News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by xyst on Saturday August 26, 2023 @06:40PM (#37277550)
The fact that a single car can even cause this much harm is a sign of a much larger problem: car centric transportation is NOT scalable.

They are testing this crap in TX and the roads here are shit, worse after/during rain events. Have seen multiple times where a traffic light goes out or the lines are not legible and the “autonomous” vehicle just sits there with its hazard lights on.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by jbotdev on Saturday August 26, 2023 @07:28PM (#37277871)
To be fair, public transport often has similar issues. If a subway/train car is stuck, nothing else can get by on the same track and thousands of people could be delayed. It happens in NYC all the time. At least with the road system there are typically ways to get around stopped cars.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by soligern on Saturday August 26, 2023 @07:30PM (#37277882)
That’s stupid. You could park a golf cart on the train tracks and it would shut down all train transport for hours. You could cut out a piece of the rail very easily (with an angle grinder) and it would cause dozens of deaths and shut down the line for weeks.

The right course of action is to make messing with automated cars like this a crime just like it is with the railways.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by almost_usual on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:11PM (#37278101)
Cutting a train track with an angle grinder isn’t the same as taking less than five seconds to put a traffic cone on a car.

It takes them 30 minutes in this video.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ISjDp5lL7_Q

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by soligern on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:18PM (#37278144)
You could disable a diverter in 5 seconds with a sledge hammer.

Also your linked video is splitting along the length of the rail instead of cutting directly across it which would take minutes if not seconds.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by almost_usual on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:22PM (#37278168)
> Also your linked video is splitting along the length of the rail instead of cutting directly across it which would take minutes if not seconds.

Watch how long it takes to cut the top of that rail. You must not have ever used an angle grinder before if you think you’re cutting train tracks in seconds.

It took me at least a minute to cut through a single leaf spring for a truck if not longer.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by soligern on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:29PM (#37278212)
What’s your point though? You’re picking an arbitrary cutoff time based on what? The intention is still disruption.

Thirty minutes is nothing. We don’t classify severity of crimes based on how long they take to accomplish. A murder is a murder whether you shot a person once or spent hours carving them up.

I have used an angle grinder and it takes me about 10 seconds to cut through rebar. I would assume a rail is like 25 pieces of rebar put together so my naive assumption would be under five minutes.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by digdugdirk on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:56PM (#37278375)
There's a big difference in both material and size between rebar and rail track, but that's just an aside.

I believe the point being made is the difference in level of intent required and the known (or hoped for) outcome from the action.

Grabbing a traffic cone from a nearby construction zone and chucking it in front of an autonomous car at a traffic light is harmless to the health of everyone involved, but is a pain in the rear for many. Meanwhile, it makes a statement, and some chunk of everyone's annoyance gets directed at the autonomous car company.

On the other hand, cutting a section of railroad takes concerted effort and a lot of premeditation if the individual hopes to get away with it. More importantly - the person cutting the track hopes/expects to cause death and destruction.

The two actions are wildly different, and should be treated as such.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by slashdev on Saturday August 26, 2023 @09:41PM (#37278637)
It’s not necessarily harmless. If that traffic jam blocks an emergency vehicle, people can die.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by danielheath on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:43AM (#37279484)
There’s been many cases of autonomous cars interfering in active firefighting (rolling slowly between equipment, stopping on hoses, etc).
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by nomel on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:18AM (#37279628)
Let’s get that taken care of, and not intentionally make things worse.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by danielheath on Sunday August 27, 2023 @05:36AM (#37280970)
Some would view disabling the cars which are interfering with emergency services as “get that taken care of”, and attempts to roll out additional cars without fixing the bug as “intentionally make things worse”.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by nomel on Sunday August 27, 2023 @10:35AM (#37283131)
That’s completely fair. Let’s work on that, with the required many times increase in efficiency for public transportation to work in cities made for cars, instead of blocking traffic. One approach for the increase in efficiency is automation. I would like to know what their approach is. As this, and interviews have shown, they have no approach or real goal.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by saulpw on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:35PM (#37286399)
Protest is a political tool. If blocking traffic raises awareness (as it has done here) then I think that counts as working on it. We're not going to get cars off the road by writing letters to our senator or donating a few hundred dollars to a political campaign (we've been trying for decades). Maybe aggravating the general public into realizing the fragility and selfishness of the tech industry's "solution" will get people to reevaluate funding for public transportation. I doubt it, because I've become deeply cynical about human nature, but I also see that the roots of progress often comes from surprising places. Like refusing to ride at the back of the bus. Or dumping tea into a harbor. Or putting a traffic cone on a robot. Keep it simple, don't hurt anyone, make your point. We can argue about the efficacy of their tactics but at the end of the day they're trying something.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by nomel on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:43PM (#37299448)
> If blocking traffic raises awareness

From the article,

> protest against the city being used as a testing ground for this emerging technology.

What awareness are they raising, exactly? Are you/they suggesting that people in the Bay Area don't know that these driverless cars exist? Or is it that they're fragile/not complete yet? This is a genuine question, because I, obviously, don't understand.

I see this similar to someone laying in the road, blocking human drivers, and saying they're raising awareness of the fact that drivers can be blocking if someone put effort into blocking them. I don't get it. Help me.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by saulpw on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @07:03PM (#37315326)
From where I sit, there's a general perception that driverless cars ("tech") will reduce traffic accidents and fatalities and be an overall significant positive improvement in transportation (source: partner is lifer at city DOT and is pro-driverless cars). There's a corresponding trust that companies/process/regulations wouldn't allow the deployment of driverless vehicles unless they're a safe and mature technology. And a similar lack of understanding of how mature the technology actually is (given mainstream hype from Musk etc). So a demonstration that extreme anti-social behavior will currently result, not from edge-case conditions that would be dangerous even for a human to be driving in, but from a simple hack that literally any miscreant could pull off in seconds and successfully run away from without any risk to themselves, might be sufficient to raise awareness that we can't trust creators of these vehicles or the larger system to do adequate testing before deployment, and that in fact the vehicles are already deployed widely enough to inflict transportation blockages with a minimum of miscreants and effort by same.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by nomel on Wednesday August 30, 2023 @04:28PM (#37328555)
> but from a simple hack that literally any miscreant could pull off in seconds and successfully run away from without any risk to themselves

Without any risk to themselves, or anyone else.

I don't think anyone will see this point of "not enough testing", when a car should not continue with a stop sign, road cone, or human on the hood, under any condition. I think most everyone will see this as expected and desired behavior, with a clear demonstration of safe handling of a dumb situation caused by some angry idiots.

Here's a question for anyone with this perspective: What should a fully tested, fully qualified, car do in this situation?

I see the "correct" answer as: immediately disable automation, and prompt a human for remote control.

What's your "correct" answer?

This is all opinion that could only be settled be a poll of those who became aware of this situation. I'm having trouble finding any, but this one from NY [1].

[1] https://observer.com/2014/12/majority-of-new-yorkers-want-pr...

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by saulpw on Thursday August 31, 2023 @11:14PM (#37346388)
> Here's a question for anyone with this perspective: What should a fully tested, fully qualified, car do in this situation?

Okay, fine: it should deploy an embedded all-purpose maintenance drone to exit the vehicle and move the cone to a safe and out-of-the-way location.

It's a good thought experiment, and I think goes to show that we can't really have Level 5 Autonomous Vehicles without an embedded all-purpose maintenance drone. I mean the dream is for humanless robotaxis to drive themselves to their next fare, right? They shouldn't need a human to come out in order to remove a harmless 5-pound object. I mean how about any number of other things that might happen onto its hood? A plastic bag, or a half-eaten happy meal? These are routine urban annoyances that require 15 seconds of attention and an eyeroll at most.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by coryrc on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:51PM (#37279297)
They are very different grades of steel. Track is over twice the yield strength of rebar from your home center and through-hardened. Rebar is mild steel and can't be hardened (maybe case-hardened). It's the difference between cutting water and ice :-).
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by manfre on Sunday August 27, 2023 @07:13AM (#37281482)
It would take only a few moments to weld a metal traffic cone to a train track. Focusing on the exact timing to disturb the mode of transit is not relevant. There are always optimizations.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by nerdbert on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:12PM (#37278104)
Railways are a little different - for the most part (except at level crossings) they are operating on dedicated rights-of-way, and someone has to go out of their way to interfere with them.

A car on a public street is mixing it up with everyone else, and the dividing line for what constitutes "messing with" them is not clear at all. What if I wear a shirt that confuses their algorithms? Shine a light that does it? Drive, bike, or walk in a pattern that does it?

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by soligern on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:17PM (#37278140)
This is not wearing a shirt though. This is people deliberately causing disruptions by putting a traffic cone, universally recognized as a traffic warning, in front of the vehicles. A lot of regular people would think twice about what to do if they came back to their parked car with traffic cones around it.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by albrewer on Tuesday August 29, 2023 @11:14AM (#37309145)
> universally recognized as a traffic warning

Except a real driver can recognize when a cone should and shouldn't be there.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by mannykannot on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:20PM (#37278161)
> ...the dividing line for what constitutes "messing with" them is not clear at all.

Putting cones out for no other purpose beyond stopping them moving seems to me unambiguously "messing with" them (though I don't think we need additional laws to address it.)

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by PhasmaFelis on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:38AM (#37290176)
> someone has to go out of their way to interfere with them.

How is this thing with the traffic cones not "going out of their way to interfere"?

> the dividing line for what constitutes "messing with" them is not clear at all.

If you're deliberately jamming up traffic by any means, it's perfectly clear which side of the line you're on.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by badpun on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:33AM (#37280640)
In fact, there's a "prankster" operating in Poland right now, who is sending the "stop immediately" radio signal to trains. All trains receiving it will automatically start braking. They were able to stop 20+ trains yesterday. Also, when they're not sending that signal, they're broadcasting the Russian national anthem on the emergency braking radio frequency...
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by interloxia on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:40PM (#37284894)
>Poland's national transportation agency has stated its intention to upgrade Poland's railway systems by 2025 to use almost exclusively GSM cellular radios, which do have encryption and authentication. But until then, it will continue to use the relatively unprotected VHF 150 MHz system that allows the “radio-stop” commands to be spoofed.

https://www.wired.com/story/poland-train-radio-stop-attack/

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by waste_monk on Monday August 28, 2023 @04:20AM (#37291271)
>You could park a golf cart on the train tracks and it would shut down all train transport for hours

If a golf cart picks a fight with a train moving at speed, I guarantee you the train will win.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by HankB99 on Monday August 28, 2023 @09:05AM (#37293311)
Yes, and then traffic will be halted for hours while the incident is investigated.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by gravypod on Saturday August 26, 2023 @09:03PM (#37278418)
My commute on the M&E line is often (~1/month) cancelled or delayed by normal every day things (tree fall, branches, etc). All trains into New York Penn from my line get stopped.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by clnq on Saturday August 26, 2023 @10:08PM (#37278820)
> car centric transportation is NOT scalable.

“When intentionally broken, this transport doesn’t work. So it is not scalable.”

There are many ways to scale car-centric transportation that have been done successfully in countries other than the US. Public transit is one example.

Autonomous buses could solve a lot of the car issues in the US. Not if we keep putting cones in front of them though.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by kelnos on Saturday August 26, 2023 @10:32PM (#37278933)
> The fact that a single car can even cause this much harm is a sign of a much larger problem: car centric transportation is NOT scalable.

I don't particularly love US car culture, but this is an absurd take. A single broken-down train will block all trains behind it on the same track. Unexpected damage to a runway can choke an airport.

So are we to believe that the only "scalable" form of transportation is bicycles, because it's easy and fast to move a broken or crashed bicycle out of the right of way? Yeah, right.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by developer93 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @04:04AM (#37280465)
I mean, that would be lovely
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lotsoweiners on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:35PM (#37284259)
Maybe we should go back to having our correspondence over pen and paper as well?
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by developer93 on Wednesday September 06, 2023 @05:14PM (#37411420)
I like bicycles. Amazing invention. There are also electric bikes. A world completely run by bikes would be lovely, yes. I stand by it.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by galkk on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:28PM (#37279182)
Not the single car. Single idiot.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by NiloCK on Saturday August 26, 2023 @11:58PM (#37279333)
> The fact that a single car can even cause this much harm is a sign of a much larger problem: car centric transportation is NOT scalable.

This is an interesting to me. From the perspective of an internet builder, systems vulnerable to shutdown from individual bad actors are obviously insecure and "not scalable". But too much time in this environment can make us forget that the actual world is about a zillion times less hostile than the internet.

As an educator, I worked with a computer security savvy 13 year old who knew my software background and would occasionally disclose vulnerabilities in the district's systems to me. He was incredulous that the network could be so insecure.

I asked about the security systems governing walking around in the hallway - was there any physical impediment preventing one person from punching, kicking, throwing a rock at another? Of course not - the security is socially constructed. Norms, consequences, etc, that on balance seemed to work out pretty effectively. I tried to make a case that security inside a local network of the size and scope of our school board was also ~90% social construction, but the student really struggled with it. There was a strong belief that because it was computers, you were expected to exploit it if it were vulnerable.

First paragraph is about the IT security mindset bleeding into real life, third is about the IT adversarial mindset corrupting our disposition toward technical equipment generally.

Given how immersed current generations are / have been in the adversarial landscape of the web, should we expect an uptick in the level of generalized adversarialism? Will xyst's (and my student's) assessments of these systems become true? Have they already and I'm just a knob?

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by psunavy03 on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:03AM (#37279354)
We're seeing a lot of this in modern society. Social media, guns, politics . . . lots of areas where individual bad actors are overturning "social construction," norms, and trust because they can. Not realizing that a lot of those norms they're pissing all over are vital to having any kind of a society worth living in, which is why seeing them brazenly violated freaks a lot of people TF out. I don't want to live in the ultimate low-trust society because it seems it'd suck for any number of crappy reasons.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by lawrenceyan on Sunday August 27, 2023 @01:12AM (#37279607)
Why not have systems be as resilient and robust as possible though? For example, with the implementation of crypto, now you can massively lower trust necessary for finance to function.

That doesn't mean we purposely try to lower trust. But in the rare event it happens, I feel like it's a good safeguard. Strong foundations in many ways can often enable greater trust too I think.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by zirgs on Sunday August 27, 2023 @02:32AM (#37279978)
Why are you talking about cryptocurrency as if it was a new technology? It's 15 years old now and it's already pretty clear that it's not very useful for ordinary people.
Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by sdeframond on Monday August 28, 2023 @05:43PM (#37300772)
> Why not have systems be as resilient and robust as possible though?

Because walking around wearing medieval armors to protect from strangers randomly "punching, kicking, throwing a rock at another" would be so annoying.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by brightlancer on Sunday August 27, 2023 @11:12AM (#37283447)
> Given how immersed current generations are / have been in the adversarial landscape of the web, should we expect an uptick in the level of generalized adversarialism?

I'm really interested by this question. My initial thought is that most teens and young adults (like previous generations) aren't savvy about computer security and Student XYZ is the exception rather than the norm.

IME, the IRL adversarialism is driven by political/ religious fanaticism rather than a hacker mentality -- they're not tech savvy, they're just determined.

That said, the reality is often less important than the perception of reality, particularly _fear_. Businesses and government are reacting to fears which are outsized to the reality, like Terrorism and School Shootings. They're adopting an adversarial mindset as defenders, even in the absence of an uptick in generalized adversarialism.

Re:Armed with traffic cones, protesters are immobilizing dri... by kortilla on Sunday August 27, 2023 @12:11AM (#37279383)
This is a shitty take. Guess how much harm a single derailed train can cause to the New York subway? Guess how much harm a single plane crashed on a runway causes?

Every form of mass transit suffers from single outsized impacts of failures.

When the Korean airline airplane crashed into the end of the SFO runway it disrupted 10s of thousands flying into the Bay Area.