How are you quantifying this? If this is true, how is it not reflected in some manner in prices? In other words, who are are the buyers propping up prices?
I'm not trolling, because if what you're saying is true it suggests that there is something fundamentally fraudulent about the Canadian housing market.
[0] - https://www.reca.ca/consumers/financial-considerations/money...
https://news.westernu.ca/2023/01/expert-insight-canadas-ban-....
Data that tracks foreign buyers and owners in Canada are scarce and patchy. The Canadian Housing Statistics Program shows that non-residents only own about two to six per cent of Canadian residential properties in 2020.
Edit: Those numbers are in line with the US. Why is the US real estate market not that crazy then?
Real estate is, at worst, used for sanction evasion and money laundering, and at best, as a loophole for citizens of restrictive countries to extract more of their money from those countries.
All of these create an incentive to overbid on real estate.
Where I live, this is a known issue. In fact, the top real estate companies specifically try to attract foreign investors, and have stated so publicly.
Look at the chart in the article. Home prices plummeted in 2022, when the Canadian government enacted a 1% Underused Housing Tax (UHT) on Canadian residential property that is considered vacant or underused.
[0] https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IF11967.pdf
[1] https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-impact-of-treasurys-p...
[2] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-set-unveil-long-awaited-...
[3] https://gfintegrity.org/press-release/new-report-finds-u-s-r...
[4] https://www.faegredrinker.com/en/insights/publications/2023/...
[5] https://lewisbrisbois.com/newsroom/legal-alerts/foreign-inve...
Then why is the Canadian real estate market so much f'ed up than the US market?
Also any data on "the demand is focused more intensely"?
Even in the US, the population and desirable RE for investment is focused in a few cities on the coasts.
True cause is Canada is facing a supply gap but politicians find it easy to blame foreigners.
https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/canadas-housing-supply-gap-tr...
Of course, China shows that you don't need outsider investing to create a ridiculous property affordability situation.
Because there was no data tracked before 2015, whether or not there was indeed a significant amount of foreign buying remains speculation and theory but there are some signs that support the notion that it was important.
For example major luxury condo builder Westbank has significantly reduced their operations in Vancouver, pivoting away from super luxury homes explicitly marketed as pied-a-terres and in the pages of Monocle magazine and are now building increasingly in the USA and even Japan. Some of their projects in Vancouver changed from being condos to rental. That this all happened post foreign buyer tax suggests that foreign buyers were a critical part of their business plan and they needed to remarkably change it after foreign buyers went away.
Essentially 92% of Canadians can't afford the average home based on the average income.
I think if you do "top" of the last month it'll be near the top.
Yes, I rent for $4250 a home that you can buy for $1.7M. The distortion here is beyond ridiculous. The equivalent mortgage would be something like $7K before property taxes and maintenance.
Because you can’t imagine government moving fast enough to change policy, the only way out is likely a sudden and shocking collapse in home values caused by the bond market failing to continue its belief that Canada is sound.
We haven’t even seen the full brunt of this—every time one of these properties changes hands at this point as the current owner cashes out, we’re going to see one more of these “affordable” rentals off the market in one way or another. (Either they hike the rent to the point of unaffordability, occupy it themselves, or leave it sit empty to just store or accumulate value.)
And just to put it in some perspective—to afford that shitty run down house I was renting, you’d need to be making somewhere around $720k/yr pre-tax to pay the mortgage and maintain the “1/3 toward housing” ratio. People in Canada do not make $720k/yr.
The scale of the problem is dramatically different. In the US, like much of the world, there are the expensive areas and then the less expensive areas, and people migrate accordingly. Gentrification happens and people have to move further afield, etc. I see listings for extraordinary homes in various towns in the US for prices that are absolutely dreamy (not like ghettos, but nice little towns). In a remote world, the US has astonishingly attainable options throughout the union.
In Canada, far-flung garbage towns have million dollar bungalows and $3000 rents. There are no inexpensive options anywhere, no matter how far out you're willing to move just to have a place to live. The country literally has politicians telling people to loan a bedroom. Yet in the face of actually falling home building and recurring disasters, the governing party has doubled down on an immigration rate that exceeds every other developed country (and I'm not talking about per capita, I'm talking about in absolute numbers!). It's unbelievable.
I'm not convinced the "affordable housing" people imagine is available if you go far enough out in the US is as available as is popularly presumed.
Obviously this doesn't mean everyone in all situations can find a home, but the scale of the problem is just dramatically different.
No, I'm not looking at teardowns. Many of these are absolutely gorgeous, extremely well-appointed homes. This is more than just touristy noise at this point: I am seriously considering relocating to the US because of what is happening in Canada, and have looked in depth at available homes across the nation.
I wish you luck in finding your bliss, but this seems like an unconstructive discussion.
PS: What's on the internet is not necessarily a comprehensive and accurate picture of reality on the ground.
The western US is a lot more expensive than the rest of the US.
https://cdn.nar.realtor//sites/default/files/documents/ehs-0...
Thank you for coming to my TED talk on location-based compensation is wage theft.
Call it volatility, and it is not easily calculable as a number. I can get a job move to cheap Topeka, KS, but how much does the volatility cost me if I lose that job or I get laid off, etc.
How? How can rural people afford it? Are you talking about rural places that are tourist locations? Do you have any data on this? It seems wrong to me.
Isn't Canada's housing problem caused by a supply crunch? Other than the Canadian government going into the real estate business and start building medium and high-density appartment blocks, what role does the Canadian government have in this mess?
Also, please note that this issue is plaguing basically the whole European housing market as well.
During the pandemic period, low interest rates caused home owners with plenty of house equity to go on a virtual binge of home buying. I know of people who bought four extra houses in 2021 just because they could. The bank gave them free money. Why not?
Is it, though? I mean, that would drive up demand, but what happened to supply? If your hypothesis had any basis, wouldn't real estate developers rush to profit from that demand by building more homes? They wouldn't turn down all that free money, would they?
And more to the point, why is that a government problem?
Insufficient labour. Anyone who builds houses was booked up for years. It looks like this is finally starting to turn, but that doesn't help right now. You need to build houses in the past to be able to live in them now.
With the strongest labour market possibly ever seen in Canada, you didn't find anyone going to build houses because they had no other work. So you throw more money at workers to try to compel them away from the work they were doing and into housing work, but that just... drives up the cost of housing.
I'm not sure that explanation is plausible.
Canada's housing stats show a drop in total investments in building construction, and a drop in housing starts.
https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/230818/dq230...
https://www.cmhc-schl.gc.ca/professionals/housing-markets-da...
If supply was catching up with demand to ride that gravy train, we would see in the very least an increase in investments. Why would anyone refuse to invest in a venture that's handing out free money?
Also, labour costs don't account for more than 30% of the build cost, which is far below the current real estate prices. Even if they doubled salaries of construction workers, selling apartments in today's market would still be very profitable.
Hence why the labour issues have started to turn...
> If supply was catching up with demand
Demand has backed away because nobody wants to take the risk on housing right now. High interest rates and a lot of increased pressure for governments to do something means that a coming crash is highly likely and nobody wants to be the bag holder.
Same reason rents have skyrocketed. If you can rent, why on earth would you buy a house right now? Indeed, housing tends to be highly sticky, but it's almost certain they will cost a whole lot less in a year or two.
It’s as if Canada is a country that pulls resources out of the ground, takes cash from foreigners, lends it out to boomers, and then buys houses. That’s all there is in the country now.
All that ended in 1993 with the Jean Chretien austerity budgets. Feds stopped participating in social housing, incentives ended, transfers to Provinces were scaled back, and Provinces responded by pulling back themselves.
Accordingly basically nil non-market housing was built for decades.
Market housing financing became harder and creation slowed and shifted toward a sort of condo product marketed toward the relatively wealthy. Creation of purpose built rental pretty much ended.
So at this point it's pretty clear that huge tax expenditure and investment from the Feds and Provinces in helping finance new housing creation both market and not market is required.
There's also policy work to be done here to try to stream line municipal rules to hopefully make it easier such that less government aid is required.
But yea just by looking at what we were doing in the 60s/70s and now there's a massive difference that suggests at what the solutions could be.
What would you all pay for such a thing? I'm ashamed of how little it actually costs, you can't even rent a car park in my old city for the same amount.
If this really is hacker news then you can either find somewhere good to live with a bit of searching or you aren't particularity good at hacking the basics of life.
All that matters is that I'm happy as a migrant from the west, I go home to visit family/friends regularly and who are always stressed with long commutes and up to their necks in debt in cities that are overflowing with population growth. I truly worry for my nephews and nieces there, we've created a rough world for the kids. There's plenty of good things from my home country that I appreciate but for the average person life isn't that great considering their net worth on global scale.
When suicide rates are on par with Japan it's somewhat comical to see the city I grew up in on the "top ten greatest places to live" stats that come out every year.
If you took the median house price from where I'm from and put it into a basic savings account you could have $60k USD annually. That goes a very long way across most of the planet, is the house actually worth that much or is it a mass delusion? Know plenty who have gotten out while the going is good.
Median income after taxes: $68,400 [1] Median rent (2 bedroom): $2,300 [2] Average tax rate (single worker): ~32% [3]
If we apply the 30% rule (it's ok to spend up to 30% of pre-tax earnings spend on rent), your assertion doesn't hold up - well over 50% of Canadians are making plenty of money to afford rent. Of course, in expensive cities where rents have far outpaced wages things are going to be bad but that's true pretty much everywhere in the West these days. If anyone has better numbers, please share.
[1] https://www.policyadvisor.com/magazine/what-is-the-average-i...
[2] https://www.zumper.com/blog/rental-price-data-canada/
[3] https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/taxing-wages-canada.pdf
-Very few Canadians can currently qualify for a mortgage for an average home in most markets. The housing market has lost all rational basis.
-Canada has approximately 2 million apartment units across all of Canada. The vacancy rate is currently at less than 1% across Canada, and in many areas is hovering around zero.
-Landlords of apartments that do come to market have become spectacularly picky, because they can be. Perfect credit. Perfect history. No debts. People have been in situations where they've offered tens of thousands in deposits and a seemingly perfect application, to be denied.
It is fascinating how often data is shown that betrays that Canada is in a particularly terrible situation -- like this very submission -- yet people still retort with "oh well it's bad everywhere". No, it is nothing like Canada.
Canada is a fully saturated market like nowhere else on the planet. And this government is squeezing a hundred thousand more a month into an already full container, with zero indication of a letup.
I really don't understand your point here since it truly seems more emotional than data-based. Why are you focused on mortgages / home ownership as opposed to being able to afford to live somewhere? What do vacancy rates have to do with affordability? Why don't you provide a single concrete example of a majority of Canadians being unable to afford rent or being "filtered out" as you originally claimed? All your points here are tangential and don't support the argument.
"Canada is completely messed up" is a common refrain online these days, but I just don't see it either in the data or in talking to friends who live outside the Vancouver/Toronto popular areas.
The median Canadian has a credit rating of 650. The median Canadian cannot remotely afford a home in any Canadian market. Apartments -- the absolute last resort -- have vacancies below 1% in most markets, 1.7% nationwide. Canada is seeing an immigrant intake of approximately 130,000 per month.
If this isn't data to you, you are clearly not arguing in good faith and are either a contrarian, agenda-driver, or a troll. Or a mix of the three. The retort of "I talked to a friend in Canada" is so absurd that it confirms the prior.
Why blame "government" and not capitalism? Canadian Gosplan didn't conspire to set housing prices at insane and rising levels. It was the market mechanism doing its own thing.
Almost all of Canada cannot qualify for a home at current housing prices. Either to buy or to rent. The rental market is currently at the level of parody where the requirements filter out almost everyone. The bottom 50% of Canada, income wise, is in the precarious situation where if anything happens to their current housing, they will be homeless. Slowly social assistance and related programs are going to have to start resetting and the costs are going to be enormous.
https://archive.ph/4xWtC
This is a problem created by multiple governments over various parties, and at this point I don't see an exit that isn't enormously painful.