And its cost.
Or more generally, where the catalyst sits in the supply chain (how easy it is to produce at scale, can it be recycled, is it expensive, what is the waste management for it, etc...)
They have one in this space: "Methods and devices using tri-transition metal phosphides for efficient electrocatalytic reactions" at https://patents.google.com/patent/US20220154354A1/en with abstract:
] Methods and devices for generating hydrogen gas with an electrocatalytic energy conversion cell by introducing a tri-transition metal phosphide catalyst at or on an electrode of the electrocatalytic energy conversion cell. The electrocatalytic energy conversion cell includes a first electrode including a tri-transition metal phosphide catalyst, such as MO3P, a second electrode of an anodic material, an electrolyte disposed between the first electrode and the second electrode, and an electric potential source connected to both electrodes. Oxidation and reduction reactions, such as hydrogen evolution reactions, occur at the first electrode.
(Google Patents says "M03P", the PDF says "MO3P" in the abstract, but the text clearly has "Mo3P".)
Even if this isn't exactly the technology discussed - Supplementary Figure 20 shows how ImF-Mo3P catalyst improves on "pristine Mo3P nanoparticles" - the authors have several other related patents, so I have no doubt a patent was filed for this technology as well.
With batteries storing that is technically possible but it would take the whole world decades to build the required infrastructure.
With propane or other similar hydrocarbons it's around 2 million tonnes. 4 million if you account for 50% efficiency of turbines (we have better ones BTW).
4 million tonnes of gas seems like a lot, but currently USA has about 5850 bcf (1.6*10^14 liters) of underground gas storage ready, at 1.8 kg per m3 you could store about 300 million tonnes of propane. Enough to power the electricity grid of the whole world for 75 years.
So it's a choice between spending billions and turning our whole industrial output to it for years - or just using a fraction of what's already there in a slightly different way :)
Another point is - once you have one kind of hydrocarbons - you can burn them in adapted ICEs or transform into other hydrocarbons to be able to use existing cars. Suddenly you can continue to use the whole infrastructure we built in the last 100 years as if nothing happened with net 0 carbon footprint.
It's the only thing that makes sense, really.
Thus we should be looking for efficient ways of turning clean energy into hydrocarbon fuel.
Propane is easy to store, easy to transport, propane storage tanks are cheaper than batteries, require no high-tech manufacturing or rare earth elements, and I'd guess the energy storage density is higher.
Many (most) existing cars could be converted to run on propane and the engines will last longer and emissions will be lower as it's a cleaner-burning fuel.
Not that I'm in favor of combustion engines persisting.
This assumes that co2 recapture and propane synthesis require less energy than is produced by burning propane.
This is maybe a workload for excess solar, making renewable propane with electric that would otherwise be wasted
EDIT: note that burning that propane in a cheap generator is only gonna net you 10MJ/kg of electricity, maybe 17MJ/kg in a large expensive generator. So the roundtrip efficiency is just 9-15% efficient. But it potentially saves you a LOT in storage costs if you’re only cycling this storage once or twice a year.
(Note that propane is a great way to store hydrocarbons as the pressure is low but it’s self pressurizing and thus it doesn’t get water ingress or have any of the storage difficulties of gasoline and diesel, which last only 3-6 months or 6-12 months respectively. It’s also very clean burning compared to those two.)
50% is almost exactly the paper's claimed efficiency for the lab cell, so it's a reasonable number.
Overall, I'm very enthusiastic electrocatalytic methods for producing hydrocarbons as a combustion fuel source for applications where direct electric technologies are not feasible. I'd much rather seen money and energy going into making something like this work, than all the effort on hydrogen. Propane, or any hydrocarbon in the 3C-8C range, is a way better fuel for any fossil fuel replacement energy system than hydrogen.
And how many years would it have taken if a patent wasn't an incentive?
Let's say my car burns equivalent of 100kWh worth of LPG, how many kWh of propane i can recover from the exhaust gas and how many kWh of electricity i need to provide for that?
It's not viable (in terms of energy availability, packaging, or economies of scale) to run that sort of cryogenic high-pressure CO2 purification and storage system on the exhaust pipe of a vehicle. I could maybe imagine a solar installation with this attached being viable at, say, a remote farm with LPG-powered agricultural vehicles, or if I stretch my imagination to scifi timescales (and think about the number of remarkable compressors installed at scale in HVAC systems) to suburban homes with rooftop solar.
Well, only if the patent-holder makes no effort to maximize the return on its investment in those 20 years. But if the technology is really that effective and the patent-holder is even a little bit economically rational, then presumably the patent holder will be the one pushing hardest to make this the standard thing to do with recovered CO2 well before the patent expires.
Not that patents are all roses and puppy dogs. But this is too big a part of the picture to just ignore.
A fossil fuels company has deep incentive to minimize the harm of fossil fuels. A solar company has incentives to make fossil fuels as bad as they can.
Even if you generally perceive fossil fuels guys as bad guys.
Regardless. Any company has incentives to do this if someone (government) will pay for it. It doesn’t really harm any profits.
Look how well that's worked out for the financial sector. Nothing but good faith actors there. Immaculate.
I’m saying that fossil fuels companies are incentivized to sell useful co2 converters because this enables them to sell more fossil fuels.
They have a deep incentive to capture the regulatory framework that might hold them accountable for that harm, which they have accomplished.
You... you're aware that the actual, historically realized, attitude of fossil fuel companies has been to deny any harm exists, right? Deny it to the tune of 200 million dollars as recently of 2019, and for good reason! That spending bought them lots of political inaction since the science was settled in like 1990, you know: the days where keeping staying below 1.0 degrees warming was a realistic goal.
CO2 conversion tech is a path to selling more fossil fuels.
Because it sounds to me, speaking of "punchy but not particularly realistic" that you have some idea in your head of how our politics and economics work, that is contrary to even a cursory examination of material reality, and is laughably naive. And I earnestly want to hear it, because I could use a laugh today.
Could you please not.
You are presenting a false dichotomy. It’s not “bribe vs. use this tech”. It’s also not really about bribing at all. Fossil fuels are important. That sucks, but we do need them in the short term.
If this tech works, and the government is willing to pay for it to some extent, it’s probably a lot cheaper to build caseload gas plants and peak daytime load renewables than it is to try and build excessive green power and batteries to tide the night over.
Or just, you know, worst case run this profitable service independently of externalities
No they've decided to go the route of tobacco companies, deny everything and party while the sun is shining. By the time the lawyers show up they're counting on being dead or too old to stand trial.
Patents? Nope.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fischer%E2%80%93Tropsch_proces...
The economics are so awful because of a complex network of reactions, there are processes that build up larger hydrocarbons and break them down and you have to balance these just right to get liquid fuels and not paraffin wax or methane. Some kind of single-entity fuel has always seemed to make more sense to me: methane isn't that good of a destination because it's not that easy to handle or liquefy, propane is quite easy to handle in comparison.
> Here we report a catalytic system composed of 1-ethyl-3-methylimidazolium-functionalized Mo3P nanoparticles coated with an anion-exchange ionomer that produces propane from CO2 with a current density of −395 mA cm−2 and a Faradaic efficiency of 91% at −0.8 V versus reversible hydrogen electrode over 100 h in an electrolyser.
This is almost too good to be true... they demonstrate commercially viable reaction rates, efficiencies and timescales.
They have presumably applied for a patent for it, so in 20 years when the patent expires this will become the standard thing to do with recovered CO2 I'd guess.