News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:24AM (#37418561)
> Way back in 2009, Chicago’s inspector general confirmed that the city had sold out for far less than the lease’s value. A report by Bloomberg Business said CPM stood to earn about 10 times what it paid over the life of the contract. Any way you slice it financially, Chicago got taken to the cleaners.

That’s approximately a 3% annualized return on investment (1.03^75 ~= 10).

That’s really not bad at all, especially if the vendor has to pay to administer, maintain, and update the meters.

I wonder how the IG got the idea that effectively selling a $10B 75-year taxable bond for $1B (in a year when high-grade muni bonds were yielding over 7%) was remotely a bad deal. Unless I’m missing something, this is a fantastic deal for Chicago and its taxpayers.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by naturalauction on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:42AM (#37418800)
>That’s approximately a 3% annualized return on investment (1.03^75 ~= 10).

That isn’t accurate, the cash flows should according discounted by the period they’re received in (this contract produces some profits in year 1, more in year 2, etc). What you’ve done is treated it as if the 10x payment is received all at once in year 75.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:10AM (#37419151)
Nice catch, it's actually an ~13.5% annualized rate of return when taking into account the cash flows (assuming annual payments distributed evenly across the contract life, I'm sure you could refine it further).

It's still unclear that this is a bad deal financially. What percentage of that return is going to the vendor's costs? What costs would the city incur if they tried to do it themselves? What were the city's other options in raising cash?

If there was a cheaper muni float option on the table and Daley went with this deal instead, then that feels worth investigating to see whose pockets got lined. Otherwise, it's probably not as bad of a deal as the headlines make it seem.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by onlyrealcuzzo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:53AM (#37418943)
Love the idea that people can project how much parking there will be in 75 years. It's possible there won't be cars at all in the areas parking meters currently make most of their money in Chicago.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by cool_dude85 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:56AM (#37418975)
Presumably any explicit policies along these lines would require the "true up" payments described in the article. If you mean a non-mandated move away from cars in that time, the only plausible scenario I'd imagine that happening is one where Chicago has much more serious problems than a bad contract.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by dharmab on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:56AM (#37418979)
There's a clause in the contract about guarantees for lost revenue, so the city may have to pay anyway.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by dfxm12 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:00AM (#37419889)
It's possible, but as others are saying, there are guarantees in the contract. All things being equal, this makes it more likely that Chicago will do what it can to motivate people to park cars next to meters for 75 years to come.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ses1984 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:39AM (#37418762)
If the city of Chicago had just raised prices instead of leasing out the meters and letting someone else raise prices, it would have been a much better deal for the city of Chicago.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by asu_thomas on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:09AM (#37419130)
It would have been a worse deal for the politicians who brokered it.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by HDThoreaun on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:05AM (#37419985)
This would likely be impossible politically though.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ses1984 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @05:25PM (#37425825)
Then the lease should have had language against setting politically impossible prices.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by sharedbeans on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:31AM (#37418660)
Maybe the report already discounted the future cash flows? I agree it would be pretty ridiculous if they didn’t.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @09:37AM (#37418733)
So when the report says “10 times what they paid”, it means “10 times the amount the $1B would be worth in 75 years at the currently-forecasted risk-free rate of return”?

I can’t imagine that’s true, but who knows I guess.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by Retric on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:10AM (#37419142)
10 times the inflation adjusted number seems to be the implication.

However, the company receives money every year not a single lump sum at the end. If I lend you 10$ and you agree to pay me an inflation adjusted 1$/year for 100 years that’s vastly better than getting an inflation adjusted 100$ in 100 years.

In the initial example the first dollar is discounted X%, the second X%^2, the third X%^3… Where getting paid an inflation adjusted 100$ after 100 years is fully discounted X%^100. The first case is equivalent to a bond paying nearly 10% + inflation with annual payments where the second is closer to 4.8% + inflation without annual payouts.

PS: Further it’s ~zero risk as the contract states the city is responsible if revenues fall below projections.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by pc86 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:36AM (#37419519)
It's local news, I'm absolutely positive it's just raw numbers. $1.16 billion paid and ~$11.6 billion in total estimated revenue over 75 years. No reporter is doing discounted future cash flow calculations even if they know how to (they don't).
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ydc123 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:26AM (#37419356)
This is unquestionably not a "fantastic deal for Chicago and its taxpayers". Did you read the article or just do a brain-dead interest calculation?

The deal forces the city to remain car-dependent, which is absolutely not in the best interest of the people. We should be moving away from cars and making things friendlier for pedestrians, cyclists, public transit and ride-sharing, not just for the climate but for the safety and the health of the city overall.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:33AM (#37419472)
Yikes. Honest mistake. Try to be civil on this forum please, this doesn’t add anything to the conversation.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ydc123 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:39AM (#37419562)
Calling this a "fantastic deal" is the opposite of civil. The article literally has "disaster" in the title and goes into excruciating detail about how damaging it has been to the city.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:48AM (#37419703)
I’m sorry you’re so angry about this, but direct personal attacks are in a different category from commentary on an article. It’s generally not considered “uncivil” to question the premise of a headline. Calling another commenter “brain dead”, however, is not acceptable here.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ydc123 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:00AM (#37419893)
You didn't "question the premise", you disregarded the content of the article and why it was written. Doing this opens yourself up to criticism.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by didgeoridoo on Thursday September 07, 2023 @11:12AM (#37420112)
I’m not sure where you’re used to commenting online, but here criticism and personal attacks are different things. As you can see above, naturalauction criticized my comment, identifying a mistake in my approach. You attacked me personally and gave rise to an incredibly boring thread that I hope for everyone else’s sake ends up [dead].

I’m done here.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by PM_me_your_math on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:39AM (#37419554)
Who is deciding what is in the best interest of "the people?"

Motor vehicles are an absolute necessity in the United States, both for economic and personal reasons. If people didn't need cars, they wouldn't buy them. Mass transit will never be able to replace motor vehicles, and trying to shoe-horn an wholly ideologically-driven agenda will blow up in everyone's faces spectacularly.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by ydc123 on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:43AM (#37419612)
I agree with everything above minus the last part. Bikes, walking, and mass transit can (and should) absolutely replace car usage if the infrastructure is there to support it. This has been proven in many European cities, Americans are just stubborn and carpilled.
Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by PM_me_your_math on Thursday September 07, 2023 @12:22PM (#37421355)
So the double amputee with no feet is going to bike to go food shopping?

America isn't Europe. We have spaces between places and are not packed in like sardines.

Re:There is no way out of Chicago’s parking meter disaster by Tactician_mark on Thursday September 07, 2023 @08:30PM (#37427680)
> If people didn't need cars, they wouldn't buy them.

This is a chicken-and-egg problem. US cities have spent billions on highways and parking and rewrote ordinances to require low density, car-dependent development. You could argue all of that is an honest reflection of voter desires (or at least voter desires of 40 years ago, when most of that stuff happened), but many have undoubtedly bought a car because their environment was designed that way.