Ex. https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/i-found-fake-firefox-up...
I miss getting those banner ads for decreasing my mortgage rates as a 14 year old who doesn't even pay rent yet
All of these are features of larger publishers, unfortunately, which means that smaller publishers suffer more malvertising. So you’re basically just supporting large publishers. Which is definitely better than supporting none, so I still commend you :)
> 2.12 People should be able to render web content as they want
> People must be able to change web pages according to their needs. For example, people should be able to install style sheets, assistive browser extensions, and blockers of unwanted content or scripts or auto-played videos. We will build features and write specifications that respect peoples' agency, and will create user agents to represent those preferences on the web user's behalf.
https://www.w3.org/TR/ethical-web-principles/#render
Don't fall for what ads companies/corporations are trying to shape users' thoughts.
That's pretty much what Medium and many general news sites are doing. I haven't paid for one yet, but I can respect the move if it means they don't need to rely on clickbait to build a customer base.
- I ask for a resource - you give it to me - any linked resources (stylesheets, scripts, images etc) are up to me to request
Therefore there is no "ethical" conundrum in blocking ads. The ad industry brought this on themselves by trying to push malware, spam and actively trying to make the web worse.
I remember when AdWords was just a humble bar of contextual text links, absolutely manageable. Not so much the case now.
Oh well...
It's more equivalent to changing the channel during a commercial, which seems to be what the GP is implying as an action.
Viewing the ad made them money.
Visiting and not viewing the ad lost them money. They paid for the server but made no money.
Only one of these three options is painful enough for them to get the point. It’s harsh i know, writers need to eat, but they need to understand I won’t “pay” them with my eyeballs unless the site is usable in return at a bare minimum.
1. sites that don't have any other model. e.g. my favorite game news website is Gematsu, but holy heck is the ads crazy intrusive. On mobile we are talking full screen video ads that have a tiny X to remove... for maybe 1 minute. I've expressed interest multiple times to donate or otherwise do something to directly fund the site but nothing has come up. And even if I did move on to make a point, this model isn't something that has spread to many, if any, modern gaming news site (and I've long since left Reddit, a topic in and of itself). Do I just give up on gaming news and let clickbait Youtubers inform me instead of written articles?
2. Exploratory purposes. I'm not going to know which and what websites do or do not have ad support, and most of my browsing when searching is very casual. I wouldn't feel too compelled to neither turn off my ad block nor pay a sub for some place I googled up once 3 months ago for a quick answer. I don't quite have an answer for this one.
3. ublock isn't simply blocking ads. trackers, certain cookies, overly large media elements, java script, remote fonts, even individual pieces of HTML elements you specify in a CSS manner. It's so much more powerful and privacy-oriented than a simple ad blocker. If it closed off any site with any of these issues there simply wouldn't be an interet to browse.
It's a compromise at the end of the day, and I can only look out for myself at some point. I'm not necessarily trying to teach websites a lesson per se.
That's actually not true. It's just that it's much harder to find that internet, because search engines are controlled by advertisers.
I'd need to roll my own email provider (and deal with that fallout since I'm now "spam". Ironic), cannot apply to 99% of job portals (employer nor job boards), cannot use most of my productivity apps on the web, and I still can't access most major news, subscription or not.If I was still in school there's a non-zero chance I can access my class portals.
I can replace most of these, but not all.
All I'm saying is that there are sites that don't do these things. That's an important reminder because I'd like people to support those sites when possible (but again, I agree that's not always possible).
The ethical principles written clearly in World Wide Web Consortium are for users, NOT for websites:
> 2.12 People should be able to render web content as they want
> People must be able to change web pages according to their needs. For example, people should be able to install style sheets, assistive browser extensions, and blockers of unwanted content or scripts or auto-played videos. We will build features and write specifications that respect peoples' agency, and will create user agents to represent those preferences on the web user's behalf.
For me, it's ethical. Loading trackers/malicious connections/contents on my own machine is unethical. That's it. I don't run those on your server, why do you run them on my devices?
What I said is simple: there's ethical pricinples standing by users' sides, and nothing for websites.
If you think it's unethical, you do you. I won't participate in arguing about your personal preferences.
Loading malicious content certainly is unethical. I'm not disputing that, I run an ad-blocker and I advocate to everyone that they should.
However, that isn't what we're talking about, we're talking about blocking ads as a concept. It is pretty indisputably unethical as it breaks the social contract of the service delivery.
The fact that is easy to do, has no punishment, and is incredibly low stakes doesn't make it ethical.
Problem is, ads now are trackers. Of course, there are few ads that are not. I also won't mind if the ads are static images (that are not generated from/linked to 3rd-party/trackers) and unable to click on. Thing is, those are just rare, and in practice blockers can't block them in general, because they are not distinguishable with other contents. So in general, those are not blocked, and blocking "ads" (the ads that are trackers) is still ethical to me.
And just FYI, blockers have the rule that don't block self-promotions (self-advertisements) by default.
I would dispute that there is such a social contract, any more than there is a social contract that if you download a crack to fix DRM, you are implicitly agreeing to install the virus it comes with.
Ad-funded businesses are engaging in market dumping, subsidizing their offerings by poisoning the minds of billions of people, and creating anxiety, insecurity, and dissatisfaction in the process. If someone gives you something for free covered in lead dust, and you accept it but clean the dust off first before touching it, I don't see the ethical quandary. Particularly when you know their widget cost them a fraction of a penny, and they were being paid to give you the poison.
Like Bill Hicks said, these people are Satan's little helpers. Engaging with Satan and undermining him may be unwise, but it's not unethical.
As others have pointed out, these people also have a level of stalking going on that I don't think the average person (or even a relatively informed person) can grasp, and so there's no possibility for a social contract to exist there.
There is a supermarket that at the checkout has a bowl of candy that operates on the honour system.
If you push a button next to the bowl of candy an ad will play and you can take a piece of candy. The candy itself costs a fraction of a cent to the business and the business doesn't care to put anyone in place to monitor compliance with button pushing.
This system is known by everyone and operating in this way for decades so there is no deception towards the person at the supermarket.
Is it ethical to take a piece of candy without pushing the button?
(Actually, in reality I'd ignore the candy since I don't need more sugar.)
I wouldn't have this opinion if user-hostile web advertising and tracking hadn't driven me to it.
The issue I personally have is:
1) When the Ads themselves contain malware.
2) Eat up all your bandwidth/mobile data.
2.1) Have auto-playing videos / popups.
1) is somewhat rare. But it is something that has happened multiple times with major websites and services.
If I remember correctly, the Washington Post and Yahoo have previously had this issue. Google's Advertisement platform has repeatedly allowed malware to spread via their advertisement system. (Both on Mobile devices, and desktop devices, but usually more focused on mobile devices.)
2) is something I have to deal with everyday on the phone. When on a train filled to the brim, a lot of times the connection speed drops precipitously. In short, I don't have bandwidth to spend on an Ad, especially a video Ad. So I block them all, and usually try not to browse any image or video heavy sites.
2.1) is really just a quality of life thing.
There is a negative feedback loop where most third party content is only published on the most popular sites, so it becomes impossible to entirely avoid these sites even if the companies behind them are cancer.
> That would be ethically consistent.
Don't drag ethics into a mud fight with billion dollar companies. I lived through ads that faked download buttons, faked virus alerts, provided links to fake "official" download sites with malware or directly tried to infect your computer. The only ethical thing you can do with the ad industry is rob those rotten sociopaths blind.
If the adversaries followed idealized ethics, they would respect DNT header, for one.
That said, actively avoiding those actors who are unethical is commendable. It’s just very difficult to do in practice, since basic communication with eg neighbors, parents, friends are mainly through these channels.
This could be avoided if websites served ads responsibly: no JS, no animations, no video, no audio, no tracking, no scam merchants, no tricks, no manipulation, no unskippable ads, no dishonesty.
Almost no websites do this, so I have no ethical qualms giving of the ads the banhammer.
Once websites start respecting their users, then we can have this conversation about ethics, but not a second before.
To that end any mechanism that reduces the presence and effect of advertising is a moral imperative.
Very interesting. Can you please expand a bit more on why do you think this is the case?
In my view, blocking this isn't just morally just, it's absolutely necessary. I deliberately choose not to partake in this and not be a target for manipulation to the best of my ability.
Maybe there was a time when advertising was more about creating awareness instead of feeling and making you want the product, but advertising changed dramatically over the 20th century. There's quite a lot of reading material out there if you're interested.
Without advertising, “content marketing”, and paid placements/reviews people would buy things when they desire or need them.
They’d ask friends, compare specs, and read/watch reviews before determining what to buy.
That is: without ads, people would gravitate towards buying what fits their needs best. They would make generally rational choices given the information available.
Advertising’s job is to subvert those rational choices and make people buy something, whether it’s the best option or not. In fact, even when they don’t actually want or need anything at all.
It causes people exposed to it to spend money unnecessarily, and on the wrong products and downright bad products. Some are more susceptible than others, but in the end it’s an illegitimate tax levied every time you buy something. Even if you didn’t respond to advertising when making a purchase, advertising is so ubiquitous and necessary in most markets that the price you paid probably contributed to the advertising the manufacturer had to deploy to keep up with the arms race.
There’s nothing ethical or necessary about any of this.
Ideally there would be legislation that would force business models to change, but while there is not, ad blocking is absolutely an imperative.
Not to sound snarky, būt have you met humans?If sociology and economics have shown anything, itš that human do NO make rational consumption choices
That's fundamentally not how the web works. If you want me to pay for content, you need to get me to agree to pay for content. Just requesting a page, which I have no way beforehand of knowing contains ads, is not me agreeing to pay for the content. If you didn't want me to view the content without paying for it, why did you send me the content?
This is morally equivalent to the fake monk scam[1] in NYC where a fake Buddhist monk gives you a prayer bracelet and then demands that you pay them for it. You don't get to give people things and then demand that they pay for it when that was never agreed upon. Even if the payment is with their attention.
This is all setting aside the ethical blight that advertising, by its very nature, poses in the first place. Advertising is just lying--either literally, or by omission through presenting a one-sided view of products. There is never a case where advertising is ethical.
Note that the NYT has mostly stopped serving up content to people who haven't agreed to pay for it, and they're doing quite well financially lately.
Reddit mastodon lemmy etc already sanitize websites I read, and often I just read the comments, not the article.
Often people quote important parts of the article in the comments.
Ad blockers is like an antibiotic, I use them but I also try to not expose myself to germs.
Any content you make available publicly is fair game to be remixed, reformatted, summarised, and yes, ad-blocked.
It’s not the user’s job to make someone’s business model work.
Funnily enough, of all websites out there one of the best is still 4chan when it comes to ads. They have 2 banners, one at the top of the page, one at the very bottom of the page. These are static banners, at most a gif, with no tracking pixels or fingerprinting capabilities or any other similar form of horrid, unethical behavior. No embedded ads masquerading as regular content, nothing that blocks interaction on the page, just simple banners that target the site's particular niche like anime or cheap junk from Japan.
But as long as websites aren't using this model of ads and are instead opting for something disgusting like https://fingerprint.com then you won't see an iota of sympathy or care for "ethical" behavior from me.
Wouldn't it be more ethical to not visit ad supported websites in the first place? Instead of removing the source of their income while still consuming their content?
Someone should make an extension "SiteBlock Origin": Everytime it detects the presence of an ad, the whole website gets blocked, not just the ad. That would be ethically consistent.