News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by akira2501 on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:45PM (#37383553)
The actual paper, which is a PHd thesis, is titled "Impact of the 2015-2015 El nino on Tropical Forests." It suggests that it is possible under _sustained_ hot and dry conditions, not single year weather events, for the carbon sink of _some_ forests to become reversed. This hyperbolic article even has to end with the same conclusion, that if we manage to keep the forests standing, the carbon sink will NOT become "switched off."

It's odd to see an institution engage in such absurd sensationalism on one of it's own researchers thesis. The carbon sink doesn't have a "switch" that "El nino" somehow magically presses.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by Loquebantur on Monday September 04, 2023 @02:59PM (#37383730)
You are misrepresenting the science here. This wasn't "just a PhD thesis" in particular.

Also, your take of this to be "sensationalism" is very odd. The danger of imminent tipping points turning "climate change" into "climate catstrophe" is absolutely real.

> The researchers today report their findings in the journal Nature Climate Change. The study united the RAINFOR and PPBio research networks, with dozens of short-term grants enabling more than 100 scientists to measure forests for decades across 123 experimental plots. The plots span Amazon and Atlantic forests as well as drier forests in tropical South America.

> These direct, tree-by-tree records showed that most forests had acted as a carbon sink for most of the last 30 years, with tree growth exceeding mortality. When the 2015–2016 El Niño hit, the sink shut down. This was because tree death increased with the heat and drought.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by IG_Semmelweiss on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:40PM (#37384152)
>>>You are misrepresenting the science here.

Please don't equate weather simulations, and excel statistical models, and estimates, to actual science.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by olddustytrail on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:45PM (#37384205)
These are not statistical models, they're physical models.

Please don't equate your ignorance of a field with knowledge.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by IG_Semmelweiss on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:48PM (#37384235)
model = not science.

Model is probabilistic by nature. Science is deterministic by necessity.

Both can create knowledge for sure.

My only point is this is not science. The article even calls it research, not science. The article doesn't mention the word science, even once.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by PheonixPharts on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:19PM (#37384575)
I think it's far more far to say the opposite: science is an ever evolving model of the world, but science is always just a model.

F = ma is a model.

And you may try to limit your argument to only "statistical models = not science" but then you would be dismissing essentially all social sciences but also ecology, geology, climate science, not to mention every single aspect of statistical mechanics.

Science is essentially hypothesis testing where hypothesis represent models of how the world works. Didn't you even take high school physics where you spend considerable time running experiments and writing up why they don't exactly match the formula's prediction in the book?

Would you mind explaining what model-free science looks like? Is it just cataloging observations?

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by mnky9800n on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:42PM (#37384850)
Dude the ideal gas law is all that matters. After that it's all just malarkey.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by IG_Semmelweiss on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:06PM (#37385070)
>>> Would you mind explaining what model-free science looks like? Is it just cataloging observations?

Anything that can be tested and replicated with all things exactly equal, except that which is the hypothesis being tested.

Most if not all of social science, ecology, geology, climate science may not be possible to do this way, since it often involves humans and/or earth, and its physically impossible to duplicate earth, or a human (with identical thoughts,feelings, or experience)

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by hgomersall on Tuesday September 05, 2023 @02:08AM (#37388393)
A hypothesis? That's just a fancy name for "model".
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by amaranth on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:57PM (#37384335)
I take it you disregard pretty much all of quantum physics then?
[dead]
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by dang on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @03:14AM (#37402160)
Please don't post like this, regardless of how wrong someone is or you feel they are. It's completely against the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

If you know more than others, that's great—please share some of what you know, so the rest of us can learn: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor.... But please don't post putdowns.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by hgomersall on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:04PM (#37385045)
No, science is probabilistic by nature. Science seeks to generate models to explain reality. The process is to test said models against reality (probabilistically).
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by _Algernon_ on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:11PM (#37385112)
Literally everything in science is some form of model. From the simplest linear regression to the most sophisticated climate models.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by breakyerself on Monday September 04, 2023 @09:31PM (#37386885)
Lmao I'd love to see a scientists laugh in your face if you said that to them irl
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by SamoyedFurFluff on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:48PM (#37384236)
Did you read the post you’re replying to, which quotes the article being that it is measuring specific plots of land on specific trees? There’s no estimates or simulations here. The only excel models I bet are just formulae executions.

By that logic if I measure the weather outside every day, and say the average weather for the past month outside my house is x, I’ve created a model and therefore not real, lol

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by wredue on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:25PM (#37383991)
Now wait till the forests burn and instead of being a carbon sink, they become a carbon contributor.

Hi Canada!

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by civilitty on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:34PM (#37384090)
The situation with Canadian forests is much worse. The Amazon accounts for 20% of the global carbon sink but the meters-thick layer of peat below Canadian forests is a third of all carbon stored (along with the peatland in Russia, which is also burning).

There’s enough carbon stored in that peat to double or triple the CO2 ppm which would be absolutely catastrophic to the planet.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by Waterluvian on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:28PM (#37384013)
I think our peatlands are of considerably greater concern.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by raffraffraff on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:36PM (#37384778)
In Ireland we're burning ours, like a bunch of idiots.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:57PM (#37384332)
Those trees are made of carbon that was already in the atmosphere, and they will release it back into it whenever they die in the next couple centuries anyway. Trees are basically irrelevant as carbon capture, unless they're cultivated to maturity and then buried underground.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by developer93 on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:27PM (#37384669)
They tie up carbon for 100+ years, they're hardly irrelevant
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:40PM (#37384833)
They buy a little bit of time. That's it.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by hgomersall on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:59PM (#37385012)
Nonsense, a region that is forested has a proportion of carbon locked up in biomass indefinitely. If that region is deforested and no longer has any carbon locked up in biomass that is unambiguously a net source of carbon.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:02PM (#37385558)
It's not locked up, it's continuously flowing in and out of that ecosystem. It's only locked up when it gets buried and can't return back to the atmosphere (except through technology). There's any number of reasons why a forest could get disrupted and die out besides intentional deforestation.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by developer93 on Saturday September 16, 2023 @04:13PM (#37538265)
Admittedly I haven't checked for sources, but I'm willing to bet that it's mostly man made these days, either direct deforestation or climate change.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by developer93 on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @05:19PM (#37411481)
I hate to break it to you but we need all the time we can get. Also a rotting tree doesn't completely turn into gas, some of the carbon (I think 30%?) goes into the soil.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by mnky9800n on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:39PM (#37384818)
Depends on if you are a climatologist or a geologist.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by dools on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:58PM (#37384992)
If you’re in a sinking boat it is the amount of water inside the boat that you worry about, rather than the amount of water in which the boat is floating.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Monday September 04, 2023 @06:08PM (#37385604)
If you're in a sinking boat you should worry about how fast water is coming in, not about how much water is inside. Would you rather be carrying 10 tons of water without leaking, or 1 ton of water and taking in half a ton per minute?
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by realusername on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:06PM (#37385075)
That's not how it works, the time the carbon got stored has an effet on the climate, the same way that 1 euro tomorrow isn't the same as one euro today.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by seizethecheese on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:10PM (#37385110)
> trees are basically irrelevant as a carbon sink.

Some quick googling shows me that all flora on earth hold about 1000 gigatons of carbon, whereas we are releasing about 40 gigatons per year. Doesn’t seem irrelevant.

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Monday September 04, 2023 @05:57PM (#37385503)
Meaning we would need to plant the entire current flora every 25 years just to break even. Sounds pretty close to irrelevant.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by developer93 on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @05:21PM (#37411501)
In fairly sure flora also plants itself if we leave it alone..
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by fluoridation on Thursday September 07, 2023 @10:26AM (#37419355)
I'm fairly sure the total biomass of flora on Earth is fairly consistent across human time scales. It's not going to double in 25 years and then continue increasing at that same rate.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by developer93 on Saturday September 16, 2023 @04:07PM (#37538209)
Do you have evidence for that? I in turn would assume that there's considerably less flora since the industrial revolution. If you ever kept a garden you know how fast weeds colonise bare soil.
Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by WillPostForFood on Monday September 04, 2023 @04:04PM (#37384412)
However, intact tropical South American forests overall were no more sensitive to the extreme 2015–2016 El Niño than to previous less intense events, remaining a key defence against climate change as long as they are protected.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41558-023-01776-4

Re:Extreme El Niño weather switched off South American's car... by photochemsyn on Monday September 04, 2023 @03:58PM (#37384351)
They're simply reporting that conditions of high temperature and drought reduce photosynthetic fixation rates more than they do total respiration rates (and fire losses). What's significant about the research is that they actually quantify these rates using a network of hundreds of carefully monitored forest plots across the region, it's not based on a computer model.

Overall they report that the tropical forest across this region became carbon-neutral, i.e. no more carbon was taken up than was released. Looks like careful rigorous science to me.