News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by jacoblambda on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:01PM (#37242429)
Well that's a terrifying precedent they are trying to set.

Tornado Cash devs blocked known OFAC sanctioned addresses or associated addresses from interacting with the service yet they are still being put on the hook for people hiding their identity to attempt to bypass those sanctions.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by Paul-Craft on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:12PM (#37242533)
I don't see where it says in the article that they were blocking known OFAC sanctioned addresses, etc., but they do state that they were operating without any KYC provisions whatsoever, and that is a big no-no if you don't want to run afoul of money laundering laws in the US:

> Tornado Cash operated without know-your-customer (KYC) or anti-money laundering (AML) programs as required by US law, the document alleges. It also did not register with FinCEN as a money-transmitting business, the indictment says. Semenov and Storm also created a document called “Tips to Remain Anonymous,” which advised customers to consider using Tor or a VPN, delete data from their web browsers, and leave their money in Tornado for longer periods of time to better anonymize their transactions. They also advised users to employ different IP addresses for deposit and withdrawal.

As a bonus, the investors wouldn't fund a compliant version:

> Storm suggested creating a version of Tornado with KYC / AML enabled, but Tornado’s unnamed venture capital investors were dismissive, saying, “I just don’t know if anyone will actually want this.” The investor added, “It would be unlikely as a fund that we’d use a ‘compliant mixer.’”

I'd say these investors are as complicit in whatever conspiracy the devs are being charged with as well.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by woodruffw on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:04PM (#37242464)
I don't think this is unprecedented: the USG's reasoning (appears) to be that all actions here were ultimately the product of human behavior.

Put another way: it's still a crime to kick puppies, even if you only indirectly kick puppies through your newly-invented fully-automatic Puppy Kicker 3000.

Edit: to refine the analogy: it doesn't stop being a Puppy Kicker 3000 just because you add a screening phase that eliminates puppies designated by the American Kennel Club.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by sneak on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:14PM (#37242556)
If someone took the Tornado Cash contract source code and redeployed it on Ethereum under a new contract address today and people began using it, do you think someone deploying such a contract should face similar charges?

Should the original developers face additional charges for that?

What if the original developers only published the contracts but never deployed them on Ethereum, leaving that up to someone else to do? Is it the author or the deployer or the user who is liable?

I mean, someone has to be liable if it didn't exist before and then it did, but if it's the author and not the deployer, you could be charged for code you wrote entirely offline and published to GitHub (if someone else later deploys it and it sees use).

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by thisgoesnowhere on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:27PM (#37242689)
In this case the "devs" are the owners and operators and they profit on the contract being run.

The answer to all of your questions is the same. When you run this code to facilitate money laundering the deployer gets in trouble and that's how it should be I can't imagine how else it could work.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by woodruffw on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:18PM (#37242595)
My “should” doesn’t enter into it. What matters is whether it’s indistinguishable from a criminal enterprise, which it is.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by GauntletWizard on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:41PM (#37243362)
Yes, no, deployer.

The code is absolutely free speech, the application of it is not. I can sell you a book that says how to circumvent financial controls, I can even give a talk about circumventing financial controls, what I can't do is fly to North Korea to talk about it.

[1] https://www.bbc.com/news/business-61090064

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by nabakin on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:12PM (#37242537)
Your analogy would only make sense if Tornado Cash (Puppy Kicker 3000) was created for the purpose of money laundering (kicking puppies), but it seems like it was created for consumer privacy reasons.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by JohnFen on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:00PM (#37243022)
I think what it seems to you is different from what it seems to others. But this is the reason we have a court system -- a judge will end up deciding if TC intentionally allowed for money laundering and if TC violated KYC/AML laws.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by nabakin on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:38PM (#37243754)
Sure and if their intent was to make a tool for money laundering or they attempted to subvert the law, I'm all for it
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by CPLX on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:25PM (#37242663)
Privacy for consumers of money transmitting services is called money laundering.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by nabakin on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @08:36PM (#37243738)
No it is not. Maybe you need to look up the definition of money laundering.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by Ar-Curunir on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:33PM (#37242751)
Seems like cash users (everyone) and cash issuers (the government) are money launderers under this exceedingly broad definition.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by CPLX on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:16PM (#37243174)
Transmitting cash for others without reporting it would in fact make you a money launderer as well.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by qot on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:35PM (#37242772)
No, put another way this is Nike getting punished for creating a shoe that was used to kick puppies.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by PeterisP on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:27PM (#37243266)
No, in this analogy the punishment is aimed at Nike employees who after creating a shoe for kicking puppies also operated puppy-kicking-as-a-service with that shoe.

The people charged are the subset of the Tornado Cash devs who ran the service, not for solely developing some code.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by woodruffw on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:40PM (#37242828)
The purpose of kicking puppies is not embedded in the concept of a Nike sneaker.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by rajamaka on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:41PM (#37242834)
Creating a shoe specifically designed for kicking puppies with enhanced puppy kicking features and instructions on how to kick puppies with said shoe
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by miracle2k on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:29PM (#37243287)
Which is, and certainly should be, entirely legal.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by MattPalmer1086 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:09PM (#37242509)
And also gave advice on how to remain anonymous, and put in place no AML or KYC processes.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by zoklet-enjoyer on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:37PM (#37242786)
Might as well ban cash transactions and any services that facilitate cash transactions.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by arp242 on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:05PM (#37243058)
Yes, many jurisdictions have limits and rules for large cash transactions, and have for many years. Suddenly showing up with $1 million in cash that can't be traced to anything is more than a little suspicious, wouldn't you say? To what degree these laws should exist is something you can have an opinion on, but fact is that crypto is not being singled out here as is being implied.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by JohnFen on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:02PM (#37243035)
There have been laws requiring reporting cash transactions above a certain amount for a very, very long time. Engaging in such transactions without doing the proper reporting is already banned.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by HDThoreaun on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @07:09PM (#37243106)
The vast majority of cash is used for its intended legal purpose. The vast majority of tornado transactions were likely used to launder money.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by EGreg on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:29PM (#37242706)
Oh, the nerve of developing a piece of software, and advising people on how to not put in place processes! I thought the default state of transactions was not putting in place processes. How exactly do we square this with freedom of speech? When Phil Zimmerman published the book with the PGP source code, Could they have simply arrested him for exporting munitions despite the first amendment? That is a serious question, how come he was able to get away?
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by JohnFen on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:42PM (#37242855)
> How exactly do we square this with freedom of speech

Freedom of speech in the US is not, and never has been, absolute. There is all sorts of speech that is illegal to engage in.

> That is a serious question, how come he was able to get away?

He was absolutely investigated for ITAR violations, but the government elected not to press charges in the end. I forget why they made that decision, but I think it was a combination of the book being published only in the US at the time (which was undeniably legal) plus the huge amount of pressure -- especially public ridicule -- from the hacker community about the ridiculousness of the ITAR regulations.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by MattPalmer1086 on Thursday August 24, 2023 @03:18AM (#37245982)
They didn't just develop software and give advice. They ran the service itself.

If they had just written some software and told people how to operate it anonymously, they could not be prosecuted under these laws.

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by ajross on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:07PM (#37242494)
There's no section 230 for money laundering. If you want safe harbor from the crimes of your customers, you need to lobby for explicit protection in the law.

In this case, there actually are safe harbor laws in place that protect banks from being prosecuted in exactly this way as long as they correctly implement KYC/AML protocols. Tornado didn't feel they wanted to do this, so quite deliberately and publicly flaunted the law that would have protected them. And this is what happens.

What's the "precedent" being set exactly here? Follow the law like your competitors do and you won't get fingered as an accomplice?

Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by lucisferre on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:21PM (#37242623)
So "move fast, break things" isn't a valid defence?
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by klyrs on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:37PM (#37242792)
Gotta move fast enough you can't get caught.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by stefan_ on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:23PM (#37242636)
This isn't a precedent at all. As expected, prosecutors were not impressed by the blockchain smokescreen. People were joking about this programmer habit of thinking they can just inject "reasonable doubt" into everything and be fine years ago on HN, and that's just not how lawyers look at things.
Re:Tornado Cash devs charged with laundering more than $1B by xigency on Wednesday August 23, 2023 @06:27PM (#37242694)
But you see your honor, I’m a sovereign citizen!

For some reason too much time spent working with machines clouds the judgement of how law and the court work.