, etc.

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by wing-_-nuts on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:06PM (#37476595)
No judgements on you, but frankly you're not the sort of person who builds a billion dollar company to begin with. Neither am I. I know damned well we'd both cash in our chips after 10s of millions and ride off into the sunset.

Those who build billion dollar companies do so for more than money.

Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by fragmede on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:21PM (#37476662)
If you had an 61% stake of a billion-dollar company, sell off 10% for your $10 million and keep running it.
Re:Retirement: How Fucked Are You? by JoeAltmaier on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:47PM (#37470855)
For a paycheck.