200 years ago no one knew radio communications were possible. We still don’t understand quantum entanglement. Our understanding of physics, while more advanced than the past, is still clearly limited. We may find that there are better ways than radio to transmit data, and this could explain why our radio surveys have so far not detected extraterrestrial data packets (as far as we can tell).
What's more telling for those in the neighborhood is the strange amounts of O2 in our atmosphere's spectral lines. That came to be long before us, it will persist long beyond us and it's a clear indicator of a non-geological process that might intrigue aliens.
One other thing I came up with on a long evening walk recently was to check for gravity fields. If you have all bigger pieces of matter mapped well within galaxy, and you grok all physical laws there are, you should be able to predict movements and gravity fields for billions of years with high precision. Kind of make a complex checksum of given galaxy. If this changes for no predicted reason, bingo you just have a very strong candidate of life evolving enough to escape its planet and start moving big chunks of matter around (think big asteroids or changing orbit of planet slightly to ie counter some natural catastrophe like greenhouse effect / ice age, or living near slowly dying star).
Obviously this is way ahead of us and maybe even not possible, just a fun thought. But if you start space mining company by any chance in the future, please don't move matter around too much.
Basically we live in the goldilocks zone of our galaxy.
Stars further towards the center are being constantly bombarded by types of radiation that make the formation of structured self-replicators almost impossible.Entropy rules.
Stars further towards the rim have not yet gone through enough generations to produce the abundant heavier elements needed.
We live in the zone that is both old enough and stable enough for technologically adept life to thrive, and we turned up on the scene about as early as we could.
So we are probably just one of the first.
We don't really have any way to know that. Considering that there may be as many stars in the sky as grains of sand on Earth, there are many many unknowns.
For another example we don't know for sure if our universe is the only one and it's entirely possible that everything that could ever happen plays out in real time across and infinite number of universes. We don't have any way to physically measure that possibility yet. We only have mathematical theories.
Similar to how Copernicus proposed the heliocentric model, maybe our universe is not even the center of existence?
It is humbling to imagine.
The fact that we don’t see the light of stars, or whole galaxies replaced by dim infrared waste heat emissions means either (1) new physics will point to free energy solutions that circumvent thermodynamic laws [unlikely], or (2) we are the first.
Which seems to be the most likely explanation to me.
1. disassembling the stars to make them live a thousand times longer
2. it only takes one expansionist civilisation seeking interstellar exponential growth — even if 99.9% of civilisations are quiet, that's just 3 digits of the 22-digit number of stars in the observable universe.
Why would they do that when there are insane amounts of start with billions of years of life ahead of them. What purpose would that serve at this point in time?
In that case, the stars are not 'waste'.
Historically, this idea of growth as method for advance is only a few centuries old. It's not hard to see its end as efficiency keeps increasing.
Going K3 to 100 billion stars of the galaxy "only" gives you a 10^11 constant factor speedup at enormous expense and with Amdahl's penalty at galactic scales.
We are indeed among the first simply because of the sheer amount of time left ahead of us vs. behind us. It's basic math. We are at 0.014% of the expected duration of this universe.
Life as we see here on Earth is extremely adaptable. Give it harsh environment, and unless its too much immediately it will adapt and actually take advantage out of it (ie too much radiation? well we can mutate to our ideal desired form even quicker).
Also, 1 billion years doesn't mean much in this cosmic scale. But imagine if civilization like ours had that much headstart. Well, you can't imagine, and neither can I in same way homo erectus couldn't imagine CERN particle accelerator or black holes.
Homo Erectus takes us back around 100 million years. A billion years gets us to very simple multicellular life which can't do imagination at all. Or logic. Or thinking. Or creativity. Or much of anything else.
So... a billion year old civ is going to have very fundamental abilities which are completely beyond our comprehension.
It's like Dunning Kruger on a cosmic scale. Except that with Dunning Kruger there's usually some potential to learn a way out of ignorance.
Here there isn't. Not only can we not do it, or understand why we need to do it, we can't see - never mind reach - the first rung of it.
Maybe not. There's no evidence that species can continually adapt and evolve to higher levels of intelligence. Humans are already hitting limits for how much we can think, figure out, etc.
But by that same token, maybe so. Humans aren't exactly the cream of the crop when it comes to higher critical thinking and emotional intelligence.
Is there any biological research that takes a look at a single or sequence of species maintaining civilizations lasting x amount of years?
We will have the technology to alter the DNA to increase our intelligence significantly. There are limits, but I don't think it is likely that human beings are at the peak of what is biological possible.
- When we reach the biological limit, we may extend ourselves by merging with technology. Our brains might be connected to a computing device that amplifies our capabilities. It may be so seamless that when answering a question, you won't notice if the knowledge was stored in your physical brain or retrieved from a central archive.
In the near term, I just wish they'd figure out how to make better mechanical parts for humans. Our natural joints suck, particularly knees and ankles. It really shouldn't be that hard to make mechanical replacements for various parts of the human body.
There is zero evidence of this.
What would that mean?
Once our intelligence encompassed communication then it began growing culturally. I.e. we are able to treat math and engineering as no biggies, despite humans needing millennia to realize "nothing" could be a number called "zero".
It's fair to say the 21st century shows no signs of intelligence slowing down. We keep finding ways to think more simply but more effectively.
Huh? Where did you get that crazy number? 100M years ago was the age of the dinosaurs. Homo erectus was around somewhere between 250K and 1.6M years ago.
> So we are probably just one of the first.
Those two sentences don't really mix. We have evidence that points to life forming basically immediately once the conditions are right. That means that for us to be the first, nowhere else in the galaxy and universe could have had the conditions. That just seems incredibly unlikely. Even in our own Solar System, other bodies like Mars had the conditions for life before Earth did.
In fact, given that most of the easily accessible coal and oil deposits will have been used up it might even be much more difficult for a subsequent species to get as far as humanity has. (Although that might be balanced a bit by lots of the metal ore being pre-mined and near the surface)
There'll be plenty of time for nature to compact and bury much of the biomass from the previous sentience attempts.
What's the evidence for this? Not asking rhetorically, I'm curious and want to read more.
Basically, as my understanding goes, life is effectively as old as the Earth is. As soon as it cooled down after forming and had liquid oceans, life started, which happened just a few hundred million years after Earth formed.
There is the book Every Life is on Fire as well, describing how life began to dissipate heat in the environment of molecules in water being heated. That seems to imply life will quickly start in such conditions. (Note: I don't strongly recommend the book, as it has a lot of religious stuff in it and honestly isn't that well written, and I have mainly learned about the author's theory elsewhere.)
Not sure this logic makes a whole lot of sense.
Imagine a universe similar to ours, but with a lifetime cut short by a doomsday device. Would you expect any difference in the likelihood that mirror humanity coincides with another alien civilisation?
Independent of other factors, adding more time doesn't really reduce the number of civilisations existing at any one time, it gives more time for civilisations to emerge.
Your logic suggests there is a fixed number of civilisations to distribute evenly across the lifetime of the universe. Now, the number of civilisations may be limited by usable energy for life to consume rather than time - but in that case I'd expect civilisations to cluster at the beginning of time when entropy is low.
Edit: in fact Drake didn't actually include any term for age of the universe in his equation.
But I think I was imprecise with my language. By "age" I meant the total lifetime of the universe as a place with planets capable of supporting life, rather than the amount of time between the big bang and now.
I don’t believe the current absence of evidence is much of a useful data point. Until we have scoured other star systems and the rest of the galaxy turning over rocks we can’t really generate useful empirical data to fill in the numbers on the Drake equation. The paradox of “where is everybody” has myriad solutions.
A mistake definitely lies in philosophers and theorists believing their sci-fi ideas are better than anyone else’s. Certainly not useful data towards writing papers that form a proof of any number as a solution. It’s hard to prove an absence, particularly when there’s a universe of empirical data that can be potentially gathered but hasn’t been yet.
If I was a betting person, I’d put a stake on there being life somewhere like Enceladus. Even life from earth in the form of fungal spores has existed for long enough to escape and float around the galaxy - they’ve had a few hundred million years. Life here could have also landed from elsewhere as easily as terrestrial abiogenesis. There’s just so much we don’t know and haven’t tested. Not being able to pull radio signals out of the noise proves nothing given the mere seventy years of attempts.
I’m not sure about many worlds, and how that could be proved either to be a useful part of science. By the same token, in an infinite universe, then literally every single possibility and permutation is being tried, so in that case, yeah there’s life everywhere. Including a universe where I’m out being the first human to find it rather than writing this comment.
universe begins
0.1 Gy
first stars
9 Gy
our solar system begins
0.5 Gy or less
early life
3.5 Gy
complex, multicellular, macroscopic life
0.5 Gy
sentient, intelligent life
I think the important delays are the 9 Gy and the 3.5 Gy. (Gy = billion years)9 Gy: After first stars, how many generations do you need of large stars, synthesizing heavy elements, going supernova and shooting the heavy elements around, contributing to the condensation of new stars (now with some heavy elements to begin with), until you cal form solar systems and planets like ours, with enough iron and heavier elements to make life chemically possible. Do you need to wait this full 9 billion years, before planets with the chemical composition of Earth appear, or did they already appear sooner?
3.5 Gy: How long does it "usually" take from early microbial life, for evolution to develop complex multicellular life? In our case it took 3.5 billion years, but are we among the fastest, or the slowest?
In other words, the likelihood that they either lived before or (will live) after us is overwhelming, since the time scale of the universe is so vast compared to the time scale (with our one known example) of a civilization.
Our timeline is like the blink of an eye, compared to the age of the universe. Very unlikely that nearby blinks would happen at exactly the same time, even with a 11,000+ multiplier.