News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by atombender on Friday August 25, 2023 @05:26AM (#37259720)
> the opportunity cost of reusing the spent fuel is not a major issue

Uranium mining is extremely destructive to the environment, not to mention using a lot of energy, so this isn't just opportunity cost, it's externality cost.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by orwin on Friday August 25, 2023 @06:40AM (#37260118)
Sources on that? I thought uranium mining was mostly leaching (which is very, very, very energy efficient, and non-destructive if you take care of the used solution) with open mining on the decline.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by DennisP on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:11AM (#37261302)
Yep, 57% of the world's uranium mining is in-situ leaching, which is basically two pipes in the ground. One pumps water down, the other brings uranium-rich water back up, into a building where the uranium is filtered out.

https://world-nuclear.org/information-library/nuclear-fuel-c...

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by m4rtink on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:53AM (#37263133)
Um, its not water down, its sulphuric acid and similar kinds of fun. We are still working out how to get ridd of side effects of that here in Czech Republic decades anfter most such mining ended.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by atombender on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:18AM (#37261371)
In-situ leaching contaminates aquifiers, and remediations have not been shown to be effective [1]. Meanwhile, this still leaves all of the mining which is not ISL.

[1] https://www.nrdc.org/bio/nrdc/epa-tries-sign-away-authority-...

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by Retric on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:20AM (#37260415)
Reprocessing is more destructive to the environment. It looks clean to have stuff take place in large buildings but the externalities are significant.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by sophacles on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:49AM (#37263088)
> Reprocessing is more destructive to the environment.

How so? Any pointers for more info - I'm somewhat ignorant on this topic.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by Retric on Friday August 25, 2023 @01:27PM (#37264507)
This was from speaking to an expert, but from what I recall recovering plutonium is perfectly reasonable trying to recover the uranium isn’t helping.

First you don’t actually reduce the number of atoms of highly radioactive waste products. You’re simply chemically separating material not transmuting it to something non radioactive. Which doesn’t really make the nasty stuff easier to deal with.

Second, you end up contaminating a great deal of additional material which then becomes a high volume of low level radioactive waste. At the same time you need an input stream of various chemicals, steel, rubber, etc to replace what’s been contaminated which then causes environmental harm when you’re extracting them.

Finally plutonium is useful as fuel, but the ratio of u235:u238 changes so you still need enrichment. Which means at the end of this process you’re spent a great deal of effort only to throw away most of the uranium recovered.

There are reactor designs that don’t need enrichment such as CANDU, but they need far less raw uranium mined in the first place.

TLDR; What you’re recovering is u235 which is a small percentage of spent fuel and it takes a huge amount of resources to get at it.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by flangola7 on Friday August 25, 2023 @09:25AM (#37261451)
I don't know anything any mining. What makes it so destructive? Or more destructive than other mining?
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by littlestymaar on Friday August 25, 2023 @10:07AM (#37261903)
Mining is destructive whatever you mine. The worst kind of mining is open-pit mining, which isn't the most common method for uranium, so in average uranium mining is probably less destructive than most mining operations.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by FredPret on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:12AM (#37262616)
The alternative is a pre-technology existence.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by littlestymaar on Friday August 25, 2023 @02:34PM (#37265482)
Or we could stop building throwaway things. Sure it won't reduce mining to zero, but when a significant fraction of what we mine is ending up in landfills after just a few years, there sure is margin of improvement.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by FredPret on Friday August 25, 2023 @02:42PM (#37265593)
Why "or"? Why not "and"?

We have massive numbers of people who are still really poor. Making quality infrastructure and products for these people involves lots of brand-new metals.

In the meantime, increasing quality and recycling is merely a multiplier increasing the efficiency of our system. You can't recycle your way to economic greatness.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by titzer on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:42AM (#37262988)
Compared to coal and natural gas, though?
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by mschuster91 on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:46AM (#37263049)
It's certainly very convenient that, sans Canada and Australia, all significant uranium mining countries are developing or virtually lawless (i.e. the government can do whatever the f..k it wants without needing to take care of nature) countries - and to be honest given how past Australian governments outright sharted on nature protection or Aboriginal activists in favor of mining conglomerates, I'd classify the country as lawless as well.

Nuclear fission based on uranium is a lot of things, but definitely not "clean" or "green" even on the raw material sourcing side like the pro-nuclear crowd keeps blathering.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_uranium_p...

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by namdnay on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:20PM (#37263479)
> Nuclear fission based on uranium is a lot of things, but definitely not "clean" or "green" even on the raw material sourcing side like the pro-nuclear crowd keeps blathering.

Depending on your criteria, no human industrial activity is green. Digging up precious metals for solar panels? Pouring tons of concrete in mountain valleys to make dams? Building forests of windmills?

At the end of the day, the question becomes “does this enable us to reduce our carbon emissions whilst keeping a reasonable quality of life”. And to that question nuclear is without a doubt a good thing

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by mschuster91 on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:22PM (#37263512)
> At the end of the day, the question becomes “does this enable us to reduce our carbon emissions whilst keeping a reasonable quality of life”. And to that question nuclear is without a doubt a good thing

Solar and wind don't leave a ton of radioactive material behind.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by ska on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:59PM (#37264119)
> Solar and wind don't leave a ton of radioactive material behind.

But they are not a plausible global replacement at this point, and - without radical storage technology changes - for the foreseeable future.

So really what you should be asking is, is nuclear cleaner than fossil.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by mschuster91 on Friday August 25, 2023 @03:05PM (#37265843)
> But they are not a plausible global replacement at this point

Do they need to be? Cut back on crap (i.e. advertising billboards, city lights), invest into decentralized storage for households (let's be real, even the demand of a home with two teenagers with gaming rigs can easily be met with a standard Powerwall), and get as many industrial processes shifted to shift operations to save on nighttime base load. The remainder can be, at least in Continental Europe and America, caught by a well-built continental grid (China manages thousands of km long lines!) and biogas/hydrogen peakers.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by mlyle on Friday August 25, 2023 @03:12PM (#37265927)
> Cut back on crap (i.e. advertising billboards, city lights)

The power usage of these is pretty small.

> Invest into decentralized storage for households (let's be real, even the demand of a home with two teenagers with gaming rigs can easily be met with a standard Powerwall)

For those of us who are upper middle class or beyond, this is no big deal, but the additional apartment cost for someone living paycheck to paycheck could be quite noticeable (or the cost to taxpayers to subsidize this).

Further, increased electrification of loads that are nighttime-centric (EV charging, heating, industrial loads) makes this less tenable. Base load is going to go up.

> and get as many industrial processes shifted to shift operations to save on nighttime base load

This might mean tripling the amount of capital equipment, which has its own costs and impacts. Electrification of industrial loads is more capital-intensive; tripling the cost of this is even worse.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by ska on Friday August 25, 2023 @04:25PM (#37266596)
> Do they need to be?

It sure seems like it? Any proposal the implies a rapid attenuation of capacity or consumption is no small thing to consider. The technical and political barriers to achieving them are likely orders of magnitude worse than those involved in taking up some of the capacity with nuclear.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by gottorf on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:15PM (#37263416)
> given how past Australian governments outright sharted on nature protection or Aboriginal activists in favor of mining conglomerates, I'd classify the country as lawless as well

Making human lives better means that you have to do dirty, destructive work like mining, drilling, and manufacturing. To some degree, we're trading pristineness of nature for increased living standards for people. As technology improves, there is potential for our footprint to get smaller, but that's almost always balanced out (or more) by an increase in population.

It's easy to make the whole country a nature preserve. You then either import things that were produced in a dirty manner overseas, or your living standards drop to that of our Aboriginal ancestors.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by AussieWog93 on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:38PM (#37268773)
>Australia ... lawless

OK buddy

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by detaro on Friday August 25, 2023 @08:48PM (#37268840)
maybe read the sentence again
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by Brusco_RF on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:19PM (#37263461)
This is disinformation and you should delete it. I don't use that term lightly, Nuclear FUD is spread by Russia to keep the west dependent on their oil, and you're helping them whether you know it or not.

In reality, Uranium is mostly mined by leaching which is the least destructive form of mining. Not to mention the quantity actually mined is several orders of magnitude less than other things we mine in much more destructive fashions like Copper, nickel, zinc etc

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by otikik on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:19PM (#37263462)
I don't think we need to go over the externality cost presented by Coal, Gas or Petrol.

I'll assume that you are a proponent of Solar/Wind/Hydro. Which also have externalities, including human death, but let's ignore that.

But I am onboard with all of those. My problem is that I think solar, wind and hydro are not enough. We don't have a way to store energy in massive ways, so in order to account for cloudy days, non-windy days and nights, we need something else.

I see uranium filing that niche. If not uranium, what else? All the options I see mentioned are along the lines of "let's continue burning stuff, then, and keep adding solar/wind/hydro".

But that is what we are doing now already. And the temperature and CO2 concentration graphs keep going up. So, what is the alternative?

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by Kon5ole on Friday August 25, 2023 @01:34PM (#37264582)
>>We don't have a way to store energy in massive ways, so in order to account for cloudy days, non-windy days and nights, we need something else.

So we can build either energy storage or nuclear plants. Storage must surely be the better choice!

It seems quite obvious to me that it will be cheaper, faster, simpler and more reliable, not least because it will be distributed and we can engage many more people to the task of building storage than we can to the task of building nuclear plants.

Heat storage, pressure storage, gravity storage, hydrogen, methane, batteries, all so easy to make (compared to nuclear plants) that you can have thousands of "small town scale" projects going at the same time.

With few notable mega-projects, solar has still grown in capacity equivalent to several nuclear reactors per year the past few years. I think a similar thing will happen with energy storage.

It's kind of happening already (several storage projects are underway and some are online) but the results are good and it's early days.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by reshlo on Friday August 25, 2023 @07:31PM (#37268340)
> It seems quite obvious to me that it will be cheaper

The New Zealand government estimates that a gravity storage scheme with a capacity of 5TWh would cost 14 billion NZ dollars to construct.

https://www.mbie.govt.nz/building-and-energy/energy-and-natu...

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by specialist on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:35AM (#37269972)
Renewables and storage today. Nuclear tomorrow (hopefully).

We need all of it. ASAP.

It's "yes and", not "either-or".

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by specialist on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:30AM (#37269950)
Advanced geothermal. Fervo Energy solved that problem. Now the challenge is scaling up.

I enthusiastically support any and all nuclear options. Especially traveling wave and SMRs.

Unfortunately, nuclear won't arrive in time to keep us under 2C. Fortunately, we'll still need it to help with going net-negative.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by hakfoo on Saturday August 26, 2023 @05:54PM (#37277266)
What is it about nuclear that keeps it from coming online quickly?

Is it solely regulatory red tape? Do we not have off-the-shelf designs (i. e. from when the French built scores of plants), or are they dependent on a catalog of no-longer-available parts?

I was hoping for modular reactors that were neighbourhood-scale-- the size of a a small shipping container, and able to be delivered rather than site built. Maybe RTG instead of steam-turbine for mechanical simplicity.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by butlike on Monday August 28, 2023 @01:16PM (#37297395)
I imagine it's regulatory for fission plants. Fusion is still a ways off, in terms of us having net-positive energy, but is the "true" nuclear energy solution as far as I'm concerned.

The difference is a fusion's byproduct is helium, and if the core "melts down," it implodes rather than explodes. Fission creates waste who's half life is 4.5bil years (which is demonstratedly toxic to humans, hence where I imagine the apprehension for bringing reactors online is coming from)

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by specialist on Monday August 28, 2023 @03:25PM (#37299196)
I wish I knew. I'm sure I'm not alone.

My current belief is that it just comes down to lack of investment.

Compare the current outlooks of biofuels, "next generation" nuclear, and now green H2.

The IRA is building a H2 economy, from scratch. Soon, the govt will pay anyone anywhere a stupid amount of money to make "green" H2 (details are still being hashed out). It's stupid to not get in on the action. So that govt investment begat a torrent of private investment. And now we're off to the races.

Just like how the Obama administration bootstrapped PV solar and lithium ion batteries, in 20 years we'll look back at the passing of the IRA as the genesis of our H2 economy.

In their times, both biofuels and nuclear were supposed to be the next big thing.

But instead of forging industrial policy and committing to moonshot level investments, our neoliberals predecessors had faith these nascent industries would magically emerge from the "free market".

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by ekianjo on Friday August 25, 2023 @12:35PM (#37263722)
> so this isn't just opportunity cost, it's externality cost.

Everything has externalities, even the "renewables" (which are not, by definition, because nothing is renewable) - if you want to have an adult conversation you need to talk in terms of pros and cons across multiple dimensions.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by idiotsecant on Friday August 25, 2023 @01:42PM (#37264680)
The difference is that renewables mostly end up paying for those externalities. Particularly nuke. We've managed to internalize the idea as a society that if I decide to burn an enormous amount of hydrocarbons I get to profit from the power generated (or whatever desirable outcome is present) but society gets to deal with the byproducts, none of which I am expected to contribute to handling.

This is an obviously silly structure and yet it persists.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by ekianjo on Saturday August 26, 2023 @12:08AM (#37269861)
solar panels and wind turbines are not produced out of thin air and need to be thrown away and replaced constantly.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by idiotsecant on Saturday August 26, 2023 @07:14PM (#37277782)
Oh? Solar panels made today have an expected e80 of 30 years before refurb is required. What is the expected capital lifetime that you'd consider not to be replaced 'constantly'? This compares pretty decently with natural gas turbines, especially considering that panels have a small fraction of the capital cost.
Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by trenchgun on Friday August 25, 2023 @11:51PM (#37269796)
Uranium mining is not necessarily more destructive to environment or energy intensive than any other mining.

And in fact, a major part of uranium is in-situ leaching, which is less enviromentally damaging than most other mining.

Re:The place where no humans will tread for 100k years by TheSpiceIsLife on Saturday August 26, 2023 @08:22AM (#37272166)
You’re wrong.

Zoom right in on Olympic Dam on Google maps.

This is the largest known single deposit of uranium in the world.

Now zoom out. Keep zooming out. Now zoom out further. Australia is big.

Uranium mining causes approximately zero damage.