Please don't equate weather simulations, and excel statistical models, and estimates, to actual science.
Please don't equate your ignorance of a field with knowledge.
Model is probabilistic by nature. Science is deterministic by necessity.
Both can create knowledge for sure.
My only point is this is not science. The article even calls it research, not science. The article doesn't mention the word science, even once.
F = ma is a model.
And you may try to limit your argument to only "statistical models = not science" but then you would be dismissing essentially all social sciences but also ecology, geology, climate science, not to mention every single aspect of statistical mechanics.
Science is essentially hypothesis testing where hypothesis represent models of how the world works. Didn't you even take high school physics where you spend considerable time running experiments and writing up why they don't exactly match the formula's prediction in the book?
Would you mind explaining what model-free science looks like? Is it just cataloging observations?
Anything that can be tested and replicated with all things exactly equal, except that which is the hypothesis being tested.
Most if not all of social science, ecology, geology, climate science may not be possible to do this way, since it often involves humans and/or earth, and its physically impossible to duplicate earth, or a human (with identical thoughts,feelings, or experience)
If you know more than others, that's great—please share some of what you know, so the rest of us can learn: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor.... But please don't post putdowns.
By that logic if I measure the weather outside every day, and say the average weather for the past month outside my house is x, I’ve created a model and therefore not real, lol
Hi Canada!
There’s enough carbon stored in that peat to double or triple the CO2 ppm which would be absolutely catastrophic to the planet.
Some quick googling shows me that all flora on earth hold about 1000 gigatons of carbon, whereas we are releasing about 40 gigatons per year. Doesn’t seem irrelevant.
Also, your take of this to be "sensationalism" is very odd. The danger of imminent tipping points turning "climate change" into "climate catstrophe" is absolutely real.
> The researchers today report their findings in the journal Nature Climate Change. The study united the RAINFOR and PPBio research networks, with dozens of short-term grants enabling more than 100 scientists to measure forests for decades across 123 experimental plots. The plots span Amazon and Atlantic forests as well as drier forests in tropical South America.
> These direct, tree-by-tree records showed that most forests had acted as a carbon sink for most of the last 30 years, with tree growth exceeding mortality. When the 2015–2016 El Niño hit, the sink shut down. This was because tree death increased with the heat and drought.