Incidentally, I think people working on these features should be ashamed.
IIRC, it's the opposite: Chrome was created to prevent other browser manufacturers (in particular, Microsoft) from imposing their rules on the Internet in a way which affected Google websites.
I'm not fan of seeing which tech giant wins the privilege of imposing their will on me.
They've done a very successful job of masquerading as a cool hip tech company, even coining the totally ridiculous (given the context) "don't be evil" saying.
As a heavy user of both browsers, as far as I can see there is really no downside to Firefox.
In fact, even though presumably there are way more engineers working on Chrome than on Firefox, I guess most of Chrome's engineering effort goes towards benefitting advertisers, not users. While Chrome seems entirely stagnant since I adopted it 4 years ago, Firefox gets a steady trickle of improvements and fixes.
So a huge +1 to the last point. Firefox rules.
Caveats: Sometimes launching apps from the browser only works in Chrome and some demos of bleeding edge experimental Chrome features obviously don't work in Firefox.
Mailgun is one of the worst offenders. when I mentioned to their support that auth among other things was broken in Firefox, their response was "use chrome"
Profiles suck. Performance (specifically around video) has been ass for years. Many useful Chrome extensions don't have FF versions. Just off the top of my head.
She is in grad school, and the online learning platform requires 3rd party cookies to work. With containers, this means enabling 3rd party cookies every where, which isn't good.
I set her up a separate school profile that has a different theme. Only that profile has 3rd party cookies enabled, and she knows to only do school stuff in that profile. It is clunky to say the least, even with the profile extension.
I'd really like to see better support for profile management!
I can also make the opposite argument for extensions. One of my most-used extensions, tree-style-tabs, has no Chrome alternative.
Extensions are complicated because they’re also one of the top sources of compatibility and performance problems. Every time in the last decade or so that I’ve known someone to complain that their browser was broken or slow / using too much memory, uninstalling extensions fixed it. It annoys me because I like the concept but I’m not sure it’s really something developers can be trusted with.
The Dutch national TV (NPO) videos do not play on Firefox for Android [1]. They do play on Chrome for Android and they do play on the Linux desktop firefox. Not sure if its some hidden setting that I need to find or something for the firefox team to look into.
Everybody and their dog want you to download "apps" - I wonder why?
Firefox on android is one of the few defence mechanisms we have.
[1] https://www.npostart.nl/nos-journaal/11-09-2023/POW_05465115
Because apps can collect more data... many apps are just spyware with some function on the top of it ;-)
I had this problem with the British Film Institute's streaming service. I emailed them about it, they replied "please try with Chrome on Windows PC" and I replied "no thanks, please send a refund, I will pirate the film instead".
The other case where I ran into videos not playing was Twitter dot com. I tend not to click links into that site any more though.
Even after installing Firefox you can’t get rid of the Google Chrome web search bar on the home screen, and in-app web views are Chrome, so you’re never really free from Chrome.
I do understand the why of ads, and I’m okay with _some_ ads. On 99% of websites from a Google search you get a sticky top and/or bottom bar, and interstitial ads between paragraphs and they’re a little annoying but not so bad. But then on about 30% of search results one of those sticky ads is an autoplaying video, which means I can’t actually read the content (since 1/3 of my screen is video) and the “X” icon is 0.5mm wide so I can’t close it without clicking the video. Then there’s the email subscribe pop up on scroll, and after 15 seconds you get prompted to allow notifications for this website.
Using the web without an ad blocker feels like you’re being attacked, it’s aggressive and stressful.
I had hoped the ubiquity of ad blocking would result in advertisers going “hmmm, maybe we can drive fewer people to install these things by acting better”, but instead it’s been a race to who can exploit the smaller pool of users for clicks.
I don't think I've ever had the search bar on the home screen for more than a couple minutes after getting a new phone.
My in-app web views are also in Firefox. I'm pretty sure just changing the default browser changes this, though there may be a second setting I'm forgetting about.
This is actually my main sticking point on refusing to try iOs. You can't even install Firefox on an iPhone, their "Firefox" is just a wrapper around Safari.
For the most part, my webviews are in FF (selected as my default browser), but it depends on what app launches the webview. Sometimes it defaults to Chrome.
Also wrong about the launcher, I’m relatively new to Android and hadn’t seen any settings for it.
The in-app views can be Firefox by just setting it as the default browser. Lest we forget, at least Android has an actual Firefox implementation, versus iOS which does not. Not sure what you're talking about, but if you bumped into certain cases where a Chromium web view would be better for compatibility, you can use a Chromium-based fork, like Bromite, Vivaldi, or Brave, all of which can fit the bill.
The only edge that Chrome has is the deeper integration on the "Install app" menu option for websites that integrate with SSB/PWA. Otherwise you can safely uninstall or disable Chrome completely (which I do).
I have a Samsung S21 Ultra, with 512 GB of storage. I can download torrents straight to my phone via LibreTorrent. The other day I downloaded 3 seasons of Star Trek Picard and started playing them on my TV. But first, I used Firefox with uBlock Origin installed to navigate a Pirate Bay mirror. The entire scenario is only possible on Android.
On my Pixel, I use FF mainly, but also have DDG and Chrome (for Google-specific sites only).
I haven't played with the default launcher, but you can absolutely get rid of it with other launchers (as many sibling comments noted).
As for the chrome//android web view, you can disable the chrome app and 99% of apps that use android web view have an escape hatch option to just open it in your default browser, so that's also a non issue.
I am so ingrained in iOS it’s hard to leave but I really did like the pixel phones and have thought about getting one.
Meanwhile, on pretty much the only competition, you can't even install a different browser, they're all just reskins of Safari. You'd be better off recommending Android...
I have been corrected on removing the launcher and how web views work in this thread.
FTFY
I'm trying to think, are there any downsides to this other than "you won't get custom ads catered to you"?
Like Google can see you requested this off and most of us are logged into a Google user account attached to Chrome. I wonder if they can "behind the scenes" label users who don't let them serve them as customized ads in a "less good" bucket? Too much of a stretch/conspiracy theory? Deny us features? Just spitballing...
I'll check back in a few weeks time to check whether Google has sneakily enabled them without my intervention...
Apple is the only tech company I know that's primarily funded by customers paying for a product directly. That's why I use Safari.
But, IIRC Google pays Apple >30x what it pays Mozilla for keeping their search engine as a default.
https://9to5mac.com/2021/08/25/analysts-google-to-pay-apple-...
That Apple has alternative sources of revenue are irrelevant for Safari's present and future. Just to give an example — both Firefox and Safari block third-party cookies, which has an impact on Google's tracking, but have you noticed that neither of them block ads by default? They couldn't even if they wanted to, given it has a direct impact on their cash cow. And Safari's ad-blocking capabilities is what inspired Chrome's limitations from Manifest v3, the latter being more capable, actually.
The more important question is: What happens to Safari if Google's payouts to Apple stop? And there's no good answer.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37427227
Top comment on that one was:
Key actionable info: to fix this, go to this URL:
and turn off the toggles on each of the three subpages.Alternatively, go to this URL https://www.mozilla.org/firefox/ to fix this permanently.