Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by malloryerik on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:40PM
(#37462601)
This is just ageism. According to this logic, why not put an upper limit on the voting age? Say, 77? There are great advantages to age, and people age differently.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by pfranz on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:14AM
(#37463153)
How is a minimum age not ageism?
> There are great advantages to age, and people age differently.
The problem is the health of elected officials can't be trusted--their medical staff explicitly mislead or omit issues. "A pharmacist says he has filled Alzheimer's prescriptions for members of Congress" A single news article from a handful of years ago (and a huge ethical breach) is often brought up because there's a problem. That's the only reason anyone is interested in finding another proxy.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by webnrrd2k on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:45AM
(#37463338)
It's a tough problem, because doctors are supposed to be strictly concerned with their patient's health. So someone would have to set up and administer some sort of medical police force.
I read today that John F. Kennedy was riddled with health problems. He was young, and was considered a good president. How would this new medical enforcement work in His case?
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by malloryerik on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:46AM
(#37463755)
> How is a minimum age not ageism?
Well you can't very well have four-year-olds voting, correct? It's unfortunate because they have a stake in election outcomes, but they can't understand that stake. I wish they could vote but indeed they don't even understand what an election is. Instead eighteen is the age that's been chosen for voting, so that one might have time to develop enough of an understanding of the world, the country, the issues, and oneself to make a responsible decision. Is that the right age? One might even have a smidge of wisdom by eighteen. How about sixteen? Then for office, the Constitution has minimum ages, yes. I'd rather see those removed than an upper limit installed. Especially in this time when people are living longer and longevity science is making great early strides.
My grandmother lived to be 104. She was extremely sharp until about 100. She had a great length of experience upon which to draw, and she did. She'd had time to witness the arc of history, to confront her own mistakes and prejudices and to view questions from several perspectives. She'd developed wisdom.
Now, if we're to talk about the health of elected officials, it's obviously true the the old are more prone to issues. Until the fountain of youth is invented we all die. But it's not because "medical staff mislead or omit issues" that it's kosher to start stripping people of their rights. Enforcing transparency around relevant health issues would be the way, rather than using hearsay ("A pharmacist says he has filled Alzheimer's prescriptions for members of Congress") to discriminate against entire groups of people.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by sneak on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:14PM
(#37462453)
It would require a constitutional amendment, obviously. Given that it would be voted on by a bunch of people who it would un-employ, as well as another huge cohort it would render ineligible in the near future, I can't imagine legislatures going for this, same as I can't imagine ranked choice voting getting traction. Why would lawmakers, en masse, vote against their own personal career interests?
A few, sure, but amending the constitution requires widespread agreement.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by yowzadave on Monday September 11, 2023 @10:29AM
(#37467816)
Right, intra-party politics seems to put way too much value in party loyalty--running against an incumbent is a way to get yourself blacklisted by the party, which leads to an unhealthy pattern of unthinking support for declining leaders. It seems like Democrats are making this mistake in 2024 by not running a candidate to replace the obviously declining Joe Biden; it could well lead to a catastrophic re-election of Donald Trump.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by maxbond on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:53PM
(#37462673)
There shouldn't be an age limit, there should be a term limit. The problem isn't really that people are old, that's just a symptom. The problem is that it's the same people in government, decade after decade.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by com2kid on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:36AM
(#37462934)
Term limits have been discussed again and again. They are a terrible idea because it results in special interests basically running the entire show. Politicians don't have time to learn how to write laws, so they instead are stuck rubber stamping whatever comes across their desks, even more so than they already do today.
Also building alliances takes time, it used to be that politicians in DC were all friends with each other, which means they could go to the bar after work and figure things out together over some drinks. Now days any politician seen talking to someone of the "opposing" party is deemed a traitor and vilified by the 24hr news media.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by D13Fd on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:01AM
(#37463068)
I still think that killing earmarks is what killed bipartisanship. There is just nothing that each side can give the other without earmarks, so there is no way to negotiate. Instead, it’s just full-on war 100% of the time.
They were a tiny percentage of the budget, and it was a small price to pay for functioning government.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by WeylandYutani on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:52AM
(#37463371)
It's inevitable with a two party system. If the US had 20 parties there would be a political tradition to form coalitions. Liberals forming a government with far right Christians- the best medicine for ideology is Machiavellian pragmatism.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by trilbyglens on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:12AM
(#37463141)
So you think special interests don't run the show right now?? Do we live in the same universe? Because the us government is almost exclusively run by special interests.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by com2kid on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:23PM
(#37469587)
> So you think special interests don't run the show right now?? Do we live in the same universe? Because the us government is almost exclusively run by special interests.
And term limits will make it worse.
This isn't some theoretical, research has been done on states that have implemented term limits, everything got worse.
OK imagine senators have a 2 term max, 12 years. They are now 100% incentivized to plan for their next job and not actually care about being a senator. We already see this with roles that are appointed by the administration, FCC commissioners are famous for this. Go from industry -> government -> higher paid industry role, utilizing the connections one gained while in government.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by rickydroll on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:36AM
(#37462936)
term limits remove institutional knowledge from government and place it into the hands of lobbyists and consultants. imagine what your workplace would be like if after holding a job 4-5 years, employees were dismissed. sounds like a recipe for chaos and failure.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by hellotheretoday on Monday September 11, 2023 @01:34AM
(#37463277)
There should be a competency test. A hard age limit is dumb; there are fully competent people in their 90s. But at the same time what’s happenening with Mitch McConnells recent issues. If he worked for apple or something they’d either hide him from public appearances or force him out of the company into retirement. And while there’s still technically some debate there (I guess) then you have a case like Diane feinstein, who is obviously completely incompetent even to the layman. Imo in any other situation that would be a reportable case of elder abuse but apparently if they’re a politician with a huge net worth that’s no longer the case
Politics is about representation and the elderly deserve representation too but they deserve competent representation. And we deserve proportional representation. But that brings up the issue that the political system is arguably rotten to its core and set up in such a way that it’s almost impossible to do such a thing. For proportional representation to be realistic we really need reforms to so many things, lobbying, gerrymandering, voting access, campaign finance, media regulation, etc. and the people who would need to reform this are the current representatives whose power would be potentially be threatened by the reforms that would be enacted.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by umeshunni on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:07PM
(#37462411)
I wonder how much of this is the gerontocracy refusing to let go of their power vs a newer generation of politicians failing to attract enough 'middle of the road' voters towards their policies and pursuing only extreme ideologies.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by voisin on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:32PM
(#37462555)
It seems like the bar is far higher for younger politicians to unseat an elderly incumbent and I think this has to do with the ease of raising money if you’ve already raised money and being a known quantity for donors.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by poulsbohemian on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:13PM
(#37462440)
I'd never really thought about this before, so my thinking might not be fully fleshed out here, but... the Baby Boomers are a numerically large generation. The Millenials are a large generation. Gen X is a small generation. In political circles, there is a thought that we may never see a Gen X President and will skip straight to the Millenials. Makes me wonder if part of why the Baby Boomers have been able to hang on so long really is a result of the smaller population of Gen X.
I think too that money can't be overlooked. Lots of wealth still concentrated in the Baby Boomers, and it takes a lot of money to win in politics, which Gen X and Millenials may not have (statistically speaking).
* you might think I'm a bit off here, but when I attend Democratic Party events, there are lots of Baby Boomers and some under-40s, but I'm one of the only Gen X in the room. In leadership it's similar.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by the_snooze on Sunday September 10, 2023 @11:32PM
(#37462552)
Vote in primaries, folks! Given gerrymandering and self-segregation, most seats are uncompetitive. That means the general election is quite meaningless. But the power remains in the nominating contests, which are thinly-attended, with seniors and extremists overrepresented in those electorates.
You want to get rid of a politician? Do it in a primary election.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by deprecative on Monday September 11, 2023 @05:21AM
(#37464741)
And in some states (Florida) felons had their ability to vote restored but the legislature made it so that you have to pay your fees, fines, etc., before your sentence is considered served. They don't have a central place by which to check if you are paid up. The result? New crimes and bye bye voting.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by naruhodo on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:28PM
(#37476706)
Well, no. The flaw in my comment. But my main intent was to speak to the broken nature of American "democracy", as it is called.
In Australia, we don't elect a president, so we don't have primaries. The head of state - the Governor General - is almost never involved in the process. Instead, the leader of the party that has a parliamentary majority (and therefore forms government) becomes the Prime Minister. And the party leader is selected in whatever arcane manner the party desires. People vote for party representatives or independents at the level of their local electorate. The prime minister (Australia) doesn't get to override the parliament by decree. And since the house of representatives and senate are functional, decrees are unnecessary.
What we don't have is:
* Gerrymandering. Electoral boundaries are drawn fairly by the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC).
* Rules that take away people's right to vote. Our voter participation rates are about 90%[1] in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. If you don't have an opinion, you show up at the polling booths, get your name ticked off, draw a nice big cock on the ballot papers and drop them in the box, or just walk out.
* Endless filibustering. We do have Double Dissolution[2] (the nuclear option) where both the House and the Senate are dissolved (if only there was a big vat of acid!) and everyone goes back to the polls. It's very rarely used, but occasionally threatened.
* First-past-the-post voting: we use a ranked-choice system called preferential voting, where if your first choice doesn't get a majority, your vote transfers to your second choice etc.[3] That means we do not have a two party system and you can not waste your vote by voting for someone other than the big two.
* Other American shitfuckery that I can't think of right now. But we do have some American-style donation shitfuckery that I wish we could fix. Money has disproportionate say in our political system, though it is far less broken than American politics.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by radar1310 on Monday September 11, 2023 @12:11AM
(#37462777)
We need leaders with a vision of the future and with bright minds and ideas. Not someone that forgets where they are, and what they were saying. Yes we definitely need age limits. 65 should be the limit.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by YeBanKo on Monday September 11, 2023 @02:13AM
(#37463519)
And with pilots, age comes with experiences. Every year of flying, on one hand brings closer to mental and physical decline, on another hand gains valuable flying hours. Sully Sullenberger landed the plane on the Hudson river when he was 58, 7 years from upper age limit. By that time he had flown all kinds of planes in all kinds of condition. With politicians, I view experience as net negative, like how long the fish has been rotting.
Re:The old have come to dominate American politics
by paulddraper on Monday September 11, 2023 @11:59AM
(#37469225)
The min age for president is double the min age to vote.
And the exclusion of minors from voting is made acceptable by existence of parents/guardians morally and legally responsible for their interests. Seniors often don't have the same.
If under 35 is too young to be President, then there should be some age that is too old.
> There are great advantages to age, and people age differently.
The problem is the health of elected officials can't be trusted--their medical staff explicitly mislead or omit issues. "A pharmacist says he has filled Alzheimer's prescriptions for members of Congress" A single news article from a handful of years ago (and a huge ethical breach) is often brought up because there's a problem. That's the only reason anyone is interested in finding another proxy.
I read today that John F. Kennedy was riddled with health problems. He was young, and was considered a good president. How would this new medical enforcement work in His case?
https://www.google.com/m?q=john+f+kennedy+health&client=ms-o...
Well you can't very well have four-year-olds voting, correct? It's unfortunate because they have a stake in election outcomes, but they can't understand that stake. I wish they could vote but indeed they don't even understand what an election is. Instead eighteen is the age that's been chosen for voting, so that one might have time to develop enough of an understanding of the world, the country, the issues, and oneself to make a responsible decision. Is that the right age? One might even have a smidge of wisdom by eighteen. How about sixteen? Then for office, the Constitution has minimum ages, yes. I'd rather see those removed than an upper limit installed. Especially in this time when people are living longer and longevity science is making great early strides.
My grandmother lived to be 104. She was extremely sharp until about 100. She had a great length of experience upon which to draw, and she did. She'd had time to witness the arc of history, to confront her own mistakes and prejudices and to view questions from several perspectives. She'd developed wisdom.
Now, if we're to talk about the health of elected officials, it's obviously true the the old are more prone to issues. Until the fountain of youth is invented we all die. But it's not because "medical staff mislead or omit issues" that it's kosher to start stripping people of their rights. Enforcing transparency around relevant health issues would be the way, rather than using hearsay ("A pharmacist says he has filled Alzheimer's prescriptions for members of Congress") to discriminate against entire groups of people.
A few, sure, but amending the constitution requires widespread agreement.
Stop voting for them and they will stop running.
Also building alliances takes time, it used to be that politicians in DC were all friends with each other, which means they could go to the bar after work and figure things out together over some drinks. Now days any politician seen talking to someone of the "opposing" party is deemed a traitor and vilified by the 24hr news media.
They were a tiny percentage of the budget, and it was a small price to pay for functioning government.
And term limits will make it worse.
This isn't some theoretical, research has been done on states that have implemented term limits, everything got worse.
OK imagine senators have a 2 term max, 12 years. They are now 100% incentivized to plan for their next job and not actually care about being a senator. We already see this with roles that are appointed by the administration, FCC commissioners are famous for this. Go from industry -> government -> higher paid industry role, utilizing the connections one gained while in government.
Hah, I wish we could hold on to engineers for 4-5 years…
Politics is about representation and the elderly deserve representation too but they deserve competent representation. And we deserve proportional representation. But that brings up the issue that the political system is arguably rotten to its core and set up in such a way that it’s almost impossible to do such a thing. For proportional representation to be realistic we really need reforms to so many things, lobbying, gerrymandering, voting access, campaign finance, media regulation, etc. and the people who would need to reform this are the current representatives whose power would be potentially be threatened by the reforms that would be enacted.
Kind of a bummer, really
I think too that money can't be overlooked. Lots of wealth still concentrated in the Baby Boomers, and it takes a lot of money to win in politics, which Gen X and Millenials may not have (statistically speaking).
* you might think I'm a bit off here, but when I attend Democratic Party events, there are lots of Baby Boomers and some under-40s, but I'm one of the only Gen X in the room. In leadership it's similar.
You want to get rid of a politician? Do it in a primary election.
Other countries have phones and all the other excuses. We just don't have a system that's deliberately designed to suppress voting.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disfranchisement#Based_on_crim...
In Australia, we don't elect a president, so we don't have primaries. The head of state - the Governor General - is almost never involved in the process. Instead, the leader of the party that has a parliamentary majority (and therefore forms government) becomes the Prime Minister. And the party leader is selected in whatever arcane manner the party desires. People vote for party representatives or independents at the level of their local electorate. The prime minister (Australia) doesn't get to override the parliament by decree. And since the house of representatives and senate are functional, decrees are unnecessary.
What we don't have is:
* Gerrymandering. Electoral boundaries are drawn fairly by the Australian Electoral Commission (AEC).
* Rules that take away people's right to vote. Our voter participation rates are about 90%[1] in both the House of Representatives and the Senate. If you don't have an opinion, you show up at the polling booths, get your name ticked off, draw a nice big cock on the ballot papers and drop them in the box, or just walk out.
* Endless filibustering. We do have Double Dissolution[2] (the nuclear option) where both the House and the Senate are dissolved (if only there was a big vat of acid!) and everyone goes back to the polls. It's very rarely used, but occasionally threatened.
* First-past-the-post voting: we use a ranked-choice system called preferential voting, where if your first choice doesn't get a majority, your vote transfers to your second choice etc.[3] That means we do not have a two party system and you can not waste your vote by voting for someone other than the big two.
* Other American shitfuckery that I can't think of right now. But we do have some American-style donation shitfuckery that I wish we could fix. Money has disproportionate say in our political system, though it is far less broken than American politics.
[1] https://www.aec.gov.au/Elections/federal_elections/voter-tur...
[2] https://peo.gov.au/understand-our-parliament/having-your-say...
[3] https://www.chickennation.com/voting/
Which is exactly why we end up with senior and/or extremist candidates.
This isn't rocket science, people.
Apparently, it's not safe to have anyone above a certain age fly a plane, even with copilot and multiple redundant backup systems.
The solution is to have an upper limit for candidate age, lets say 60, and an upper limit to voting age, lets say 65.
There is already a lower limit for voting, we should have and lower limit for candidate age as well, lets say 30.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capital_in_the_Twenty-First_Ce...
And the exclusion of minors from voting is made acceptable by existence of parents/guardians morally and legally responsible for their interests. Seniors often don't have the same.