News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by Ozzie_osman on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:31PM (#37244069)
The interesting thing is a few years ago (before becoming the "SPAC King") he did a media tour where he criticized Venture Capital as being a "massive Ponzi scheme". [1]

Then he went all-in on SPACs... Which ended up being the ultimate Ponzi.

[1] https://www.cnbc.com/2018/10/10/start-up-economy-is-a-ponzi-...

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by bko on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:50PM (#37244165)
How are SPACs a ponzi? My understanding is that its a pool of money that gets raised to essentially take a private organization public through a merger with (theoretically) less red tape and cost. You buy into the SPAC without knowing exactly what is being bought but at the time of purchase you have the option to redeem you investment. There are other clauses if the organizer can't find a suitable takeover target.

You can criticize the fees or the fact that they are essentially trying to get around regulatory and reporting requirements. They did well a few years ago now they are doing poorly. But how is it a ponzi? Not everything that loses money is a ponzi

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by majormajor on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:59PM (#37244225)
SPACs make it easier to get the next round of money for your Ponzi with less due diligence needed (where Ponzi is used in the loose sense of "there's no long term real business model, just sell it off to the suckers before it blows up").

So, sure, more accurate to say "SPACs make passing laughable-business-plan Ponzi schemes off as real businesses and cashing out to public investors" than "SPACs are ponzis directly" but... I'm not sure this hair needs splitting.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by epgui on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:01PM (#37244238)
It's not hair-splitting, a SPAC is simply not a Ponzi scheme. That doesn't mean it's a good investment.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by mlyle on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:03PM (#37244247)
SPACs may not always be ponzi schemes, but plenty are of dubious, unvetted businesses and for the principle purpose of paying returns to prior investors.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by epgui on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:14PM (#37244295)
Yes, but that's only superficially similar to a Ponzi scheme. They're just not Ponzi schemes.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by iancmceachern on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:31AM (#37245013)
How so? I'm genuinely curious, what are the specific distinctions? Many others consider it so:

"Holmes duped just about everyone about the efficacy of Edison. For 12 years, she essentially ran a Ponzi scheme by attracting millions of dollars from primarily venture capitalists that saw it as a unique opportunity to cash in on the boom in Silicon Valley."

https://www.ethicssage.com/2022/01/fake-it-until-you-make-it...

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by throwawaymaths on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:00AM (#37244880)
I lot of legitimate businesses fall into that category.

Also illegitimate businesss. Theranos was definitely illegitimate (and had the characteristic of little fish investors trying to sell to bigger fish), but it would be a pretty severe category error to call it a ponzi scheme.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by iancmceachern on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:30AM (#37245009)
I dont agree, many others consider what she did no different than a ponzi scheme. It's not just me and the patent commenter:

"Holmes duped just about everyone about the efficacy of Edison. For 12 years, she essentially ran a Ponzi scheme by attracting millions of dollars from primarily venture capitalists that saw it as a unique opportunity to cash in on the boom in Silicon Valley."

https://www.ethicssage.com/2022/01/fake-it-until-you-make-it...

I would appreciate, for my own edification, what specific things you believe are different between what Ms Holmes did and what Maydoff or Ponzi did. I'm genuinely curious.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by throwawaymaths on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:17AM (#37245292)
Theranos was fraud. She made material lies about what the machines do.

Ponzis are accounting malpractice that don't even necessarily involve defrauding anyone.

It's a problem if you're going to call everything that goes south a ponzi scheme, because it elides failure modes and dulls peoples ability to distingush and analyze bad situations. Is social security, for example, a ponzi scheme?

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by iancmceachern on Thursday August 24, 2023 @01:28AM (#37245355)
Didn't Ponzi make material lies about what his company did also? It just seems like a dubious distinction. More than what they did being different, I think the laws and terminology around those laws are different now. I don't think there is much pragmatic difference, mostly just semantics no?
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:00AM (#37245514)
There is a meaningful difference. A ponzi scheme involves: schemer takes money from Mr. A. At a later date he takes money from Mr B. He gives some of the money from Mr. B to Mr A, and tells Mr. A that it's "returns". He tells Mr B. all is fine. Then Mr C comes along and his money is given to Mr. A and Mr. B, as "returns". This continues.

It's a very specific type of fraud. Most fraud isn't a ponzi, just like every injury isn't a broken arm. It's silly to go around calling all injuries a broken arm.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by axpy on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:07AM (#37245920)
It's not because A ==> B that B ==> A. A Ponzi scheme is a fraud but a frauds doesn't necessarily imply a Ponzi scheme. That's is not just semantic, it's a logic falacy.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by throwawaymaths on Thursday August 24, 2023 @05:18AM (#37246684)
I think it's still considered a ponzi scheme if you tell people exactly what you are doing.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by epgui on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:44PM (#37254293)
I believe that may be correct, although in practice there is often/usually/historically-always (?) deception involved, because presumably no morally competent adult would willingly give their money to an honest Ponzi unless they knew they stood to benefit by being one of the first to pull out.

But as you point out, I don't think deception per se is really the defining feature of the Ponzi.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by epgui on Thursday August 24, 2023 @04:48PM (#37254347)
> many others consider what she did no different than a ponzi scheme

I can interpret this in many different ways. Maybe they mean "no different than" in the sense of "no better than", ie.: as a moral or value judgment.

But if I interpret the words literally, then these people are just wrong. Theranos was a terrible waste of capital, and there was plenty of fraud involved, but it was not a Ponzi.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by sdwr on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:15PM (#37244307)
Book smarts vs street smarts

You're paying attention to the technical definition. "It's just an investment vehicle!"

He's paying attention to the real-world outcome. Insiders made money by offloading bad investments onto retail suckers.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by gravitronic on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:27AM (#37248498)
We call those scams
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by Ozzie_osman on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:35PM (#37244717)
I mean... How is VC a Ponzi? Obviously I'm using a very loose definition, not a technical one, but I'm using the same one Chamath used.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by danielmarkbruce on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:02AM (#37245523)
The argument is that VC A's returns a propped up by VC B making an investment at a higher valuation, thereby making VC A's marks look great. They can go raise more money. This can continue for quite some time. While it's not a completely ridiculous analogy to a true ponzi, it's probably better to just call it a bubble. It's closer to a credit bubble, housing bubble etc.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by Lazare on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:44AM (#37245773)
When people say something is a ponzi, they generally mean that they think it's deceptive, fraudulent, or otherwise unsavoury. They don't mean that it's literally the sort of scheme made infamous by Charles Ponzi.

I think there's value in using precise language, so I reget this usage, but it's common whether I like it or not.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by comex on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:56AM (#37246177)
Most of the time I’ve seen something called a Ponzi scheme, there is at least some purported element where earlier investors in an asset make money off of later investors in the same asset, without the asset’s true worth actually increasing. That definition isn’t hard to satisfy – it could be something as simple as a stock price becoming overinflated due to hype – and it may even apply to SPACs, but it’s still a more specific requirement than just being fraudulent or unsavory. YMMV.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by daveguy on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:41PM (#37253630)
Earlier investors = VCs funding a bunk company.

Later investors = SPAC pawns putting up money for a bad investment that doesn't require the normal regulatory scrutiny that an IPO requires.

If not Ponzi, seems very Ponzi-like.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by thefounder on Thursday August 24, 2023 @05:49AM (#37246921)
Then people should just use the correct term: Rug pull
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by newshackr on Thursday August 24, 2023 @09:35AM (#37248592)
SPACs aren't a ponzi scheme but they are set up for the creator to win. Typically they get 20% of the business at lower than market rate and sometimes have clauses for them to still win if it can't find a business to acquire.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by daveguy on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:37PM (#37253575)
This is the key point:

> essentially trying to get around regulatory and reporting requirements.

It's just a great tool for a ponzi scheme. A ponzi tool rather than a ponzi scheme. When it gets so tightly coupled to the schemes it enables specifically to get around regulatory and reporting requirements... Tomato, Tomahto.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by Fatnino on Friday August 25, 2023 @04:34AM (#37259434)
So theres some small startup that seems maybe interesting, you're looking forward to investing when they go public.

Suddenly you hear they are going public through a SPAC. Why? Why aren't they going through the usual channels, crossing their eyes and dotting their tees? Laying everything out on the table so everyone can feel confident?

The very fact they are going for this SPAC backdoor is a HUGE red flag.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by epgui on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @09:59PM (#37244226)
Not everything that is a bad investment is a Ponzi scheme.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:20PM (#37244327)
For some reason calling out "it's not achshually a Ponzi scheme!" is the new "correlation is not causation!!"

Yes, I agree with you, it doesn't have the features of the Wikipedia definition of a Ponzi scheme. But language changes over time. I think the salient point that people now think about when calling things a Ponzi scheme is "Early investors are aware that, at its root, the investment sucks. So their goal is to entice new investors to buy into the original investment, which has the effect of transferring wealth from new to old investors, with the hope that the old investors can get out before the gig is up, thus leaving the newer investors as bag holders." That description applies both to the original definition of a Ponzi scheme, and to newer uses that don't include other features of the original Ponzi scheme.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by 0xf8 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:58PM (#37244865)
This response to should have all but conclusively ended the silly debate in outlining the semantic drift of the term “Ponzi scheme” to encapsulate the relevant spectrum of linguistic variations, and yet…
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by jhanschoo on Thursday August 24, 2023 @12:18AM (#37244956)
And language change results in miscommunication and confusion where a community meets another that doesn't have the same changes in theirs... as has happened here. The use of the more general term fraud would have been more appropriate. That's why we typically aim to use a sanitized, more standard and formal register when communicating broadly rather than to friends and family.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by qwytw on Thursday August 24, 2023 @02:56AM (#37245847)
What the comment above described is not fraud, though. It's much closer to a Ponzi scheme.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by VirusNewbie on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:39AM (#37250142)
That is extremely different than a ponzi scheme. Plenty of people who buy and sell stock every day think the underlying investment sucks.

Using imprecise wording should be discouraged and it reflects poorly on people who do so.

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by nonameiguess on Thursday August 24, 2023 @11:49AM (#37250286)
You described any business going south where the incumbent insiders know that and future investors do not. As long as the company sells some sort of real product and earns revenue, even if it's lying about how much or the quality of that product, it's not a Ponzi. What makes a Ponzi is money from investors is the only money at all. There is no actual investment being made, not even bad ones.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by tiffanyg on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:30PM (#37244383)
This is true. However, much like "crackers" are always looking for the next exploit ... chasing that dragon of the next n00b who doesn't sanitize strings passed to their DB, or, above that rather script kiddie level, oh, say, something like infecting all the computers in Iran related to running centrifuges to enrich uranium ... there are various kinds of economic fraudsters looking for that next way to extract piles of money into their own personal "Scrooge McDuck"-style "money bins". And, Silicon Valley has been ground-zero of this sort of activity* in recent years as well.

But, IPOs became rather passé post-2010ish, for the truly depraved. Too much regulation, you see. SPACs are ever so much more exploitable. Though, IPOs continue to be successfully used to funnel money from the have-nots to the already-haves.** And so, here we are.

Yes, there have been people legitimately trying to use SPACs to finance efforts they truly believed in. My sense, having traded SPACs myself during the height of the frenzy was: much less than 50% had much of any real legitimacy. And, solidly more than 10% or even 20% were scammy as hell ... particularly at that time when the money taps were wide open and fraud was absolutely rife across many vehicles etc. (helped along by ... survey says: the very "internet" Silicon Valley made such a massive economic force...).

* On a much larger scale and with a much more "legitimate face" than some of the other "operators" better known in this area, generally

** See, for example: https://www.businessinsider.com/venture-capital-big-tech-ant... ... I'd provide more refs in general, but sadly, super pressed for time right now ... so, obviously, I would advise anyone to take what I've written without solid refs with the usual grain of salt. Plenty can be found with some searches (quite neutral searches ... i.e., no "leading the search engine" required).

Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by DesiLurker on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @10:26PM (#37244356)
But the point here is that SPAC as an investment vehicle allows sidestepping a bunch of due diligence in the name of 'just avoiding wallstreet commissions'. that basically ends up becoming prime target for any non-IPO-worthy-but-shiny security to be offloaded to general public. then the next argument from same folks will be .. well price of anything is what somebody will pay for it, so buyer beware.
Re:The median return of 2022's SPAC mergers: -82% by duped on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @11:46PM (#37244795)
More of a pump and dump than a Ponzi scheme