I agree in general. There is some stuff the federal government can do, which is to return to funding social housing. The Federal government for a long time provided subsidized housing in the post war period up to the 1970s-80s.
> If I had a singular policy suggestion, after having talked to some friends in the industry, it would be to pump federal money into expediting site plan approvals and environmental assessments done at a county or municipal level.
I've seen similar. One of the biggest issues that is almost never talked about is development (land improvement?) taxes occur late in the process. So when it comes to multi-dwelling development, there is substantial risk the developers have to take on and manage, because they could get slapped with losing all their profits in surprise taxes near the end of the project (besides all the risks for building costs in general). I think the stats is in the ballpark of 2/10 building are successes, 6/10 are break even, and 2/10 are are losses. At $100-$400 million a piece for a medium sized tower, imagine taking on that risk profile... I can't. So cities need to understand the risks they're transferring to development, and fund their infrastructure upgrades through good and solid planning upfront.
Another related idea I saw from a youtube video on Vancouver I think it was, was the return to the Vancouver standard house plan. It was one of the post war house plans, and while there were a couple variations and you could make superficial changes, it was extremely cheap to get approvals for because the city was basically approving the same structure every time, and were so used to it the reviews were cheap and easy.
So you're right, just finding the opportunities to optimize that process for both the City and Developer is essential. And also allowing basement apartments and other medium density development. The giant towers are hella expensive if that's the only density getting built.
The issue is at the municipal level (mainly), and the provincial level (less so).
Look at what California has been doing in the last 2 years. You force constraints on zoning regulations down on the lower level entities. You force permitting time limits and acceptance rates. You force a minimum level of multifamily lots per population.
It's really really really not as hard as it's presented. It's just in political gridlock.
The municipalities are creations of the province so personally I would assign them just as much blame. The provinces have the most power to address the issue but seem to be happy to hide behind the Feds and Cities.
[1] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/british-columbia/arti...
Same reason why we have things like the notwithstanding clause that allows provinces to overrule the constitution
So in other words, them not making babies has nothing to do with economics?
There is much we don't know about the long-term impact of some of these types of chemicals people ingest nowadays as part of their diet.
The solution (in my opinion) is simple. Increase taxes on unearned income and balance that with decreased taxes on earned income (i.e. productive activity). Unfortunately this looks like political suicide in a climate where a large portion of the population has gone all in on a strategy of investing in unearned income.
We've embraced the exploitative aspects of capitalism at the expense of the creative aspects and it has made our societies sick and fragile.
It's too bad that's such important discussions happen in private. Between this and the shenanigans with the Ontario Premier and developers, I think it is obvious that most politicians don't actually want to solve the problem.
I'm hoping we get something like a single issue party with a mandate to implement a land value tax.
Federally they can do an immigration moratorium. Immigration-driven population increase is clearly making quality of life worse for Canadians.
As we've seen, the accumulated potential energy in the housing market has now grown to such an extent that we don't know what to do with it. Eventually, the "sandpile effect" is likely to come into play, since the laws of nature always wins.
Have they identified the root causes?
It was completely asinine for Trudeau to refer to potentially restricting the number of foreign students[1] because, while this is a contributing factor, he sidestepped the primary driver which is that the largest reason for Canada's population growth[2] is our immigration targets, whose policy is set primarily by the federal government (although some provinces have overlapping programs for immigrants such as Quebec).
[1] https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-trudeau-hou...
[2] https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/canada-record-population-grow...
Given the amount of time and prep that is put into government communications and policy, if they actually had some concrete policy to announce after the retreat it would have meant that the whole retreat was actually a sham and they had something planned all along.
The government has switched out the housing minister from a dud to a rising star, and had a retreat where they listened to a bunch of experts. These are promising things to notice, but if they are only now changing tack on this issue, it will likely take months from now until we see a coherent policy response.
Truthfully I don't think this is an issue the federal government is in a position to solve any time soon. The long and short is that our population has grown faster than our supply of housing, COVID being an unfortunately timed disruption which further strained that supply. Nothing was built for almost a year, but the population continued to grow.
If I had a singular policy suggestion, after having talked to some friends in the industry, it would be to pump federal money into expediting site plan approvals and environmental assessments done at a county or municipal level. Some of these offices have tiny rosters who end up being the bottlenecks for enormous projects which otherwise would be breaking ground. Environmental assessments are notoriously time-consuming and particular in Canada, something we're largely very proud of. That said, I believe if there were ever a time for Canadians to be okay with cutting corners if it meant getting more of us into homes, I think it would be now. From my understanding, there are many housing projects in Ontario for which construction could begin next week, if not for the Sisyphean approval processes.
Here's an example of a site plan approval process for a town in Ontario[2] - just imagine all the points in which that chain of communication can get gummed up and projects can sit idle. We're used to steps like this taking a couple weeks in tech, but in the land development industry things move s l o w.
Canadians often take pride in our ability to do things the way they're meant to be done and to follow the rules as presented, even when they might not make sense in the moment. I think occasionally our love of process can be our downfall.
[1] https://archive.ph/CZE3y [2] https://www.middlesexcentre.on.ca/sites/default/files/2021-0...