Fwiw, I agree it’s scummy and the average person is likely to rollover because they think they already agreed to ____.
This specific situation is of course in reference to the U.S so the following pertains https://ironcladapp.com/journal/contracts/terms-and-conditio... and actually I'm not sure if this fulfills the conditions of a contract?
>According to contract law, in order for a contract to be valid, there must be an offer, consideration, and acceptance. Being able to prove your customer accepted your terms (and therefore entered a contract with you) will determine whether or not your Terms and Conditions are enforceable.
In this case someone is accessing their account, not signing up for an account, not purchasing anything - so not sure if there is actually an offer or consideration the way there would be if a user purchased a pair of shoes.
I don't think that argument is going to hold up very well.
This is much more okay than the alternative, in other words.
For example, if I buried a clause stating that you transfer all your assets to me somewhere deep inside my website's Terms of Use, there is no way in hell I will be able to enforce that. It would be considered an "unconscionable contract", and it would be voided.
An on-topic example would be Uber v. Heller, where an arbitration clause in the contract was ruled unconscionable, and as a result the plaintiff was allowed to file a class action lawsuit against Uber.
Similarly, clauses can be deemed unconscionable because they are an "unfair surprise". An example is Williams v. Walker-Thomas Furniture Co, where the fact that Williams did not understand the contract was considered to be a major factor for the contract being unenforceable.
So yeah, when it comes to a contract between an individual and a large business, "I didn't read it and assumed it to just be the standard legalese stuff" is in fact a valid defense.
Interesting, and not supported by the case law.
In general, many more services ought to be treated as common carrier services than actually are.
How about people realize services cost money and pay their own way?
Yes. I'm happy to do so. Can't the gov even make money through this? Seems like they could buy bonds with that money. But I'm no economist
> How about people realize services cost money and pay their own way?
That's not the calculus. It's part of it but far (FAR) from the whole calculus. There's also the cost of not providing the services. Again, there's more to the calculus, but this other side always needs to be considered and almost never is because we weigh money spent far more then rewards not received. But the ability to do this is exactly what makes us human and distinct from many animals
Keep in mind that banks receive enormous support from the government and society. There’s the FDIC, Fannie Mae, Freddy Mac, the Fed (and its discount window, FedWire, etc), the fact that banks are effectively permitted to create M2 money, and more. And the governments (federal and state) essentially require a bank account to do many useful things, including paying taxes. The government regulates the banks quite firmly in exchange, but the regulation is missing the bits where the banks may not refuse service or abuse their customers.
Both of these we've seen the government hold up frequently in the past. We monopoly bust as well as bust when companies become too big. For some reason people think precise monopolies are different from effective monopolies. Contract law itself doesn't allow you to put illegal things into the contract. Anarchocapitalism doesn't work, despite libertarian beliefs because power is not linearly proportional, natural monopolies exist, and collusion exists. Two-three big companies that control 70% of a market can all gain if they decide to include clauses where they acquire all your assets immediately. Insurance companies can maximize profits by kicking you out as soon as you get sick and requiring that you have to have one. The solution spaces are large and even when competition exists the nash equilibrium isn't always what's best for consumers. Nuance is requires because multiple solutions exist, not just the one we want to exist.
Of the 11 sectors making up the S&P 500, over the last 15 years, finance is one of the least profitable. Banks are not very profitable compared to other sectors of the economy. [1]
The reason is there are ~5000 banks in the US, and a huge number you can choose from. If a few banks were simply charging tons more than it actually costs to run a bank, another of the 5000 would lower costs and attract more customers from the costly banks. The largest bank by deposits, JP Morgan Chase, holds < 8% of deposits held by banks. There is no monopoly, or duopoly, or anything approaching market dominance. [2]
If you're sure they making "an absolute crapload" you should invest in them. But since in reality they are not very good investments, you should rethink your beliefs. Your beliefs simply are not true, as demonstrated by market evidence.
>Keep in mind that banks receive enormous support from the government and society.
Keep in mind that society and government receives enormous support from banking. That's why they have trillions in assets - because they provide value to those using banks. When people, or govt, chooses to use a bank, both sides gain (consumer and producer surplus in economics). So the amount of business some entity obtains is reasonably proportional to the amount of utility they provide to customers. This is simple econ.
>There’s the FDIC
Paid for by banks....
>Fannie Mae, Freddy Mac
Paid for by, you guessed it, banks.... Where do you think the loans the FMs holds originate?
>the Fed (and its discount window, FedWire, etc)
Designed to help banking remain stable from bank runs, from, guess what, panics of people. It's such a good system for stability compared to previous times that the structure has been adopted by all 200+ countries on the planet. Not a single one has decided not to use this structure.
>the fact that banks are effectively permitted to create M2 money
A common misconception - it is not "free" money. It is backed by an exactly equal debt, netting zero in assets for the bank. To cover the risk that the borrower defaults, the bank charges interest. If the bank makes enough bad loans, the bank, not you, lose money.
The alternative is no loans, for college, cars, houses, payroll, etc.
>the governments (federal and state) essentially require a bank
To fund their functioning. How do you think the govt runs a deficit? Banks lend them money. Without the markets made by the banks to provide liquidity to govt, at the municipal, state, and federal level, society would be tremendously worse off.
Go spend time learning how the bond markets work, how treasuries work, detailed differences between the Fed and Treasury, and look at historical events and how they were paid for.
>the regulation is missing the bits where the banks may not refuse service or abuse their customers
Then you have not read any laws, ignore the many agencies that precisely do this, or the long history of punishments.
[1] https://novelinvestor.com/sector-performance/
[2] https://www.statista.com/statistics/727546/market-share-of-l...
It sounds like you want a credit union.
you aren't actually entitled to online banking services from Chase
While this may be true today, it would be better if regulators would make it a rule. It's a great suggestion to send to regulators.If the contract is so long that initialing every clause/paragraph is a burden, maybe that's a sign that it's too damn long.
The system is working as intended.
But, the average person is scared, think it's official and meaningful and feels very impressed by all this complicated-sounding gibberish. That's why they don't pursue litigation, thinking they indeed forfeited the right to.
But in fact any judge would toss that aside and do as if it never existed, because contracts have to be reasonable in the first place, and consent must be established clearly, not "I can't pay my kid's meal if I refused JP Morgan's conditions".
Imagine a tiny line saying "I give all my panties to the CEO upon my death", you think clicking "I agree" on a website will... actually make anyone enforce this ?
There's a weird legal issue that I don't get why it is widely accepted. Why is an average person expected to understand legalize? There is absolutely no reason to believe the average person a) reads that whole thing (clear dark pattern) and b) understands the whole thing. Even intelligent people! Because it is lawyer language written for lawyers. It is like expecting the average person (not on HN) to be able to tell you what metadata is or how machine learning models work (okay maybe HN too ;). How do we not see these as patterns of deciept and taking advantage of people? We live in a highly specialized world and that has been great, but we can't reasonable expect people to comprehend these decisions. It comes down to some combination of trust, naivety, and arm twisting in the end, and this shouldn't be seen as okay.